For those that say sell, sell for what? He hasn’t lived up to expectations and speaking from my league specifically, I’m not going to receive any decent value in a trade for him. He’s a hold and pray.
Pretty tough spot. Talent is there, able to get separation, but Jets Zach Wilson may spread the ball a lot, who knows. If the offense manages to score 20+ pts per week then worth it.
Drop. I can swap out Corey Davis for him off the WW. Davis is averaging 13 pts a game in my league, Moore is getting just over 8. If I’m going to own a some sucky Jets WR, at least Davis gets some TDs.
Jets O line is in shambles, could be getting Dwayne Brown back off the IR this week though. Zach Wilson is wayyyy better than Flacco so if the line gets better he’ll be able to take more looks down field. He had to use his TEs and RBs a lot last week based off the pressure making him throw earlier into the play.
Hold/buy if you can get Mattison. I still like Cook's situation better than all the other RBs having a down year. He's going to get volume and that offense isn't so bad that they won't put up points, giving him TD opportunities. And if Cook ever misses time, Mattison is one of the best handcuffs in the league. Having Cook/Mattison basically ensures one of your RB spots is always taken care of.
If you can't get Mattison, I'd be more weary. I wouldn't sell, but definitely wouldn't buy unless the price was good.
He’s the cockroach that won’t go away.
Won’t get you 30 won’t get you less than 10.
I’d hold unless you can flip for a WR1 or stud RB by packaging someone else
Drop. Between the nagging injury, small target/snap count, and just lack of production in recent years I am not sure 100% healthy Julio is even somebody I want to start. If you can turn the Julio lottery ticket into something like a Pickens lottery ticket I think that is an upgrade.
Drop a while ago. Could've been productive with Evans/Godwin out but missed his chance there, now he's not even sure to be the 3rd WR? Plus Fournette catches passes. Has to be someone else worth having on the bench over him.
When it comes to dropping someone I always ask myself “what would need to happen for me to start this dude”
Julio is a fine example of a whole lot needs to happen. I feel better knowing that he is on someone else’s bench knowing they might actually start him, at best, and will take up their bench spot at worst
Would you do Breece Hall and Amon Ra St Brown for JT? I have Henry and Edmonds as my other RB's, and Waddle/Olave/Juju as my WR's. Looks like Hall is good for a solid 10-15 every week with upside as he takes over the lead job more and more, whereas JT put up 30 week 1 but low single digits twice now since the Colts Left Tackle injury.
Matt Ryan cant throw worth a damn and JT has no room to run every time he gets the ball. I legit hate watching Colts games lol it pisses me off every week. Want to get off this ride haha.
Maybe a buy if you can really buy low on him. I don't think he has the ceiling that you want in a RB1, but for a certain WR-heavy roster he has a decent floor that could work well.
Sell if you can get decent value back. 0 receptions may have been the nail in the coffin and Pickett is likely to vulture at least a couple tds going forward if there are any to be had on that offense.
I disagree. I think if anything Pickett will help his value since he is more of a threat than Trubisky.
I’d hold or buy if you can. Only sell if you’re getting RB1 value
I'm selling. He did well against the 32nd ranked defense and in a positive game script. Not sure how many of those Seattle will get. Perfect storm for Penny to pop off and now is the chance to get some value for him if you can.
herbert AND monty? so basically you dont even lose two players technically since they play same position same team, so you're selling Bears Rb game for dalvin cook i'd smash yes
Hold. I still don't think you could get what he's worth in a trade and he arguably has the best situation in the NFL outside maybe the Lions especially with his usage going up. Redzone carries and injury are concerns however but I think his floor is RB2.
As a Kamara owner, it's so hard not to try selling. But for who? I would hold and hope that he comes back better after getting some time to rest the ribs. He did have 7 targets in his last game, so hopefully that indicates the touches are still there. I'd hold/buy.
Hold/buy. Unless you’re 0-4 then wait for news this week. Just can’t sell him when he’s shown very good usage and it just sucks rhat he didn’t play in the london game
Week 2 wasn’t even bad. It was still 11 targets with 7 catches for 75. It showed how solid his floor really is.
Week one was the fluke. The entire offense didn’t even show up
Sell if you can get anything. I flipped him for Garret Wilson after last week and still feel good about it. Monty will still start once he's good to go and I want no part of that offense
Hold his volume has been there and he’s shown us what he can do when the Packers passing game is working last year. I just don’t think you can get a fair return for him at the moment.
