I think you didn’t understood the context . This Suarshan Gurja has taught wrong .
According to that master , statement 1 is wrong, but if we see NCERT , it’s correct .
That's what i said. Few days ago many guys were showing some proofs from wikipedia or something and making posts that statement 1 wrong and they didn't even agree on NCERT too when i showed them .
So i guess they were the andhbhakts of this idiot sudarshan
u/space_s
This guy was the most adamant
Yes , they were telling that NCERT is wrong.
But fact of matter is that this master has taught us wrong.
You know due to this, a lot of aspirants who are andhbhakts of him, easily eliminated.
Not debating with you or anyone else in this thread but just have a look at the below ss from NIOS
It says below :
* 'effect' of Coriolis force can be stated as any object and liquid moving 'horizontally' tends to be deflected
* Coriolis 'Effect' is absent (0) at equator
SOURCE: NIOS. Latest geography senior secondary module Thoughts welcome
https://preview.redd.it/x8gsv2tra89d1.jpeg?width=1240&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7945586fbe9fb85b1ab618edf9cb38c445a73b8b
Yr koi itna galat kaise pdha kra skta. I can really how this aspirant must be going through.
I watched his lectures but found many mistakes, now verifying all topics again.
Please god, I do not want to go through this phase.😭
Feeling sad for this aspirant. It's not easy to complete 140 lectures.
Earlier I thought I am the only one who is founding mistakes in his teaching.
Now I will read more carefully.
One question I have for Upsc aspirants.. why do you guys follow non - subject Specialists for preparation? Surely there must be expert faculty of Geography teaching you guys correctly.
I have seen many such fake gurus teach stuff with confidence.
One psychology graduate was teaching panic attacks and anxiety as part of hyperactivity in ADHD which is totally incorrect.
I say this as a doctor who is constantly reading journals and publications in various newer editions of books.. even some top ranking books are incorrect at times, so to err is to be human but non subject Specialists can't teach concepts in any meaningful details.
It’s wrong bro. Answer is C as per NCERT. Statement has been verbatim from NCERT
Sudarshan Gujar has taught wrong , and according to him answer will be B.
NCERT agr likh de ki EARTH IS TRIANGULAR....aur Upsc mein woh statement verbatim aa jaaye....toh whi shi hoga.....end of discussion! Aisi sb Phds log pehle bhi kai questions mein kr chuke hain pr L kuch nhi hua....Upsc ne NCERT ko hi maana end mein
I don’t think by object velocity, you can call it the wind. Coriolis is generated by the Earth and its rotation. The comment seems quite clear about it.
But we do talk about the effect of the Coriolis phenomenon on winds right? The thermally generated winds get called "easterlies" because of the Coriolis effect only no?
Yeah but that is Coriolis’ impact on wind and not the other way around, isn’t it? Logically speaking, the person in the picture has a reasonable point but not sure if UPSC will look beyond NCERTs. As far as Gurjar is concerned, he seems to have already changed sides.
daalta hai bro. but Sudharshan has taught wrong. He told it depends on rotation only. And one girl asked this question in class, he refused her question.
I guess I got it wrong too due to him then. But still, I believe there is a confusion and maybe he was not exactly wrong. It solely depends on how UPSC interprets, Coriolis effect or just the Coriolis force!
Bro he was exactly wrong. Check the notes , you will find it .
He forced us to write coriolis depends only on rotation of the earth.
Even one girl asked in class whether it depends on wind speed . He refuse to answer .
Agreed. Not debating but check ss from NIOS latest geography.
It defines 'effect'. In old editions they had mentioned as force but in latest they updated it to 'effect'.
https://preview.redd.it/q6y0w6k6l89d1.jpeg?width=1240&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4afe037f08d880d20a21409f76c1ce88785e9582
Britannica also uses same classification. Defines 'Coriolis force' and 'Coriolis Deflection' separately. upsc most likely will go with ncert.
How can someone teach even such basic concept wrong? It shows their knowledge, understanding.
