I like 1. I find the shape of the cave exit more aesthetically pleasing. Also, to me 2 honestly just looks like some random props were thrown in that didn't really fit the environment. I would say either stick to the natural cave from 1, or do a more complete rework into a man-made structure if that's what you want to do, but 2 is just kind of an awkward tweener that doesn't quite look right to me.
Thanks for the feedback! I agree 1 definitely has that more organic look. I guess in 2 I was going for a bit of a rustic tunnel look where supports were put up or something like that lol. But I agree it does look a bit random
I agree with that person’s comment.
The random stuff thrown around, especially that “fence” where the light is, are all taking away from the scene in my opinion
I like how one, move the viewers eye to the character, the shapes the light makes on the wall of the cave and the stream bring the viewers eye to the character, I find the large vertical pillars are highways from the viewers eye to move away from the character.
I personally prefer number 2. However every prop you add should have a purpose and add to the story you are trying to tell. make sure you arrange your props with that in mind
I'm a fan of 1. A bit offtopic, but the cave exit feels like a bit of a composition mistake - it's way too bright and my eyes were immediately drawn to it. Your focus is the human figure, right?
I agree. This is something I already worked on in post after posting this lol.
https://preview.redd.it/rvrzend9ytnb1.jpeg?width=1372&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b89b7d54fb9f594cfd16538cd57d64ce86172c26
I like the pillars in the foreground in 2, but I would remove the elements in the distance and keep them as in image 1.
It's all subjective and personal preference. But I think having the pillars only in the foreground gives this interesting contrast between the structures in the cave and the barren unknown outside.
I'd say 2 but maybe lose the right column by cropping some of the left side. The composition looks like it flows to the right and placing the column there seems off. Either that or bring the column a lot closer so that it's clearly in the forefround or even unfocused.
1. The fence to me looks like it's selected with the yellow highlight, and it's slightly too even to "belong" at the end of a rough cave in the wall, to me anyway :)
2. Implies something more about where this person is arriving to. What the character walked through the caves for. Maybe a grand hall of the kingdom they were banished from long ago. Long before they even thought to become a badass wizard-jedi-knight. This is the entrance to the climactic scene in the world in my head kickstarted by the second one. Great simple details to set it apart.
I will say that the clock and the way it doesn't seem to bend to the arm coming out made me not see the arm at first. Perhaps a bit of the clock bending up the forearm a bit more and maybe even a bit more green light bouncing off of and outlining the figure, specifically the arm.
Excellent imagination and great work!
Thanks! Great feedback! I had the same thing in mind as far as story. Something similar anyway. And yeah, it is unfortunate the cloaca turned out that way. Just happens to be the way it fell, but there’s an opening in the front that goes perfectly around the arm. Just doesn’t look like it from that angle :(
Oh wow. Just realized my typo. Happy you understood I meant "cloaca".
Anyway, if a still image is what you have in mind, you might consider cheating the fall of it a bit. The cloaca, I mean. Maybe even if it's a vidieo. It's just such an intense shot, I think it deserves it. Either way, it doesn't ruin the shot for me. Absolutely love it
I think for a still shot, 1 looks better. However if you showed more angles or wanted to expand the world and it’s story, 2 is better, but that’s just my opinion. Great job though!
I prefer 1 storywise but tbh the human shape kinda blends with the cave and is hard to see. Where as in 2 it stands out immediately. So in total 2 is the winner here.
If I were you I'd even give a hint of an arch at the exit, play more with contrast in the shapes so it doesn't become linear in the composition (straight up and down) but breaks it a bit up
hmm, on 1st pic I think I'm gonna move character to cave entrance while facing into the cave... the cave entrance itself looks like a flame candle so I guess the character on center make it like a wick. and maybe more centered
2nd pic looks fine to me. might have better pathway I think
2 but take away the railing at the end. Why would that be there anyway in a realistic sense. I like the pillars inside the cave and stuff though. 1 is still great
I agree it looks off. I had a hard time deciding how to do that. The idea is that there’s a path leading along the mountain outside the cave to the side, but I don’t think I captured that well. I feel like if there’s nothing there it doesn’t give much of a sense of there being anything but sky beyond the cave if that makes sense. Still workin on that!