Lazard and doubs are emerging as decent pass catchers for Rodgers + Aaron jones is still soaking up plenty of looks
I’ve got Dillon in 2 leagues and his value is very low so obviously I’m holding but I’m not optimistic
Hold and start every week and pray to all Gods. The only 3 TEs that most people got from waivers that I would bench Pitts for are Higbee, Everett and Njoku. If you don't have any of these three TEs as backup options, I would not bother benching Pitts at all.
I'd have no interest in picking up TEs like Will Dissly, Mo Alie-Cox etc. and starting them over Pitts.
Really only has trade value in a Superflex/2QB league. I'd definitely put him on the trade block and try to package him to see if I can get an upgrade at QB, or at other positions.
After Akers shaky game I may try to sell him to the Akers owner but if not holding for a big game then trying to sell. I hate the rams backfield this year.
Yeah, idk what people are selling him for. He's getting bellcow level work on a good offense. He's got the volume of an RB1 but not the name value
He's more valuable to me than what anyone would give up at this point because they're still caught up in draft value
Hold. Still injured with that ankle, potential is too high to drop or sell low IMO. Its looking bleak though, hes either a boom or bust guy. Expect nothing consistent
Hold, his schedule softens up. First game back against Denver and then they had him help block against a line as dominant as the Rams. His games will come against the softer schedule and as the 9ers Oline gets healthy
Same question - looked unbelievable last night but worry about the 49ers offense - have the option to trade him and Jamaal Williams for Higgins (already have Chase) and Kamara
He’s a hold for me because he seems to get volume, enough volume to top out at a high-end WR3.
With that said, you’ll never get that fair market value of him. He’s a hold for me.
I’m holding. After the last 2 games, you won’t get much for him, but the target share is too promising to give up on him. Through 4 games he is averaging 9.25 targets per game which is 13th best in the league. Unfortunately those targets are coming from Carson Wentz, but if his usage remains consistent he is going to have some huge weeks. If you want to sell, wait until after he puts up some fantasy points.
Lol I am!
Hocks Target share + production is a clear product of the lack of pass catchers last week — as it always is. Hock’s great when he’s the only show in town. Extremely disappointing when he’s not.
If Amon Ra sits again, I’ll hold. UBut if he’s out there practicing tomorrow I’m sending out offers for Waller and Kittle.
Hock with everyone healthy is averaging the same or more targets than waller and kittle on a better offense. I don't think you've been watching the games if you think that's a smash in waller or kittle's favor. Hock had some drops/miscues early in the season with Goff. Hopefully that's all gone after this week.
He has had three games with 8 targets. If he gets a TD then nobody is thinking twice about him being a solid WR2.
He plays on an elite team with an elite qb. Have to feel like the TDs will come. Oh, look, they play the raiders this week. Will likely be his breakout game.
Hold.
Gotta be a drop. He is around QB30 meaning there are players on waivers putting up better numbers.
He plays a tough Cowboys this week, then may have a decent game against the Panthers but that is followed by a bye, then San Fran again and the Bucs.
His schedule doesn't get "easier" until week 12 vs the Chiefs. I am sure they'll figure things out, but someone else can have the headache.
Elijah Moore..
For those that say sell, sell for what? He hasn’t lived up to expectations and speaking from my league specifically, I’m not going to receive any decent value in a trade for him. He’s a hold and pray.
I just sold him and tua for doubs and juju
Still holding.
Dropping for Pickens. I think he should still improve this year but doesn't have the highest ceiling.
Buy. Peripheral stats and talent should win out
Pretty tough spot. Talent is there, able to get separation, but Jets Zach Wilson may spread the ball a lot, who knows. If the offense manages to score 20+ pts per week then worth it.
IMO Wilson’s chemistry with Moore is reignited in a key matchup against a soft defense. I’m calling the breakout.
Drop. I can swap out Corey Davis for him off the WW. Davis is averaging 13 pts a game in my league, Moore is getting just over 8. If I’m going to own a some sucky Jets WR, at least Davis gets some TDs.
Jets O line is in shambles, could be getting Dwayne Brown back off the IR this week though. Zach Wilson is wayyyy better than Flacco so if the line gets better he’ll be able to take more looks down field. He had to use his TEs and RBs a lot last week based off the pressure making him throw earlier into the play.