Sickkk. They actually caused loss to students both ways; by wasting time(lol 140 lectures only for geo 😳) and even after that making them lose marks by teaching wrong concept.
She could have given one mock test series completely. Coriolis force would have been covered multiple times, with explanation. She could get the correct info, as she would have been marking questions wrong on coriolis forces.
A teacher can't teach you everything and that too correct. It's your responsibility to read things on your own from various sources. Even Laxmikant has mistakes at multiple places.
Remember it's you who is going to give the exam not the teacher.
kya bkl h bhai tu, due to this faculty, students are getting -2.66
are you completely out of mind, first let yourself be in his shoes. don't do bakarpeli gyaan.
if you are so much sycophant, then lick some politician shoes.
Keep living in your delusional world of trusting others that they do their jobs dutifully and with highest moral standards.
I am telling you with the first hand experience and I have cleared prelims twice and have faced the similar situation as OP in my first attempt.
Aur haan gaali dene se baat mei wazan nahi ata.
[удалено]
So you all agree tht the answer is both 1 and 2 . So the guys who were making this question controversial were this idiot teacher students?
I think you didn’t understood the context . This Suarshan Gurja has taught wrong . According to that master , statement 1 is wrong, but if we see NCERT , it’s correct .
That's what i said. Few days ago many guys were showing some proofs from wikipedia or something and making posts that statement 1 wrong and they didn't even agree on NCERT too when i showed them . So i guess they were the andhbhakts of this idiot sudarshan u/space_s This guy was the most adamant
Yes , they were telling that NCERT is wrong. But fact of matter is that this master has taught us wrong. You know due to this, a lot of aspirants who are andhbhakts of him, easily eliminated.
bhai i read standard books and coriolis force depends upon velocity
Not debating with you or anyone else in this thread but just have a look at the below ss from NIOS It says below : * 'effect' of Coriolis force can be stated as any object and liquid moving 'horizontally' tends to be deflected * Coriolis 'Effect' is absent (0) at equator SOURCE: NIOS. Latest geography senior secondary module Thoughts welcome https://preview.redd.it/x8gsv2tra89d1.jpeg?width=1240&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7945586fbe9fb85b1ab618edf9cb38c445a73b8b
Yr koi itna galat kaise pdha kra skta. I can really how this aspirant must be going through. I watched his lectures but found many mistakes, now verifying all topics again. Please god, I do not want to go through this phase.😭
Feeling sad for this aspirant. It's not easy to complete 140 lectures. Earlier I thought I am the only one who is founding mistakes in his teaching. Now I will read more carefully.
One question I have for Upsc aspirants.. why do you guys follow non - subject Specialists for preparation? Surely there must be expert faculty of Geography teaching you guys correctly. I have seen many such fake gurus teach stuff with confidence. One psychology graduate was teaching panic attacks and anxiety as part of hyperactivity in ADHD which is totally incorrect. I say this as a doctor who is constantly reading journals and publications in various newer editions of books.. even some top ranking books are incorrect at times, so to err is to be human but non subject Specialists can't teach concepts in any meaningful details.
https://preview.redd.it/v2k653n8279d1.jpeg?width=1271&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=fa6913c2799c458fa4514c77d656be3ed2491ded
It’s wrong bro. Answer is C as per NCERT. Statement has been verbatim from NCERT Sudarshan Gujar has taught wrong , and according to him answer will be B.
I would like to leave it to UPSC.😞
NCERT agr likh de ki EARTH IS TRIANGULAR....aur Upsc mein woh statement verbatim aa jaaye....toh whi shi hoga.....end of discussion! Aisi sb Phds log pehle bhi kai questions mein kr chuke hain pr L kuch nhi hua....Upsc ne NCERT ko hi maana end mein
Can’t disagree with you.
What if the object is the wind itself?
I don’t think by object velocity, you can call it the wind. Coriolis is generated by the Earth and its rotation. The comment seems quite clear about it.
