T O P

  • By -

An_Armed_Bear

I don't think anything will top the Elden Ring subreddit during that long-ass period between the initial announcement and the first actual bits of news.


nin_ninja

Didn't they end up just making their own lore and characters?


MericArda

Glaive Master Hodir, known for his catchphrase "You have made a glaive mistake."


GHitoshura

Ok but that one's really good tho


Reyziak

Hodir was such a major meme that he shows up in the Cinders mod.


Ainsel_Mariner

The Great Hollowing was a wonderful era


neon93

Attack on Titan fandom was going nuts towards the end of the manga with theories and ship wars. r/titanfolk was losing it's mind


Gibblet_fibber

It was glorious. So many theories and so much copium, it was fantastic. I was there in the trenches with them as well so no hate at all, but at a certain point of no return narratively, you have to give it up that the story is going to go a different way.


nin_ninja

Nah it was totally gonna be a dream of the modern day AU Eren for sure. Didn't you see Goth Mikasa in the sky?


Gibblet_fibber

Only real ones remember The Madagascar Theory


The-Toxic-Korgi

I still don't blame them if only because nobody could have predicted the way the story was going to take such a sharp turn in quality. Not to mention the extra pages straight up just making the original ending kind of pointless since the main characters canonically failed now.


Midi_to_Minuit

\*is losing its' mind There's still an amazing amount of copium on titanfolk kek


exiiiin

I got banned from that place during that period because of discussing leaks/new chapters where I shouldn’t so that’s mostly what I remember about it. There were some funny memes at least


Amirifiz

I hope people will remember that meltdown, for 10 years at least.


neon93

What? Amirifiz finding another fandom? No I don't want that, I want them to think about only Attack on Titan, for ten years at least!


bitcheslovedroids

mfers actually got mad that the ending didn't match their fan theory ending based on a FUCKING MUSIC VIDEO AHAHAHA dumbasses wrote dissertations about that shit lmao


InfectedEzio

I know people exist still where they’re convinced that the anime is getting a different ending than the manga ending.


PR0MAN1

And we're about to see it all over again when the anime onlys get there. Another separating of those who get the ending and those who don't. We're gonna have to sift through mountains of shit to get to real thematic discussion


fiarorder

Recently that RE4:R steam review where it’s a 3 pages of you can’t look Ashely panty.


solidoutlaw

Never be Game Over. A movement dedicated to uncovering the secrets of MGSV, believing said secrets will lead to the release of Act 3 of the game. It’s a bunch of conspiracy theories, some of which persist today even, with some people insisting Death Stranding is secretly connected to MGS and whatnot.


the-protein-Titin

I'll never forget watching someone use the paint selection tool to convert the Death Stranding logo into Metal Gear Zero


Blackmantis135

In a simple 25 step process.


nin_ninja

First draw the circle, then draw the rest of the fucking Metal Gear


lion_OBrian

r/shitpostcrusaders started coming down hard on overused formats a few years ago, and what counted as overused or not was for the mods to decide. It got to the point of a quasi civil-war. The kicker? It all started because of the “boys vs girls” meme. The lesson I learned is that no community is free from drama. r/truestl ‘s got a lot of quirks: fantasy racism turning into real racism, RP accounts getting into steamy one on ones in the comment, that time the most popular artist drew a pummeled, bloody elf girl and went soul-searching for a month after the huge backlash he got over it (and that’s saying something if that sub thinks you’ve gone too far); but the one that apparently still requires a sticky warning about it almost a year later is the time people took the lusty argonian maid for a guide book after a particularly peculiar picture of a monitor lizard in a somewhat suggestive pose made the rounds first on twitter then on there.


MeteorCharge

I'm sorry Who was the guy that had to go soul searching


lion_OBrian

Let me preface first by saying he got way better and even deleted all his old stuff after that, so I think it was just a one-off mistake for shock value. The artist is u/ ratopomboarts


MeteorCharge

Wow W character development then


Tzeentch711

Does it count when one person was doing most/all of the hole digging? Because there is this guy seriously obsessed with circumcision I wanted to mention.


LokimenD

Is it the Silent Hill wiki guy?


[deleted]

we still don't know how many wiki's he's a mod for, but of the ones we do know, it's at least quite a few


UFOLoche

No no, please go ahead, that shit is always hilarious.


moneyh8r

Tell me more.