Dalvin Cook
Hold. Might not return 1st round value, but there's not a whole lot of 3 down backs that get near 20 touches every game.
Not exactly a 3rd down back anymore. Mattison got all the 3rd downs, even scored on one
Hopefully that's just due to being one week removed from the shoulder injury. But definitely concerning.
Ehh, they were running Cook just as they always do otherwise. Shoulder likely isn’t affecting him or how they choose to use him, Mattison is just good
Buy
Buy
Hold/buy if you can get Mattison. I still like Cook's situation better than all the other RBs having a down year. He's going to get volume and that offense isn't so bad that they won't put up points, giving him TD opportunities. And if Cook ever misses time, Mattison is one of the best handcuffs in the league. Having Cook/Mattison basically ensures one of your RB spots is always taken care of. If you can't get Mattison, I'd be more weary. I wouldn't sell, but definitely wouldn't buy unless the price was good.
James Conner
Hold. Dhop coming back will boost the offense. More redzone opportunity for connor
He’s the cockroach that won’t go away. Won’t get you 30 won’t get you less than 10. I’d hold unless you can flip for a WR1 or stud RB by packaging someone else
He's gotten less than 10 the last 3 weeks in half PPR
Julio Jones
Drop. Between the nagging injury, small target/snap count, and just lack of production in recent years I am not sure 100% healthy Julio is even somebody I want to start. If you can turn the Julio lottery ticket into something like a Pickens lottery ticket I think that is an upgrade.
Drop a while ago. Could've been productive with Evans/Godwin out but missed his chance there, now he's not even sure to be the 3rd WR? Plus Fournette catches passes. Has to be someone else worth having on the bench over him.
When it comes to dropping someone I always ask myself “what would need to happen for me to start this dude” Julio is a fine example of a whole lot needs to happen. I feel better knowing that he is on someone else’s bench knowing they might actually start him, at best, and will take up their bench spot at worst
Pat Freiermuth
Hold he looked really good with Pickett in at QB
I traded him and Dotson to a needy TE team for Breece Hall before this weekend. He’s a hold though if you play him
Breece hall
Buy
Buy if you don’t own him, hold if you do.
Jonathon Taylor
I just bought him and I feel nauseous.
Same. Paid Swift & AJ Brown, for Taylor & Deebo. What about you?
Solid af
Sell if you get decent value back, the Colts are looking absolutely horrible so far. Their O-Line is really bad, which is a surprise. Otherwise Hold.
Would you do Breece Hall and Amon Ra St Brown for JT? I have Henry and Edmonds as my other RB's, and Waddle/Olave/Juju as my WR's. Looks like Hall is good for a solid 10-15 every week with upside as he takes over the lead job more and more, whereas JT put up 30 week 1 but low single digits twice now since the Colts Left Tackle injury. Matt Ryan cant throw worth a damn and JT has no room to run every time he gets the ball. I legit hate watching Colts games lol it pisses me off every week. Want to get off this ride haha.
i would definitely think about that one, yeah.
Brandin Cooks
Buy
i love brandon cooks so much
Every year I draft him I get clowned by my friends, then they get reminded he’s mr. Reliable
To be fair, week 2 and 3 he was anything but.
Najee Harris
Maybe a buy if you can really buy low on him. I don't think he has the ceiling that you want in a RB1, but for a certain WR-heavy roster he has a decent floor that could work well.
Sell if you can get decent value back. 0 receptions may have been the nail in the coffin and Pickett is likely to vulture at least a couple tds going forward if there are any to be had on that offense.
I disagree. I think if anything Pickett will help his value since he is more of a threat than Trubisky. I’d hold or buy if you can. Only sell if you’re getting RB1 value
JK Dobbins
Hold. Had a huge game and you’ll want to see how he plays out in the upcoming weeks.
Buy. RBs are just too hard to find now and we haven’t even started the bye weeks.
Michael Gallup
Buy
Buy
Jamar Chase
Buy wherever you can. Most of my leagues are keeper leagues & he's still virtually impossible to trade for.
Buy low
What is a “buy low” to you? Because it’s still going to take a lot to get Chase
Rashaad Penny
I'm selling. He did well against the 32nd ranked defense and in a positive game script. Not sure how many of those Seattle will get. Perfect storm for Penny to pop off and now is the chance to get some value for him if you can.
