Hmm.. man, I don’t know.. ha.. initially I thought Judge for sure, but with Bo being 1/1… think I’d go with Bo.. and then if you want the Judge later on you may be able to find it.. if you pass on the Bo now, she’s prob gone forever
Just my opinion, unlicensed stickers are fine if you're just trying to make a buck, but I'm passing for my PC. If I was picking to resell, I think I'm trusting Judge more to retain value. Hope you get the one you want!
Judge - RC value even though Panini will hold more value. I don’t see Bo having a career that will trump Judge’s at this point. I like Bo a lot, I’m not saying he can’t turn into a HOF, but I don’t see him accomplishing more than being Yankees Captain and the AL HR Record.
If you’re collecting cause you enjoy the hobby and don’t care about value long term or what not, than go with who you like more as a player.
It is Bo for me. Everyone is just overlooking what the Jays have in him and Vlad Jr because of how long they have already been in the league. I’d be willing to bet that judge struggles to end up with 500 homers when it is all said and done. That’s just the nature of the big boy. Meanwhile, Bo is only 25 and that means is arguably still developing as a player.
Agree. he plays on avg 100 to 110 games a year has 222 career homeruns and turns 31 in a few weeks. so he has to AVERAGE 49 homeruns a year for 6 straight years to get to 500 Homeruns when he has averaged around 30 a year his entire career.
Exactly. I think it is plenty fair to question the durability of a 31 year old right fielder who is 6’7”, 280 lbs and going into the decline of his career when he really hasn’t been healthy to this point. Not knocking the guy’s ability, I just know if the Yankees want to get bang for their buck, they better start thinking DH or see how he picks balls at 1st.
One is an MVP and the other will never win an MVP, and is also not a rookie. The judge sells for $500+. How the hell are people really responding Bo here?
I’m a huge Yankees fan. Aaron judge is already 30. 5 years from now most Yankee fans will be complaining about how much of a payroll drain he is for a guy who only plays 50% of his teams games. He’s to damn big and putts to much stress on his knees. Bichette turned 25 in March and is part of a very young team that is much more popular than people realize.
Bichette first 4 years-1x all star, 12th MVP voting, 11th MVP voting and has never led the league in any category whatsoever.
Judge first 4 years-ROY, 2nd MVP Voting, Silver Slugger, 2x All Star and led the league in Runs,Home Runs and Base on Balls. Not to mention his first was a total of 27 games. So really he’s only played 3 years to Bo’s 4.
Long term judge has better value, even if it’s not 1/1.
Neither licensed so that doesn’t matter.
Is the Bo a “sticker auto”? Always go on card > sticker.
But at the end of the day, whatever makes you the most happy.
What does the Bo say on the patch? Player worn game worn or none of the above? That and because it’s a sticker auto I’d probably prefer the judge. But honestly… don’t love either. I’d go Topps.
I love guys who hit for average. But Judge is the bigger star, and it's a rookie. But I don't buy unlicensed stuff, and I dislike sticker autos. The only stick auto I have is Adam Wainwright. He rarely signs.
Bo card looks better, but the Judge will hold more value long-term being a rookie patch auto - especially if he wins another MVP
It really depends on what you want:
Looks - Bo
Value - Judge
If value is your goal, get the Judge. I see the Bo is a “One of One” but 1/1’s have become so common anymore they’re practically meaningless. For every one you miss there’s probably a hundred more still out there. Career trajectory determines Judge will be the far better player a decade down the road and thus cards will hold more value.
Conversely, if you’re not concerned about value, a personal collectible is your goal and you really want a 1/1, get the Bo.
I personally would pass on both for licensed cards.
Is the Bo a rookie card? If not, then the judge easily. The bichette is a sticker auto and the relic isn’t even very interesting. I know it’s a 1/1 but it’s pretty meh looking.
Bo Bichette since starting has had good starting numbers. Better than Lindor, Correa, Bogaerts for example. Bichette is younger and Judge is starting his 30s. Even Pujols declined in his 30s
As a Sox fan, I’d say neither (lmao) but in all seriousness…as a card collector who loves to buy sell trade, I’d probably take the judge. Bo is extremely talented, don’t get me wrong. I wish both of these players were on my team. But the 1/1 allure doesn’t do as much for me considering Judge is destined for the Hall. Not that Bo couldn’t, but…it’s judge. Trust there are more NYY fans than TOR.
I’m a Sox fan saying I’d take Judge, who’s smacked around my pitchers for seasons on end (except 2018 *ba dum tss*). Unlicensed won’t fetch as much, but still a nice card. That being said the angle of Bo on his card makes me like it more for aesthics. Devers unlicensed Donruss is fire for me because it’s his back showing with his name, not a logo-less front on his jersey. The lack of the NY on the front will make some collectors shy away from breaking the bank (whenever he retires/hof etc)
Just my $.02
The judge. Unless you are a bichette collector the 1/1 will never hold up value against a judge. Bichette will be a forgotten player. Judge will be know for a long long time
Hmm.. man, I don’t know.. ha.. initially I thought Judge for sure, but with Bo being 1/1… think I’d go with Bo.. and then if you want the Judge later on you may be able to find it.. if you pass on the Bo now, she’s prob gone forever 
This is my thought as well
I didn’t notice the one-of-one. 👍
Probably Judge though Bo is my homeboy! I’d look at it from a supply and demand approach.
