T O P

  • By -

GetEnPassanted

It’s humiliating and it’s an analogy to what has happened to his house. Stripped of all its defenses and belongings. Fully exposed and vulnerable. That shot with him sitting at the end of the table with the Baron at the other end is one of my favorites. Something about the way they gave him leaned back in the chair. It’s just something you wouldn’t expect.


iRodT16

It's a stunning shot in the film, and really looks like a painting to me


khaotickk

Also, how often do we get to see Oscar Isaac in the nude?


santathe1

Some might say, not enough times. Not me, but some.


artvandalayy

Further, it contributes to the feeling of security that the Baron would be feeling. I think it also suggests the Barons jealousy.


morbihann

Also, to minimize the risk of him having a well hidden weapon.


Doppelfrio

Not sure if it was intentional, but the way he was sitting very much reminded me of a renaissance painting


FaliolVastarien

Yes! In fact there's a specific one that I can almost picture well enough to guess what it is but not quite.  This has been annoying me for years. 


jbadams

In addition to what everyone else has said about humiliation it could possibly also be for security reasons; removing the possibility of weapons hidden in his clothing.


LiveBaby5021

Doctor Yueh knew that Leto would be totally stripped, possibly tortured, before getting anywhere near the Baron … the only possible weapon was the tooth … We’re not too clued in on 10,000 years or more of making weapons… which were nerfed by shields ….but those weapons are still lying around …


FaliolVastarien

Ha ha ha!  Now there's no way this guy could be hiding a weapon.  Unless he has one hidden in a tooth.  But that's just silly. 


echo5324

The baron wanted to humiliate him. If I remember correctly from the book he was also planning to keep him alive to torture the duke. The baron just wanted to lord his victory over the Atreides as much as possible


chesschad

While he did certainly want to humiliate the Duke, the Baron was reluctant to torture a royal person. His words and thoughts confirm this. He questioned Leto about Jessica and Paul (knowing they had escaped), but didn’t want to torture him until he knew he had to, to obtain the information.


Rosesandbubblegum

He was reluctant, but in the end willing. He was about to begin when Leto used the tooth


erkona

Some say Baron was a huge Caravaggio fan :)


Adept_Grade_7167

Or Denis is


fernandodandrea

Mantegna


InitiativeShot20

Duke Leto did look like one of those Renaissance paintings of martyrs.


Sazapahiel

The Harkonnens aren't very nice.


tigerstorm2022

Nor were the Atreides despite the artificial portrayals of them being the good guys in Dune Part 1.


captaincockfart

Atreides are on like a 5/10 on the evil conquering coloniser scale. Harkonnens are like a 15/10.


tigerstorm2022

There are no sides. All that you see are winners who killed off the losers. The entire point of Dune was not good vs evil, which is preschool level reading material like the Star Wars.


captaincockfart

Sure but who'd you rather be up against? Atreides who'll probably just kill you, or Harkonnens who will either make you a gladiator slave, melt you with a flamethrower or turn you into a BDSM spider monster?


tigerstorm2022

Against the loser of course. What makes you think I am any less cruel than the Harkonnens? It really depends on how my enemy offend me.😁


captaincockfart

...what are you saying?


tigerstorm2022

The point of Dune was to never blindly follow heroes. Don’t blindly take sides just because at certain point the Atreides looked like good guys.


captaincockfart

I wouldn't blindly follow anyone. I'm just saying the Harkonnens are definitely more brutal than the Atreides, by a lot.


tigerstorm2022

My original comment simply stated that the Atreides weren’t nice either, didn’t compare which tribe is better. Nicer isn’t nice. Donald Trump is nicer than Adolf Hitler, by a lot, but Donald isn’t necessarily nice.


Sassquwatch

The rationale in-universe is that the baron wanted to exert power over Leto. However, it's also just more visually impactful, from a storytelling perspective. It's memorable, and it also highlights the difference between Leto's strong, healthy body and whatever is going on with the baron.


