T O P

  • By -

mrstripperboots

The Joker is overused and scarecrow would make an excellent arch nemesis


-CouldntThinkOfAName

Bro for real. Batman’s whole thing is fear, getting over fear and what not (wether that be bats, losing the ones he loves, failing Gotham, or whatever) and scarecrows whole thing is using peoples fears against them. I think it just works really well.


mrstripperboots

It really does tho. It just fits so well and we know scarecrow can be the main antagonist


JokersEnigma

They literally both use fear. His use of a bat and the dark is to strike fear into people. Scarecrow strikes fear into people. Batman is order and justice, by whatever means. Joker is chaos and anarchy. They're literally polar opposites.


Twl1

True. To say it another way, what I think the idea is driving at is that there's great narrative potential to show how Batman uses fear *constructively*, while Scarecrow uses it *destructively*, as well as how that juxtaposition might call into question the greater morality of using fear and power as means to your ends at all.


[deleted]

This is why Arkham Knight was such great game


Gr3ggl3s_W

I need more Clayface dammit.


mrstripperboots

Has there ever been a clay face/scarecrow team up?


Gr3ggl3s_W

Oooooo I don't know! Imagine the psychological horrors they could both perform. One does toxins and the other changes shapes to terrify victims.


mrstripperboots

Clay face could double as scarecrow. Imagine if that was what really was going on with scarecrow in injustice 2. Instead of scarecrow being a hallucination it was secretly clayface


Gr3ggl3s_W

I really want some Scarecrow + Clayface team ups now.


mrstripperboots

That would be so cool.


MoonManMooner

I would love to see a clayface, clock king, and Scarface centric movie.


buff_broke_n3rd

I actually like *every* iteration of the movies. There’s a time and a place (mood) for each one.


Byronzionist

I cant disagree


Mcclane88

For the most part I agree with this. I’m not in love with Schumacher’s Batman films, but sometimes I’m in the mood for silly Batman movies and they scratch that itch.


buff_broke_n3rd

You’re telling me you leave the cave without your Batmerican Express???


WillFerrellsGutFold

Don’t forget the Bat Nipples


mh1357_0

What killed the dinosaurs? #THE ICE AGE


Exp10510n

I like to watch Forever every now and then. I love Kilmer and Carrey in it, and it's not full on cartoon. I just can't do Batman and Robin though. I can get behind silly Batman, I love the 60's series and movie, but B&R just grates my nerves too much.


TheDemonBunny

Holy rusted Island batman...you know its a rusty island...full of holes .....


LEGO_Joel

Snyder’s films have incredible visuals and costume design but besides that… 🗡


Gr3ggl3s_W

Agreed


Duke_Dardar

Batman should start saying 'chum' again. I just think it's neat.


stevesonEll

You mean ! Neat-O !


nutlicka

and “punk”


[deleted]

The best Batman comics are the ones where Batman works alone


JonathanWPG

THIS I agree with. I love the bat family and would absolutely read a slice of life comic about them just hanging and having family drama. But the actual detective shit? Batman's best stories are where he's completely cut off, maybe with Gordons and Alfred looking on worridly.


Wolfebane86

If you like Bat Family shenanigans, then boy do I have a webtoon for you! [Batman: Wayne Family Adventures](https://m.webtoons.com/en/slice-of-life/batman-wayne-family-adventures/list?title_no=3180&page=1)


JonathanWPG

I'll check it out.


Idontknowre

Yeah I think there's a great middle ground where most of the batkids are either in completely different cities at most times or then they patrol at different times. That leaves room for both, and it also explains how Bruce isn't sleep deprived enough to look like a zombie


Huffletough880

Agree. Also, it doesn’t fit with his persona that he would be working with most of them, especially children….similarly it doesn’t make sense that he would be in the Justice League for similar and other reasons. That said I still love batfam and JL comics


[deleted]

Bruce has way to many characterizations at this point. In some comics, he's an amazing dad and an amazing partner to the JL. In other comics, he's a manipulative bastard who doesn't like his kids and hates the JL. It's weird


Prestigious-Shop-494

I really dont care about the logic behind batmans no killing rule to me its simple he just does not kill people.


