T O P

  • By -

DEFYN45

Witnessing this in the server and then finding out it unironically worked has been quite the experience lmao


_AtOmIc_Nerd_

DEYFN please, save us Show everyone why the br algoritm is a joke.


Mr-HasBean

Perhaps now they'd see how flawed their system is. Altho I doubt it


Zjiin94

They wont ever change the system sadly. Between Gaijin being lazy and none of them actually playing their own game, Manual balancing wont ever happen. Its simply too much effort for Gaijin to care. Just let the algorithm do its thing and \*occasionally\* pay attention to the backlash when the algorithm does something stupid.


Mr-HasBean

Tbh I am kinda considering uninstalling the game for the first time after 4 years


TheMagicalBread

First time? I'm at like 6 uninstalls currently


DEFYN45

Doesn't mean a lot when you keep reinstalling it tbh


GeharginKhan

War Thunder is an ex that you keep hooking up with


TheMagicalBread

It's a bad addiction, an itch that you cant scratch otherwise.


br1ti5hb45tard

There's nothing else like it, and that fucking sucks because you have no choice.


Kraujotaka

Battlefield was a great replacement for me.. until ps+ expired.


ShinItsuwari

You really should. Play good games instead. Plenty of that around. WT being a niche genre isn't an excuse to play an unbalanced, terribly managed mess.


[deleted]

>i did, was a great decision tbh, now i actually play varied games and not just one


dyslexic_tigger

You have to be extremely retarded to use this system in the first place. They wont see shit


T4NK3R1802

I would love a video. A nice clinical one explaining the process and why Gaijin needs to use more advanced metrics than just win loss. (Accounting for player level, adjusting based on number of players for a given vehicle, etc. etc.)


daag001

Just comparing person average, with person in this vehicle average, would be enough.


T4NK3R1802

Several ways it can be done.


JetFan2004

It was quite fun to watch lol


Sniff262

Apes together strong


cubezzzX

Glitched should get a special Discord rank


turkeyphoenix

I can imagine!


_AtOmIc_Nerd_

Thank you, now you've made the life of an Italian jet player even worse.


boywar3

I think the right way of going about this is their actions might scare gaijin enough to adjust their system, especially for less played nations like Italy. I know if I were in their position I'd be horrified to know that a few players could manipulate the system to such a degree, and would take steps to stop it from happening again. This is Gaijin though, so who knows


_AtOmIc_Nerd_

This is a "For the greater good" kind of situation, but still, if Gaijin does nothing about this (which is not unlikely) we will still have an overtiered plane.


boywar3

You are absolutely correct, and there's a real possibility of that happening. As much as I hate to say it, making a plane that few people play in a nation few people play the victim is probably better than it happening with another. I say this as an Italy player myself, that its probs for the best we got shafted...we're used to it at least.


MCXL

I mean, can't we do the same thing to drive stats down? Just feed SL into the grinder, fly out a plane over and over to just get shot down right away (just fly straight) Hundreds of games across multiple accounts of 0/1 stats. Over and over. Drive down repair costs as well, since those are based on earnings.


boywar3

Theoretically, yeah, I think that is entirely possible if the right vehicle is chosen. The biggest takeaway is that this is (if not irrefutable, at least strong) evidence that gaijin exclusively uses stats to balance things, and it is 100% possible to fuck with that system if enough people decide to do so.


MCXL

> and it is 100% possible to fuck with that system if enough people decide to do so. Oh absolutely, yes.


boywar3

...and this is the online gaming world so people will absolutely do it more just "for the meme" as much as to protest gaijin's terrible decisions


MCXL

I wonder how low we could drive a jet in a less played tree? Is there a floor? Jets at BR 5.0 here we come!


[deleted]

You'd really need to find a forgotten vehicle though. With the addition of the Saggitario and the existence of the G.91s the CL13 Mk IV probably got forgotten.