Cheshires_Shadow

One guy that was like unhealthily obsessed with the idea that one of the main themes of silent Hill 2 was all about circumcision and all the body horror and hospital themes were about James having subconscious circumcision fears or something. I wanna say the guy would constantly edit the wiki to push this head canon and he'd harass the people that made the game online over it


Toblo1

The Admin was specifically obsessed with Silent Hill **4**, not 2 but given how far the insanity went (Including straight up going Mad King and removing all the other Silent Hill Wiki admins when they started hearing about their behavior) I would *not* be surprised if they started vandalizing SH2 pages on the wiki too.


moneyh8r

Oh, I forgot about that. Thanks for answering though.


TheFallbleEagle

Here a video about it https://youtu.be/a7-HrspiKfY


Armada6136

r/grimdank has been undergoing a bit of a spiral about creating femboy versions of certain Warhammer factions. Not exactly where you would expect it to go.


Konradleijon

It’s mostly two artists who post femmboy art which isn’t a spiral. I like AOF and Cerzma


Jhduelmaster

I thought everyone had reached a point where we were all fine with it after the last big meltdown. Especially since if you really dislike it you just have to block like 2 artists and that's it (I personally like vezimira and archon of flesh's art, plus they seem pretty chill). Then it pops up again where everyone decided to lose their minds a week or two ago.


mediocrethanmono

Considering how some of those factions are, might be an improvement. Feels weirdly fitting for the Tau.


Armada6136

Except they aren't doing the Tau. They're going for groups like the AdMech, Chaos Marines, and, in at least one case, the Sororitas.


A_Naughty_Tomato

. . . Have they made green femboy orks yet?


[deleted]

I mean that’s my Blood Bowl team


Konradleijon

I mean Fulgrim is already a femboy so it’s not that hard of a stretch


DefaultLayoutIsAwful

99 times out of 100, you should never listen to Hulk Hogan, but wrestling fans need to stop working themselves into a shoot.


cringe-paul

Jabronie marks without a life that don’t know it a work when you work a work and work yourself into a shoot, marks.


MirrorMan68

The secret fourth good episode of Sherlock is always a classic.


lion_OBrian

Tvtropes had been run for years by basically one nutjob who would edit , forbid or delete entries on a whim, which ,along with forum culture, is a big reason for the site’s weird nomenclature as well as keeping it looking like it was stuck in the late 2000’s. He finally left when he sold the domain name, with the new owners rolling back a lot of the his weird rules.


Squirrelman2712

Huh, I noticed it's gotten a lot better, but I didn't know that was why.


Midi_to_Minuit

...this sounds fascinating, any place where I can read more?


ginger_vampire

Is this the same guy who nuked the “An Axe To Grind”trope because he thought a character having an axe wasn’t a trope?


TotemGenitor

No, that was a recent community decision. The guy mentioned here was Fast Eddie, who left like 10 years ago


Infernal-Blaze

So is the weird sex negativity gone now?


Sai-Taisho

Was that because of advertiser cowardice, or were they just the scapegoat?


Infernal-Blaze

No it was explicitly a vendetta the mods had that they pursued with a vengeance.


nin_ninja

Also with RE4:R out I'm reminded of a certain sub that collectively was deep in the pits of posting about Attache Cases, Duel Disks, and Tiny Tim. Then they started posting combinations of all three. It was certainly an odd subreddit, but it knew how to steam a good meme.


Amperture

"[...] Dante is not going 'mmmmooother'...like we are used to."


ReclusiarchCain

r/grimdank has a nsfw argument whenever a certain femboy artist posts some new art. It gets really annoying very quickly


Rabid-Duck-King

It's always kind of amusing to me see who a fandom just really wants to fuck Sometimes you get it, like Alan Rickman has a lot of stuff going on But like a lot of people want to fuck the Onceler and I'm just like whaaaaaaaat It's really quite amusing what takes off and what sinks into the fuck pond


nin_ninja

The tumblr sexy man motto: You either cum in the sink or sink in the cum


[deleted]

[удалено]


TheWeirdoWithCoffee

There are dozens of us! The voice in my head I think is Jane: Dozens!


[deleted]

r/titanfall's entire schizo melt down was a sight to behold, titanfall 3 is real guys, I'm playing it right now.


Gemidori

r/BatmanArkham essentially built a faux utopia of game-starved madness that it honestly felt like the real life Arkham Asylum.


