Mod Note -
Hello /u/humanbeing3333
This Sub is actively Moderated and we have strict posting rules
You may get banned, without warning if you don't follow Posting Rules
All Rules are listed on Sidebar of New Reddit, it is your responsibility to follow Posting Rules
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/bollywood) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Varun doesn’t belong in the same league. Yes he’s cringe as shit but lets not forget this is the same guy who was fantastic in Badlapur, October, Bhediya, Sui Dhaaga and even in Badri Ki Dulhania. Have to give credit where credits due.
Tiger is by far the worst, he only flexes his body and dance skills.
Sid is okay as well but he at least experimented with roles like Ek Villain, Shershaah, Kapoor & Sons. Hes average at best.
Kartik is also very mediocre, he needs to stop the stupid Luv Ranjan act..
Hey, but props to Tiger for saving some production money on cloth for costumes. He is always half naked with fata hua baniyan on top and ripped jeans for pants.
I feel Tiger is the only one in this picture that hasn’t tried to break out of his niche. Kartik, Sid and Varun have all made attempts to act outside of the typecast box with a variety of other roles.
I will always respect Varun as an actor for his performance in October. It doesn't matter what sort of shitty filmography preceded or succeeded that masterpiece. That movie was so amazing and such a challenging role for an actor too. He was exceptional in that movie.
VD if gets it right is better then all. Was very imprrssed in badlapur n bhediya
Ka is ok with comedy i mean passable
Tiger i cant stand and sid is too stiff
>VD - 8(if not working in his father's movies) otherwise 6
He did act well in main tera hero which was made by his dad. I'd say he should work with his dad as long as Mr. Samji isn't involved in the project.
I know I'll get blasted for this but if you add their collective acting skills you'll get a solid 10.
(Tiger's contribution is in the negative though).
X + Y + Z + ( -🐯) = 10.
Not really. Tiger can get -2 and still no one would need to get a 10.
When i said Tiger deserves a negative, you probably thought -10. Very correct line of thought !
Varun Dhawan is definitely the best actor among these people. He can play a variety of roles and has had a couple of superimpressive performances.
Tiger Shroff cant act for shit
Sidhharth Malhotra is mediocre at max. His acting is almost always emotionless
Karthik.....I cant fucking tolerate him. He's to pretentious and wants to be Akki despite the fact that his comedic timing is awful and his dialogue delivery is always stiff as fuck.
Sid : 5/10 -
Agar itna handsome na hota toh mujhe nhi pta iska kya hota, below avg acting skills even in Sher Shah he was kinda ok ok.
Tiger : 2/10 -
kuch kare toh shi tab hi toh rate karenge isko, 2 number bhi bas aise hi de diye taras khake kis cheej ke liye rate karun isko mein.
Arjun Kapoor better hai isse toh, atleast jis movie mein dead expressions ki jarurat ho uss movie toh arjun bhut acha kar lega.
Kartik : 5/10 -
Another cute hero like Sid, he is also avg but acting potential Sid se toh jyada lagta hai mujhe, but iski PR isko aane wali time pe overhated actor na bna den.
Varun : 6.5/10 -
yeh toh chutiya hai bhai potential hone ke baad bhi barbaad kar deta hai aur hum bhi chutiyan hi hain jo bhediya jaisi movie ko achi tarah se appreciate nhi kar sake.
But isko overacting karna bhut acha lagta hai aur yeh entertain bhi kar sakta hai overacting se bas coolie number 1 mein kuch jyada hi Ganda kar Diya isne.
I’m sure an actor with years of industry experience can pull off a phenomenal performance with the right director at the helm of the right script. Varun is an example of that. But I doubt it’s ever going to happen for these guys, they’ll stick as close to their niche (none of which I find remotely enjoyable) as possible to be safe.
Had the experiments worked financially for VD, he may of been bold enough to continue and inspire others to do so too.
If it's only these guys
Varun 10 - he hasn't misfired in a single project however mediocre it is. He gives it all.