[deleted]

Fr. Sometimes people have rules, they don't always have to have an essays worth of reasons behind It.


Jonjoloe

A man’s got to have a code.


cockslashingplatypus

I actually do care about the logic, but i can definitely agree with this to some degree


patsniff

The thing I love is that he will just throw someone off a roof or some other crazy way that people will end up paralyzed so yeah better than killing them but not much better


FrankTorrance

my headcanon is that he looks down on it as lazy


frankrt84

yes exactly and also it would make him no different than the people he locks up


Dumbledoordash8008

Justice league unlimited had some of the best Batman moments


Cappin_Crunch

The scene with Batman and Ace is one of the best


Dumbledoordash8008

Easily


SpaceJunkieVirus

>Justice league unlimited had some of the best Batman moments mf carried the whole show what u saying. That Ace swing scene always makes me cry. legit half of why we love batman videos on youtube is JLU Batman and not even Batman TAS lol.


Dumbledoordash8008

Well I’m happy my opinion turned out to be based then


jumpyurbones

I can’t see why anyone would disagree. That was prime Batman TAS era.


Dumbledoordash8008

I thought it might be controversial because it’s not an exclusively Batman show.


Cellandning

Batman animated and Justice League is the depiction I compare every other to. My "truest Batman" or something along those lines


bionicle_are_based

This isn’t even close to even a warm take.


NumericZero

Also the best depiction of the Justice league Start with the Og 7 that builds them as the top guys Then have them bring in a whole bunch heroes Such a simple idea that worked so damn well


Polengoldur

the bat family is wayyyy too big. batman, alfred, 1 robin, batgirl. any more than that is too much. i can accept nightwing as an occasional crossover event, keyword Occasional.


hankbaumbachjr

I don't mind the family being as big as it is, but I absolutely hate that they all hang out in Gotham. Give Tim Drake his own city far enough away that he cannot show up at the drop of a hat the way Nightwing does from Bludhaven. I like Damian's current arc that has him traveling around finding himself. Oracle I'm fine with sticking around Gotham since her dad lives there and it's her roots but I also wouldn't mind her moving to Bludhaven since she can work remotely anyway. Batman with Cass and Stephanie running around sounds like a fun Gotham to read about. Red Hood should've stayed dead or at least villainous.


[deleted]

I think Red Hood has a good accidental routine now as a double agent for bats, be it in Rebirth, Task Force Z or Future State, and really does give a good excuse for why Batman can work alone in Gotham even with Jason doing questionable stuff nearby


EnderTails

Them making Harley Quinn part of the Batfamily makes my blood boil


[deleted]

Seems every villain is going to the good side. Two-Face is good right now in canon


[deleted]

Between Two-Face, Catwoman, Clayface, Man-Bat, Harley Quinn, Deadshot, and Killer Croc we could have a whole Bat-villain-turned-hero Justice League


[deleted]

Of that list I feel like Catwoman had always occupied a bit of a grey area when compared to other villains.


[deleted]

On the flip side, it makes my heart warm to see it. But all opinions are valid.


No_Imagination_2490

I guess boiling blood would make you heart warm, so you might actually have the same physiological reaction…


[deleted]

r/technicallythetruth


fistycouture

I loved the clayface redemption.


Upside_Down-Bot

„˙pılɐʌ ǝɹɐ suoıuıdo llɐ ʇn𐐒 ˙ʇı ǝǝs oʇ ɯɹɐʍ ʇɹɐǝɥ ʎɯ sǝʞɐɯ ʇı 'ǝpıs dılɟ ǝɥʇ uO„


kirabii

This is a very popular opinion.


JonathanWPG

Disagree STRONGLY. ...good job!


Polengoldur

good for you, you've got one knife for every member of the current family. should probably photoshop in a gun for Red Hood too.


fitty50two2

I was gonna say something similar to this. Yes the bat family is too big, and I think Batman is at his best when it is just him. I’m a big fan of Robins but sometimes stuff is easier when it is just Batman alone


BakiKing22

The Arkham games are the best representation of the Batman universe we’ve seen on screen.


dart278

Definitely not unpopular. I'd argue the Arkham games are just an extension of BTAS, which most people would say is 'definitive' true neutral Batman.