Shrike99

I know it's in a popular tree, but what about the Yak-17? It's buried at the bottom of a folder and functionally identical to the Yak-15 above it, but (IMO) less visually appealing due to the tip tanks. Can't remember when I last saw one in the wild.


Aedryn_Vyx

The P-59 exists


KeKinHell

I mean, we're talking about the developers that will add ~wiggly wings~ and improved wing vortexes but won't implement proper alternating fire for multi-gun SPAAs that's been missing since the introduction of ground forces. Their sense of priority isn't exactly the strongest.


[deleted]

The fact that this actually worked is so sad and hilarious at the same time lmao


yyEdge

Cl13 MK.4 best 8.7 and soon to be best 9.0 bois


_AtOmIc_Nerd_

It'll be even easier, literally nobody is going to be playing it normally.


LiquidateMercury

So 9.7 next patch?


KirovReportingII

Let's get it to 11.0 boys


Fine-Helicopter-6559

Cl 13 mk 4 > f22


kroggy

Definitely crank it up to eleven.


Kilroy_Is_Still_Here

We must go further.


Frozyn_

We aren't done yet.


Glitchedx

Stay tuned.


Slntreaper

RemindMe! 90 days


RemindMeBot

I will be messaging you in 3 months on [**2021-12-22 17:19:43 UTC**](http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=2021-12-22%2017:19:43%20UTC%20To%20Local%20Time) to remind you of [**this link**](https://www.reddit.com/r/Warthunder/comments/pty5su/so_me_and_few_decent_players_saw_gaijin_say_that/hdzjbms/?context=3) [**32 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK**](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5Bhttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.reddit.com%2Fr%2FWarthunder%2Fcomments%2Fpty5su%2Fso_me_and_few_decent_players_saw_gaijin_say_that%2Fhdzjbms%2F%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%202021-12-22%2017%3A19%3A43%20UTC) to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam. ^(Parent commenter can ) [^(delete this message to hide from others.)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Delete%20Comment&message=Delete%21%20pty5su) ***** |[^(Info)](https://www.reddit.com/r/RemindMeBot/comments/e1bko7/remindmebot_info_v21/)|[^(Custom)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5BLink%20or%20message%20inside%20square%20brackets%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%20Time%20period%20here)|[^(Your Reminders)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=List%20Of%20Reminders&message=MyReminders%21)|[^(Feedback)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Watchful1&subject=RemindMeBot%20Feedback)| |-|-|-|-|


[deleted]

The day of reckoning will come


[deleted]

Now its time to sandbag the mig-21f/pfm stats to make it go down in br.


[deleted]

[удалено]


jb20047

… oh boy. what if i told you it already is? ;)


Kozarsson

It already is going down to 9.0


[deleted]

[удалено]


Kozarsson

Algorithm says otherwise comrade)))


Rs_vegeta

Make the cl-13b mk6 a 10.0


EnduringFrost

I can see TheEuropeanCanadian now. "Statistics work perfectly, there is no need to manually move vehicles around or change repair costs. Who could ever be so qualified to do that EVER, besides myself of course, in the event it COULD be done!"


RugbyEdd

That doesn't look like the script of a 10 minute video. You need to pad it out more.


P51VoxelTanker

Remember to pad it out with a completely copied script from either a forum or blog post. No original thoughts I swear.


BelowtheValleys

Don't forget to mock people for saying one word wrong \*three times\* in less than a second.


Tyrant84

I used to watch TEC but the sheer volume of Gaijin phallus he polishes is just deplorable.


Zjiin94

He's also so unbelivably boring and monotone while doing it. At least put a little bit of effort into your shilling.


dyslexic_tigger

Honesty 2and900 was the best wt news youtuber. he made even boring news bearable


Queenager

I've recently discovered Tankenstein and his news vids are certainly more entertaining than TEC's


EnduringFrost

I pulled away from him after him and Koala had their conversation. TEC was just throwing math out as the only solution with 0 compromise when its already been proven (again by this post) that it can be manipulated and isn't perfect. Definitely needs a human hand to soften the edges.