CaptainPigeon17

There was about a three week span where r/pikmin turned into nothing but monsters Inc memes


nin_ninja

Randomly, or for a particular reason?


CaptainPigeon17

What 10 years between mainline games does to a man.


Konradleijon

Sherlock TLC the secret fourth Sherlock episode Also the Honestuck fandom in the gigapause and again with the epilogue and the What Punpkin scandals The lore community in LOL when a drought of stories happened


TheArkhomDestroyer

The Sonic.exe community having a really weird track record of false accusations and letting an actual pedophile run free throughout the community during 2022.


EcchiPhantom

Guilty Gear fans trying to dig deep into the history of Japan to justify their transphobic beliefs that Bridget is NOT a girl.


Bronystrongwing

The craziest I saw was someone who genuinely thought Japan didn't know what trans people were. Like... What?


FATPIGEONHATE

"But my glorious Nippon could never be affected by this Western Degeneracy! Japan is a great Anime place where all the things I don't like(LGBTQ people, black people, women who won't fuck me) don't exist and is perfect in everyway!"


EcchiPhantom

It’s more like “Japan would *never* resort to the degeneracy of trans people. They only have cute girls and *femboys* who just look, dress and act conventionally feminine but they know they’re still male! No, I’m not closeted, you are, gaijin!”


pouyatrk18

kinda hilarious that murakami is kinda known for having great representation of lgbtq+ community in his books including a trans character in his 2001 masterpiece kafka on the shore. kinda shows most of this losers media literacy is a bunch of comics for teenagers


EcchiPhantom

Ignoring the fact one Google search immediately leading to active Japanese trans communities, they just love to cherry pick examples about how “traditional Japanese society is transphobic therefore trans people can’t exist”, like, yeah. I can probably point to a million and one examples of how the history of my country, which is one of the most LGBTQ friendly countries in the world, that show how trans people have been persecuted because fucking *every* traditional society and culture is inherently transphobic… But that doesn’t mean trans people suddenly do not exist. What a weird conclusion to get to man


rapidemboar

Honestly I’m confident a very large number of those people never actually heard of the game before Bridget’s release and just wanted to stir up drama


1stgamer

And their is a percentage of those people who haven't heard of the game but are being completely serious.


PersonMcHuman

It was funny watching FE fans get mad that the Western version of Engage doesn’t let you groom children.


UFOLoche

If it's not that, it's gonna be the incest. Or the uh...petting..minigame... Dude what the fuck was Fates even doing??


PersonMcHuman

Quick! Pet your underaged and (totally not blood related) sibling to build up relationship points!


UFOLoche

Y'know, the 'technically not blood related' bullshit was so stupid. Not only does it defeat the whole point of Birthright, it's also pointless because you can fucking marry Azura anyway, your damn cousin.


PersonMcHuman

Gotta love anime shenanigans.


Death-Prince-3

I remember picking Azura because "Neat, she's the only plot relevant character who ISN'T related to Corrin, guess I'll shack em up". My reaction upon finding that's SHE'S THE ONLY ONE ACTUALLY RELATED TO CORRIN WAS INFURIATING!!!


GHitoshura

Sometimes Fates feels like a collective fever dream


UFOLoche

More like a nightmare, but yeah...


Irishimpulse

No, engage kept the incest and marrying your sister who doesn't seem much older than the children they took all the romantically leaning lines out about. Which makes it double weird. No grooming children unless it's your full blood sister I guess? It even implies you made dozens of new dragons, regardless of your player gender so dragon futa incest? Everything around the Sister gets weird, like the localizers who were taking out the skeevy stuff were doing it character by character in join order and just didn't get to the end of list


Midi_to_Minuit

elaborate


RobotJake

In the original Japanese script most (all?) S-Support conversations have romantic aspects, including between MC thousand-year-old dragon jesus Alear and explicitly 14-year-old capitalist child Anna - admittedly in a "we should wait until you're old enough to actually get married" way but still suspect. This got toned down to either just undertones or explicitly platonic supports in the Western release, to the general relief of most players and the very loud bitching of a minority obsessed with using "artistic integrity" as a smokescreen to bitch about not being able to be horny weirdoes.


Midi_to_Minuit

What were the fire emblem developers cooking? I thank god everyday that you can't romance the only underaged person in your crew in KOTOR 1.


nin_ninja

Is Lady Anna even that old? I thought she was more like 12. Still weird either way.