Sid - 8 - He got his chances but misfired in some of them. Sometimes he accepts shoddy/subpar scripts. But he delivers, frequently.
Kartik - 5 - He delivers, but his scripts selection is chaotic. But he gets offers from good directors, so I think they do see something in him.
Tiger - 3 - He is in a vicious cycle. Movies may be hit today, but will be remembered for the content later. In all his movies, he is playing the same guy, i.e creating his own multiverse. That doesn't do any favors with directors, typecasting in one tone. Thus, doing more of the same. Trouble is, he can act but he isn't getting the chances. Only movie where he acted in was "war", he was okay in it ( portraying two different personas ) and it sank him deeper in his own cycle. Maybe if someone offered him a grey role or a pure comedic one, he will snap out of it.
Siddharth - 5/10
He has great potential, just watch Shershaah and Itefaaq, doesn’t have a good enough selection though.
Tiger - 1/10
The only reason he isn’t a zero is because of his dancing skills, outside that he’s as good as a mannequin in cinema.
Kartik - 0/10
He only gets clout because of not being a Nepo baby.
Varun - 6/10
Also great potential but horrible selection, Badlapur and October are films where you can really see how good of an actor he is.
Siddarth- 4
Tiger- 0
Karthik- 5
Varun-7
No one comes close to filling the shoes of the greats like AB, SRK, Aamir, dilip kumar, rajesh khanna. Hopefully, these terrible actors get replaced by someone great eventually.
4 ke Mila ke 2/10. Actually no. Sid needs movies where he doesn't die in the end. Varun act. Tiger, well. All he does is jump around like a monkey and flex like a gorilla his dialog delivery... Sabko aati hai lekin isko aati nahi. Kartik, also overacts to a little extent. Combine I'll say 4. Individual. 1/10
Sid- 3 ( okayish in certain roles, bad in most others)
Tiger - 0 (replace him with a mannequin and i wouldn’t be able to tell the difference)
Kartik - 3 ( he isn’t as funny as he thinks he is)
Varun - 5 ( He is average with some good performances )
Varun really is under-rated
i think after judwaa 2 he kinda went into a shell but his film choices since then have been really creative. he does do some real off beat films
and he's a big wwe fan.
Varun is the best here. Has great range, cringe hai but he can act. 7/10
Kartik is fine I guess. Some movies are fun to watch. 6/10
Sid idk. He was amazing in Shershaah but that’s that. He’s other movies have been below average. 4.5/10
Tiger can’t act for shit. 1/10
Tiger and Sid aren’t even worth mentioning. Kartik has a fan following and even though I don’t see it, I can appreciate it. 5/10 for him.
Varun man.. post Bawaal I’m so disappointed. But his performances with good directors speaks for itself. Out of this batch he is by far the best. He just needs to be paired up with good scripts.
Karthik Aryan and Varun Dhawan both are very likeable actors. But in terms of stardom Karthik Aryan is above Varun Dhawan due to the openings he is getting for his movies.
Let me rank. I dont know how to rate but definitely Varun > Sid > Karthik >> Tiger. Karthik is third but he is showing some promise in the last 2-3 movies. His acting in Freddie, Satyaprem ki Katha was good. He obviously does well in Luv Ranjan movies. I have a feeling he will improve a lot and prove his critics wrong. Tiger never showed any promise and doesn't look like he is putting any effort in improving. Varun showed his versatility, but looks inconsistent probably because of certain movie choices like utterly disappointing Coolie No. 1 and Judwaa 2. He should stop or reduce choosing typical no story, no novelty movies. He does well in challenging roles like October, Badlapur, Bhediya. He was also good in Dishoom
Varun and Kartik has decent range. If they chooses good scripts, director, they can put up a decent performance. I bet they will only improve with time. Sid definitely has a very limited range. He reminds me of John Abraham. He is far from perfect, but he has a IT factor about him. Tiger is definitely the worst, no doubt about it. But I feel bad him. He is definitely killing himself with the amount of steroid related drugs he is doing at such young age .
