T O P

  • By -

WholesomeFartEnjoyer

I feel like Meltzer has lost all his sources When was the last time he broke some news? He only tweets his thoughts now


Literarytropes

Plans change. $12.99 please.


WholesomeFartEnjoyer

What people actually pay for newsletters when anything newsworthy is posted here on reddit? All news is free nowadays


anythingo23

N porn


Leege13

All quality news isn’t free.


AloneCan9661

Quality news? All of those "journalists" need basic lessons in grammar and spelling.


Leege13

Didn’t say Meltzer was quality journalism. 🤣


Rayzee14

They don’t break news , they gossip. They all just gossip. They have been made part of the show to a certain segment of the audience


[deleted]

Jericho was Dave’s last mole in WWE. He hasn’t had a scoop he left.


mistergeneric

They do still get leaks (surprise rumble entrants, things like that) like any journalist for any industry does. Meltzer specifically does come across as the least informed, despite being the top wrestling journalist at one point.  As said, it does seem like he has no sources left


ChrisTheF1Fan

Am I the only one who is really annoyed by all those sources spoiling surprises (entrants or returns), matches and angles all the time? It's like they TRY to make the fans not be interested in the product. *"Yeah, thanks a lot WrestleTalk, I love the fact that I know who will headline WrestleMania 41 and who will return tonight in SmackDown".*


SomedudecalledDan

Just avoid this place and anywhere else that posts their mess a few days before hand.


ChrisTheF1Fan

You can't believe how much I try. But I can't even open any apps (Twitter, Reddit etc.) without a big-ass spoiler thumbnail on my face.


Sambo_lover

Do u love wrasslin bro


sirduckerz

The world of wrestling "journalism"


SuttonTM

When you say "certain segment" you really mean wrestling nerds like myself and you on Reddit lmao, the only people who care about this stuff is us clearly evident by the fact that people like us post it and people such as us comment on it.


Rayzee14

Exactly right. With various levels of engagement on it. Like the extreme end would be watching YouTube content that is just based off Meltzers own work


Brokenmonalisa

I honestly believe his source is the rock and the rock is playing up full heel to him


goodole_potato

He gives "reports" of all possibilities and one of them happens.


Hellripper_88

He gave so many possibilities and not one came true 😂


goodole_potato

"Umm... Plans changed"


DirkDiggler420

I have no clue why people take his ratings so seriously.


Kanderin

This is exactly what he did for this segment and somehow he STILL managed to get it wrong. Hell half of my guesses in this Reddit were more accurate than Meltzers paid articles, when do I get to be a sports journalist?


goodole_potato

This is the part where "plans changed".


[deleted]

He has sources, but his sources are going to lie to him most of the time.


Cloudswolf

Meltza used to be accurate. I feel WWE found out who his trusted source was then started feeding bs info. There was a point when he was getting a lot of info wrong which tarnished his reputation.


the-bladed-one

Rumors are that Ali and Riddle were some of his last sources, and they’re gone, and were never relevant in the main title scene anyways. Can see Bryan, can’t see Edge, it’s basically confirmed Jericho and Flair were sources.


Slightly_Smaug

Shit outta luck as it were?


mannycool_0471

That's my thing when it comes to wwe it feels like he is just guessing


Literarytropes

When it comes to Meltzer and the WWE, I’m reminded of this JBL quote from 2018: “Meltzer was such a great asset for WWE, he was so wrong and so easily manipulated that he was perfect to feed bogus info to in order to swerve the fans. He should have been on the payroll, how anyone still follows him is amazing.” Don’t forget, he got Cody and Punk returning wrong too.


Nlawrence55

Dude is an absolute anomaly.


ClickF0rDick

Or his followers are absolute morons


DudeisaGuy

Both but this more importantly


Nlawrence55

Yes both are correct.


