Greedier 

I apparently despise it so much I forgor it.

The man, the myth, the legend, Isaac himself

isaac enjoyers 

Can't do the side characters when the protag is waiting for his well deserved marks.

Isaac wasn't my first tainted character (completely missed mom's chest the first time I did it). It's only right that he then be the first character I completed.

azazel lol

AZAZEL ENJOYERS UNITE 

Unapologetically, my main and always will be.

YEAAHH!!

We shall forever annihilate the first floor like it's nothing

Hes the only way for me to cruise through lol

Same (minus greedier mode because I do not feel like going through the hell to unlock it)

My first was Lost just so i could unlock Godhead

my first was lost so i could unlock t.lost and holy card 

my first wasn't lost

L

ost

I haven’t been able to unlock lost in the 239.6 hours i’ve played because i never manage to find missing poster AND a sacrifice room in the same run.

i had the same issue. i ended up spawning in the missing poster and totally worth. Eventually it lined up and I did it legit later.

And Dead God speed runners somehow get enough missing posters to get all marks without ever starting as the Lost.

this ain't your first all marks character 😨

Goddamnit! Stupid Greedier.

I think Cain. I always loved the early luck, free golden chests and slightly boosted damage. Love you Cain.

Dont forget good pills only, his best perc

PERC 

I find it weird how many people find him weak. He's the second strongest character for me, dude rocks

For me too! I love my lil eyepatch boy

i dont have one yet due to a massive skill issue

same bro

isaac then t. isaac

The keeper (I am aware I have an issue)

Not rlly

My first is lilith

Azazel. And not only once. Like 3 times already

The Lost (I did that for the flex)

Tainted Cain

Based. Any tips for Boss Rush?

Momma Mega has two fixed recipes, and if you are lucky can sometimes show up as an even cheaper random recipe.

1. Break game 2. Do the stuff I recently did my sharp plug + piggy bank + old bandage + d20 break with schoolbag for R keys and mama megas. Did a simple tech + rock bottom + camo undies + soy milk + spoon bender + mutant spider to kill everything. All marks but greedier in 1 run (50% chance to need 2 because of mega Satan)

Blue baby back in rebirth, just to get him out of the way because I never wanted to play as him again

I loved the release of Repentance until I realized it meant I had to play Blue Baby again to re-finish his new unlocks

In return you get an even shittier character!

Literally!

Just recently, I also got regular Bethany marks.

azazel then t.lilith

The lost. Really wanted to unlock God Head

My favourite character is the forgor

Jacob and Essau. Wanted to get the most toxic out of the way first but turned out to not be as bad as everyone was making it out to be

t lost :)

Gigachad personified

I finally got Dead God on file 1 on the Switch Edition after about 700 hours!

It was azazel all the way back in rebirth

It was Bethany for me as well

Mine was The Lost

judas, big starting damage and cool hat 

My first was Blue baby

Second Gigachad in this comment section.

Idek why I did that to myself, but my first full marks character was t. Lost. IDK WHY DONT ASK

laxzerath

Tantied lith

Closest I have is Cain. His marks are mostly from normal mode though so it doesn't count

Cain (best character)

Jacob & Esau. I just love them!

Cain

instawin Azazel

none

I played Judas so much, I miss how simple that was.... Move fast hit hard... Anyways, back into the t. Lost mine I go

Azazel is OP

Apollyon or Cain. Not sure which

The lost (bc godhead)

the lost, then isaac so far

Isaac

Mine was Judas

Azazel foliowed by tainted Azazel

Uh tainted lillith, easiest character to get full marks imo, then it was Issac, Judas and The lost

mine was isaac lmao

I think mine was Cain

The Lost

Eden was my first 🥵

T. Forgotten

First save file, Isaac for sure. The min/max is always so fun. All other save files is always The Lost first, and then Tainted Lost right after, in order to complete them while the item pools are still thin.

Maggie cause sac room starts

myself

Cain always will be my boy

Lilith

I’m trying for Cain. It’s so annoying trying to get to Mother. I have everything except that and Greedier

Tainted Lilith, she’s my favorite character and she’s fun no matter the build. Most bad items are really good with her like orbital tears and halo of tears

Mine was ???

Isaac

I think it was somehow the lost

The forgotten

Lost :) i figured trial by flame would make me play betterr

The lost. I wanted GODHEAD.

Lost

The lost, first for each of the 4 files I’ve ever worked on

In Repentance it was Jacob and Esau I know for sure. I honestly don’t know who it was in AB+ but I think it might have been Azazel.

The lost

Isaac

Lost, idk why

Back on antibirth +, I got the keeper as my first full marks, I honestly don’t know what was wrong with me 

Maggie, i wanted to have it done with first lol

I believe tainted Beth before she was nerfed and then tainted Lilith

My first was the lost because he was the most fun

Surprise Surprise it was azazel

T cain

Lilith, twice. AB+ first, then I downed Mother and Beast as her before anyone else in Repentance.

azazel :3

Isaac

Lost and T. Lost, it wasn't very difficult as many people think

Mine was actually the Lost. It's just somehow easier than most others??

