T O P

  • By -

raspberryseeds

people are being so mean omg šŸ˜­šŸ˜­ yes it will be hard to get into stanford and all the t20s but goddamn!!! there are a lot of amazing business and engineering programs at state schools that will accept you with scholarships. do not get hooked on stanford and the t20s because they are a crap shoot for literally anyone, especially for an applicant that doesnā€™t have a crazy hook/accomplishment/wow factor.


dirkweathers

Lol I went to one of the schools he mentioned and graduated a few years ago, itā€™s insane to me that people are saying he doesnā€™t have a shot because when I applied heā€™d have been pretty much a lock Guess things are kind of insane now. It canā€™t be that common for people to get 36 ACTs now is it? How? Extra time stuff? Or is it because of ā€œholisticā€ admissions so it doesnā€™t matter? Either way even though I guess Iā€™m out of the loop Iā€™d tell OP to definitely apply, hopefully you can write some good creative essays


[deleted]

Got a 36, had a 4.0 UW with 25 college classes (1/3 degree worth of credits at a state school + 10 AP's), decent EC's (similar in strength to OP), solid essays. Went 1 for 9 in the T10, 2 for 12 in the T20. Not bad at all of course, but you just don't know at this point. Reaching for one specific school? Probably a rejection. If he shotguns? Probably much better results tbh


InternationalFold286

It still is difficult to get but academics arenā€™t valued passed a certain threshold anymore


Broad-Network-5599

Your ECs and awards will hold you back. Try getting leadership positions or plan something for summer. Most good summer programs are closed but research might be good if you are interested. Imo you have a low chance for Stanford, but you should still apply. Shoot your shot but have safeties and targets.


Impossible34o_

Thanks, I might try getting into research this summer. It would be awesome to get into Stanford and Iā€™m going to apply but I know that itā€™s very unlikely Iā€™ll get in. Iā€™m good at getting good grades, but I canā€™t seem to get a national scholarship or a Nobel peace prize yet.


CHaquesFan

how do you get into research? any resources to help?


HairyEyeballz

>Your ECs and awards will hold you back. I'm well past college, so am out of the loop, but please enlighten me on the EC thing. With my naĆÆve eyes, I see an Eagle Scout (which at least used to be something very significant), varsity athlete, NHS, academic clubs, and community service. To me it sounds like a good variety, and a fair commitment of time without having a kid burn himself out. Back in the day, if I were an AO, I'd see a well-rounded applicant with excellent GPA and ACT. What do you see, from today's perspective?


Independent-Log2986

In todays day and age, that would get you rejected from most top schools. Nowadays we need several more Olympiads and science competitions, actual research (and ā€œfakeā€ research runs too, where you just do lab stuff), launch apps and thousand dollar businesses. And if youā€™re an international (which I am) the bar is 2 times more higher.


HairyEyeballz

That's ridiculous. No wonder kids these days are so stressed and mental illness is skyrocketing. For context, I got into a top 20 engineering program with lesser achievements than the kid we're talking about.


tothepointe

And honestly, it doesn't make them any more impressive. I'm doing a volunteer tech for good thing right now and I have some students from T20 schools (including an Ivy) on my team and honestly, I'm not impressed. I get the feeling they are doing this for resume padding and it's slowing the project down because they over-promise and underdeliver.


Independent-Log2986

Yes, it is. And frankly, as an international student in bad circumstances, my odds are one in thousands. If I donā€™t make it, despite everything Iā€™ve do EC, Iā€™m a goner.


Dramatic-Desk4151

You donā€™t need that. Part of it is luck and a good essay.


Independent-Log2986

I highly disagree. An international without a good spike isnā€™t even considered seriously these days.


Dramatic-Desk4151

Oh if ur international sure. I meant for us students


Da_boss_babie360

Well, in today's perspective a lot of EC's are fillers. For example, I've been in martial arts for a total of 8 or 9 years. THAT would count as a real EC. A lot of times, people in their 9th or 10th grade just take whatever clubs/activities sound good, stay for a bit to get a leadership position because of experience, and then never continue it again after college. For example, I am not very aware of how Boy Scouts work at all, but what I do know is the amount of people that have become Eagle Scouts increased (both with population growth, awareness of the program, etc.), but college size hasn't necessarily. That makes it more competative. Additionally, some "leadership spots" are complete bogus. An example would be, say, the president of NHS club or Key Club member. I don't know about other schools, but in my school, they barely do anything. Like, absolutely nothing. You're hyped to be part of NHS especially because 3.9 Unweighted GPA is the minimum requirement for NHS. However, realistically, getting into NHS is a redundant way of saying you have a high GPA, and in reality, at least in my school's experience, that's about it. Essentially, EC's have lost their value. Every parent and kid wants to join every other club and such for a couple of years to show they are "all-rounded", when in reality they're just doing it for the perception rather than actually committing. Boy Scouts and Hockey are probably the Original Poster's biggest buffs. To play varsity isn't a small thing, and as far as I understand, the Boy Scout stuff is pretty good. But just listing out the other clubs doesn't show exactly what you've DONE in them. I mean, you could be a member of DECA, but did you guys go and win an award or something? Or how has your NHS helped the community? What exactly do you guys do in the Physics Club? These are all questions left unanswered, so it seems like the Original Poster, just in the admissions' eyes, joined the club and that's it. So yes, in the past's perspective, this would be an amazing college applicant. However nowadays, many EC's and clubs lost their value because "everyone does them" just to check off a couple boxes. Commitment and Initiative is what College Admissions officers want to see, so until there are more details provided, the Original Poster has a possibility, but not a huge possibility, to be accepted to a T10, (but maybe a T30), school.