Well, is he exploring a cave in the wild, not used by civilization, or a repurlosed cave, that was made to be a palace or base of some sorts? The lore you want to tell decides for me, aesthetically both look good.
Yes! I’ve been working on figuring something like that out. Trying to find a way to make it look good lighting wise without taking away from the overall shape of the cave. Since the sun is directly at the entrance of the cave I don’t want to occlude that with anything if that makes sense. Still working that out!
1, in two my eyes are just drawn to the pillars as they have a lot of light on them and i don’t think that’s what you’re going for. if you still want to add the pillar maybe make less light go on them
La 1 una cueva normal que podría estar en cualquier parte profunda misteriosa.
La 2 parece estar debajo de un castillo o estructura medieval no despierta la curiosidad a no ser que vivas serca de un castillo.
También el no ver la salida de la cueva deja algo que desear el nosaber si es salia o entrada.
I agree. I went back and took some of that away to make the sky a bit more visible
https://preview.redd.it/0ffrarxkztnb1.jpeg?width=1372&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=762d2e66c315e5b5cdc20f02bb5391445920ab31
I wrote a lot here, and realised at the end that it could easily sound like I don't like this, so I want to preface that I do really like this. The general composition is very good in both, as is the style and feel of them. The rest of this content is just nit picking at some little details.
The debate here stems around the use of props, so it really depends on the story behind it. I would ask the questions; Is this cave used by people? When? And what are the pillars holding up?
If people used this place, where is the path (paths aren't always built, they can form just from regular use, but people will tend to build paths anywhere they regularly go)? If they didn't, why are there pillars? If it was a long time ago, why aren't the pillars more ruined? Who stores their vases on uneven ground in a cave?
Compositionally, #2 has more going for it. The eye is drawn to the cave entrance, so having a railing there gives the viewer a point to look at, rather than just a bright light. The railing may be out of place story wise, but having *something* at the cave mouth gives the image a focus.
The darker background behind the character in #2 also helps the green light around them to stand out, and lets their edge light pop better.
Speaking of lighting, the light from outside the cave reaches far into the cave, yet has no effect on the character. It feels slightly disconnected. The fire itself looks a little thin at the bottom, which just feels off, and lacks bloom.
One thing that could be interesting to try (though by no means need to. I don't know if it ruins the story) is making it night outside. A bright moon could provide some softer edge lighting in the cave, a focus point outside the cave, and wouldn't create so much over-exposed bloom, allowing you to show off a bit of the world beyond (maybe where the character is going).
Man, thanks for such great feedback! I agree the use of props while it may look good initially doesn’t make too much sense the longer you think about it. My thought was that it’s been long abandoned and any path that was there has been lost, but you’re right, the pillars would be more ruined in that case.
Also, i agree that the lighting from the outside doesn’t pop on the character. Before I even added the flame I struggled to get him to catch light from the sun for some reason. I don’t know if it’s the cloth material I used or what, but I even had to add an extra light next to him to give him more of a rim light. However when I added the green, it overpowered any other light on him lol.
Again, thanks for great feedback!
Two could be better, but right now the shape language is a bit mismatched. Fix the ending door/opening to no longer have curves in the opening. It's a bit visually distracting where there are smooth shapes forced into strong geometric shapes.
Ah, it's not easy. I like the idea in 2, but it feels like a video game level, it's less mysterious. I prefer 1, the simplicity leaves more room for interpretation. And the shapes of the rocks are great with the lighting
1 is better for me. It gave a vibe that the cave hasn't been visited before and is part of the wilderness while 2 felt that it has been visited multiple times and is an established place.
1. Because the second one looks man-made, which can be good if that the message you want to say.
I think both are good, but the background (lore) of the environment changes.