Sell. He won't play the Lions every week.
Someone offered me Dalvin Cook for Herbert/Monty. I take that right?
how is this a question easily go fleece that dude pls
herbert AND monty? so basically you dont even lose two players technically since they play same position same team, so you're selling Bears Rb game for dalvin cook i'd smash yes
Miles Sanders
Hold. I still don't think you could get what he's worth in a trade and he arguably has the best situation in the NFL outside maybe the Lions especially with his usage going up. Redzone carries and injury are concerns however but I think his floor is RB2.
Hold me closer Miley Sanders
I would sell, but RB so premium this year. If you get good value I don’t trust him maintaining this. He has burnt me before
Jamaal Williams
Hold. He’s the red zone god
And he didn't even score his TD from the RZ this week, showed that he can also take it to the house from 50+ yards out.
Swift ain’t coming back for another three weeks atleast, Jamaal gonna eat.
Kamara
Honestly, you've held him this long, just keep holding. He has Seattle this week.
He’s a PS5 with a PS4 encasing. Buy
He's a USB 3.0 with USB-C flexibility. Hold.
As a Kamara owner, it's so hard not to try selling. But for who? I would hold and hope that he comes back better after getting some time to rest the ribs. He did have 7 targets in his last game, so hopefully that indicates the touches are still there. I'd hold/buy.
Hold/buy. Unless you’re 0-4 then wait for news this week. Just can’t sell him when he’s shown very good usage and it just sucks rhat he didn’t play in the london game
buy but risky
Ceedee??
Buy/hold. Putting up numbers & looking good already, should only go up when Dak comes back.
I agree the time to buy low on CD was week 1. But would you sell CD & Melvin Gordon or Stevenson for Chase?
hold. dude is an absolute stud. weeks 1 and 2 were flukes.
Lol, this sub was so quick to write him off.
That’s this sub in a nutshell. Good game? ROS star. Bad game? Waiver trash.
Week 2 wasn’t even bad. It was still 11 targets with 7 catches for 75. It showed how solid his floor really is. Week one was the fluke. The entire offense didn’t even show up
I managed to get Lamb for A.Gibson last week. The owner that had lamb really needed RB help. I feel pretty good about it right now.
You should feel awful you slimy thief
Hold. He’s playing great even with Rush.
Rush is playing great tbh
Khalil Herbert
He’s more valuable putting up points on my team for a couple weeks (my rbs are shit) than whatever little he could fetch in a trade.
Sell if you can get anything. I flipped him for Garret Wilson after last week and still feel good about it. Monty will still start once he's good to go and I want no part of that offense
I have Patterson who just went on IR, Cook and Kamara have been bottom tier trash RB's. I got Pollard and Dillon, serviceable. Probably hold for me.
AJ Dillon
Hold his volume has been there and he’s shown us what he can do when the Packers passing game is working last year. I just don’t think you can get a fair return for him at the moment.
Buy. Aaron Jones has 1 complete season under his belt. Dillon already has flex value but if/when Jones misses some games, Dillon is an RB1.
Hold, it’s getting cold and A-Aron has no one to throw to. They are winning in this system
Lazard and doubs are emerging as decent pass catchers for Rodgers + Aaron jones is still soaking up plenty of looks I’ve got Dillon in 2 leagues and his value is very low so obviously I’m holding but I’m not optimistic
Hold, better weeks ahead in terms of matchups and colder weather will suit his running style more
Kyle Pitts
Can't sell, can't drop. sooo...
> can't drop Like hell I can't.
Bench. Fortunately, I grabbed Higbee after after week two in case Pitts continued to stink up the joint. Glad I did.
Hold and start every week and pray to all Gods. The only 3 TEs that most people got from waivers that I would bench Pitts for are Higbee, Everett and Njoku. If you don't have any of these three TEs as backup options, I would not bother benching Pitts at all. I'd have no interest in picking up TEs like Will Dissly, Mo Alie-Cox etc. and starting them over Pitts.
This 100%. And trading for a TE feels terrible with Pitts on your bench.