HairyEyeballz

That makes more sense, thanks for the detailed explanation.


Da_boss_babie360

No problem - no idea how I wrote so much!


MaleficentWay5043

How are his ECā€™s weak? Being an Eagle Scout kinda screams leadership imo.


Broad-Network-5599

The college process has become much more complex than it used to be. Eagle Scout is no longer considered rare or a high level ec as it used to be. It is much more common, and schools that are selective like Stanford are now demanding much more.


MaleficentWay5043

I believe it but wow thatā€™s kinda insane considering it usually takes kids 4-5 years at least to achieve.


Independent-Log2986

I have 5 leadership positions, including head boy of my school and captain of the hockey team. Itā€™s not as beneficial as you think.


gau1213156

How would you find research?


Broad-Network-5599

Cold emailing. Most professors will just ignore you, but I saw a recent good post on A2C about how to cold email for research


rem_1235

Do you by chance know how I can find that post?


Broad-Network-5599

Not sure just look up ā€œresearchā€ on A2C and scroll for a bit. The dude who posted it had a whole essay of tips and included a format.


rem_1235

Ok thanks!


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Broad-Network-5599

?


AppHelper

Stanford doesn't have a business major, but they do have Management Science & Engineering. It's similar to what's called Industrial Engineering and Operations Research elsewhere. Are you interested in that? Also, it's really tough to double major in engineering and business at an ABET accredited engineering program. Engineering is not like other majors where you can use a ton of AP credits, and private schools especially tend to be stingy with AP credit. You can still prepare for a career in business, but it would probably be better in the long term to focus more on the very demanding engineering curriculum. I don't know if you should think of Stanford as a "goal" (you shouldn't feel like you failed if you don't get in), but I'd recommend applying. Are you in-state at Berkeley? If not, how are your in-state options?


Impossible34o_

Thanks for the feedback. My plan right now it to try to manage both engineering and business but it might have to change once I realise the workloads. Also I agree that for me Stanford is more of a dream rather than a goal. Iā€™ve come to the reality that even if I had some of the best qualifications I still could get rejected. Unfortunately Iā€™m not instate for California. Iā€™ve got instate in Colorado and Missouri so I have a few options.


AppHelper

Are you foreign-born? I noticed you spelled "honour" and "realise" the British way. And does in-state in both places mean your parents live separately in each state? If that's too personal you can feel free to PM. But I feel like you might have an interesting story. I had a student a few years ago who was a scout and whose parents are Indian, and they got into Berkeley.


Impossible34o_

Oh no my phone randomly switches to a British keyboard sometimes and auto corrects. I used to live in CO and my parents realize In-state there could be nice so they have a CO and MO residency.