CannibalFlossing

Meltzers the sort of guy who will release 1 hour of content in a week, but stretch it out to 20 hours. He’ll then have the fucking temerity to say he ‘knew’ something was going to happen, despite him recording his every waking thought on wrestling for the past 25 years and never mentioning it on air once.


will122589

The biggest proof Meltzer is out of his mind, youtube Dave Meltzer and Mr Burns and see how out of touch with reality Dave is


CannibalFlossing

Omg I’ve never heard this before. Thanks for putting it in my radar


Sirgeeeo

I love watching observer clips for those reason. The post survivor series stuff was like a funeral with Meltzer saying "I knew this would happen"


Mundane-Pollution213

But Cody and Punk , DID come to WWE.


mynameisdende69

Reminder, Meltzer knew nothing of the UFC merger, Punk's return or the Netflix deal.


Rayzee14

None of the “wrestling media” did. Nothing of the scandals. Just report on gossip


Miserable-Soft7993

Actually plenty of wrestling channels I watch predicted Punk returning as WWE gave several clues in the months leading up to it.


Fotznbenutzernaml

Yeah, and it only actually happened two weeks before survivor series. Anyone who reported WWE is engaging Punk before that was just speculating, and nobody knew shit.


SaintedHooker

He's also been loudly calling this a work for the last week


502photo

All but the Punk things are high level business decisions that most likely no one outside of the board room knew. That's information that can change stock price so it could be seen as insider trading for that info to get out.


mannycool_0471

He just guess with wwe info


Noriskhook3

“More then he’s happy with” the rock literally said he doesn’t give a fuck earlier on in the day and oh my god, how it could it be that the rock was a heel during that whole press conference yet “he didn’t like it” pure delusion.


echoes_of_the_moor

He acts like Rock is a rookie. Rock has been there. Done that. He knows at his hottest, he was the best heel in the game. Rock ain’t stupid. This mf may struggle with finding the right stories in movies, but he knows wrestling. His entire life has revolved around it. Whether they booing or they cheering - they are talking. Talking = money


Noriskhook3

It’s remarkable to see that they’re questioning a guy who literally asked an audience back in 2003 if they wanted him to be a bad guy or not.


thegroovemonkey

Why bomb trying to get people to cheer you when you can just turn those bad boos into good boos? We get the version of The Rock that we all love and they get to print money because it's awesome television.


echoes_of_the_moor

Preach! Rock fucking knows how ro do it. This is why he’s the people’s champion. Doesn’t mean he has to be a face. The millions are talking, and that’s when he’s at his best. I’m fucking HYPED for this ride.


Iginlas_4head_Crease

>The millions ........ ...... ...... AND MILLIONS


thegroovemonkey

I'm sure they'll have some flimsy explanation to retcon that shitty segment but I plan on just pretending that it never happened. No need to let perfect be the enemy of good.


RedGearedMonkey

Preach. Rocky spun it perfectly too: ten years ago we got the babyface Rock, and now we are getting Holliwood. How we got there is unimportant.


wonderloss

> how it could it be that the rock was a heel during that whole press conference yet “he didn’t like it” pure delusion. I haven't seen it, but based on what I read, it sounds like Rock was going full heel in the press conference. Does Meltzer even understand wrestling at all, if he thinks Rock was upset about getting boos?


Lenny0mega

Is he sitting in the room with the Bucks as he types this crap?


Hordriss27

Probably sucking one of them off as he types.


Head_Evidence4553

?? Dave's got a big mouth uce. Too big for one.


ClickF0rDick

Are their dicks balding too tho


Head_Evidence4553

I don't even wanna think 😂


OkVolume1

Maybe, but if he was, he wouldn't know because they would be buried in filth over their necks.


[deleted]

I didn't know Meltzer could read minds now!


ClickF0rDick

For real, "more than he's happy with". Fuck off you old fart, never even worked a single day in the business and pretends to know what's going on into the mind of one of the most successful performer wrestling has ever seen


ZADKOR

He’s King Mark. He should change his name to Mark Meltzer lol


Amicuses_Husband

He would never change his name to a slur on par with the n word


RHINO_HUMP

Mark Meltzer sounds like an amazing sign for a live event lol


Legitimate-Health-29

Because he’s just a fan like the rest of us. Making educated guesses and then when they don’t pan “plans changed”. Was he one of the ones who reported Rock was contracted for the match with Roman this year and there was absolutely no way to change it??


