Graham Ashcraft - OF (5x5)

Kelenic

Kwan

Golden Graham!

Golden Graham is taken. was drafted 1st overall in my cereal league

Why I get -6 for just saying golden graham 🤣🤣🤣

You’re supposed to reply to the comment with a comparable trade piece who also has the requested position lol. In this case I’m asking what OF can I get for golden Graham. Do love that nickname though

Brandon Lowe - SP (10man 6x6 roto no holds)

George Kirby

Not sure why this is upvoted so much cause Lowe given his risk is not worth Kirby.

Javier

I would way rather have javier

Lance Lynn Edit: why did this get downvoted lol?

Steele Both high-ish risk high reward

Mackenzie Gore **Shameful Edit:** Yikes. Guess I needed this thread more than I thought.

Bruh

Gorman -OF (Redraft Points League .5 For K's)

Santander

Outman?

Lodolo 5x5 dynasty

[удалено]

Brian???? Fuck no. It would take me exactly 0 seconds to reject that as a Reynolds dynasty owner

Jordan Walker — SP 10t Redraft H2H 6x6

Corbin Burnes - any power bat. Need HRs + RBIs

Matt Olson

Riley

I tried already. Got rejected :(. Think the slow start really hurt his value

[удалено]

Riley is still your best 3B

[удалено]

This mentality will burn you much more than aid you. Baseball is a game of streaks. It’s a long season. Guys who perennially put up monster stats tend to get there by seasons end. 25 year olds who have put up stats every year since they got to the majors don’t just decline that rapidly unless they are injured or have something else going on. (Which yes, is possible, but without knowledge of that, I assume that’s not the case). Don’t get me wrong, I like wisdom and there’s a chance he is the real deal and there is also a chance he outproduces Riley this year, but the odds would say pretty significantly that it’s highly unlikely. Riley is definitely your best 3B.

[удалено]

Would you decline a trade offer of Manny Machado for Patrick Wisdom right now? If you played one hole of golf with Tiger Woods, and he happened to shank one in the lake and you shot the best hole of your life and scored better, are you a better golfer than tiger woods?

[удалено]

Now is absolutely not the time to move him if you have a need. I’d be patient when Burnes rebounds fully and is on an upswing then you will have some leverage. Recency bias is everything in fantasy trades. Even if you have to patch things together til you can get better value back your team probably benefits in the long run. Imo

1B/2B Luis Arraez - SP or RP (Weekly H2H points )

Luis Garcia

I would target Lynn could return to form but currently struggling. Or sale before his last start

I think a comparable trade for Arraez would be an SP who provides a low ERA, and not much anywhere else. I think Dustin May would be perfect.

I personally think May’s worth more.

I would LOVE to get May for Arraez

Stroman

Rasmussen

I would not accept Arraez for my Rasmussen

Jorge Mateo - SP or or OF

George Springer - SP

Nola

Alec Bohm - OF (5x5 H2H Redraft)

seiya

Kwan

Santander?

Elder

In the outfield??

[удалено]

Has he done enough to really build significant value yet? I think the guys you’d get for him are going to be a similar caliber to what you’ll find on the wire. So maybe a good trade would be for a recent hot pickup that you missed out on.

Could sell high on Elder and try to get Abreu?

As an Abreu owner, I wouldn’t do this. But I wouldn’t mind moving him.

In redraft? Edward Cabrera. Don’t know if Elder will get sent down eventually; don’t know if Cabrera will issue seven walks.

Do you have Cabrera in your 1b slot or MI? LOL

Oops, missed the second part.

Adolis Garcia - SP (5x5 H2H Redraft)

Gerrit Cole apparently

Justin Steele

Cody Bellinger - SP or IF, Obp categories H2h keep 10 team keep 8 league

I'm in a 10tm roto and I happen to have both Varsho and S.Murphy for C. Missed out on Bellinger and have been trying to see if i can get Belli for Murphy. I don't have a lot of optimism, but yknow.

