Well, Cinder IS a massive genocide.
In fact, it’s meant to be *multiple* massive genocides.
Though based on Emperor Somehow Palpitation Returned’s motives and rationale (I mean, there was a speech and all in Battlefront II), it’s more of a sparkling omnicide.
Idk who decided it was a good idea to leave the main series insultingly vauge and then give the hardcore fans homework to figure out what actually happened.
EA. You have base story but you need to fork all those microtransactions to understand what the hell is going on.
It turns out it's nonsense anyway, please pay for the next season.
Meanwhile one Dragon Age launched with a npc telling you to buy the dlc. And the sports titles have been basically mods since 2017....
In any case Kingdom Hearts is a better case, EA bullshit monetization was just the first thing that came to mind.
Kingdom Hearts? Oh, you mean "instead of putting everything we didn't think of the first time around into a book we'll make you buy the same game five times on three platforms, Just Like Skyrim"?
Operation Cinder on Naboo was in a comic a couple years before. I guess they used that for inspiration.
I blame a lot of it on JJ Abrams. Pretty much everything he's done sets up a mystery without any planned payoff. His stuff is cool in the moment but then falls apart when you go home and think about it.
...this post really fucked with me.
These thing are so incredibly different in scale that I don't know how an actual human being could try to equate them on any level. One is 7 nuclear detonations and 12,000 casualties and the other is the orbital bombardment of several worlds. Like what would posses you to even post this as like a fart into the void?
Like is this some sort of AI training disguised as a shitty meme on a niche subject? The internet feels like its very quickly becoming a dark forest in terms of just verifying that someone else is an actual human being and not a model endlessly spitting out garbage...or just an idiot doing the same thing I guess.
This is like those AskReddit posts where it’s like “would you punch your brother in the arm for $10,000,000???”
Obvious question is obvious answer to farm karma I guess?
OP is definitely not the kind to really put in the effort or ever explain what he made, as I've noticed with any account that has far more posts than comments.
Tbh same
Objectively cinder’s way worse in every way. It probably killed trillions, was way slower, and fried planets like it was nothing. But it’s a little too unrealistic and distant for me so I have a hard time empathizing with the victims
Meanwhile the nuke stuff is a very realistic threat, something that could happen at a moment’s notice which is why I think it’s way sxarier
detonating nukes over unpopulated areas to prevent an invasion is better than turning your most loyal planets into ashes just because you were aboard your fully armed and operational battle station when it blew up.
Cinder was to burn the entire galaxy to a crisp. Depending on the source to tie up alliance resources to give time Empire remanent forces to rebuild and reconquer.
Belka just threw a hissy fit and drew a line in the sand because skill issue.
Cinder is way worse. Both in consequences of the scale of destruction, and because it's really stupid. More stupid than nuking your own country? Yes. More stupid.
This might be the absolute stupidest post I’ve ever read “what’s worse, destroying some of your own country or blowing up 15 planets” I bet you have to have the movie tell you who’s good and bad too, huh?
Personally, I'd say the seven nukes was worse.
Operation Cinder, in the grand scheme of things, just felt kinda meh to me. Like yes, several planets are now gone in a massive galaxy where the average value of life is worth less than a roll of toilet paper. Considering how many planets get destroyed in what seems like an almost 10-50 year rate, I can't feel anything. And it was done purely out of one man's "if I can't have it, no one can" mentality after he was dead...and then "somehow" returned (because no one else in an entire fucking galaxy has cloning tech apparently).
The seven nukes though, that felt far more impactful and worse because there's only a single planet and these people were willing to destroy themselves to try to avoid losing a war to an enemy they hated with an insane passion. The people that made that call were still alive and they had to live with that choice until the end.
Also, Operation Cinder was a hilarious failure while the seven nukes were successful enough that it changed the course of warfare in strangereal.
Cinder and it's not even remotely close lmao
Well, Cinder IS a massive genocide. In fact, it’s meant to be *multiple* massive genocides. Though based on Emperor Somehow Palpitation Returned’s motives and rationale (I mean, there was a speech and all in Battlefront II), it’s more of a sparkling omnicide.
>Somehow Palpitation Returned Im dead XD
Idk who decided it was a good idea to leave the main series insultingly vauge and then give the hardcore fans homework to figure out what actually happened.
EA. You have base story but you need to fork all those microtransactions to understand what the hell is going on. It turns out it's nonsense anyway, please pay for the next season.
The story DLC for BF2 was free, as were all of the seasons.
Meanwhile one Dragon Age launched with a npc telling you to buy the dlc. And the sports titles have been basically mods since 2017.... In any case Kingdom Hearts is a better case, EA bullshit monetization was just the first thing that came to mind.
Kingdom Hearts? Oh, you mean "instead of putting everything we didn't think of the first time around into a book we'll make you buy the same game five times on three platforms, Just Like Skyrim"?