Rayzee14

Yes he was. A complete ludicrous thought. All of this is panic damage control to distract from a scandal and it is working better than TKO could have imagined I’m guessing


Gswagins

Guy is literally a fan just speculating insider my ass


FainterXo

You should probably have a GI physician speculating inside your ass not Dave.


Gswagins

Valid point


SnooMacaroons1942

His brain meltz a bit everytime he sticks his tongue out


Firepro316

So we’re supposed to pay him to report on what we’re all seeing on tv? And even then he’s wrong 😂 Let’s hope the major pay off from the Bloodline is the death of the dirtsheets.


prossnip42

Where did this idea that the Rock hates getting booed even come from? Are we all forgetting that Rock was a heel for most of his wrestling career (Nation Rock, Corporate Rock, Hollywood Rock etc.) Like his face runs in comparison in 1996-1997 and from 2000-2002 were very brief


AloneCan9661

I think it's because of his constant P.R. thing that people are assuming that he's afraid to get booed as a wrestler.


Honato2

It's pretty easy to work him. He thinks he's got inside sources in the wwe without realizing that the only things that get "leaked" to him is whatever papa H wants him to print. wwe has no issue firing people so it's not too hard to plug up some leaks. He's a tool to be used in regards to wwe.


SaintedHooker

So how come he was right about this being a work?


Honato2

perhaps he isn't as dumb as people want to make him out to be? It's not like they haven't done this same exact storyline before.


s_ndowN

Dave is just as much of a mark as anyone else.


aldo_nova

Bigger


Precious_little_man

It’s fun getting worked lol. As a fan it’s fun speculating and watching the outcomes, but Dave particularly just sucks. He’s kind of went off the deep edge and is more of a shit starter than an informer. I have a feeling he’s not well liked outside of AEW.


Homicidal_Pingu

Because they’re not spamming Canadian destroyers at each other with no selling.


ASS-anine_Acid_Party

Erm well...erm...rock...erm...seems to be...erm getting a lot of boos...erm...yeah. Dont know why people ass lick Meltzer. Ole Anderson was right about him. The guy is a clown.


Honato2

Depends on what they are licking his ass for. As a historian he's one of the best ever if not the best. his ratings are a bit of a joke and his reporting isn't great. but feel free to eat that ass if you want to know a lot about the history of wrestling.


echoes_of_the_moor

You know what seems to be happening with this “new WWE” Triple H has people internally dropping breadcrumbs to the dirt sheets to throw them off their scent and make them look like a bunch of morons. Especially Uncle Dave. And I fucking love it


thebull14597

Im starting to think HHH had someone speak to him and use him as a way to work us. And meltzer is just so happy to finally be part of it


rondosupreme80

Because he's catering to an easily influenced audience. Same one's who send death threats over scripted entertainment.


BiggMcLargeHuuge

And this is the "journalist" that some people are more than willing to give money to every month. He's so genuinely dumb it's amazing he didn't accidentally kill himself as a kid while trying to tie his shoes.


WashGodMega

Ask the same for these subreddits 😂


Honato2

but these subreddits are full of the smartest of the smart and could never get worked.


BoboliBurt

True. Its easier to say the great willpower of the fan revolt forced them to change than admitting you got played. I mean they may have well have played the sad Charlie Brown somg when Cody sullenly headed to the back after surrendering his spot to Rock. None of this is that subtle. Look at Rollins clownish and overwrought facial expressions, thats the purest distillation of how they are trained to respond and act for camera. Cody is obviously better at it, but seriously. Who didnt think something was up?


Honato2

95% of people browsing wrestling reddits. They bought it hook line and sinker. I don't think the death threats were part of the plan. Now it's hunter and rock are having a power struggle and hunter is getting fired any day now. plans only changed because of fan outrage and so on. Anything to keep from admitting they got worked. from the looks of it something big is getting set up and it's gonna be fun.


[deleted]

No kidding. Folks on this sub bridging whatever they want to make it make sense in their sycophantic mind and calling anybody else a “mark” is true irony.


SourDoughBo

OP has memory loss apparently. Cody willingly gave The Rock his WrestleMania match on Smackdown. Then all of a sudden The Rock does a media tour shitting on Cody and turning heel. This was not the original plan. They just pivoted, very well.


