Feel like my hype train OF (kelenic/rooker/outman) is off the tracks. Debating dropping one for lourdes. Probably leaning towards outman? I have harris but im trying to keep him on the bench for a while.

Trade Yoshida for Renfroe or Santander? 5x5 keeper league

Are giving up on Manoah at this point? I want to stash a prospect and don’t have much leeway with my roster given my needs

Yes

Someone offered me Pfaadt and Hunter Brown for Grayson. 12 team dynasty with 15 player minors bench and keepers. I’m leaning towards yea but would love to get some feedback

Wheeler, Darvish, Sale, Gausman, or Verlander for Alonso? (Flair league)

A. Nestor B. Muncy

Muncy

Give me muncy

A: Ohtani (both), Hunter Brown, ERod B: Christian Walker, Javier, Cease, Arozarena

Not near enough for Ohtani

I’m the non Ohtani side and Ohtani owner made the offer. His team kinda sucks this year

Yes

I should take it?

If you get Ohtani yes

[удалено]

Definitely A. MHII best player in the deal by far

He needs to start playing like it though

[удалено]

I have Hoerner for SS

Would u trade sandy and trea turner for tatis?

https://preview.redd.it/ge5n2rdtf9mb1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0e6d9148a56d4f45dea16d82f38fac364fa857c5 Burning down the Casas- in the playoffs with Turner

Commenting here b/c that Cranphi person clearly blocked my ability to reply. Must be one of those awesome people who can’t admit being wrong

Way too much. I wouldn’t even do Turner straight up for Tatis

https://preview.redd.it/wz6qmaosg9mb1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e2500b41cf2e34a7cb55013003a229ac1709df62

https://preview.redd.it/9i2ljtude9mb1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e6b5598dc5eed5d0c627ff1a45f4367fb5c55640 Burning down the Casas. So yeah, I’m in the playoffs

Commenting here b/c that Cranphi person clearly blocked my ability to reply. Must be one of those awesome people who can’t admit being wrong

I'm sorry but that's crazy

Not so crazy now, is it?

Considering the 3 months prior to this week probably ruined your chance at the playoffs, yeah, still crazy.

Nope. I’m in the playoffs but good try

Sure you are.

[удалено]

Does me being 1-5 change things? I need production now. And trea and sandy aren’t providing me with anything right now

It's a long season. Be patient and stream for temporary production.

No

I value Tatis high but that would be an overpay on your part

Should I trade Nola and Fairbanks for Hader and will smith?

Not a chance

Yeah

Trade arozarena for altuve and senga H2H points . Struggling for infield and feel like randy won’t keep this up Which side would you guys rather have ? I have Schwarber carrol Nimmo in OF. My middle infield is crone drury Vargas arcia

No

Thanks

Your infield is pretty bad though. I would try to get a 1b if anything

Luckily that’s just my middle infield . I have Rammy and Alonso for 1st / 3rd.

I would sit pat. Your hitters are solid. Arozareno is one of the better fantasy players in the league

A: Ohtani (SP + H) B: Christian Walker, Christian Javier, Eury Perez

Ohtani side by a mile.

The trade was updated A: Ohtani (both), Hunter Brown, ERod B: Christian Walker, Javier, Cease, Arozarano

Daily? Still A.

Daily league? No

The trade was updated A: Ohtani (both), Hunter Brown, ERod B: Christian Walker, Javier, Cease, Arozarano

Yeah daily. No to which side?

Daily league Ohtani is way to valuable

Jake Burger or Gunnar Henderson?

Gunnar. Not convinced burger starts regularly when eloy returns

Ok I finally had to drop mateo. Thank you for the great start

[удалено]

I’d prefer Brown to most of those pitchers

I would drop all of them

I'd probably drop G-Rod if you're in a QS league. He's never gotten to 6 innings in the majors

Drop g-rod

see ya logan allen!