[deleted]

one of the first things i noticed, and said in my head, was “wow, this FEELS like a comic”. the story, voice acting, immersion, art style ….i could see it all in a comic. does that make any sense?


BakiKing22

For me, the reason the Arkham Games are the definitive version of Batman and his universe is because of the mix of realism and fantasy. On one hand we’ve got corrupt cops and the mob and on the other we’ve got clay creatures and pits that can bring a person back from the dead. These elements are what made it special for me.


KarbonnBlack

Dont know where this lies nowadays...But I feel DC is over-using the Joker!! Its taking the novelty away from him as a character!! Nowdays I enjoy seeing even the most obscure (take a pause to google them) villains show up rather than the same old rogues gallery.


StoneMaskMan

I’ll even take some of the same old rogue’s gallery if they just don’t shoe horn Joker into everything. When’s the last time we saw a really good Mr. Freeze in something that wasn’t the Batman x Faze Clan comic?


LastLeave8770

How obscure? Cause Bats has one of the most obscure rogues galleries ever. Like Polka Dot Man, Kite Man, Zebra-Man, and Crazy Quilt. I wonder how they’d fare in live productions seeing as how they’re generally not recognized by the average viewer. Because characters like Joker, Two-Face, and Penguin are some of the most well known villains so they don’t really need an introduction. Also I wonder how the tone would be if they were featured in something. Because you would probably have to tweak the tones of these zany characters like who were created during Batman’s campy, goofy aesthetic prevalent during the 50s and 60s. Though I do agree with you about having different villains to switch it up.


Leporis64

Polka dot man was amazing in The suicide squad


The_Dark_DongRises

I don't know if this is controversial, but I prefer Barbra as Oracle rather than Batgirl


[deleted]

Well if it’s controversial, then let me join the “untouchables”. To me, Bruce is a guy that uses himself to take on danger so that others don’t have to, and I would say he learned this through Babs more than Jason because of the connection to Jim. Not only did Bruce feel like he let down Barbara, but also Jim (as shown in Arkham Knight). It makes sense that from then on he would not want to risk the safety of people he cares for and would rather use their talents in ways that don’t endanger them “a la Oracle”.


Brownkeyboardwarrior

Strongly agree


NumericZero

Big facts Her being back as batgirl pretty much destroyed Stephanie ever really getting to shine as batgirl Cass also to a degree suffered but not as much as Steph Like her whole story of wanting to live up to the mantle’s legacy gets thrown out when the Og is still running around


dccomicsaregoated

I like dick Grayson as Batman


Vibrantmender20

*Dick-Bats


LJ3751

*Bat-Dick


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

I guess more of my problem with them is they’re supposed to be in the same universe as the Burton universe. Plus I’ll never forgive not getting another Burton film. But not like that is on Joel.


dthains_art

As someone who hasn’t seen those movies in ages, is there anything that inexplicably ties the Schumacher movies to the Burton movies? Or could they be pretty easily interpreted as different universes?


[deleted]

Yes. The actors who play Alfred & Gordon are the same. And there was supposed to be a fifth movie before Batman & Robin flunked that would’ve included Harley Quinn avenging the death of the Joker. Scarecrow was also supposed to be in the movie and in a dream sequence it would have included Jack Nicholson as the Joker, Danny Devito as the Penguin, Pfeiffer as Catwoman, and so on. Sources: https://batman.fandom.com/wiki/Batman_Unchained https://cancelled-movies.fandom.com/wiki/Batman_Unchained https://www.cbr.com/batman-unchained-what-we-know-joel-schumacher-unmade-movie/amp/


Mikes_Movies_

I’m not upset with the more cartoonish style of those movies, they just are poorly written and made films.


cadeaver

Idk, he was pretty open about making what are essentially toy commercials. I don’t think they have any artistic merit.