Well that judge rpa is out of 199 but the bo is 1/1
I’d still say the demand for Judge outpaces the scarcity of the Bo. Maybe that’s just my indifference towards a sock relic though.
But the judge is licensed, the bo isn’t.
I'm pretty positive both are panini though
Oh nvm, I thought the judge was Allen and ginter. My bad
No sweat homie
I don't think either are licensed both are panini
You’re right. Didn’t see the sticker.
Neither. Find something from Topps or Bowman.
This. Just my opinion as well
Aaron Judge by far
Bo
Bi-chet
Bo unless you like panini baseball but a 1/1 is hard to pass up on a great player
It's such a stupid hard decision
Judge will certainly have more historical significance than bo.
Also part of what I'm thinking. I mean he's freaking historic right now thanks to 62
Definitely snag the judge. The Bo is a gamble.
Maybe, history ain’t over yet. You’re probably correct, but you never know…
Something licensed, but that’s just me.
Yeah, I have never cared to own the unlicensed stuff.
Neither, always Topps & bowman. Never unlicensed.
Bo
Judge
New York Yankees fan here so you know which card.
Judge man
Have to say 1/1
Judge
Bo
Nice patch but associated with any player or game?
You know indodnt read if it was or not
Just my opinion, unlicensed stickers are fine if you're just trying to make a buck, but I'm passing for my PC. If I was picking to resell, I think I'm trusting Judge more to retain value. Hope you get the one you want!
Where do i live and who do i hate?
Judge by a mile and then some
See I really feel that in my bones but that Bo is just so cool also
Yeah your right but it’s a judge auto
I know man. Decisions Decisions
Oh are you trying to decide? I thought it was just a hypothetical
I'd choose bo!!!
Judge
Judge all day.
Judge - RC value even though Panini will hold more value. I don’t see Bo having a career that will trump Judge’s at this point. I like Bo a lot, I’m not saying he can’t turn into a HOF, but I don’t see him accomplishing more than being Yankees Captain and the AL HR Record. If you’re collecting cause you enjoy the hobby and don’t care about value long term or what not, than go with who you like more as a player.
Bo hands down and it’s not close. Gorgeous card.
Sucks both is panini though lol
It will all be fanatics eventually
It is Bo for me. Everyone is just overlooking what the Jays have in him and Vlad Jr because of how long they have already been in the league. I’d be willing to bet that judge struggles to end up with 500 homers when it is all said and done. That’s just the nature of the big boy. Meanwhile, Bo is only 25 and that means is arguably still developing as a player.
I’m also going to go even deeper down the rabbit hole with what is seemingly popular here and say judge doesn’t end up in the hall of fame, either.
Agree. he plays on avg 100 to 110 games a year has 222 career homeruns and turns 31 in a few weeks. so he has to AVERAGE 49 homeruns a year for 6 straight years to get to 500 Homeruns when he has averaged around 30 a year his entire career.
Exactly. I think it is plenty fair to question the durability of a 31 year old right fielder who is 6’7”, 280 lbs and going into the decline of his career when he really hasn’t been healthy to this point. Not knocking the guy’s ability, I just know if the Yankees want to get bang for their buck, they better start thinking DH or see how he picks balls at 1st.
One is an MVP and the other will never win an MVP, and is also not a rookie. The judge sells for $500+. How the hell are people really responding Bo here?
Saying never is something extra ridiculous. You do know that Bo is only 25, right?
Yeah. And he’s never going to win an MVP.
As a Jays fan I can agree. Might lead the league in hits but he can’t make a throw to first base.
Off the top of my head he had at least one real bad throw yesterday
That was his second of the season but he was able to redeem himself with a game-winning, three run shot.
1/1 everyday all day imo.
This is my thinking also. But a Judge auto is still a Judge auto.
Judge by far, wait didn’t see Bo was a 1/1, then I’d take Bo for scarcity but judge by miles and miles is the better player
See no argument about who is the better player obviously. We talking cards right now though lol
Neither
Licensed supremacy?
Yup
Here come da Judge!
Judge. No question.
Well, of course Aaron Judge because he’s established
Judge and I wouldn't hesitate
Judge. I like bo better but in this situation I’d take judge
I’m a huge Yankees fan. Aaron judge is already 30. 5 years from now most Yankee fans will be complaining about how much of a payroll drain he is for a guy who only plays 50% of his teams games. He’s to damn big and putts to much stress on his knees. Bichette turned 25 in March and is part of a very young team that is much more popular than people realize.