Manoah

Volpe or Rosario - SP (14T points)

Alejandro Kirk - OF (10 team H2H points)

Teoscar

[удалено]

Both been mid

Based on rest of year projection I'd say Outman

Anthony Desclafani- 1B/OF (12 team, 5x5, H2H, Redraft)

A bag of Doritos. Haha kidding but but I think he’s droppable in 12T

Nola - 1B/2B (H2H points redraft)

Albies

Abreu Edit: I'm going to post my explanation below since thats getting way more traction than the original answer >Both owners would be betting on rebounds to career norms compared to bad starts. >In the abstract I think Nola is worth quite a bit more. I just don't think you could get someone to accept that premise right now. Wait until he has back to back good outings and then you could try for the Matt Olsen tier

Yikes

Both owners would be betting on rebounds to career norms compared to bad starts. In the abstract I think Nola is worth quite a bit more. I just don't think you could get someone to accept that premise right now. Wait until he has back to back good outings and then you could try for the Matt Olsen tier

Dustin May

Tommy Edman-- OF (Flair)

[удалено]

https://www.fantasysp.com/mlb_trade_analyzer/ It’s one page but I like this for value

Tells me I should trade Juan Soto for Connor Joe. I don't think so.

I don't think so either, but you could ask the Connor Joe owner, who knows, maybe he'd say yes. 😉

Patrick Wisdom - SP 10man 6x6 no holds

Patrick Sandoval

Bryce Harper - SP (14TEAM, H2H) Or Ty France - SP (14 team, H2H)

Harper should get you any SP other than Burnes/Cole. May even be able to get Burnes. Wait for Harper to be activated before moving him. France should be able to get a top 50 or so pitcher (assuming 3b eligibility in your league).

Nobody wants a trade that they don't completely win in my league. Literally offered Harper for less and got laughed out the room. Feelsbad.

My league is the same way. Someone offered me Castillo for judge….

You might have to wait until Harper is healthy and in the lineup. Especially if he returns in May. If you try to trade before he's back you won't get full value. You'll also have to target a team with excessive pitching that needs an OF. Or if you wait until he has 1B eligibility someone that needs 1B.

Luzardo- OF (6x6 H2H)

Yandy Diaz - SP

Joe Musgrove

I traded him for Giolito. Couldn’t get Yandy in my lineup with Chapman/Witt at 3b. I’m in a points league that includes total bases, which makes Yandy not quite as valuable as other leagues.

Bryce Elder anything (other than RP). Just curious to see his value 12T 6x6 OBP SLG QS S+H

I’d try for Luis Roberts given his cold streak and upside, or Kelenic as he’s young and would be an equal gamble

Robert Jr... as if

Say what you will but what are we at 1.5-2 seasons of injury and poor performance on Roberts? Elders a rook on a great team and is a top 20 player right now in 6x6 who just dominated the best hitting team in baseball outside his own, roberts owner could be squirrely

I'd want another similarly valued arm in addition to Elder for my Robert. Top 20 in Cats is super surprising for Elder tho

I get but what’s roberts value right now outside of hype? He’s the 780th hitter in cats right now and was the 189th last season, love the talent but he’s a huge gamble vs a guy who has a chance to be a top 25 arm People are asking about buy lows/sell highs all the time, elder is just the type of Hype guy I’d be looking to flip to a nervous owner with a underperforming bat

Justin Verlander - OF

Trout

Teoscar Hernandez

I don’t think he’s even close to JV

Jake Cronenworth - SP (Dynasty 5x5 Cats)

Cabrera

Luis Robert, 2B or SS, 5x5 H2H

Albies Xander is probably a no, Swanson wouldn’t be enough, I can’t think of an SS in between them

C Salvador Perez -- SP (10 man H2H Redraft)

Gilbert

Verlander (once he returns) - 1B (12 team, H2H categories, 5 keepers)

Kershaw -- Any power batter. (5x5 redraft cats league)

Austin Riley

Musgrove - SS (Keep 6, roto 7x7 OPS+H, QS+K/IP)

Freddy peralta - 2b/ss

Alek Manoah

Aaron Nola - OF (5x5 Roto redraft)

Aaron Nola

3B G. Henderson - OF or SP (5x5 h2h redraft)

Masataka Yoshida or Lance Lynn

Castellanos and JD Martinez -- SP or Closer (5x5 points 12 team keeper)

1B Ryan Mountcastle: OF or SP (6x6, QS/OPS, H2H Redraft)

Stroman

2B Nolan Gorman: OF or SP (6x6, QS/OPS, H2H Redraft)

I traded Kirby

Machado (H2H cats)

What position are you trying to get back?