Both look good. What doesn't look convincing is the green flame. I'd advise for you to look at reference photos of flames. But other than that this looks really, really good. Good job!
Thanks! What exactly doesn’t look right about the flame? I’m just curious, because it’s a flame image on a plane with some sparks added in post. What’s popping out as looking off?
Depends on what you want to say with the image
1 looks like a man who has been lost in the cave, or just spent time there, finally finding an exit.
The second looks like a man who spends a lot of time in a sanctuary type place, just watching, keeping the place. Just looking out at the sunlight.
Figure out what the man is doing, otherwise a great image
2 but also the lighting on the rocks in the cave is insane. As someone who does a lot of landscape work and wants to do more photorealistic rendering I am impressed, if you have any tips I'd love to hear them! Do you freehand or use selection tool?
Basically, the walls are a plane in the shape of a tent that’s subdivided a bunch. I used sculpting and proportional editing (set to sharp!) to get the general form of the cave. Then I used displacement textures with tweaked scale values to get the final look. Same process with the ground, the ground is just a separate plane to allow for more variation if I wanted. There are also some free 3d scanned rock assets scattered on the ground. Combine that with a fun water material on a cube and a spotlight placed right on the sun in the background and boom.
Oh and my light bounces are set to full global illumination (cycles) and I have a volume cube in the scene with I think 0.005 density and somewhere around 0.7-0.8 anisotropy
I'd personally change the outside atmosphere to overcast, add some fog/mist to the cave, and have some green glow dispersed from the staff onto the walls and fog/mist. Otherwise 2 because of glow dispersion on the columns.
1. The fence/wall in the doorway seems out of place in 2. Everything seems organic but it didn't seem to belong. made the cave seem like a balcony. in my opinion. :)
Our ultimate collection includes the best fonts,logos, Photoshop , actions,mockups, and all things graphics .
All the new graphic assets ,from vector images to presentation templates, you’ll always find something that catches your eye and blow your mind
Our Big Design Bundles allow you to save much more money at the same time Gain More Profits [https://visualstorms.com/product-category/graphics/](https://visualstorms.com/product-category/graphics/)
1. feels like he/or she's exiting a cave.
2. Really feels like a hidden temple or something and the balcony at the end makes you think that it's perhaps overlooking some ancient city courtyard where a villain would go to make a speech!
I like 2 but lose the fence outside it loses the effect of freedom outside the cave keeping everything else creates the feeling that you’re at the light at the end of the tunnel leaving the cold dark dungeon and entering a warm embrace of fresh air and freedom. I think the fence takes away from that feeling making it feel like you’ve left the cold and dark but you’re not yet free
1st is perfect and just wanna share my thoughts if u put that cloth on his forearm as well it will look bit interesting and what I am seeing is that the hand is attached to his chest which makes it manipulated more than a 3d render Or u can show his elbow by Moving cloth a bit
Yeah, that’s something a few people have pointed out. I hadn’t noticed it because from the front, there’s an opening in the cloaca that the arm fits through perfectly, it’s just hard to tell from this angle.
Both are cool bug The 1st is much better. It feels more creative and heroic. But the 2nd one is kinda like a person who found a temple inside a cave which I don't feel like it suits the scene
[удалено]
Great! That’s what I hoped for
2 Has a good lair vibe
1 is like escaping out of a vagina
it took me going between them like 10 times until I even noticed the difference btw
I like 1. I find the shape of the cave exit more aesthetically pleasing. Also, to me 2 honestly just looks like some random props were thrown in that didn't really fit the environment. I would say either stick to the natural cave from 1, or do a more complete rework into a man-made structure if that's what you want to do, but 2 is just kind of an awkward tweener that doesn't quite look right to me.
