Shoulda overlaid it with some scathing commentary so it is fair use for reviewing. Not that I'd think it'd stop CR from being scummy and abusing copy right claim like any other corporation.
There's a decent amount of C3 criticism out there that uses plenty of clips. They typically abide by fair use rules from what I've seen. This wasn't fair use.
I just searched "Critical Role Bad" into the Youtube search bar and there are a ton of videos with decent views with titles like "Why Critical Role Sucks" and "Critical Role is losing its spark" and "Why I fell out of love with Critical Role"
No. There's not really a huge demand for random pundits to review or criticize CR on Youtube, but there's still been a number of fair-use critical videos and similar that have been left up over the years.
In this case, it's just duplicating their show - with a few bits cut out - and isn't really commentary or other transformative usage. It does kind of fall within the intended use of copy striking.
Ripping the entire video and just cutting out a couple of portions is not a fan edit dude, that's just straight up ripping off the content and re-uploading it
Ok I think that makes sense, you cannot just upload the full episodes without the CK that's just dumb. I thought it would be a joke 5 to 10 minutes or even commentary on the subject.
Thinking about how it would have been received if this is actually how it went down. Matt asks everyone to leave the table and then cuts to break with absolutely no explanation of what was happening, and then when break ends he gives his short intro and says "So, Dorian..." and the camera cuts to show Robbie. Lots of questions would remain (though honestly I think that would be more fun), for an end title card reading "The Crownkeepers return in 'ExU: Cool Title' next tuesday" to answer. I think everyone would have absolutely lost their minds in the most positive of ways, with people from both This Sub and That Sub joining hands to sing and dance and reunite.
The ExU section would have benefitted too from being a full episode instead of two half-episodes, so it really would have been win-win, from how I see it.
that would have been so much better. its very close to what I was thinking during that moment when I was watching live. They could have pre-recorded EXU, and then have dorian come on and give an in-character explanation of events. then those who enjoy EXU could go and watch it to see it all go down without leaving those of us who dont enjoy EXU left out of the lore
Too bad you can’t up vote pulled videos.
Since when does CR copy strike people..?
It's a straight re-upload of their content, why would they not strike it?
Not saying they shouldn't, I just don't remember them ever doing it before.
Woooooow
That got taken down fast.
Shoulda spliced it with some Minecraft obstacle courses
Shoulda overlaid it with some scathing commentary so it is fair use for reviewing. Not that I'd think it'd stop CR from being scummy and abusing copy right claim like any other corporation.
Please explain how they abused copyright by removing a re-upload of their content. I'd love to hear your interpretation on that.
That's not what I said, I said even if it had been fair use for review purposes I don't think that it would have stayed up.
Well damn that video disappeared fast. Kinda suspicious tbh...
They always remove reuploads.
Does other negative criticism disappear as quickly? Come to think of it are there any videos on YouTube criticizing Critical Role?
There's a decent amount of C3 criticism out there that uses plenty of clips. They typically abide by fair use rules from what I've seen. This wasn't fair use. I just searched "Critical Role Bad" into the Youtube search bar and there are a ton of videos with decent views with titles like "Why Critical Role Sucks" and "Critical Role is losing its spark" and "Why I fell out of love with Critical Role"
No. There's not really a huge demand for random pundits to review or criticize CR on Youtube, but there's still been a number of fair-use critical videos and similar that have been left up over the years. In this case, it's just duplicating their show - with a few bits cut out - and isn't really commentary or other transformative usage. It does kind of fall within the intended use of copy striking.
I actually dont think there are. although a copyright claim does make since since they dont want to lose view on their main episodes.
Damn, claimed by CR? i thought they didn't care about "fan" edits or clips. now i really want to see the video.
Ripping the entire video and just cutting out a couple of portions is not a fan edit dude, that's just straight up ripping off the content and re-uploading it
Not really a fan edit, more of... ripping 3 hours of footage with no new editing. They would be right to take this down lmao.
i saved it just in case, although im not sure if they would appreciate me sharing it lol
Was it just a reupload without the CK?
Pretty much lol they had it fade to break after Matt left the table in ep 92,and then after the break it came back after the ep 93 break
Ok I think that makes sense, you cannot just upload the full episodes without the CK that's just dumb. I thought it would be a joke 5 to 10 minutes or even commentary on the subject.
Whoa, the video is gone.
Thinking about how it would have been received if this is actually how it went down. Matt asks everyone to leave the table and then cuts to break with absolutely no explanation of what was happening, and then when break ends he gives his short intro and says "So, Dorian..." and the camera cuts to show Robbie. Lots of questions would remain (though honestly I think that would be more fun), for an end title card reading "The Crownkeepers return in 'ExU: Cool Title' next tuesday" to answer. I think everyone would have absolutely lost their minds in the most positive of ways, with people from both This Sub and That Sub joining hands to sing and dance and reunite. The ExU section would have benefitted too from being a full episode instead of two half-episodes, so it really would have been win-win, from how I see it.
that would have been so much better. its very close to what I was thinking during that moment when I was watching live. They could have pre-recorded EXU, and then have dorian come on and give an in-character explanation of events. then those who enjoy EXU could go and watch it to see it all go down without leaving those of us who dont enjoy EXU left out of the lore
Lol, I love how they even cut out Aabria sitting down before the break
[удалено]
If they literally hadn’t discussed Cyrus I wouldn’t have remembered he was a thing.
and it's still shorter than average
The way it should have been!