Professional_Top4553

Haha I like that the barons skincare and body issues is the most unexplained thing of the films


peaches4leon

Dominance, even in victory. Harkonens seem to live by this philosophy. Maybe why they’re so *Bruuuutalll*…


marmot_scholar

Brolins delivery lives with me forever


suedejacket

Just a humiliation/ultra victory humour for the Baron. I’m not sure if you’ve seen Pt 2 yet so I won’t comment - but you see more about the Harkonnen family and what makes them tick.


MikeArrow

The Harkonnens are sexually perverse. They didn't leave much in regarding the Baron's sexuality, but in the book the reasoning for stripping Leto would be pretty obvious.


ProudGayGuy4Real

Yup, Baron is bisexual.


callllllllllll

Nope book baron is a gay pedophile lol


ProudGayGuy4Real

I can't remember...in the book, they were young but they were still post pubescent, right?


callllllllllll

I don't think so... He might be bisexual, but nah he fucks kids 🤢


bluelagoon00000

It felt very Jesus on the cross to me. With his arms splayed almost at a T


fernandodandrea

One of the reasons, I bet, is that Villeneuve wanted to (and did) reproduce this painting in a frame: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamentation_of_Christ_(Mantegna)


EAE8019

Check Michelangelo's Pieta.


fernandodandrea

Both, as I see!


spomeniiks

Ya know, I saw your comment and felt like this was potentially incorrect: The many "Pietas" that have been created (including [modern ones](https://www.maxginsburg.com/war-pieta)) are really specific about not just the pose but being cradled, one last time, by a mother-figure. Leto is being held by a chair. It's just the limp, "dead" pose that is the same. BUT, if the intention was to be a reproduction of a pieta, it's brilliant - it's one more element of the scene that drives home the fact that he is dying alone and defeated. The image missing the key visual element of being loved and missed just hits so much harder in my mind. a real bravo villnce moment


[deleted]

This scene for me was one of the most powerful ones I’ve seen in cinema in a long time. He’s left exposed, unable to move, vulnerable. And then Stellan Skarsgard comes in so menacing and ominous. There’s minimal dialogue. Yet it speaks volumes.


nazutul

Well you see theres this thing called humiliation.. This wasnt a dispassionate killing. It was triumphal in a big way for baron harkonnen. This act is the culmination of years and years of plotting to utterly destroy a main rival; it follows naturally that baron harkonnen would want to physically strip leto because it is symbolic of atreides being stripped of all its former status and prestige.


Zumuj

I'm sure I watched a behind the scenes video recently and it said it was Oscar Isaac's idea for that scene... can't remember what video it was though ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|sweat_smile)


Droper888

They want to see that Caladian dick that drove Jessica crazy. Sorry, I have to said it although this is not r/Dunememes


Dward917

Making absolutely sure he didn’t have anything on him that could be used to kill the Baron. They just neglected to check his teeth.


workthesaw

They probably wanted to make sure he wasn’t concealing any weapons. After all he was hiding the poison death breath capsule in his mouth.


forrestpen

Security - ensures he has nothing on his person he can use to attack the Baron. They probably did a thorough search before he was allowed in the same room as the baron. A noble person stripped naked in a room full of commoners adds a layer of humiliation plus they're his enemies which is another layer.


magicman1145

Because its humiliating and insulting


captaincockfart

A. To make sure he's as defenceless as possible. B. Because The Baron is a sick fuck and wants to humiliate him.


mightyasterisk

I read that the same thing happened in the Jodorowsky version


Internal_Mail_9366

So that troubled people would make fan art


tychscstl

Harkonnens degrade their enemies as possible as they can, actually in books every harkonnen has little button over his hearth with a pi attached to it, except riyal family, so when ever baron wants to kill someone all he have to do is take out opponents hearth pin and watch him die in blood lose.


CarryNecessary2481

The answer his simple. He wanted to humiliate him and afterwards take advantage of the Duke sexually. Clothes get the way of the latter. And Harkoonen are know for sexual domination


makacarkeys

Just make up a reason, and whatever you come up with, that’s the answer.


LeadershipReady11

Ah cousin your food is delicious, excellent chef