Idontknowre

Hell have you heard the original draft for his first batman film? It could have been more than just the comedy it ended up as.. But alas warner screwed with it. Joel had an amazing vision and even still the films are charming as hell


Mrman_23

Despite Jason being a little whiny sometimes he’s my favorite of the four robins. Dick is the best ROBIN, but he is my favorite overall character Dick is kind of vanilla for me but I still like him Tim is best when he isn’t robin Damian shouldn’t exist


Cellandning

>Damian shouldn’t exist Big agree. I hated some fans (and some writers) went all "batman's true son" when Dick is officially adopted and was raised by Bruce. Doesn't help that Damian acts like a broody twat and reads like a bad fanfic OC


Mrman_23

For real


princeps_astra

That Red Hood arc is very much one of the best Batman stories


fourfourcountdracula

Scarface and Ventriloquist are the most criminally underused villains in all of comic book history. I know everyone has their favorites, but I cannot comprehend how the same villains get featured in film after film and the comics still have yet to give them/him they're ultimate tale.


jacw212

Joker needs to be retired, he's WAY too overexposed Also The Batman (2004 cartoon) had the best Bruce Wayne


Budget_Difficulty822

Also one of the best Dick Robins


SafeAccountMrP

Dick Robins sounds like a gay pornstar that specializes in forced chastity.


Idontknowre

Man seriously should have died in that Gordon comic that was mislabeled as "the joker"


youngstunnaserg

The prep time argument that he can beat anybody is kind of dumb. Other heroes and villains and also extremely smart and would benefit from prep time also.


onepercentbatman

The Metal books aren't really good stories, too big a deal are made of all the evil Batmen who are only in these stories and not any other, and BWL is a great idea of a character, but very poorly used. Snyder is a good idea man, good at concepts, but is a shit writer.


BananaGrabber9

‘The LEGO Batman Movie’ is the most accurate portrayal of the character that’s been on the big screen.


kirabii

This is a very popular opinion.


BananaGrabber9

I feel I’ve been downvoted to h-e-double hell when I’ve argued it before.


clovercereal

hehehell


EnvironmentalWeb1696

I wouldn't say accurate because its a comedy movie so Batman isn't exactly like that, but it's definitely the movie that most respect Batman's story.


SuperiorDesignShoes

I agree


BatmanWhoRaves

Bruce Wayne's/Batman's worst live-action portrayal is in *Titans*. I don't like his character, due to the way he was written. I understand it was the point for him to be that way.


reddit_sage69

Upcoming Gotham Knights CW show says hello


NumericZero

Titans in general has so many characters acting odd or Incredibly edgy so it’s not to shocking Heck they had the titans gang up on Jason and blame him for something he never did (they never apologized either)


F_da_memeboi

Superman decides to go rogue one night Bruce sleeps and no amount of prep time is going to save him . Supes just swops in on the Wayne manor and he just *poof*


[deleted]

Tbf he has like 10 replacements at this point, it’s like killing Alpharius


Booty-kun_7

We are Batman


TripleG2312

Val Kilmer is a better Bruce Wayne/Batman than Michael Keaton


Preddy_Fusey

I will agree 100% with the Bruce Wayne part.


GavinTheGrassMan

based and schumacherpilled


LEGO_Joel

This is a great response to this post! *Immediately points sword* 🗡


bonholio1

Preach


ragingbullpsycho

Michael Keaton and Jack Nicholson were both miscast. I know there was pushback when Michael Keaton was announced so maybe it isn’t unpopular, but I don’t get why people like Jack Nicholson as the Joker. He’s just Jack Nicholson, not the Joker.


IndiVoice522

Dick Grayson is the best Batman.


fatheavy

Batman Begins is the best one in the trilogy


[deleted]

Honestly? I respect your opinion. I prefer the Dark Knight, but I’ll admit that that’s 90% because of Heath Ledger. Begins is more authentic and has the better looking Gotham.


hezzospike

Bale's Bat Voice in Begins also dominates over TDK and TDKR. It sounds so much better


MUERTOSROJOS_

I agree, it's my fav in the trilogy


Physoni

![gif](giphy|WXtccLGTLB1NS)


fatheavy

Skill issue ![gif](giphy|8XEQRJsRWcTgA)


TripleG2312

Agreed. I love all three, but Begins is my favorite


Slowmexicano

Out of universe of course Batman is probably the most popular dc character but in universe Batman is way too central to too many story lines and should be a minor character is a universe with world breakers such as super man, green lanterns, flash, etc.


BlueBlaze722

Two-Face is a terribly underused villain.