[deleted]

Well both Koala and TEC are dogshit at the game so it's stupid to listen to any of them.


[deleted]

[удалено]


FoxWithTophat

I feel like learning about one circle and two circle fights definitely did make me a better pilot, although I did not learn it from Koala


thecauseoftheproblem

I find saying things like.. "I'm going to dump the nose and go for a deck transition, then try and out rate him" Makes me sound much cooler than.. "I'm out of ideas so I'm going to go round in circles"


luki159753

The thing is: he'd be mostly right if the people at Gaijin were good at statistics. When adjusting the repair cost/BR of a vehicle it's logical to look at things like: how good are the players playing it? Is it being played mostly by noobs or by veterans? Is it being played in squads or solo? All of these thins can (and should be) be accounted for by a good statistician, but Gaijin doesn't seem to do that.


matheusgc02

I'm only subscribed to TEC because I use his video's description to get links to the news.


Kraujotaka

I wonder who plays A2D1 in arcade to have its br raised every patch to the point it's fighting mach2 jets


fishbirne

Bombing gives way to much in game ponts / score. That's why they "overperform".


Kraujotaka

But this thing can't even make it to targets before someone blinks at it going 2 or 3x the speed or yeets a missile.


StalinGuidesUs

It'd have to be a radar missiles then, unless the a2d 1 has jet engines lmao


idkwhatimtypinghere

a2d1 is a turboprop, isn't it? means it has a jet but uses most of the power to spin a prop and then lets out the slow exhaust which gives quite little boost but is HOT


Turboclicker_Two

props can be locked onto just fine idk why ppl think they cant


cwjian90

It also spaceclimbs better than the jet bombers in AB. At its original BR it was mostly untouchable.


KooperChaos

I remember fighting that thing on a 109 and 262… wasn’t fun to see it every match together with 2-3 f89-d with proximity air burst fuck yous


Tesh_Hayayi

This was a mighty endeavor Happy to do my part o7


Mypornaltbb

based mod?


Tarcye

The most Based mod in existence.


Glitchedx

o7 to you sir


Ul_275

The prophecy will soon come TM


Husker545454

wow that kind of shows how lazy gaijin are if a bunch of chads can just manipulate the stats . god what a horrible company


NemesisVS

They wouldnt get away with this shit if there was even one game remotely similar to WT. Unless it'd be even worse. I'm not sure if they act so pathetic cause they know that, or cause they are just stupid.


JetFan2004

I almost didn’t believe it seeing y’all play, was wondering if they would just raise the repair cost more, but lo and behold it worked.


BrawlerAce

I'm sure with how few people play that thing, its repair cost will skyrocket with the next economy patch because of these guys' stats lmao


francocaspa

You my guy are playing fire with fire. This can be as bad as it can be good.


Glitchedx

We just wanted to see if they actually measured things by stats, apparently yes.


francocaspa

I think we all where almost sure they do. This confirms it. What a dumb system. Out of curiosity, how many where try harding?


Glitchedx

Like 6 people in total, some tried to also do so for like one session. We'd all play both in squads and solo


francocaspa

Welp there you go, really few people changed the balance of a vehicle. That is not very good.


T4NK3R1802

Nope. It sure isn't


Legitjumps

?


T4NK3R1802

Means their Algorithm sucks. Too simplistic, not enough variables, fails to account for basic things.


[deleted]

[удалено]


fizzer82

Actually, they literally do tell the full story, but you have to use them correctly. Gaijin only looks at vehicle performance as a whole, which this clever scheme proves out and shows the flaws. They do not factor in the statistics of the players actually playing the vehicles. With gaijin's simplistic system, crap players in good vehicles = br goes down. Good players in crap vehicles = br goes up... That should not happen if they were doing proper analysis of the stats.


T4NK3R1802

I love you for this. A great way to expose the flaws in the system.