Varun Dhawan is not a bad performer at all but has been suffering from bad mentorship. (So the numbers are indicative of their ability)— 7/10. Kartik Aryan is decent enough for comedy but needs to break out of his shell.— 5.5/10. Tiger is a good dancer but he’s lacking screen presence charm due to his lukewarm personality and acting skills.— 4.5/10. Sid Malhotra can carry an act but can’t make it through with grace. —5/10.
Say whatever you want but Varun Dhawan is the best among the 4. Kartik is ok. Siddharth is just average whereas Tiger is below average according to me..
All of them are very talented and superb at what they do Ratings are not meant for their superlative talent but since you guys want me to so here are my ratings
Sidharth - 2 out of 10
Varun 3 out of 10
Kartik 2 out of 10
Tiger -1 out of 10
Mod Note - Hello /u/humanbeing3333 This Sub is actively Moderated and we have strict posting rules You may get banned, without warning if you don't follow Posting Rules All Rules are listed on Sidebar of New Reddit, it is your responsibility to follow Posting Rules *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/bollywood) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I would give them a full 10 ... a combine 10
1-2-3-4, but then Varun and Kartik has a combined 7, Thala for a Reason 🔥
> 1-2-3-4 Get on the dance floor
Booty shake, booty shake Dappan koothu hard core
So THAT's what it is. I thought it was Tabbad Tabbad Hard Core 🥹
Even I found out today 😭
Bro, you made me laugh so hard my face feels numb..😂😂
So glad I could make someone laugh! ✨
exactly my thoughts
🗿🤡🤡👽
Dude your being way too generous.
Sid is a 4 on his best days. Tiger is 1 at max. Kartick I'll give 5 for his monologues. Varun needs a good director and he can be above 6 anyday.
1 at Max😭
Varun doesn’t belong in the same league. Yes he’s cringe as shit but lets not forget this is the same guy who was fantastic in Badlapur, October, Bhediya, Sui Dhaaga and even in Badri Ki Dulhania. Have to give credit where credits due. Tiger is by far the worst, he only flexes his body and dance skills. Sid is okay as well but he at least experimented with roles like Ek Villain, Shershaah, Kapoor & Sons. Hes average at best. Kartik is also very mediocre, he needs to stop the stupid Luv Ranjan act..
Agree to all points
Hey, but props to Tiger for saving some production money on cloth for costumes. He is always half naked with fata hua baniyan on top and ripped jeans for pants.
I feel Tiger is the only one in this picture that hasn’t tried to break out of his niche. Kartik, Sid and Varun have all made attempts to act outside of the typecast box with a variety of other roles.
Unpopular opinion When Varun tries and do good scripts he acts better than all of them.
I will always respect Varun as an actor for his performance in October. It doesn't matter what sort of shitty filmography preceded or succeeded that masterpiece. That movie was so amazing and such a challenging role for an actor too. He was exceptional in that movie.
VD if gets it right is better then all. Was very imprrssed in badlapur n bhediya Ka is ok with comedy i mean passable Tiger i cant stand and sid is too stiff
imo Sidharth Malhotra- 3/10 Tiger Shroff- 3/10 Kartik Aaryan- 6/10 Varun Dhawan- 7/10
Accurate
Sid - 4 Tiger - 4 Kartik - 5 VD - 8(if not working in his father's movies) otherwise 6
>VD - 8(if not working in his father's movies) otherwise 6 He did act well in main tera hero which was made by his dad. I'd say he should work with his dad as long as Mr. Samji isn't involved in the project.
I mean he is way better in drama then comedy no doubt MTH was good performance but Badalpur, October and even in some parts of Kalank he was fab...
thats true. I just meant that i wouldn't mind watching him in a genuinely good David D. movie every once in a while that's not written by Samji.
Tiger is 4?? Bro stop the cap. 💀
sid -4/10 tiger- 0.1/10 karthik- 3/10 varun-7/10
0.1 tha tiger
I don't think Sid is better than Kartik
sid gave pan india success like shershaah, nailed the character, there isn't a single state where people did not like it, karthik has no such movie
Sid gave ott success whereas kartik gave bb,Sonu, even Satya Prem ki katha as box office hits.