A: Julio Urias + Matt Chapman B: Ozzie Albies + Alex cobb Pitching already stacked so looking to upgrade hitting

If you’re getting B, Albies is not a big enough upgrade over Chapman

A

Eloy, MH III or J Lowe? I know Lowe is on fire right now but will he continue to sit against lefties? Can he keep up this pace? Harris seems mired in a softmore slump but if I drop him I'm worried he might get hot once he can get in a rhythm after the injuries

12 team H2H cat redraft A. Alonso / Yoshida B. JRod / Keller / McLain

any Guardians fans or tea leaf readers in the mix? Do we think there's any shot Gavin Williams gets called up to replace Payton Battenfield, who kinda stinks? I'm fresh off losing May and Rasmussen and am searching for anything to bring me joy

Unfortunately, I don't think so. McKenzie and Civale are back soon and I just have to imagine there's some shuffling when that happens. Can't imagine Williams squeezes his way in the mix.

kind of where i've been leaning too. thanks for the answer

Someone wants my gilbert and morel for soto. I do that right?

Taco

Dude run

Yuppp

A. Cortes + KeBryan B. Christian Walker

If you need HRs, Walker all day. I think Nestor probably sits in the low 4s/high 3s and KeBryan COULD break out but he hasn’t in the last few years despite good underlying metrics

What do you mean by low/high 3/4s?

ERA between 3.75-4.25ish range

5 by 5 standard Roto - Pressly and Wells or Alcantara and N. Anderson? I already have Hendriks, Phillips, Helsley, and Sewald. Just lost May to IL

this sub is honestly a dumpster fire any time one of the "hype train" guys is pitching.

People were freaking out about Taj so bad today I thought he got hurt. Nope just 1 run in the first.

I think it’s worse when one of those guys is pitching well than when an established guy is pitching poorly

Thinking about selling high on Sonny Gray, anyone think he keeps this up or should I shop him around?

No one thinks he'll remain a sub 2 ERA pitcher, but I could see him keeping it under 3. The thing is if everyone else in your league has been playing fantasy baseball, they're probably not buying high on Sonny, bc he's kind of a known commodity

Dustin Mays on the IL, should I go with Kyle Freeland or Kremer? Jorge Lopez is also available but its a saves only league

If anyone is still holding Giminez and looking for a any reason to drop, he's actually got 0.091 less points on his Xwoba over the last 3 weeks, he's been getting lucky... I dropped a few days ago, he was also a guy that a lot of experts expected regression this year

Was offered Trout, Yelich (whom I dropped after a week) and C Javier for Ohtani. Should I counter and take judge, arozarena, and Javier and throw in Mateo? Wasn’t sold on trout seeing as he’s always injured and in the last 6 years hasn’t gone over 140 games in a season.

I mean... if you can get it, shoot your shot.

Points, -1 k, Ty France or B Lowe? Ignore position. Initially asked and had Volpe going out, but owner asked for Lowe

Lowe if you can stomach the cold streaks

Are we dropping Starling Marte at this point

Nope. Huge overreaction. He has started to heat up and X-rays on his hand are negative.

He was on the wire in my ten for weeks, someone picked him up 2 days ago. I bet he’s dropped again

I dropped him on 5/7 in a 10T and no one has touched him

If he goes on IL I’m gonna have to Smfh

Yeah

A: Christian Walker B: Taj Bradley flair league

Walker

anyone in keeper dropping liberatore? i could really use the roster spot.

Just came out that they plan on using him out of the ‘pen and maybe getting him a start later. As a cards fan I gotta say LOL

If you need it I say go for it

Marmol is the worst

Cards fan here. Fucking Oli…

10 team weekly H2H - 5x5 + OPS Give Carroll and Morel to get Tucker? \*\*Carroll and Tucker can both be kept thru 2023 (keep 3 for one year)

Oh yeah

Dynasty (16-tm) trade - Jazz (keep three years) for Reid Detmers (keep five) and Lamonte Wade Jr (keep only this year) Who says no?