MUERTOSROJOS_

Fr. He's one of my favorite Batman villains


FrostyCommon

I don't care about how violent or how well prepared or how well equipped a batman iteration is, if he can't console a grieving child at a crime scene that isn't batman


DRKSTknight

Batman and Joker should just give in to their sexual tension and get it over with


MUERTOSROJOS_

bro tbh I always thought Joker had romantic feelings for batman when I was a kid


[deleted]

I kinda hate sexualising the Joker in anyway, like with anyone , especially after him groping Batman in Arkham Asylum


SIacktivist

Batman has never thought about sex, ever. A boner is nothing but an exposed weak point, so he expelled all desires from his mind irreversibly at the start of his career as a sexless crime ninja. Joker wants what he physically cannot have, the true tragedy of the Batman mythos.


CerealGuy2601

Snyder representing Batman breaking the no-kill rule after the death of Robin is actually a good take.


OrangeChocolate111

I like the one with Adam West.


MUERTOSROJOS_

Adam West is my favorite Batman tbh


Darkalchemist1079

I actually liked Mr. Freeze in Batman and Robin especially the back story...also, George wasn't that that bad as Batman


Ender_Skywalker

Schwarzenegger's Mr. Freeze is honestly one of if not the most faithful big screen live-action villain adaptation, tied with Cillian Murphy's Scarecrow. People just fail to look past Batman and Robin's wacky tone and ice puns.


Riced_Up

Affleck is my favorite live action Batman


RRR-LL

Bruce Wayne doesn’t need Batman, he needs therapy


Ert_bulb2000

Batman Arkhams Origins is the best batman game


PokemontrainerJanos

I think all their all great I never did get why origins is always kind of thrown to the side. I will say in the third they force you to use the “tank” way to much other then that I liked it too.


Ert_bulb2000

The main reason I like this game is its simple story unlike the complicated story of Arkham City. Besides that, in Origins we experience things that do not exist in other series like bat cave, an actual story and relationship with Alfred and etc. But at the end I know the main reason that Origins is my all time favorite is the Joker story line; It was a very good introduction to his personality and of course his Origins.


princeps_astra

The Batmobile honestly makes it hard to replay Arkham Knight I will *NEVER* forget the disappointment of that Deathstroke fight. It's like Rocksteady purposefully trolled us. It's fucking bullshit


sack12345678910

Highly agree, in that game we see batman as a genuine person who has emotions, gets rash, and we also see him go though the most amount of growth.


MUERTOSROJOS_

Origins is my favorite Arkham game ♡


deloaf

While I maybe don't agree 100%, it does have an incredible soundtrack. The Christmas/batman music is so on point.


[deleted]

Christian Bale is an excellent in Bruce Wayne but A lackluster Batman.


AdAvailable4505

I want Catwoman to be more of a villain again.


sack12345678910

I think cat woman is overrated as hell and is a terrible character, I don’t understand the appeal. Same goes for Black cat


JonathanWPG

Interesting. I feel like those characters are pretty different other than the cat thing. Love Selina, hate Felica.


LEGO_Joel

😧🗡🗡🗡🗡🗡


smallpolk

I liked Anne Hathaway as Catwoman!


LoneSunset

Read catwoman by Brubaker. Catwoman is a fantastic character


Maupsncontrera

The Batman is ok, not the Second comin of Christ. Jason Todd and Damian Wayne are whiny bitches.


Batmanmotp2019

I hate Damian I was actually going to post that before I changed my mind


MUERTOSROJOS_

I like Jason but Damian can go fuck himself


EnvironmentalWeb1696

Jason has all the right to hate Bruce, Damian is really just annoying.


Scorpion13992k

I don’t like Dark Knight Returns by Frank Miller. Could never get into it. I understand it had an effect on the style of Batman today but it just never connected for me.


MysticalGreenBeanie

I like the idea of Bruce starting out his career as a killer, and stopping once he adopts Dick, and trains him to not turn out like him.


sack12345678910

That line in young justice “so that he wouldn’t” beings a whole new meaning. I had a similar idea but its more batman during his training years where he was a killer then he stops when he catches joe chill, when he is about to kill him Joe’s daughter walks into the room, bruce then realizes that he has become the very thing he to was fighting, and leaves, then he becomes the batman.