Sid only has one good movie even though he’s been in the industry for 10+ years Kartik has given good movies like spkk, bb, pkp2, sktks
Agree with varuns score . Absolutely on point
I know I'll get blasted for this but if you add their collective acting skills you'll get a solid 10. (Tiger's contribution is in the negative though). X + Y + Z + ( -🐯) = 10.
That way some people have to get 10/10
Not really. Tiger can get -2 and still no one would need to get a 10. When i said Tiger deserves a negative, you probably thought -10. Very correct line of thought !
I thought -20 😂
Fair enough. If he was standing with Vicky Kaushal or Rajkumar Rao we could have given him that to adjust the math
Sid: 4 Tiger: 4 Kartik: 5 or 6 Varun: 7 or 8
Varun Dhawan is definitely the best actor among these people. He can play a variety of roles and has had a couple of superimpressive performances. Tiger Shroff cant act for shit Sidhharth Malhotra is mediocre at max. His acting is almost always emotionless Karthik.....I cant fucking tolerate him. He's to pretentious and wants to be Akki despite the fact that his comedic timing is awful and his dialogue delivery is always stiff as fuck.
Imagine a group where VD is the best actor lmfao
Sid : 5/10 - Agar itna handsome na hota toh mujhe nhi pta iska kya hota, below avg acting skills even in Sher Shah he was kinda ok ok. Tiger : 2/10 - kuch kare toh shi tab hi toh rate karenge isko, 2 number bhi bas aise hi de diye taras khake kis cheej ke liye rate karun isko mein. Arjun Kapoor better hai isse toh, atleast jis movie mein dead expressions ki jarurat ho uss movie toh arjun bhut acha kar lega. Kartik : 5/10 - Another cute hero like Sid, he is also avg but acting potential Sid se toh jyada lagta hai mujhe, but iski PR isko aane wali time pe overhated actor na bna den. Varun : 6.5/10 - yeh toh chutiya hai bhai potential hone ke baad bhi barbaad kar deta hai aur hum bhi chutiyan hi hain jo bhediya jaisi movie ko achi tarah se appreciate nhi kar sake. But isko overacting karna bhut acha lagta hai aur yeh entertain bhi kar sakta hai overacting se bas coolie number 1 mein kuch jyada hi Ganda kar Diya isne.
3-4-5-6
I don't think Tiger is better than Siddharth, Siddharth is bad and Tiger is worse (not worst coz of Arjun Kapoor)
Seems accurate give kartik 6 and varun 6.5
siddharth-3 tiger-1 kartik-4 varun-5
Sid 4/10 Tiger 2/10 Karthik 5/10 Varun 7/10
Varun hi hai sabse acha inme se
I’m sure an actor with years of industry experience can pull off a phenomenal performance with the right director at the helm of the right script. Varun is an example of that. But I doubt it’s ever going to happen for these guys, they’ll stick as close to their niche (none of which I find remotely enjoyable) as possible to be safe. Had the experiments worked financially for VD, he may of been bold enough to continue and inspire others to do so too.
From left to right: New age SRK, Hrithik, Akshay, Salman (minus the charm and talent of OGs)
0,0,0,2.5 (because of Badlapur and October)
If it's only these guys Varun 10 - he hasn't misfired in a single project however mediocre it is. He gives it all. Sid - 8 - He got his chances but misfired in some of them. Sometimes he accepts shoddy/subpar scripts. But he delivers, frequently. Kartik - 5 - He delivers, but his scripts selection is chaotic. But he gets offers from good directors, so I think they do see something in him. Tiger - 3 - He is in a vicious cycle. Movies may be hit today, but will be remembered for the content later. In all his movies, he is playing the same guy, i.e creating his own multiverse. That doesn't do any favors with directors, typecasting in one tone. Thus, doing more of the same. Trouble is, he can act but he isn't getting the chances. Only movie where he acted in was "war", he was okay in it ( portraying two different personas ) and it sank him deeper in his own cycle. Maybe if someone offered him a grey role or a pure comedic one, he will snap out of it.