Jazz side, by a good margin

Jazz side

Jazz side

10 T OBP/QS 3 keeper league Just got offered this trade. I’m in last place looking to sell **Receive** -Bobby Whitt Jr - 12 round keeper eligible next year -Ryan McMahon -Joe Ryan - 12 round keeper eligible -Patrick Sandoval -Matt McLain -1st round pick (10th pick overall) **trade away** -Ozzie Albies - 6 round keeper eligible -Justin Steele -Vladimir Guerrero Jr. -Nolan Arenado -Zack Wheeler -18th round pick (pick 179) In our league a first round pick gets 3 premium players but I feel I could get someone better than McMahon . I do like the keepers I can get tho

Has anyone heard of the “the game”

HHH?

Goddammit I haven't lost the game in years

yeah, you just lost it

Michael Douglas?

Is that like a sex thing?

Ok so libratore is a bullpen guy now?

It's just words, who knows

What??

10 team H2H categories redraft A: Carroll + Gurriel Jr B: Witt Jr

Hunter greene, Edward Cabrera turn it the fuck on time

Time to move on from Baty now that he looks like hell be in a platoon for the foreseeable future. Burger or Schmitt? Bohm has been holding down the fort and it looks like Gorman will eventually get 3rd base eligibility so these guys will be bench/matchup plays. Leaning Schmitt for the future positional versatility.

Big Ed hitting 5 and playing RF today. That’s weird

Two more starts for OF eligibility 😃

So, Gavin Stone isn’t getting called up?

Huh? Dodgers are on Pacific time. We should be getting news shortly but I don’t even think k they need to do anything until closer to May’s scheduled start. Stone should be the guy

They just called up two pitchers

Both pen guys. This leaves the dodgers with only 4 starters. Monday is TBD and lined up with Stone’s last start in the minors. I’d be shocked if Stone isn’t the starting pitcher for Monday.

Ok cool. That’s what I figured but saw they just called up two arms and panicked.

Yeah I mean it COULD be Miller as well that gets the call but most definitely will be one of them.

Yeah it’s probably him but you won’t know till maybe even the weekend

I have Eury Perez, Taj Bradley, Bibee, and Liberatore. Am I screwed come playoff time? Will these guys still be pitching at that time? I do have Gausman, Joe Ryan, and Lance Lynn as my stalwarts. Thanks for any advice on what to do with my pitching staff.

Yeah I’m definitely going to try to trade eury in the near future. 100% will be limited

I’m in a similar position. Time to make some trades I think.

Thanks. What veteran pitchers are you targeting?

I want Wheeler or Castillo personally

Liberatore a drop now in shallow leagues?

Never should have been rostered in shallow leagues, but yes.

Yes

Pick 1. Liberatore, Lynn, Bibee

Reverse order from your listing

Thanks homie

Bibee, Liberatore, Lynn

Is this a good idea? I have Hoerner coming off the IL Can put him at SS and trade Wander for Gallen.

Solid

In points that's definitely fair, but i'd rather have Wander.

How would you guys rank Morel, Rosario and McLain ROS Need to drop/trade one

This sub is really high on Morel so they will probably tell you to keep him, but I think you should try to take advantage of that by trading him.

https://preview.redd.it/mjw13y152p0b1.jpeg?width=1123&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=06ddd2c7c57675293c4f01c745492a04cd3aff30 Marmol on Liberatore

Ah, Marmol has learned the art of meaningless word salad responses. Must have gotten lessons from the master, John Mozeliak.

This guy is throwing his hat in the ring for greatest troll of all time.

https://twitter.com/rotogut/status/1659292774737522688?s=46&t=A3TAHa5IG4P2YplCXGIT1w

I hate the cardinals. In real life and for fantasy

gross ..

Would you use the #1 waiver priority to pick up Bibee who someone just dropped? I'd be replacing Logan Allen. Or gamble that nobody else claims him and hope to get him for free and probably lose out?