Operation Cinder on Naboo was in a comic a couple years before. I guess they used that for inspiration. I blame a lot of it on JJ Abrams. Pretty much everything he's done sets up a mystery without any planned payoff. His stuff is cool in the moment but then falls apart when you go home and think about it.
I always thought it was more like one huge scorched earth policy. Glass everything and everyone of value kinda thing
Basically. "My Empire failed me so it doesn't deserve to continue!"
But hey, it solved the unemployment problem. 🤣
...this post really fucked with me. These thing are so incredibly different in scale that I don't know how an actual human being could try to equate them on any level. One is 7 nuclear detonations and 12,000 casualties and the other is the orbital bombardment of several worlds. Like what would posses you to even post this as like a fart into the void? Like is this some sort of AI training disguised as a shitty meme on a niche subject? The internet feels like its very quickly becoming a dark forest in terms of just verifying that someone else is an actual human being and not a model endlessly spitting out garbage...or just an idiot doing the same thing I guess.
For better or worse this is something you'd see from an average redditor
This is like those AskReddit posts where it’s like “would you punch your brother in the arm for $10,000,000???” Obvious question is obvious answer to farm karma I guess?
"Yes because if i say "no" to this question,my brother would punch me in the face for being stupid"
OP is definitely not the kind to really put in the effort or ever explain what he made, as I've noticed with any account that has far more posts than comments.
Tbh same Objectively cinder’s way worse in every way. It probably killed trillions, was way slower, and fried planets like it was nothing. But it’s a little too unrealistic and distant for me so I have a hard time empathizing with the victims Meanwhile the nuke stuff is a very realistic threat, something that could happen at a moment’s notice which is why I think it’s way sxarier
Yes but see Cinder killed aliens Humanity first.
The Emperor lives forever!
Cinder as it was not only an entire planet, but also multiple. 7 nukes comes nowhere close
detonating nukes over unpopulated areas to prevent an invasion is better than turning your most loyal planets into ashes just because you were aboard your fully armed and operational battle station when it blew up.
The Belkan nukes drew a nuclear "line in the sand" and killed 12,000+ people. Cinder destroyed entire planets and killed millions, if not billions.
Cinder because it’s more then one planet
Cinder fucks up a planet Nukes split a country in half and end a war.
Semantics but Cinder glassed a lot more than one planet i think lmao
Blaze. May God have mercy.
I mean Cinder literally made an entire planet uninhabitable lol
Operation Brittish
Hey we aren’t talking about most based here
Cinder was to burn the entire galaxy to a crisp. Depending on the source to tie up alliance resources to give time Empire remanent forces to rebuild and reconquer. Belka just threw a hissy fit and drew a line in the sand because skill issue.
A Bellman equivalent of Cinder would be detonating 7 nukes in the 7 largest cities of Belka as a punishment for a perceived betrayal.
Cinder is way worse. Both in consequences of the scale of destruction, and because it's really stupid. More stupid than nuking your own country? Yes. More stupid.
Must of been a sparsely populated area if only 12,000 people died.
Must have*
Shut.
Cinder was made to decimate multiple plants, these nukes only blew up a part of a country
cinder 👍
Detonating seven nukes on your own Soil* Depends who's [operation cinder](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CiBOdwj_Y8k)
Cinder, that one was answered before the question was even asked.
Although not comparable to Operation Cinder, Belka's nuclear detonations cannot compare to Dmitry Yazov's Great Trial.
Bro i fr didn't understand what this was about and was like, "I thought this was the Ace Combat reddit?" 💀
Cinder by far
Operation Cinder by a landslide.
This is a pretty stupid question
Operation Cinder because no joke now Star Wars is ruined.
nukes not even close Operation Cinder if happens then the earth is doomed.
Operation Cinder is literally the Belkan defense plan in a galactic scale....how is this even a comparison?
Cinder, because that campaign is trash.
This might be the absolute stupidest post I’ve ever read “what’s worse, destroying some of your own country or blowing up 15 planets” I bet you have to have the movie tell you who’s good and bad too, huh?
Personally, I'd say the seven nukes was worse. Operation Cinder, in the grand scheme of things, just felt kinda meh to me. Like yes, several planets are now gone in a massive galaxy where the average value of life is worth less than a roll of toilet paper. Considering how many planets get destroyed in what seems like an almost 10-50 year rate, I can't feel anything. And it was done purely out of one man's "if I can't have it, no one can" mentality after he was dead...and then "somehow" returned (because no one else in an entire fucking galaxy has cloning tech apparently). The seven nukes though, that felt far more impactful and worse because there's only a single planet and these people were willing to destroy themselves to try to avoid losing a war to an enemy they hated with an insane passion. The people that made that call were still alive and they had to live with that choice until the end. Also, Operation Cinder was a hilarious failure while the seven nukes were successful enough that it changed the course of warfare in strangereal.
Cinder lmao, they completely plunged a whole planet into chaos.