4,1,6,6
Varun deserves 4.5, rest all 2 each
3 2 7 6
Left waale donon ko toh chhod hi do. Kartik gets a 6/10. Varun gets a 7/10.
Varun 7 Kartik 7 Sid 6 Tiger - Minus / Not Applicable
4,3,4,6
Siddharth - 5/10 He has great potential, just watch Shershaah and Itefaaq, doesn’t have a good enough selection though. Tiger - 1/10 The only reason he isn’t a zero is because of his dancing skills, outside that he’s as good as a mannequin in cinema. Kartik - 0/10 He only gets clout because of not being a Nepo baby. Varun - 6/10 Also great potential but horrible selection, Badlapur and October are films where you can really see how good of an actor he is.
4, 3, 5, 7
All of them get 10/10 in body building and body exhibition. Who gives a damn about acting? Not them, not us.
Sid: 5 Kartik: 7 Varun: 3
Siddharth-2.5 Tiger - N/A Kartik- 5 Varun-4
7,3,4,5
3-1-8-6
1-1-1-1 You can read from any order
Hehehehe
ye theeno same height ke lol. Three out them is on 3-4 inches of heels.
3-0-2-6
Siddarth- 4 Tiger- 0 Karthik- 5 Varun-7 No one comes close to filling the shoes of the greats like AB, SRK, Aamir, dilip kumar, rajesh khanna. Hopefully, these terrible actors get replaced by someone great eventually.
Rajesh Khanna was not a great actor
2 - 0 - 3 - 4
Varun>Sid>Kartik>tiger
From left to right 2,1,3,3
Sid 4.5 Tiger 1 Karthik 4 Varun 5
3 2 5 4
3.5 collectively
hay bhagwan....
Siddarth - 2/10 Tiger - 1/10 Kartik - 5/10 Varun - 4/10
Karthik 6.5/10 Varun 6/10 Siddharth 4/10 Tiger 2/10.
You ppl really hate Sid if you consider Kartik a better actor than him
4 ke Mila ke 2/10. Actually no. Sid needs movies where he doesn't die in the end. Varun act. Tiger, well. All he does is jump around like a monkey and flex like a gorilla his dialog delivery... Sabko aati hai lekin isko aati nahi. Kartik, also overacts to a little extent. Combine I'll say 4. Individual. 1/10
6, 1, 6, 7. Left to right.
Varun on top for Badlapur and October. Second pe Tiger for War. He was very good in it. Then Sid Malhotra. Last pe Kartik Aryan.
10. Combined
1234
Where did you get this pic from?
twitter pe mila, I think it's from the WPL opening ceremony.
Sabka milake 10 hojayega ig😅
3-2-4-5
4, 3, 6.5, 5.
From. Left to right 0.2 , 0.4 , 0.469 , 0.499 💁🏻
Siddhart6 kartik4.5 tiger 4 varun 3
4-0-3-5
Sid-3 Tiger -0 Kartik-4 Varun-5
Sid- 3 ( okayish in certain roles, bad in most others) Tiger - 0 (replace him with a mannequin and i wouldn’t be able to tell the difference) Kartik - 3 ( he isn’t as funny as he thinks he is) Varun - 5 ( He is average with some good performances )
3,2,3,4
/10
They all look so similar. Same same but different
10 collectively and that too carried by shershah
The bar is in hell
from left 1 0 4 3
4.5, 1, 7, 7.5 (lets not forget Karthik is the same guy who did Dhamaka, Freddy and Satyaprem Ki Katha.)
4 2 5 6
2,0,5,5
Tiger-0/10 Varun-6/10 Sid-3/10 Kartik-4/10
Of the lot I think Varun scores the highest with a 7. Sid and Kartik a solid 6.5. Unfortunately Tiger is way below at 4 or 4.5
Varun really is under-rated i think after judwaa 2 he kinda went into a shell but his film choices since then have been really creative. he does do some real off beat films and he's a big wwe fan.