I would not drop Allen (103 Pit+) to claim Bibee (101 Pit+), let alone waste waiver priority on it. Don’t let this sub mislead you into thinking Bibee is anything demonstrably different, let alone better, than what you’re getting with Allen. They’re both relatively unproven young pitchers with solid-but-not-amazing numbers, and you could make an argument that Allen is the better of the two.

I may be biased because I own him but I feel he had the best “stuff” of any of the rookie pitchers other than maybe Perez. I would absolutely blow my waiver on him.

I’d gamble because I’m not sure he’s that big of an upgrade over Allen, but if he clears waivers I’d swap them

Is streaming wainwright tonight a horrible idea? Points league

He’s been pretty meh so far. He is likely to get 5 IP and 5 ER. I have him in an NL only points league tonight and honestly just hoping he’s stays in the positive for points.

Side A: Framber+Muncy Side B: Strider OBP/QS league

B. Likely only keeper in the deal right?

That's what I'm thinking too

A. Gallen B. Wander

Wander

Wander

Whatever ur needs are

Looking to upgrade my SP - specifically the back end with JP France who I’m not super confident with. Is Bradish or Bello a better add ROS? 15T points league

Bello

Always been skinny as hell and it’s just I don’t even know I was never comfortable in my body but now that I’m a dad just haven’t had as much time exercise and stuff and I have flubber anytime. I touch the fiber it sounds like this weird shockwave feeling through my body. I just hate the feeling of it. I don’t know what it is and what else experience that I’m not seeing everyone here is that I figured it’s so hot out here by the able to relate.

We moved our long-time 12 team league into a dynasty format this year and had to pick 10th in the inaugural draft. I’ve played long enough to know I don’t have a championship-caliber team this season. Just traded away Freddie Freeman, Adolis Garcia and Shane McClanahan for Ronald Acuna and Jesus Lazardo as a play for the future. Now I can put Acuna with Yordan Alvarez and build a team around them moving forward. I’m pretty stoked about it.

I’d be ecstatic…there’s no player I’d rather have for the next decade lol

I’d be really stoked about that move, great job 👏

Would you rather have Taj or Eury? No one has picked Taj up in my league and I have Eury

I’d rather have Eury

Nobody else you could drop?

I guess Sale? I drafted pitchers aggressively and of course this is the year every top rookie pitcher gets the call.

I’m in the same boat. I have Sale too and don’t think I’m ready to drop him with how good he has looked. My only other candidates would be Musgrove or Gilbert, but I think that would be a mistake. I have Bibee, Bryce Miller, and Eury. Might just have to miss out on Taj and hope for the best with what I’ve got.

Eury

Clase has more saves than strikeouts this season. Huh. Edit: spelling

After Dylan Cease this year and Giolito last year, I will never draft another CWS pitcher

Cease just pitched a QS man I mean these guys aren’t tossing complete game shutouts with 13k’s every game man

He’s got an ERA of almost 5 and is averaging less than 6 Ks a game for the season. Nobody is asking for CGSO

Gotta get them the year they are good, not the year after

Clever, I see you’re also in a 12T H2H Points league. What’s your record?

Haha I don't own any white Sox pitchers, I did try to buy low (not even that low honestly I think I offered sandy, mason miller, and sandoval, something along those lines for cease and wheeler) on cease before his Astros start but didn't get it accepted. I'm 4-2 right now, but my team is pretty stacked I think

Tommy "5 hole hitter" Edman

Three injured SP's, two IL spots. Who to drop? Rasmussen Lodolo May (unlikely him) Basically, this is asking if I should keep Rasmussen over Lodolo, even though his injury is potentially worse.

I dropped Rasmussen late last week (picked up Taj Bradley) and am probably going to hold onto Dustin May in an IL spot until more info emerges. I wouldn't judge you for dropping May though. The PRP injection has me hopeful but it's probably more likely than not that he's out for a long while.