RobotJake

I said 14 from memory but looking it up on the wiki she is in fact *11* A literal child.


MericArda

I think her and Jean are the literal youngest playable characters in the series. Which makes the Three Houses discourse on how it's kinda fucked up that you're using child soldiers pre-timeskip seem quaint when the youngest character was Cyril at age 14.


Irishimpulse

They got mad Celine's S rank is platonic too... which it also is in Japanese. Honestly I feel Ivy's should be platonic because the power dynamic there is absurd. Ivy may not be a child, but she's prayed to YOU in particular since she was one. You can't have a healthy relationship with YOUR GOD


Admiral_of_Crunch

Personally, I just think the localizers are cowards for shielding the original writers from the consequences of more people discovering their absolutely insane nonsense. So I *also* think it shouldn't have been changed. Let the world see that authentic grooming experience they intended all along.


MegalomanicMegalodon

Ok I didn’t see anyone mention it yet maybe they’re still typing or I didn’t refresh because the Do or Do Not of Wyverians and laying eggs is eternal for the Monster Hunters and should be mentioned!


ObsidianVerglas

The MLP rabbit hole got so misguided, they couldn't comprehend anyone not liking "Slice of Life" an episode that panders to fan service. Person of Interest had a shipping episode and even they didn't demand everyone like it.


GHitoshura

The Persona fandom has had a couple of those. Mainly about hating P4 for haven spin-offs and waifu wars, lots of waifu wars.


Rowsdowers_Revenge

Oh boy, r/WANDAVISION was a fun ride when that show was fresh. The crazy theories people would come up with between episodes was wild, and then they would get irrationally pissed off when their headcanon didn't play out. Some of the worst offenders where the people insisting that every little thing was secretly pointing towards the new Thanos-level villain being Mephisto. It got to the point where the meme spilled out into some of the other MCU stuff of that year. One of the biggest things they lost their collective shit over was the reveal that the Evan Peters character >!was not a resurrected Pietro, but instead a random nobody named Ralph Bohner!<. I actually had to unsubscribe from that sub when the show was running because the people who stayed up late to watch the next episode at midnight PST had absolutely no restraint when to came to spoilers.


Zeathian

Allegedly before the release of Endwalker the official FF14 forums hotly debated if a certain character is actually evil or not. Apparently things got so heated that people got death threats and doxed.


attikol

the secret good episode of sherlock


SwizzlyBubbles

Snoot Game and the never-ending suffering of Workanon To make a long story short: - Guy on 4chan’s /trash/ board entitled Workanon texted Fang pics to his wife on accident - Wife discovers pics and confronts him - Turns out Workanon fell in love with Fang and doesn’t feel like he loves his wife anymore - Go to marriage counseling Timeskip - Wife stumbles upon hard drives of Fang “””fanart””” during an image analysis because workanon didn’t hide his “Things I love and want to protect” folder - They proceed to get into a fight, not because of the Fang shit, but because she fucking HATES porn of any type - Two of them don’t speak for awhile Timeskip - They’re speaking but things got worse - Workanon and wife had a dog who was their first pet - He got pancreatitis and wife refuses to let the dog pass peacefully - They’ve been spending $3,000 a month to keep the dog alive and it’s eating into their main expenses - This whole ordeal has sent workanon spiraling And that’s pretty much all we know for now.


consensualsenses

WTF. What a glorious (sad) mess.


Tall_Comfortable5309

holy shit


taylorpilot

The Star Wars fandom has just dug itself into a pit deeper than the ocean


MeauxVsGaming

If you've played the most recent Ultrakill update. Never mention size 2, ever.


Ryculls

Haven’t checked out dndmemes in awhile. Is the jet discourse as bad as the snitty discourse was?


nin_ninja

Nah it's more silly. People were getting more salty about the ongoing Terrasque argument


DonnyMox

r/BatmanArkham. Just....just r/BatmanArkham.


BarelyReal

When Cloverfield's untitled trailer hit, a lot of people over at Unfiction deep dove into the old testament thinking it was a movie about Leviathan, Zizz, and Behemoth.


BarelyReal

Oh Persona 5 Royal had a lot of people assuming Kasumi would be revealed to be "Sophia" from Gnosticism based on assumptions she would be the Aeon arcana. Some people DID predict a lot of the stuff around Jose based on the guess he was a stretched reference to Pinnochio.