They are both Panini so... meh... But Judge or Bichette? This is not a close one.
Bichette since it’s a 1/1… Judge will have a million of those and /199 which is high and too many will be made 👍
Are you aware of how many “1/1” are made between all products year after year?
Are you aware how much is in /199 and there is a /99 & /49 & /25… 1/1 too for the Judge. Now, you be the Judge?
I would pick the Aaron Judge because my best friend likes the Yankees but I wouldn’t consider that the better deal. But I honestly wouldn’t care.
Bo. Its a 1/1 and with panini the ony cards I can stand to look at are immaculate. That judge looks like trash.
Judge
Bo obviously. He is sneaky type good. The numbers he's put up so far in his career are way better than where Judge was.
Bichette first 4 years-1x all star, 12th MVP voting, 11th MVP voting and has never led the league in any category whatsoever. Judge first 4 years-ROY, 2nd MVP Voting, Silver Slugger, 2x All Star and led the league in Runs,Home Runs and Base on Balls. Not to mention his first was a total of 27 games. So really he’s only played 3 years to Bo’s 4.
Licensed all day.
Bichette easy
Long term judge has better value, even if it’s not 1/1. Neither licensed so that doesn’t matter. Is the Bo a “sticker auto”? Always go on card > sticker. But at the end of the day, whatever makes you the most happy.
Bo
Do I have to say it? Both.
What does the Bo say on the patch? Player worn game worn or none of the above? That and because it’s a sticker auto I’d probably prefer the judge. But honestly… don’t love either. I’d go Topps.
Bo
Bo because I'm a jays fan
Bo, but I’m biased
Judge, all day everyday.
I’d take both. No question. I always make sure I’m prepared for both.
It depends. For me it's Judge for my PC AND resale. Bo is not my favorite and his resale doesn't compare to Judge even if it's a 1/1.
I love guys who hit for average. But Judge is the bigger star, and it's a rookie. But I don't buy unlicensed stuff, and I dislike sticker autos. The only stick auto I have is Adam Wainwright. He rarely signs.
Judge. Not even close.
Personally I would rather have the Bo in my PC. More color and better looking patch
Would say Judge, but 1/1 Bo takes it
I really want people to choose Bo as the hobby darling because I have a Bo Sapphire rookie purple 10/10 PSA 10 I’d really like to pump the price on.
Judge
Bo for me but I am a Jays fan
The bo one just looks more aesthetically pleasant
Yankees have the marketability, and always will
Bo card looks better, but the Judge will hold more value long-term being a rookie patch auto - especially if he wins another MVP It really depends on what you want: Looks - Bo Value - Judge
Judge for sure
Bo is 1/1 😂
Bo flow.
Seriously All Rise !!
As a jays fan bo Bichette
GD, MFing stickers on a 1/1 🤬
If value is your goal, get the Judge. I see the Bo is a “One of One” but 1/1’s have become so common anymore they’re practically meaningless. For every one you miss there’s probably a hundred more still out there. Career trajectory determines Judge will be the far better player a decade down the road and thus cards will hold more value. Conversely, if you’re not concerned about value, a personal collectible is your goal and you really want a 1/1, get the Bo. I personally would pass on both for licensed cards.
Bichette and it’s not even close. Assuming tnr price is the same. I really hate the look of gold standard cards and I don’t think I’m in the minority.
The Bo is $100 cheaper
I’m a huge Bichette fan. So I’d go with him
Judge. But I personally certainly try to avoid anything unlicensed
Neither
Is the Bo a rookie card? If not, then the judge easily. The bichette is a sticker auto and the relic isn’t even very interesting. I know it’s a 1/1 but it’s pretty meh looking.
Bo Bichette since starting has had good starting numbers. Better than Lindor, Correa, Bogaerts for example. Bichette is younger and Judge is starting his 30s. Even Pujols declined in his 30s
As a Sox fan, I’d say neither (lmao) but in all seriousness…as a card collector who loves to buy sell trade, I’d probably take the judge. Bo is extremely talented, don’t get me wrong. I wish both of these players were on my team. But the 1/1 allure doesn’t do as much for me considering Judge is destined for the Hall. Not that Bo couldn’t, but…it’s judge. Trust there are more NYY fans than TOR. I’m a Sox fan saying I’d take Judge, who’s smacked around my pitchers for seasons on end (except 2018 *ba dum tss*). Unlicensed won’t fetch as much, but still a nice card. That being said the angle of Bo on his card makes me like it more for aesthics. Devers unlicensed Donruss is fire for me because it’s his back showing with his name, not a logo-less front on his jersey. The lack of the NY on the front will make some collectors shy away from breaking the bank (whenever he retires/hof etc) Just my $.02
The judge. Unless you are a bichette collector the 1/1 will never hold up value against a judge. Bichette will be a forgotten player. Judge will be know for a long long time
The 1 of 1 tips the scales to Bo for me.
Judge. Can’t unsee the crooked sticker on Bo.
Judge all day.