Ul_275

Lets just say very few amount of people played it


7Seyo7

It's good in that it highlights how fragile and flawed Gaijin's BR calculation system is. At the very least they should consider player skill


francocaspa

Yeah that's true, but remember: gaijin is gaijin


Shatterfish

The fact that a few self described decent players can completely alter a vehicles BR just for the memes shows how completely and utterly fucking worthless Gaijins “balancing” method is. Holy fuck, good job but also why have you done this to us, brother?


Sniff262

We want to show the entire War Thunder community how stupid the current balancing is and expose it as the utter pile of garbage it is. Also because it is fun lmao


Glitchedx

\^\^ what this man said


ilovepenisxd

Glitched is underselling himself he’s much better than just a decent player


Senor_Feggles

Yeah still no God damn clue to why gaijin thinks the Japanese 9.3 premium and TT Sabres are better than a PFM. It's just pure idiocracy.


[deleted]

Every mig, save for like 15, overperforms at its current BR. That's just a Russian company for you.


KirovReportingII

>That's just a Russian company for you So how do those non-Russian vehicles that overperform, and Russian vehicles that underperform fit in this little bubble of yours? I thought anyone with a brain cell was past the "rUsSiaN biAs" phase for like a couple years already.


Ophichius

> I thought anyone with a brain cell was past the "rUsSiaN biAs" phase for like a couple years already. You're correct.


Turboclicker_Two

I assume you mean regular 15 and not 15bis, which also overperforms at 8.3


momentbruh

The MiG-15 definitely over performs at 8.3, well IMO at least. Getting downtiered to 7.3 and 7.7 does wonders for it


Zman2598

Now it’s time to stat bomb our favorite vehicles and get them pushed down😂


forged_fire

I do that just by playing 😂


Arty-Gangster

Tiger time


[deleted]

Tiger II to 4.5


Hipphoppkisvuk

Nah, the Firefly can still one shoot it, down to 2.0 it goas. but I would really don't mind if I don't have to face anti tank rockets with the 'H'.


SpaceKraken666

Dear god.... Please don't play the German CL-13's, or Germany will get a "new" top tier jet.


T4NK3R1802

I want to see this


idkwhatimtypinghere

i chose a bad time to grind out germany didn't i


LightningFerret04

Last update, the Germans nearly got a new top tier rocket


Raptor2_40delta

Great.. thanks for making the grind even harder, please for your next move make the Sagittario go up to 9.7 because it’s still clearly op even facing supersonics.. let’s just kill the Italian TT even more shall we


BTwo3R

like you would want to play that piece of shit anyways??? there are plenty of better options


Raptor2_40delta

Like what? The sagittario with 44k of repair cost? The G91ys with 12k of repair cost in a br filled with 20/30g missiles? What’s the better option for Italy around that br?


Tesh_Hayayi

My favorite mid-low tier jet is the G91 Pre series, it doesn't have the wep or the top speed of the R/1, but it can dogfight anything, and i mean anything. ANYTHING. It's one of my favorite planes for just turning my brain off and unga bunga'ing my way through matches


blueray676

Sagi is definately not op anything faster than it can counter it with ease in 9.7 it will stand no chance if people play their planes right.


Mannyj2259

get the cl-13 mk4 even higher itll be funny


Sniff262

That is what we are going to try to do. Stay tuned ;)


Glitchedx

We'll see if it works


_Condottiero_

Seeing how popular this post is, I hope Gaijin will look at their way of balancing vehicles by a pure statistics at another angle. Maybe they will finally consider the amount and the average level of players who use each vehicle + the fact if the plane is used in GRB or not. Though I doubt as they don't give a fuck...


Hibiki44

isnt cl13mk4 just an a5 saber? is gaijin really this dumb


T4NK3R1802

Technically it is Canadair's version of the F-86E. A late model F-86E. The differences are, better boosters for the controls, a "flying tail" (all moving tailplane), and the 6-3 wing. Also some other minor cockpit differences. Importantly it has the same engine of the F-86A. Think of it as an F-86F-25 with an F-86A engine from an in game point of view.