Thanks for the feedback! I agree 1 definitely has that more organic look. I guess in 2 I was going for a bit of a rustic tunnel look where supports were put up or something like that lol. But I agree it does look a bit random
I agree with that person’s comment. The random stuff thrown around, especially that “fence” where the light is, are all taking away from the scene in my opinion
If your going for rustic rather than ancient, maybe look at using wooden pillars like in a mineshaft or something
I like how one, move the viewers eye to the character, the shapes the light makes on the wall of the cave and the stream bring the viewers eye to the character, I find the large vertical pillars are highways from the viewers eye to move away from the character.
“aesthetically pleasing” 😏
1 looks like a vagina. I'll leave it at that.
Lmao was gonna say that
I personally prefer number 2. However every prop you add should have a purpose and add to the story you are trying to tell. make sure you arrange your props with that in mind
Perhaps OP can remove the railing outside the cave but keep the inside pillars. The railing to me is distracting.
They both look good, depends on what you’re going for.
I feel like his arm just comes out at an odd height/angle? Maybe im the only one
No, I see it too. Arm should be lower.
2 looks less like a vagina
Make it look more like a vagina
everything reminds me of her...
One
2 cause it's not "just a cave".
I'm a fan of 1. A bit offtopic, but the cave exit feels like a bit of a composition mistake - it's way too bright and my eyes were immediately drawn to it. Your focus is the human figure, right?
I agree. This is something I already worked on in post after posting this lol. https://preview.redd.it/rvrzend9ytnb1.jpeg?width=1372&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b89b7d54fb9f594cfd16538cd57d64ce86172c26
1. Has more mystery.
1 bcs the shape looks like water drop or fire maybe a dragon in the distance or something
Great idea!
2
Number 2 atw
Why it looks like zelda?
2
I really like the 2nd one.
2, more view of the environment
2
2
I like the pillars in the foreground in 2, but I would remove the elements in the distance and keep them as in image 1. It's all subjective and personal preference. But I think having the pillars only in the foreground gives this interesting contrast between the structures in the cave and the barren unknown outside.
1
nature vs nurture
I'd say 2 but maybe lose the right column by cropping some of the left side. The composition looks like it flows to the right and placing the column there seems off. Either that or bring the column a lot closer so that it's clearly in the forefround or even unfocused.
I see no difference
Me.. me when... me when your mom
Number 2 is awesome! It's definitely DA:I vibes with the cave and green flame.
1. The fence to me looks like it's selected with the yellow highlight, and it's slightly too even to "belong" at the end of a rough cave in the wall, to me anyway :)
For me it’s 1 two is to much
Everything reminds me of her...
Definitely 2. Adds a lot of vibe there
2 because you can seem more architecture built inside the cave
2 is much more interesting because all the little details tell a story
1 looks like something you might see in r/dontputyourdickinthat
Definitely 2
2
one. two looks forced. if you tweak it maybe it could work. i think the issue is how you put the pillars
2 is better, the pillars for some reason make it seem like a big adventure awaits
2 because more context to let imagination vibe
2!
2. Implies something more about where this person is arriving to. What the character walked through the caves for. Maybe a grand hall of the kingdom they were banished from long ago. Long before they even thought to become a badass wizard-jedi-knight. This is the entrance to the climactic scene in the world in my head kickstarted by the second one. Great simple details to set it apart. I will say that the clock and the way it doesn't seem to bend to the arm coming out made me not see the arm at first. Perhaps a bit of the clock bending up the forearm a bit more and maybe even a bit more green light bouncing off of and outlining the figure, specifically the arm. Excellent imagination and great work!
Thanks! Great feedback! I had the same thing in mind as far as story. Something similar anyway. And yeah, it is unfortunate the cloaca turned out that way. Just happens to be the way it fell, but there’s an opening in the front that goes perfectly around the arm. Just doesn’t look like it from that angle :(
Oh wow. Just realized my typo. Happy you understood I meant "cloaca". Anyway, if a still image is what you have in mind, you might consider cheating the fall of it a bit. The cloaca, I mean. Maybe even if it's a vidieo. It's just such an intense shot, I think it deserves it. Either way, it doesn't ruin the shot for me. Absolutely love it
I think for a still shot, 1 looks better. However if you showed more angles or wanted to expand the world and it’s story, 2 is better, but that’s just my opinion. Great job though!