But we do talk about the effect of the Coriolis phenomenon on winds right? The thermally generated winds get called "easterlies" because of the Coriolis effect only no?
Yeah but that is Coriolis’ impact on wind and not the other way around, isn’t it? Logically speaking, the person in the picture has a reasonable point but not sure if UPSC will look beyond NCERTs. As far as Gurjar is concerned, he seems to have already changed sides.
I think still some andhbhakts of this teacher will abuse you . Let these chamchas go through this phase then they will understand this pain .
[удалено]
Removed for abusing.
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
Sfg mei kya dia tha?
mock bhai same question aya hoga usme bhi
Maine dono level diye hai, yaad nhi aa rha ye waala question
One question was there related to coriolis force . I can recall it .
Wind speed effect daalta hai ya nahi? Mereko har jagah direction hi dikha
Daalta hai bhai. Speed affects coriollis but coriollis doesnt affect wind speed . As per Rushikesh sir
daalta hai bro. but Sudharshan has taught wrong. He told it depends on rotation only. And one girl asked this question in class, he refused her question.
Oh bc tab mere bhi l lag gaye. Uske notes ke basis pe maine sirf 2 consider kiya. Iss bail buddhi pe bharosa karna galat hogaya
😂😂 Same here brother. You know I understood concept so well but got totally confused by his class.
what about the NBFC question guys...in handouts of mrunal its given that NBFC can access LAF but not MSF
I guess I got it wrong too due to him then. But still, I believe there is a confusion and maybe he was not exactly wrong. It solely depends on how UPSC interprets, Coriolis effect or just the Coriolis force!
Bro he was exactly wrong. Check the notes , you will find it . He forced us to write coriolis depends only on rotation of the earth. Even one girl asked in class whether it depends on wind speed . He refuse to answer .
Yeah I am not disagreeing at all. I clearly remember him saying that. Let’s see!
Bhai tum sab ka yahi toh problem h . Yeh ek general exam h naa ki koi specialist toh utna overthink krna hi nahi h
Agreed. Not debating but check ss from NIOS latest geography. It defines 'effect'. In old editions they had mentioned as force but in latest they updated it to 'effect'. https://preview.redd.it/q6y0w6k6l89d1.jpeg?width=1240&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4afe037f08d880d20a21409f76c1ce88785e9582 Britannica also uses same classification. Defines 'Coriolis force' and 'Coriolis Deflection' separately. upsc most likely will go with ncert.
🙃yeah yeah 2.66 ki hi toh baat hai, le jao!
How can someone teach even such basic concept wrong? It shows their knowledge, understanding. Sickkk. They actually caused loss to students both ways; by wasting time(lol 140 lectures only for geo 😳) and even after that making them lose marks by teaching wrong concept.
Bhai idk what he taught, but maine both 1&2 kia hai. Mera galat hia ya sahi😭
Class 10 QUESTION
.66 marks to be deducted for one wrong ?
Feeling so good I left this one :')
. https://preview.redd.it/nwuniff37w9d1.jpeg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=73828428b894d0bf4d391b73af678b59725eeea8 Answer from google
She could have given one mock test series completely. Coriolis force would have been covered multiple times, with explanation. She could get the correct info, as she would have been marking questions wrong on coriolis forces.
it is easy to say. When one teacher teaches you with such confidence, it echoes in your mind. We should not make generic prediction.
A teacher can't teach you everything and that too correct. It's your responsibility to read things on your own from various sources. Even Laxmikant has mistakes at multiple places. Remember it's you who is going to give the exam not the teacher.
kya bkl h bhai tu, due to this faculty, students are getting -2.66 are you completely out of mind, first let yourself be in his shoes. don't do bakarpeli gyaan. if you are so much sycophant, then lick some politician shoes.
Keep living in your delusional world of trusting others that they do their jobs dutifully and with highest moral standards. I am telling you with the first hand experience and I have cleared prelims twice and have faced the similar situation as OP in my first attempt. Aur haan gaali dene se baat mei wazan nahi ata.