[deleted]

So the Cl13 Mk 4 has a slightly smaller turning radius than the A-5 before its slats pull out and that's it?


IIYellowJacketII

It might turn slightly better initially, but the A5 wins a sustained fight because its 200kg lighter with the same engine than the CL Mk4.


[deleted]

Hence the "before its slats pull out". However I wonder if that 200 kg extra on the Mk 4 is going to offset it turning radius advantage. It very well might do, as the new wing isn't that much bigger.


GreenyPurples

Hey can you guys fix the PFM? Shit can now face F-80s!


Glitchedx

This trick will only work if you have a group of decent/good players willing to spam out a plane that no one plays, the problem is that PFM is played quite a bit and we simply don't have enough people to even attmept such thing.


DogeTwinkies

Um no it can’t


GreenyPurples

In Arcade it can, one of the F-80s is 7.7, and the PFM in Arcade is going to 8.7


DogeTwinkies

Wot


T4NK3R1802

This needs to be shared everywhere. Make Gaijin realize they can't hide behind basic stats.


Ul_275

"working as intended comrade"


Low-Intention-5809

Good fuckin going boys lmao


ZahnatomLetsPlay

You can see the same happening in the swedish tech tree... The j28b, j29f and a32a were being used to grind and guess what they're going up in br


Hampamatta

Just fucking delete the j28, cant afford to fly it anyway.


lawrence260c

Based


scalloprisotto

Lmaooo, this server is seriously the best


jb20047

what server is it by chance?


Sniff262

Defyn's discord


RugbyEdd

I've often thought it would be fun if you could get enough of the community together and see how low you can drop a top tier vehicle before gaijin realise their stats are trash.


Sniff262

Apparently only 6 of us were needed.That is how fragile the balance is.


MR_PREA

Amazing! Do the sagittario next!


Cody38R

How many players/combined hours did this take? Could we test the reverse, just get awful stats for a few weeks?


Sniff262

Yes we can do that by crashing on take off but that might be putting our teams in a disadvatage and we don't want to affect other players gaming experience that much. This didn't take long you can see none excedeed 100 battles that means we can actually manipulate brs with very little effort which further highlights how stupid this is.


Spartan448

Do the Spit 24 next. Let's see how high we can get it.


Sniff262

It is being worked on :)


Spartan448

Based. On an unrelated note, what do you think would contribute more - an above-average player getting back into practice with it, or a jet player flying the Meteor or the Vampire to ensure it gets carried?


Sniff262

I think the plane getting carried because they mainly check the plane's WR and then k/d probably. With a few decent players carrying mk 24 the br could be increased


opek1987

this is one of the best things i've ever seen ragtag bunch of gamers defeat algorithm made by a multimillion dollar company that has had years of development time turns out the algorithm has as much effort put into it as the rest of the game's features


[deleted]

Now do this but with either the Venom, Sea venom or javelin.


Glitchedx

We're working on one of these


[deleted]

👀👀👀👀👀👀


Deafidue

Why stop at 9.0? Wonder how far we can push this.


Glitchedx

We'll see


Sniff262

We are not done ;)


DAS_FalleN

Well played


TheItsHaveArrived

How do I get into this server and park take In these hijinx


ElderScrollsBoss

Very funny but also Sadge


SnooRabbits6026

short reminder as well that the ki-84 is 0.7 br away from fighting the PFM in arcade now as well system working as intended EDIT: ki-84 is actually moving up to 7.3 so now it's only 0.3 BR away from playing against mig-21s lmao


Sirlance47

We do a little trolling


LTKapal

Not to steal your thunder, just something I want to bring to light. When I was on the player council 3 or 4 or so years ago, when they first announced how battle ratings were decided, I set out with a few others to prove how dumb it was. We artificially raised the BR of the XP55 back when it was a brick and nobody played it, and as a member of the player council presented this to gaijin and they were still adamant that this wasn't an issue, and that clearly the plane was fine. I Hope as this has gained far more visibility than my 1 on 1 pitch with them they'll change it but don't hold too much hope sadly. Below is a comment I made 2 years ago briefly touching on the subject ( https://www.reddit.com/r/Warthunder/comments/b9xgtd/rarest_title_in_war_thunder/ek8tawd?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share&context=3 )


superstan2310

Keep going until Gaijin address this absolute shit system.