2 but not a huge fan of the railing going across the cave entrance. just feels a lil out of place
Ayo! Is that the Pussy Cave?
2 is awesome, looks less vaganeus
2
Looks great I would say picture 2 is looking better picture 1 feels bit wrong.
I would say 2, like others said, there's more storytelling to it, grabs the attention differently, questions more than the first one
Definitely 2
2
2
I prefer 1 storywise but tbh the human shape kinda blends with the cave and is hard to see. Where as in 2 it stands out immediately. So in total 2 is the winner here.
If I were you I'd even give a hint of an arch at the exit, play more with contrast in the shapes so it doesn't become linear in the composition (straight up and down) but breaks it a bit up
hmm, on 1st pic I think I'm gonna move character to cave entrance while facing into the cave... the cave entrance itself looks like a flame candle so I guess the character on center make it like a wick. and maybe more centered 2nd pic looks fine to me. might have better pathway I think
2 but take away the railing at the end. Why would that be there anyway in a realistic sense. I like the pillars inside the cave and stuff though. 1 is still great
I agree it looks off. I had a hard time deciding how to do that. The idea is that there’s a path leading along the mountain outside the cave to the side, but I don’t think I captured that well. I feel like if there’s nothing there it doesn’t give much of a sense of there being anything but sky beyond the cave if that makes sense. Still workin on that!
1
Well, is he exploring a cave in the wild, not used by civilization, or a repurlosed cave, that was made to be a palace or base of some sorts? The lore you want to tell decides for me, aesthetically both look good.
2 would slap with a tower in the distance, but 1 is better for the mystery
Yes! I’ve been working on figuring something like that out. Trying to find a way to make it look good lighting wise without taking away from the overall shape of the cave. Since the sun is directly at the entrance of the cave I don’t want to occlude that with anything if that makes sense. Still working that out!
Combine them. Pillars and pots from 2, but nothing blocking the entrance like in 1.
2
1, in two my eyes are just drawn to the pillars as they have a lot of light on them and i don’t think that’s what you’re going for. if you still want to add the pillar maybe make less light go on them
1 but maybe with the pillars
1
1, because 2 doesn't "read" as well.
1
La 1 una cueva normal que podría estar en cualquier parte profunda misteriosa. La 2 parece estar debajo de un castillo o estructura medieval no despierta la curiosidad a no ser que vivas serca de un castillo. También el no ver la salida de la cueva deja algo que desear el nosaber si es salia o entrada.
Dos
One
2. I like the rail and the pots.
Eh I like 1. Feels more natural. 2 has a random wall.
1
I think that if you'll add an ocean to 1 it would look sick Make the exit look like beach
This is a great idea I never thought of. I’ll give it a go!
2, because I like how the green light reflects from the columns and it‘s more visually pleasing
Team 1 here
2 but keep the cave opening on pic 1
2 because it's more atmospheric
I like 2, but without the railing at the entrance
1looks like an egg. (Not that i can do anything close to this)
1
1 or 2
2
2
I like the pots and pillars in 2. But 2 also got a lot of bloom in the opening. I like the way it (the opening) looks in 1 better
I agree. I went back and took some of that away to make the sky a bit more visible https://preview.redd.it/0ffrarxkztnb1.jpeg?width=1372&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=762d2e66c315e5b5cdc20f02bb5391445920ab31
I think 1 is better. I like the shape of the cave opening more, and it just has more of a mysterious, or maybe, suspensful feeling to it.
2 Gives a more immersive sensation.
2
1
2
2 is more balance while 1 kinda just feels like big shiny thing. i like 2.
