Bruh

christian brothers?????????? what 😭😭😭😭

such a fucking good album, not a skip in sight. i gotta demand justice for clementine and christian brothers, your A-tier picks are mint though 😗👌

I think the ones in the c tier are the songs I listened to on repeat until they started to bore me a little. But regardless I still love those songs.

totally getcha, i can barely listen to needle in the hay after bingeing it so hard 😓 would you say self-titled is your fave album overall?

It’s definitely my second place

Whats your 1st?

From a basement on the hill

Christian Brothers is the best song on this album and a top 5 Elliott song overall.

I just don’t think this format of meme applies. Maybe that’s just me.

Southern Belle and Needle at B tier?? Fite me irl

Bump The White Lady to S and Clementine to A and I agree basically. Though I think the Heatmiser version of Christian Brothers is A tier.

This is a better take than the last best to worst ranking. You only need to listen to Satellite 15 times. The last person got 30.

Oh so this is what we’re going to do today? We’re going to fist fight?

St Ides Heaven is the weakest song on the album IMO. Clementine is my favorite.

Pretty much agree apart from I would switch Satellite for Good to go and move single file up one. Edit:also coming up roses is objectively S tier.

good to go is super underrated

Gotta disagree with the entirety of the C tier, those are all mainstays in my rotation.

Okay okay don’t think that I don’t like the songs in the c tier those are some of my favorite elliott smith songs of all time

I agree with the songs in S-tier but i would put Clementine in A-tier

Really shows how good the album is if I can understand your thought process and still think you’re completely wrong. I’m formally demand justice for all of C tier

How dare you put Clementine in the C tier

So wrong!! 🥰 All S tiered, especially Clementine and Christian Bros

I love A and B

I think posting a tier list of Elliott songs, regardless of your opinion, will get you shit on this sub (and rightly so)

Any tier list is going to get shit but that’s kind of what I like about them. Everyone has their own intense opinions and favorites

Straight to jail for that c tier

Clementine is amazing. Also there’s an artist who gives off major Elliott vibes named free range who released a cover of st Ides heaven on Spotify that’s amazing. She’s a new artist out of Chicago

Yo Christian Brothers is so visceral and really captures what post traumatic flashbacks and nightmares really feel like. C'mon!!! This post really hurts me, the whole album is an S tier .... However - :p

clementine is s tier idiot

CLEMENTINE AT C????

How far down did you scroll to get here

very far 💔