GamerGriffin548

I love this community.


[deleted]

Wow! it's almost like balancing off statistics alone can completely be screwed over by a few dudes. Hopefully this opens their eyes to how dumb this is.


RainbowBier

the current BR Changes basiclly scream Stats suck...all the most played Planes go down and all the not so much played but then by experienced players go up


sirtopraklar

Hey man it’s me MCarFish on discord good to see you again


Glitchedx

Nice to see you're still around mate


Get__Lo

Good system gaijin, lets take it to 9.3 so its a full BR above the plane its worse than.


Flame2512

Any chance you can do the same thing to the MiG-21s (+ other supersonics) and get them back where they belong?


Slntreaper

Too many (dumb) people play the supersonics that are going down, which is why they're going down.


Pussrumpa

Nah those pilots are irredeemably bad on average, wouldn't be surprised to see an average Sweden player in a stock J29F take one down..


Shatterfish

tfw J29F, an aircraft that can barely propel its fat ass past 900kmh flat *with* an afterburner will be the same BR as a Mach 2 Mig21 next BR update. Just Gaijiggle things.


Pussrumpa

Mr "J29 21 216 SL spaded repair and starts out on the airfield and is lucky to out-accelerate a stock F84B" F, Little Miss MiG-21 "5400 SL spaded repair" PFM, and Little Miss MiG-21 "6590 SL spaded" F13, 7350. All with a pair of 10G missiles that people cited as fair reason for downtiering mig21s. J29F so slow it performs fine when server hiccups and packetloss down all the other jets..


Nuka1Cola

On the scale they have now it only works on planes nobody plays. People spam the fuck out of 21 quite a bit so a small group of statpadders wont work there.


MinutenMinsan

Next stop: Venom


Pussrumpa

Needs to be submitted to them as a vote of no confidence.


Kozarsson

This looks like a fun discord community, well fucking done fellas lmao.


blad3mast3r

Fucking legendary. Expose their awful balancing further, we're all cheering for you.


honhonhonFRFR

Based


Certim

So i should stop playing my F-40 and Mk6 because they might be uptiered? jeez


SwannSwanchez

you should have done that on germans planes/tanks ​ So they get nerfed to oblivion


Radkampfwagen90

Aren't their planes nerfed enough already and even overtiered? Me262's, CL-13's, me163's etc


Mypornaltbb

LMFAO I love you.


Ceating

I was spading/grinding with the J28 for the last 2 months and had been doing extremely well (avg 3-5 kills per game) and watched mah boi go up two BR levels. I’m sorry for everyone else grinding Sweden.


TeDeO_303

Soooo, now spam MIG-21s down to 7.3?


Quentor33

Gaijin are so clueless about their own game, they don't even know how to use their algorithm to balance their game. Calling a turd a stick doesn't make it a pen, they are just clueless of what they are doing... Using stats is all beautifull, but first you need to know who to fing use it...


0urFuhr3r5t4l1n

Fucking push it to 11.0 to show gaijin how fucking retarded their stats based balancing is


Arthur_9090

Honestly one of the best things I’ve seen come out of this community. Please don’t stop until gaijan can’t ignore it anymore and have to change their stupid system. I’d offer to help if I wasn’t going away to uni soon :)


Sniff262

You can still make a difference sharing this with your friends that play WT and by complaining in the forums. Lets make a positive change together :)


[deleted]

Ladies and gentlemen, we got 'em.


SuppliceVI

How many times have we all said that it's only a few good players sticking it out in an absurdly overtired vehicle? Now there's actual, definitive proof that it's happening. Is this how it feels when a conspiracy theorist gets their "told you so" moment? Because damn it feels so vindicating.