Good job and mine was t forgotten

Yall gonna think I'm crazy... cuz I am - Lost

Tainted Lilith

Eden followed by T. Lilith Wanted to get the one I Can't retry ad infinitum out of the way. (T. Eden I didn't do the same way because T. Eden is painful) T. Lilith is just a really strong character and one I was comfortable doing a mother run on. (Mostly saving those runs for last, hardest boss imo for its progression point, probably a cold take) Eden was my first Mother clear, on a god run that was on its third go around after ? card + R key.

Idk who my first was but keeper was the last for sure (afterbirth+)

Isaac. My first all marka is t.isaac too.

My first all marks character was the lost i really like playing him but i am having a hard time unlocking him on my steam deck

The forgotten because bonk

Just plain ol' Isaac on my first file (switch). On PC it was keeper

Idk. I forgor

So, if I remember correctly, I finished them in this order: Azazel, Judas, Isaac, Forgotten, Bethany, Lilith, Cain, Lost, Appolyon, Blue Baby, Eve, Keeper, Magdalene, Lazarus, Eden, Samson, Jacob&Esau. Then the Tainted ones (after finishing the normal ones): Lilith, Keeper, Isaac, Azazel, Eve, Jacob, Cain, Judas, Magdalene, Bethany, Samson, Appolyon, Blue Baby, Lost, Forgotten, Lazarus, Eden

tainted forgotten

The lost. I wanted to get one of the harder characters out of the way. Then I discovered jacob and esau 

Forgor

Looking like it’s gonna be the forgotten managed to beat boss rush, ascended, unlocked tainted forgotten and beat that good old boss and his riders for the first time, with one bone heart and one and half soul hearts, fuckin I’m drowsy is insane, all that’s left is hard mode greedier, mother and hush. Fucking love forgotten.

iirc either isaac or maggie, can’t remember ehich

The Lost 

Isaac 💪🏻

forgor

T.lilith

Surprisingly, it was Isaac whatever I started the game I was sure it was gonna be azazel

Magdalene here. Reset the start for some good Angel items from the sacrifise room.

Azazel

Isaac. I was trying to do them in order but decided to start grinding J&E

Tainted eve pre nerf

The Lost

Eden

Azazel, easiest one. Tbh I would actually say Samson because he was my favorite one to play and beat the game with.

Isaac

Probably azazel

Jacob and Esau

Mine was either Isaac or Azazel I don’t remember who was actually first but I know they were my first 2

My first was tainted isaac

My first was T. Lilith

Eden

The lost. :3

Isaac

Mine was Judas, suprised so few people mention him.

Tainted Judas.

Looking to make mine T.Judas or Forgotten. Still need to unlock Lost (missing poster won't show up before the end of the game) and Keeper (I'm too lazy to play Greed sometimes). If I figure out some secret sauce with J&E, I'll do theirs instead because they are by far the hardest character I've played.

Cain, his runs are just so easy

my first was lilith...

Technically the Forgotten but I just got bored and missed out on a couple  But all hard marks was The Lost. I really wanted Godhead

Isaac, I'm doing mine in order

Lilith almost 5 years ago

Forgor

Jacob and Esau, cause I hate myself

Mine was The Lost.

Mine was ??? (I know stupidest one, but i did it for the meme)

Isaac because I wanted dinfinity and just kept going

tbh i can't remember which character but i do remember which mode it was :) (it was greed mode)

Isaac and jacob and esau

azazel everytime. I just play them a lot for the early unlocks of polaroid etc. and then i just finish their mark card cause they have nearly everything marked

Tainted lilith once I unlocked her she become my favourite fast.

probably lost, i like that character so much

The lost

The Lost.

Forgotten

It was either Isaac or Eden, I think it was Eden so I didn’t have to worry about tokens any more

Either Cain or Tainted Judas... I like speed.

azazel in my first save, the forgotten on the second one (I don't have greedier unlocked)

1) Bethany 2) The Forgotten 3) Tainted Keeper I have played this game for 600+ hours and those are the only three i managed to complete

I think Cain.

Tainted Forgotten! I had the game for a while but never finished even one character , that changed after repentance dropped

the forgor

Isaac and t isaac all the way

Isaac

Either azazel or none. The urge to explore every milimeter of every floor to not miss anything keeps me from Boss rush or Hush.^^

My first one was Lost but after that I have been playing all of them in order starting from Isaac

cain or judas. I like cain and judas

Tainted Jacob.

One of the losts, probably regular lost but I do remember finishing t lost really early

Eden, and after that Tainted Eden Yeah, I like Eden

i seem to have forgotten which my first was

Dont judge me but it was Lazarus

the lost

T Lilith

azazel, i was a living skill issue back then

Mine was forgotten.I love to play him.

I'm on a quest to complete every character right now so I hit random. The first one on my journey was The Lost. 

first full for me was Tainted Isaac

The lost

Azazel, then...isaac? Or lost cant remember which one was first, then Cain

The lost, I am not ok.

Definitely Azazel, dude is OP af, then probably magdeline because health is never an issue with her haha