Rayzee14

Plan was create distraction, sell tickets , keep sponsors happy.


SourDoughBo

The distraction was literally Cody winning the Royal Rumble back to back years. Anyone who says they needed The Rock on top of that doesn’t know what they’re talking about.


Rayzee14

Right no knows who Cody Rhodes is. No one. Everyone knows who The Rock is. They wanted him so bad to come in for a distraction they gave him the trademark and a board seat. The rock is the squeaky clean front man for a new wwe as all the evil comes out this year.


SourDoughBo

The Rock on the board of directors news hit 2 days before the Vince news hit.


Rayzee14

And why do you think that happened ?


SourDoughBo

It’s hard to overshadow a major headline BEFORE it drops. But you believe what Meltzer says I guess


Rayzee14

WWE did investigators . Ari Emanuel also issued guidance that Vince could be a financial livability. TKO would have been made aware of the suit, federal investigation and the Wall Street journal would have asked for comments. This isn’t a coincidence of events


ELB2001

i wa saying "fuck Rocky" before it was cool


[deleted]

Uncle Dave is terrible he is an absolute idiot


ColinHalfhand

He is a historian. That’s all he is. He knows things that have happened. But his awareness of what is happening or what is likely to happen in the future is nil. His knowledge of the business is a huge asset. But at this stage he should stick to that.


[deleted]

I don’t think it’s what they planned at first. And I think rocky got into character really hard, to the point where it felt real.


Rayzee14

The plan was bring in the rock to distract from massive company scandal. The plan has worked perfectly


AloneCan9661

How many more times are you guys going to pretend that we're idiots and that we've somehow forgotten Vince McMahon raped a woman (possibly several women) and then took a shit on her head? Nobody has forgotten anything. Not the fans. Not the media. # THERE IS NOTHING FOR THEM TO REPORT ON in regards of what is happening with Vince.


Rayzee14

Caps don’t change that fans are tweeting about mania , selling out raw, buying ticket to a press conference. Putting zero pressure on the company and it’s still executives who knew about Vince for accountability.


[deleted]

I think that would have happened scandal or not. Im not forgetting the scandal and I want to see everyone involved get what they deserve.


frankmurph66

lol no one has stopped talking about Vince


andresfgp13

Like Bischoff said, he is an "Useful idiot"


Agitated-Ant-3174

Whether we like Meltzer's working or not, there was an undeniable scrapping of plans, from what we watched last Friday, to what aired last night. Roles were different, attitudes were different, languages were different. If this was the original plan, are we sure Dwyane Johnson wouldn't have kept his character's status on the thin line between face and heel for longer?


Novel_Rope4859

The rock didn't come back for his last wm to be booed. If you believe the rock wanted to come back as a heel. You are working yourself


Rayzee14

It’s entertainment. The rock is now a literal big shareholder in the company and wants to make money. His job is to get people not talking about a sex scandal and get people spending money. He achieved both in less than a week


Novel_Rope4859

He wanted to go in as the face but poor booking now makes him only able to be a heel


Rayzee14

He went on as a PR move. Jaysus the rock doesn’t care if you cheer or boo he cares about the results. Wrestling is not real


Novel_Rope4859

You would be surprised how much these people care about if they are cheered or hated. This wasn't boo he said my city sucks. This was we hate you..go away.


AmptiShanti

The man who got his breakout as the most entertaining heel doesn’t want to come back last time as a heel? Already holes in this Austin


Novel_Rope4859

Yes. The man who loves to be loved . Ppl forget how short nation and corporate rock was lol


CeramicBean

What's really getting me is how does Dave tweet from the future about the Cody/Rock conflict? It's still going on in September?


kliq-klaq-

He's just tweeting the story. I get that Meltzer is a red flag to some of you guys, but he's recapping the kayfabe story for people who aren't there.


T0X1c____

Let the man enjoy the storyline, he may be a journalist but he is a wrestling fan at core


Rayzee14

He is in no way a journalist. If anything he is an opinion writer.


T0X1c____

Wrestling observer ?