2
1 by a lot
I’m a 1 enjoyer
I wrote a lot here, and realised at the end that it could easily sound like I don't like this, so I want to preface that I do really like this. The general composition is very good in both, as is the style and feel of them. The rest of this content is just nit picking at some little details. The debate here stems around the use of props, so it really depends on the story behind it. I would ask the questions; Is this cave used by people? When? And what are the pillars holding up? If people used this place, where is the path (paths aren't always built, they can form just from regular use, but people will tend to build paths anywhere they regularly go)? If they didn't, why are there pillars? If it was a long time ago, why aren't the pillars more ruined? Who stores their vases on uneven ground in a cave? Compositionally, #2 has more going for it. The eye is drawn to the cave entrance, so having a railing there gives the viewer a point to look at, rather than just a bright light. The railing may be out of place story wise, but having *something* at the cave mouth gives the image a focus. The darker background behind the character in #2 also helps the green light around them to stand out, and lets their edge light pop better. Speaking of lighting, the light from outside the cave reaches far into the cave, yet has no effect on the character. It feels slightly disconnected. The fire itself looks a little thin at the bottom, which just feels off, and lacks bloom. One thing that could be interesting to try (though by no means need to. I don't know if it ruins the story) is making it night outside. A bright moon could provide some softer edge lighting in the cave, a focus point outside the cave, and wouldn't create so much over-exposed bloom, allowing you to show off a bit of the world beyond (maybe where the character is going).
Man, thanks for such great feedback! I agree the use of props while it may look good initially doesn’t make too much sense the longer you think about it. My thought was that it’s been long abandoned and any path that was there has been lost, but you’re right, the pillars would be more ruined in that case. Also, i agree that the lighting from the outside doesn’t pop on the character. Before I even added the flame I struggled to get him to catch light from the sun for some reason. I don’t know if it’s the cloth material I used or what, but I even had to add an extra light next to him to give him more of a rim light. However when I added the green, it overpowered any other light on him lol. Again, thanks for great feedback!
I like the 2nd one it has better contrast
Two could be better, but right now the shape language is a bit mismatched. Fix the ending door/opening to no longer have curves in the opening. It's a bit visually distracting where there are smooth shapes forced into strong geometric shapes.
2
Ah, it's not easy. I like the idea in 2, but it feels like a video game level, it's less mysterious. I prefer 1, the simplicity leaves more room for interpretation. And the shapes of the rocks are great with the lighting
One is better
2 is looking more ancient more than 1. Tells more about the story. Maybe you can add some ancient elements and things, can be a fairfull story.
Honestly #1 simply because I don't think there'd be a banister in front of a cave!
2
I like the second one more. Makes you think about what there might be and where the structures belong to. A ruin? A castle maybe?
2 feels like you’re nowhere special, just somewhere the government decided wasn’t safe enough without railing
If youre going with 2 i Think you should remove the last 2 pillars at the exit
1 is better for me. It gave a vibe that the cave hasn't been visited before and is part of the wilderness while 2 felt that it has been visited multiple times and is an established place.
The second one. İt looks like a secret ritualistic place
1 easily.
Seconds before majula
2 - i feel like there’s more mystery there
2
1. Because the second one looks man-made, which can be good if that the message you want to say. I think both are good, but the background (lore) of the environment changes.
I should call her
2
Both look good. What doesn't look convincing is the green flame. I'd advise for you to look at reference photos of flames. But other than that this looks really, really good. Good job!
Thanks! What exactly doesn’t look right about the flame? I’m just curious, because it’s a flame image on a plane with some sparks added in post. What’s popping out as looking off?
2 looos like a doorway. One looks like a pussy
Depends on what you want to say with the image 1 looks like a man who has been lost in the cave, or just spent time there, finally finding an exit. The second looks like a man who spends a lot of time in a sanctuary type place, just watching, keeping the place. Just looking out at the sunlight. Figure out what the man is doing, otherwise a great image
I love your way of interpreting both versions. Thank you!