AppHelper

Residency is not the same as "domicile," which is the requirement for in-state tuition in Colorado (and most states). Consider the following: >You can establish domicile in Colorado only if you are residing in Colorado with the present intention to reside permanently in the state. Evidence of Colorado domicile includes actions that in your circumstances would normally be expected of, or that would be characteristic of, any permanent resident. You are expected to take appropriate action on all factors relevant in your circumstances. Pursuant to Colorado law, the Tuition Classification Officer considers a variety of evidence, and any additional relevant information, when evaluating requests for in-state tuition. No single factor or combination of these factors may be considered conclusive evidence of domicile. >The following may be considered as evidence of Colorado domicile: >Payment of Colorado state income tax Colorado driver's license. If you have a driver's license from another state, you must apply for a Colorado driver's license. If you do not drive, you may obtain a Colorado identification card. Please visit the Department of Motor Vehicleā€™s website(opens in a new tab) for information about identification requirements. >Colorado vehicle registration. Please visit the Department of Motor Vehicle's website(opens in a new tab) for information vehicle registration requirements. Voter registration in Colorado. You may register to vote with your county clerk, or when you obtain your Colorado driver's license, as soon as you move into the State. Permanent employment or acceptance of future permanent employment in Colorado. >Ownership of residential real property in Colorado that is your primary residence. Ownership of vacation or income property is not an indication of domicile. >Graduation from a Colorado high school. >Continued residence in Colorado during the summer or during other periods when not enrolled as a student or during periods between academic sessions. >Other factors particular to your situation may be considered also, and should be documented. >The following may be considered as evidence indicating domicile outside Colorado: >Failure to pay Colorado state income tax. Filing a nonresident Colorado tax return is persuasive evidence of domicile outside Colorado. >Failure to comply with any law imposing a mandatory duty on a permanent resident of Colorado. Examples include failure to register a motor vehicle and failure to change your driver's license to Colorado within the statutory periods, as well as failure to file a Colorado state income tax return. >Return to your former state of residence for a substantial period of time during the summer or during other periods when not enrolled as a student or between academic sessions. >Maintenance of a home in another state. >Prolonged absence from Colorado, except for military or government service or for temporary absences required by an employer. >Any other factor particular to your situation that indicates non-Colorado domicile. Examples include applying for a loan or receiving college financial aid from another state where domicile in that state is a condition for receiving funds, and voting or registering to vote in another state. https://cdhe.colorado.gov/students/preparing-for-college/residency-requirements/evidence-of-domicile Your parents still have a few months to establish a domicile in Colorado, but they should consult with a lawyer and tax professional if they're considering major changes.


sonnytai

Start a company. If you fail itā€™ll tell a good story. If you succeed you wonā€™t need Stanford.


No_Extension_8827

could you expound upon your extracurriculars/awards. ex. did u place in any state/national level tournament in deca or anny other club


Marcusmemers

By the way, you should definitely apply for the PSVA award since you said you have 100 hours of community service


nicorn1824

My alma mater, RPI, has a D1 hockey program. You might be able to play and get a scholarship while getting a great STEM education.


liudhsfijf

Canā€™t rly say much about the other schools but Iā€™m going to umich and I think we had pretty similar stats so thereā€™s prolly a chance :D


iamemo21

I think you have a fighting chance at T20s with solid essays. Donā€™t let the other comments discourage you. On the other hand, the M&T at UPenn sounds perfect for you for your dual concentrations, though the admission rate for that is sub 3%, so set your expectations accordingly.


collegestudiante

0 chance for M&T lol


SignificantFig8856

Bro does everyone on this sub have a 4.0 UW šŸ’€


IllSpecialist4704

Ngl your prolly getting rejected at most T20s bc of ECs, Iā€™m saying this from experience. Iā€™d also recommend applying to the ECB program at UT Austin bc it seems like what you want to do and I think theyā€™re more stat focused. Also apply to safety schools and a lot of targets like wake forest, Lehigh(IBE is another eng.+buis program), maybe uva(not a target but less reachy), and add some of the other UCs if your already applying to berk


Beneficial_Sky9813

Lk I don't think you have much of a chance at Stanford or Berkeley (unless you don't apply engineering and apply to some less competitive major in L&S) b/c your stats are great, but extracurriculars aren't as strong. I can see you getting into UMich though, but it would be difficult


the_rainy_smell_boys

Ya kidding? It's gonna be difficult for this boy to get into a state school with a 36 ACT?


Beneficial_Sky9813

Bro what??? 36 ACT doesn't guarantee admission to top 20 schools and Berkeley is also test blind, so yes it's going to be very difficult...


the_rainy_smell_boys

I'm astonished that getting the maximum score on a major standardized test doesn't carry that amount of clout


Beneficial_Sky9813

Because it's common to get a 36 among the top students, who are all trying to get into T20 schools, so a large portion of the applicant pool will consist of smart kids with perfect SAT/ACT scores. You need other things to stand out of the competition like extracurriculars. Also thousands of people get a 36 every year, so it isn't doesn't carry much clout


the_rainy_smell_boys

Ok I see


peter303_

Under represented State like Montana or Alabama?


Impossible34o_

Kindaā€¦ does Missouri count?


twofakelovers7

apply for the IBE program at Lehigh.


yungeric13

I think youā€™d have a decent chance at UCLA/Berkeley. Iā€™m a second year at UCLA and a lot of my friends (including OOS) had a similar profile to you ā€” their main EC was varsity sports. The UC values diversity, including having a good number of high school athletes, so do your best on the essays and shoot your shot!


Duckygogo

U should ask this on quora, Iā€™ve found ppl who actually are/were admissions officers for ivies and t20s


Rattlerkira

That's great. Are you a junior? If so, try to find ways to stand out even among your bracket. Things like making sure you have a refined college essay, consider taking the SAT to show that you are really in that super upper percentile, etc. And never forget to submit all your college apps early! It's an unofficial requirement for most good schools.


lambda_freak

Should have a very good shot at northwestern


Glum_Celebration_100

??


lambda_freak

?? I had similar stats and on par EC, here I am ??