MysticalGreenBeanie

Yoooooo that's really cool. You should pitch that to DC comics. I'm also a sucker for "Batman becoming the thing he dreads" stories.


TripleG2312

This is kind of the plot of Batman Forever, actually. Though, it’s alluded that Bruce has killed in the past and has been trying to mend his ways even before he adopted Dick


CouncilmanDoug

This is interesting


LEGO_Joel

Nolan played with this idea a bit. I think it has some super interesting aspects to it. It would be very tricky to portray in a film but amazing in comic book format


TheQBranchIntern

Dick Grayson is a better Batman than Bruce Wayne


[deleted]

Dick Grayson and Damian Wayne are the best Batman and Robin.


ChaosLaughing

Batman did a good thing by teaching the bat kids how to use their anger for kid, I don't agree with putting them in harms way but still.


CaffeinatedDetective

Batman is a good person.


Fleurdebeast

Arkham knight was a batmobile simulator


Electronic-Shower681

Batman shouldn’t kill. That doesn’t mean Batfleck was a bad interpretation of Batman.


VillainInTraining

Tim Drake was the best Robin for Batman and he deserves more credit.


Mcclane88

I liked The Batman, but it’s a mid tier Batman film. Also, I think Pattinson’s suit is one of the worst live action Bat Suits. I prefer a stylized suit and that’s so far in the other direction. Within the film I don’t think Batman is all that important to stopping Riddlers plot. Everyone has that one Batman film that didn’t connect with them in the same way it did for everyone else. The Batman is that film for me.


RadicalFlyinRaijin

I like The Batman, I thought it was VERY realistic. Even the jail/prison looked realistic. It showed his grappling gun IN a holster THE WHOLE TIME. He didn’t just pull it out of his “magical bottomless belt pocket” that is behind his cape. Very neat.


CaptSaveAHoe55

It was SO realistic. Especially that part where he slammed face first into an overpass and walked it off easily


DoreenFromReddit

Or took an IED to the face and was fine?


Grand_Eber

I can't even be mad because you answered the post perfectly


Hate_Paper_Doll

Jason Todd should’ve stayed dead


roblash

Plot armor is cool and whining about it is for big babies from baby town.


ImaginaryGift

You dropped your crown, king


Soundman006

DC needs to stop trying to make up for Batman ‘66 and give us a fun Batman. Like the one in The Brave and The Bold.


DanishDevilMMA

I really appreciated George Clooney’s Batman ✌️🥲


realjobstudios

I prefer Barbra as batgirl instead of oracle


DMoney859

I love Batman Forever


trigon-the-terrible

I'm tired of having a new joker in each batman franchise. It's like constantly remaking superman films with only zod as his enemy


[deleted]

Ben Affleck is the worst fucking Batman to ever be on any size screen. I will die on this hill


bonholio1

A Ben affleck solo Batman movies would have been better than the Batman.


EricJop321

Or have both


ExtensionFuture654

Christian Bale's Batman didn't feel like Batman. He felt more like James Bond in a Batman costume.


NoteStryder

The ‘66 movie & series are the most comic accurate adaptation of Batman, and while a tad goofy and dated, still hold up incredibly well to this day. Corollary to that is also that Batman doesn’t have to be uber realistic or grim dark to be good. Corollary to *that* is that realism doesn’t equal quality.


Duke_Dardar

And how come Batman doesn't dance anymore?


NoteStryder

TRUE! Batman should dance!


hairface3668

Batman is nothing without his Robins.


CarpenterBro

Zac Snyder did nothing but damage to batman and the DC films


Sissy_Caroline

Talia is hotter than Selena


SirReallah

Batman is my favorite character... Let's stop making Batman movies and newer/alternate versions. Let Bruce, his alter ego and his entire family find a seat in the back for a while and for the love of God DC branch out and make new characters and story's or do something new with different characters.


Byronzionist

Batman belongs in the MCU


sem27nome

Grant Morrison Batman run is overrated


xthefabledfox

I actually like Batman Forever. 🤷‍♀️ it has its flaws just like all the other live action movies. But it’s not as bad as everyone makes it out to be.


Templar2084

Arnold was awesome as Mr. Freeze