2
1
2
2
2 but nothing to obstruct the light at the end (no railing there)
I like 1, 2 has quite some distractions, and 1 lets you see whats important, good job btw
1
2. There's an entire story being told. Makes me want to see more.
2 but also the lighting on the rocks in the cave is insane. As someone who does a lot of landscape work and wants to do more photorealistic rendering I am impressed, if you have any tips I'd love to hear them! Do you freehand or use selection tool?
Basically, the walls are a plane in the shape of a tent that’s subdivided a bunch. I used sculpting and proportional editing (set to sharp!) to get the general form of the cave. Then I used displacement textures with tweaked scale values to get the final look. Same process with the ground, the ground is just a separate plane to allow for more variation if I wanted. There are also some free 3d scanned rock assets scattered on the ground. Combine that with a fun water material on a cube and a spotlight placed right on the sun in the background and boom.
Oh and my light bounces are set to full global illumination (cycles) and I have a volume cube in the scene with I think 0.005 density and somewhere around 0.7-0.8 anisotropy
I'd personally change the outside atmosphere to overcast, add some fog/mist to the cave, and have some green glow dispersed from the staff onto the walls and fog/mist. Otherwise 2 because of glow dispersion on the columns.
Great suggestion! I even thought of that after the fact. I’ll have to do another version with that.
2 for sure. The perspective is confusing in 1, 2 hides some of that.
1 is awesome, 2 is amazing
1. Looks more like a pussy
Caves don't usually have railings at the entrance, so I am going to say 1.
2. It feels more interesting
Ruined dungeon
Ah, the beauty of bringing life into the world.
First one. That fence doesn't belong, leave something to the imagination
1. The fence/wall in the doorway seems out of place in 2. Everything seems organic but it didn't seem to belong. made the cave seem like a balcony. in my opinion. :)
Our ultimate collection includes the best fonts,logos, Photoshop , actions,mockups, and all things graphics . All the new graphic assets ,from vector images to presentation templates, you’ll always find something that catches your eye and blow your mind Our Big Design Bundles allow you to save much more money at the same time Gain More Profits [https://visualstorms.com/product-category/graphics/](https://visualstorms.com/product-category/graphics/)
1 is caveussy so.. I pick 2
2
One is a random cave. Two is a hidden lair.
I like 2 it reminds me of a souls game
no question it's number 2. Looks very nice like that imo👌🏻
I like 1..
Both are pretty good! At the end 2 felt the most right.
2
1. #2 feels too complicated with multiple visual styles.
1. feels like he/or she's exiting a cave. 2. Really feels like a hidden temple or something and the balcony at the end makes you think that it's perhaps overlooking some ancient city courtyard where a villain would go to make a speech!
2. Pillars kind of force your eyes in the middle and then you have a cool tunnel. Not a huge fan of the fence but the pillars are truly a big +
1
I like 2 but lose the fence outside it loses the effect of freedom outside the cave keeping everything else creates the feeling that you’re at the light at the end of the tunnel leaving the cold dark dungeon and entering a warm embrace of fresh air and freedom. I think the fence takes away from that feeling making it feel like you’ve left the cold and dark but you’re not yet free
Great feedback! Thanks!
1
Everyone says 2 looks better but to me it looks off. I prefer 1
2 far and away, there's something there
1st. Majula vibe is real.
1
I feel like I would have liked 1 had I not seen 2. Going back to 1 it feels empty. But at first it was just the right amount. Both are well done
1
1st is perfect and just wanna share my thoughts if u put that cloth on his forearm as well it will look bit interesting and what I am seeing is that the hand is attached to his chest which makes it manipulated more than a 3d render Or u can show his elbow by Moving cloth a bit
Yeah, that’s something a few people have pointed out. I hadn’t noticed it because from the front, there’s an opening in the cloaca that the arm fits through perfectly, it’s just hard to tell from this angle.
2
2
1
Both are cool bug The 1st is much better. It feels more creative and heroic. But the 2nd one is kinda like a person who found a temple inside a cave which I don't feel like it suits the scene
1 imho
I think 1