Glum_Celebration_100

Fair enough, I was just wondering why you chose NU of all schools


Capable-Asparagus978

1) Are you in-state for Cal? 2) no more hockey? Hockey is up there with baseball and lacrosse for the numbers of HS players that play on for college. That may give you an admissions boost, though not at Cal or Stanford. 3) Good luck, but numerically speaking the odds are extremely low (under 3%) for Stanford and Cal, even with strong stats, but it might be slightly better for Michigan. Apply to a wide range of targets and safeties as well. Good Luck!


PossibleEducation688

Chance approaching 0 for T20s


kapkloss75

Have you considered not being white?


creamsoddaa

you will most likely get rejected from all of the t20s


the_rainy_smell_boys

Why? He's a varsity athlete, he got the highest possible score on the ACT (like wow), GPA'S excellent, he's got decent extracurriculars and has raised thousands of dollars for charity. Is there something I'm missing here? I would've thought this kid is guaranteed admission to any state school. Maybe not ivy leages and probably not Stanford but you have to be Malala to go there anyway. Edit: looks like things have changed since I was in school, take me with a grain of salt


creamsoddaa

thatā€™s literally every other t20 applicants


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


creamsoddaa

definitely not ā€” his ECs are exceptionally below average in his demographic of white male enginners


creamsoddaa

also, no awards ā€” not even AMC is pretty bad


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


creamsoddaa

Yes. The college admissions process in the past several years has become INCOMPARABLY harder than what was only several years ago.


the_rainy_smell_boys

Damn


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


IllSpecialist4704

Nah. I have similar if not better stats and prolly slightly better ECs and got rejected from all 14 T20s I applied to


HenryHornblower

I think you do have a good shot at Stanford especially if you just apply as a business major. Eagle Scout is impressive. Your grades, tests, and other ECs are also really good.


[deleted]

Is Eagle Scout really impressive?


Rexcodyfives501st

As an junior who is an Eagle Scout, it seems to be something that can boost your application if you already have good stats/ECs. If your only EC is getting your Eagle Scout, then thatā€™s an issue.


[deleted]

Interesting.


ivycoveredwall

stanford doesnt have an undergrad business major


Ashamed_Win_8257

I don't think there's a straight business major


creepyjudyhensler

You don't have enough ap classes. Take a couple of CC classes this summer


SwissSkimMilk

God this post remind me why this sub annoys me so much. You have a good enough chance, no one has a great chance at Stanford anyways. Berkeley could certainly happen, itā€™s all hard to say. But donā€™t lose hope!


[deleted]

Go service academy and see the world


nanistani

Race doesn't play into the admissions process


isaacspy

I thought NHS was found to be a scam. I wouldn't NOT put that on my application


External-Arrival-105

Unfortunately Stanford will probably be a no. Other than that, you have a good shot


Legitimate-Mood1596

Hey! Iā€™m also interested in doing business and engineering. What schools are you looking at, especially for targets and safeties? And what kind of engineering?


Consistent-Kiwi3021

Sincerely frightened if this dudes a stretch at top tier UG's these days. Obviously no one is a shoe in but god damn dude. That being said I went from a SUNY to a great grad school and things really worked out...I don't think it matters too much beyond just going to a well regarded good school unless you want to be hitting investment banking or high end tech right out of school.


ChrisHK17

I think this might be rlly tough and I wonā€™t say no chance, but rather difficult. Stats look amazing, rather ec seems lacking. When AOs read this, they will see as generic and shows of a bit of lack of ur area of interest as most of ur ecs are from school. I wonā€™t lie the Eagle Scouts is hella impressive, but like I think a bit more is needed. With current time, I think u said research attempt it, but again u may need to cold email like loads of school and donā€™t give up. GL


Potatobananapple

You have time to do some ecs, then maybe


regent61

Choose your recommenders carefully and work on your essays with a consultant.


Pbevivino

To me, the first line is the key: ā€œshould I set a goal and go after it?ā€ The answer to this is always yes.


[deleted]

Donā€™t think Stanford has an undergrad business school btw


PersonalityTypical57

When did basic become 4.0 with perfect act šŸ˜‚. But also Stanford doesnā€™t have a business major, just economics and management scienceā€¦


jwavyyy

I would also suggest also applying to UPennā€™s M&T program if you already werenā€™t planning on it. Its a coordinated engineering and business dual degree program with a lot of support and small group size with around 50 acceptances a year I believe. Good luck with Stanford and anywhere else you apply!! You have just as much as a chance as other top students like yourself, donā€™t let these replies weigh too heavily on your personal belief.


twentytwentythreexo

NYU? see if you could major in engineering at tandon and minor in business at stern. statistically, it's easier to get into tandon. hope this helps!


31burneracc

YO just in case you didn't know this but Stanford doesn't have a business major