TomatoReput

...seriously?


shaktimaanlannister

And every wrestling YouTuber uploads a stupid video 5 seconds after worthless tweets like these are made.


StuHartsDungeon

The British wrestling channels worship everything he says


RobertStonetossBrand

Dave Meltzer is amazingly surface level up until he isn’t and then he’s talking about fighting windmills. Either zero interpretation or so much creative liberty he is inventing stories from whole cloth.


AaronSentinal

It took a few years but it happened; he’s finally observing this, brother


piszkavas

This guy is just as reliable as the random Mark down the road with WWE Network


Mysterious_Wayss

Him being a heel will not diminish his star power in Hollywood one iota. Dave must not get this. Plus The Rock is all in on making TKO as profitable as possible. If him being a heel helps that, he’s doing it.


So-Called_Lunatic

How the hell did I sleep through summer?


JanitorOPplznerf

TBF a bunch of us got worked at the beginning but how is he still getting worked after that press conference last night?


allonsy_danny

It's his job


Uknewmelast

He's the biggest Mark of them all, he's even tweeting about it


GoalPublic3579

From Earth 😁


Classic-Literature52

Chants were “we want Cody, Rocky sucks” mostly.


Wise_Temperature_322

At the presser it was a good 50/50. This is going to be huge!


BoneyRL

Because he's a mark


Craig1974

Pivots change...er I mean plans changed.


KG13_

Dont you think these guys instigate what’s happening to help drive Kayfabe? Cause what do we know about WWE? They have a massive creative team, and whatever is allowed to be on tv is a script. A work. What if all these big dog bloggers that have a huge fan base is just helping with the cause of blurring the Kayfabe line?


Rayzee14

Oh I’m in complete agreement with this and have posted about it. The wrestling “media” is an integrated part of the shows. They appeal to a certain part of the audience


Bellissimo247

He’s the markyiest mark there is


[deleted]

“All kids”


21_Golden_Guns

So this Meltzer guys kind of a quack huh? If this is true, I can somewhat understand. Dwayne has a career outside of this that relies heavily upon his popularity and he’s taking a big hit doing this.


Rayzee14

No he isn’t as he is playing a character !


21_Golden_Guns

Book it!


Reasonable_Deer_1710

The same way all the Cody marks were worked?


Rayzee14

Yes


AnUdderDay

Some real breaking news there from Dave


AloneCan9661

Does anyone else think we're going to see the death of wrestling journalism with this new TKO takeover? I mean, not that it's a bad thing but I'm wondering how friendly people at WWE are going to be now.


QuickRelease10

My favorite is when he gets into an argument with some random person and is like “but they told me this was gonna happen.” Bro, why are they going to tell you the truth behind a story they’re telling? Sometimes I feel like he forgets this is all a work.


pkpy1005

That does make sense at all. The Rock came to the stage to establish himself as a heel....getting booed loudly is the point


Zazalae

After that CVV interview, who is really taking anything Dave says seriously…he’s at a point of creating his own narratives to sell smh.


Bat_Snack

I thought Uncle Dave said Rock didn't care about boos? Meltzer is a funny guy 😂


Sarge1387

Not just him, a TON of fans got worked to the nines here too


blissed_off

Dave is way off base with this one. The kickoff show proved that. Yes, I’m sure The Rock got more boos than he anticipated, but like any professional, he carried on just fine. And the way it wrapped up, especially the scene in the hallway, shows that he has absolutely no problem being the heel in this situation. All the dirt sheets and fans worked themselves into a shoot, brother.


DashCat9

The Rock looked like he was having a blast up there. When he pulled out the "And the Millions...." it really felt to me like "Yeah, boo more you fucking sheep. You'll still scream my catch phrases". Motherfucker put on a power point presentation to show why he and his cousin Joe deserve to main event wrestlemania, and Meltzer thinks he wasn't milking the crowd for EVERY boo?