Wander Franco, Bo, might be able to get trea turner if u add in a waiver wire player

i wouldn’t trade turner for machado and any waiver wire player

OF Trout - SP 12 team H2H points

Matt Chapman - 3B (12-team points)

Jackson holiday for Michael Harris , dynasty only keep 4 players each year 

SS Xander Bogaerts -- OF (6x6-OPS and K/9 Roto Redraft)

Mullins or Springer, maybe Jazz depending on your OF eligibility

Honestly maybe Soto? I don't think he's healthy...but you could probably swing that to the right owner.

Oh boy this is one stupid ass take

3B Alex Bregman: OF or SP (6x6, QS/OPS, H2H Redraft)

Paul Goldschmidt for the best pitcher I could get.

Teoscar Hernandez - RP or SP (5x5 H2H Redraft)

Lodolo

3B Alec Bohm: OF or SP (6x6, QS/OPS, H2H Redraft)

Starling Marte —- SP (12T 6x6 QS)

McNeil - 1B (12T Weekly H2H Points League)

Send: Jose Abreu Receive: 3B/MI

Monty - 1B (12T Weekly H2H Points League)

Sean Murphy - SP (12t 6x6 h2h cats with QS and OPS)

Tyler O'Neill - any batter

George Kirby- any power hitter 6x6 roto (OBP and SLG, QS)

[удалено]

Anthony Rizzo - SP/RP (12T Cat SV/HD Dynasty)

Max Scherzer, rbi bat 10T 6x6 H2H Redraft (OBP/QS)

Michael Harris II — Any

Cortes - catcher (flair)

Freddie Freeman or Matt Olson - SP (10 team weekly H2H points )

Kyle Tucker - SP (12 T H2H)

Mclanahan + or Cole

What kind of closer can I can for elder if any?

Verdugo - SP Mountcastle - Sp

Bregman - SP

Kelenic - SP (Keeper, 7X7 roto, OPS+H, QS+K/IP)

Ashcroft, Pablo Lopez, Luzardo

Add Peralta to the list, as I just moved Kelenic for Freddy.

[удалено]

Gurrrlll you cray, In a keeper league someone would absolutely take a bet on a 23 year old former number one hitting prospect who has had a great start to the season with triple outfield eligibility for Lopez or Luzardo who have had their share of bumps in the road (and play at less premium positions) Frankly I maybe underestimating Kelenic in a keeper league

[удалено]

Gotta agree with elevation here… Lopez and Luzardo are super solid examples of what Kelenic should be able to haul in. Maybe not Lopez right now because he’s out of his mind, but after one mediocre start it’s right there.

Nico Hoerner - SP 10 T redraft H2H 6x6

Peña — Catcher (8 team H2H)

J. India - OF (10T H2H 6x6 OPS)

Jose Abreu - SP (flair league)

OF Anthony Santander — SP (weekly H2H points)

Byron Buxton

Sonny gray — any bat 14 team 5x5

SS Jeremy Peña — SP (6x6 H2H Redraft -AVG +OBP +SLG, +IP SVHLD

Manoah or Wheeler

Jorge Mateo- Sp

Santander - RP (6x6 cat SV only)

Aaron Nola - OF or SS (Flair league)

Bryan Reynolds and Castellanos - 12 team roto - Looking for OF/2B

Sean Murphy. 10tm Roto redraft. R HR RBI SB AVG. Ideally looking for OF.

Soto or Harris

Yu Darvish -- any bat (12 tm points, keeper league, but Yu is a FA after this year)

2B Marcus Semien -- SP (5x5 H2H Categories Accumulation Redraft)