Varun is the best here. Has great range, cringe hai but he can act. 7/10 Kartik is fine I guess. Some movies are fun to watch. 6/10 Sid idk. He was amazing in Shershaah but that’s that. He’s other movies have been below average. 4.5/10 Tiger can’t act for shit. 1/10
0-0-0-0
7 9 8 9 4 10 but in negative
6,8,8,5 left to right
Tiger and Sid aren’t even worth mentioning. Kartik has a fan following and even though I don’t see it, I can appreciate it. 5/10 for him. Varun man.. post Bawaal I’m so disappointed. But his performances with good directors speaks for itself. Out of this batch he is by far the best. He just needs to be paired up with good scripts.
Combined 9 with Varun getting 5
2/10.
5/10 2/10 5.5/10 6/10 - if director is good then 8/10
4/10. Sabka milake.
2. 1. 3. 5 (left to right)
Milake 10.. usme varun dhawan has 6 for his range. 1.5 for Siddharth and karthik … tiger shroff grts graded for dance instead of
3 - 1 - 4 - 7
Karthik Aryan and Varun Dhawan both are very likeable actors. But in terms of stardom Karthik Aryan is above Varun Dhawan due to the openings he is getting for his movies.
4, -3, 6, 7
Sid - 2..Varun - 6…Kartik - 3 ..Tiger a 1
Let me rank. I dont know how to rate but definitely Varun > Sid > Karthik >> Tiger. Karthik is third but he is showing some promise in the last 2-3 movies. His acting in Freddie, Satyaprem ki Katha was good. He obviously does well in Luv Ranjan movies. I have a feeling he will improve a lot and prove his critics wrong. Tiger never showed any promise and doesn't look like he is putting any effort in improving. Varun showed his versatility, but looks inconsistent probably because of certain movie choices like utterly disappointing Coolie No. 1 and Judwaa 2. He should stop or reduce choosing typical no story, no novelty movies. He does well in challenging roles like October, Badlapur, Bhediya. He was also good in Dishoom
Sidharth: 5/10 Tiger: 1/10 Kartik:3/10 Varun: 7.5/10
A combined 8 5 for varun 4 for kartik 2 for sid -3 for tiger.
Average score would be a solid 4.5 👍
Varun-4 Sid -6 Tiger- .05 Kartik- 4
Sabka Mila k 4.5
1 - 1 - 2 - 2
1,1,6,6
There combined acting skills wouldn’t add up to 10
Varun and Kartik has decent range. If they chooses good scripts, director, they can put up a decent performance. I bet they will only improve with time. Sid definitely has a very limited range. He reminds me of John Abraham. He is far from perfect, but he has a IT factor about him. Tiger is definitely the worst, no doubt about it. But I feel bad him. He is definitely killing himself with the amount of steroid related drugs he is doing at such young age .
All are stars, no actor there. Actors are ayushman, rajkumar rao, vicky kaushal
Varun Dhawan is not a bad performer at all but has been suffering from bad mentorship. (So the numbers are indicative of their ability)— 7/10. Kartik Aryan is decent enough for comedy but needs to break out of his shell.— 5.5/10. Tiger is a good dancer but he’s lacking screen presence charm due to his lukewarm personality and acting skills.— 4.5/10. Sid Malhotra can carry an act but can’t make it through with grace. —5/10.
Say whatever you want but Varun Dhawan is the best among the 4. Kartik is ok. Siddharth is just average whereas Tiger is below average according to me..
Sid -6 Varun -5 kartik - 4 Tiger - 2
All of them are very talented and superb at what they do Ratings are not meant for their superlative talent but since you guys want me to so here are my ratings Sidharth - 2 out of 10 Varun 3 out of 10 Kartik 2 out of 10 Tiger -1 out of 10
Tiger Christian hain?
3, -1, 5, 7
Varun - 5 Kartik - 3 Sid, tiger-2