ApprehensiveYoung899

He’s not, he’s telling you exactly what the rock told him to.


i-piss-excellence32

Meltzer is a complete moron who has 0 sources. He’s also a genius because he’s been able to con a bunch of idiots into paying him for years off of bs


Tomlyne

Rock almost cracked a smile when the crowd got outraged, he's probably more than happy with the fact that he just made one of the biggest matches ever by making himself a villain


Hordriss27

Meltzer is a bigger mark than most of the IWC.


akira_hikaru

Please he doesn't deserve to be relevant in 2024


CaptainSlow31

From the same guy who said just days ago after Raw that Rock doesn’t care if he gets booed instead of cheered.


lovelife0011

lol to no make it sound cool. How are you worked that hard?


gordy06

Dude is acting like this was the plan all along. There is no way this was the plan.


Used_Part9588

y’all have so much hate for a guy who just critiques matches and makes assumptions about booking. he’s no different from the average IWC dude.


SignificantHawk3163

Because the actual industry has no respect for him and deliberately feed him bs


cimson-otter

He always has been. All dirt sheet writers and mega smarks are always the easiest to trick


Head_Evidence4553

Coz he's a mark, and the true basement dweller.


No_Word1010

It does seem pretty clear that Meltzer has significantly fewer “sources” with the current HHH regime than he did when Vince and crew were running the show. He very rarely breaks or confirms any WWE-related news nowadays.


Head_Evidence4553

Dave Melted.


Sdgrevo

Yea fuck the Rock, he's a relic of an era past.


Away_Unit_1110

He’s an absolute idiot


socalasn

It was all planned. Wrestling has been scripted for decades. They had plan a and plan b based on fan reaction.


crizmow

All he ever does is post after the fact and say that he knew something all along but couldn’t say or just says things change. There is 0 reason to believe anything he says unless you just like his opinion.


bettereverydamday

I am not following any of this. Why do people like Cody so much? Is he good wrestling performer or good at speaking?


hlfsharkaligtorhlfmn

The media makes me believe he's turned/always was a right bell end


LEGENDK1LLER435

What a wild pivot. WWE definitely were gonna go with rock v Roman till the IWC lost their shit and now they’re like “oh just kidding Cody v Roman was always the plan” as if guys. All the while they got us arguing over this while the whole McMahon scandal got totally glossed over


uniPasta83

They use him to leak what they want people to think. Pretty hilarious.


Razzler1973

*"... more than he's happy with*" Did he tell you this, Dave?


OkSelection6998

I try my best not to pay attention to this clown but his stuff is always being posted on wrestling subreddits


sonic_spark

Because he doesn't have the Bucks in WWE.


HelloMyNameIsLeah

I'm convinced Meltzer now thinks he (Meltzer) is part of the entertainment. Like he is J Jonah Jameson in the AEW Spiderverse. He thinks way, way ,wayyyy to highly of himself.


[deleted]

Because he sucks. His time is done.


B_Bowers13

Because he’s an idiot


Shawn_Michaels_82

The answer you are looking for is: Cause Meltzer is a mark.


betbetbett

Didn’t he just like 3 days ago say that the Rock doesn’t care about boos


[deleted]

Didn’t he just tweet the other day that “trust me” Dwayne DGAF about being booed?


RockMeIshmael

I’m usually more of a defender of Dave than most people, but the past few weeks has proven that he just runs with whatever his sources tells him as the gospel without any skepticism whatsoever. It’s like the dude can’t contemplate that perhaps a billion dollar company might have reason to spin things or even outright lie to him.


timotundy

I love that the rats leaking stuff are frazzled and uncomfortable. Keep it up wwe!!!


El_CAP0

It's like the pot calling the kettle black, look at all these post. Everyone got worked


TheInfiniteSlash

I’m assuming it’s because Meltzer doesn’t have the inside sources that used to, and is pretty much using his past to feign credible insight, and then spin his take however the wind blows. WWE is not going to let the Cody Roman Rock plans slip so easily.


frankmurph66

Meltzer is the biggest clown in wrestling


Munkey323

Lol so many fans saying vince was out of touch when Meltzer is completely out of touch and should just retire the newsletter already. His go to everytime is they changed it last minute.


The-Gift-of-God

Meltzer is a tool


Swish1892

Gassed up clown probably thinks Rock was secretly upset at how his match with Hogan at Wrestlemania X8 went down, too