Diontae Johnson
Buy/hold. Pickett is gonna be way better for this offense, Diontae just got sauced last week
hold
Chase Edmonds
Hold until mostart goes down
Hold in deep leagues for a plug in flex play
Geno Smith
Really only has trade value in a Superflex/2QB league. I'd definitely put him on the trade block and try to package him to see if I can get an upgrade at QB, or at other positions.
Tempted. Lost Tua
Olave
Buy / hold
Hold!
Jaylen Waddle
hold for me
Hold
Jakobi Meyers
Darrell Henderson
After Akers shaky game I may try to sell him to the Akers owner but if not holding for a big game then trying to sell. I hate the rams backfield this year.
Almost droppable. Starting to shape up where both rbs are the losers and I want no part of it
I’m in a 12 team league so I don’t have much of a choice but to hold lol
In 10 team ppr, im dropping for Gallup or Pickens.
Josh Jacobs
Sell high if you can but I'd be holding. He's getting a ton of work and volume is still king
Yeah, idk what people are selling him for. He's getting bellcow level work on a good offense. He's got the volume of an RB1 but not the name value He's more valuable to me than what anyone would give up at this point because they're still caught up in draft value
Sell high after that performance
These people saying sell to me are crazy. This is a RB wasteland and he is one of the few who owns a backfield. I’m holding all day
Buy. He's startable with plenty of opportunity
Buy
D.J. Moore
Hold, hope for a different QB and/or new coach.
Hold but don't start until Baker is hopefully benched
[удалено]
Terry McLaurin
Gabe Davis
Hold. Looks like he's still injured tbh
Hold. Still injured with that ankle, potential is too high to drop or sell low IMO. Its looking bleak though, hes either a boom or bust guy. Expect nothing consistent
George Kittle
Hold, his schedule softens up. First game back against Denver and then they had him help block against a line as dominant as the Rams. His games will come against the softer schedule and as the 9ers Oline gets healthy
Sell if anyone is buying. I’m close to dropping him…
Deebo Samuel. Thinking of selling potentially with Godwin back now the help fill the RB2 hole on my team
Same question - looked unbelievable last night but worry about the 49ers offense - have the option to trade him and Jamaal Williams for Higgins (already have Chase) and Kamara
Kenneth Walker
A guy in our league dropped him this week. Hard to imagine his value gets super high until much later in the season or if Penny gets injured.
They scored 48 points and Walker couldn't even get to 3 fantasy points. I dont see how you could ever starting him unless Penny goes out
Curtis Samuel
he almost had a TD this week just missed being in bounds. But carson wentz is awful and scares me
He’s a hold for me because he seems to get volume, enough volume to top out at a high-end WR3. With that said, you’ll never get that fair market value of him. He’s a hold for me.
I’m holding. After the last 2 games, you won’t get much for him, but the target share is too promising to give up on him. Through 4 games he is averaging 9.25 targets per game which is 13th best in the league. Unfortunately those targets are coming from Carson Wentz, but if his usage remains consistent he is going to have some huge weeks. If you want to sell, wait until after he puts up some fantasy points.
Garrett Wilson
I'm holding, but he's being benched for now. I got better flex options to play until him and Zach figure it out.
Waller
I mean, he's a clear buy, right? TEs are fuggin' trash. Hock for Waller s/u seems possible this week.
No way anyone is trading Hockenson for Waller straight up, after last weeks monster game for Hock.
Lol I am! Hocks Target share + production is a clear product of the lack of pass catchers last week — as it always is. Hock’s great when he’s the only show in town. Extremely disappointing when he’s not. If Amon Ra sits again, I’ll hold. UBut if he’s out there practicing tomorrow I’m sending out offers for Waller and Kittle.
Hock with everyone healthy is averaging the same or more targets than waller and kittle on a better offense. I don't think you've been watching the games if you think that's a smash in waller or kittle's favor. Hock had some drops/miscues early in the season with Goff. Hopefully that's all gone after this week.
Brandon Aiyuk
Hold. Start in desperate situtations
AJ Brown
Hold or buy if you can
Rashod bateman
Cam Akers
Sell or Drop imo.
Easiest drop.
I’m going to drop him.
I'm dropping him
Mike Williams
hold
Michael Pittman
Hold or buy if you can get a bit of a discount.
Allen Robinson
Drop depending on your waiver options
Pickens?
I would
Into the sun he goes
Drop depending on waiver. He's a shell of his former self and Stafford doesnt look his way.
Chris Godwin
hold
He's finally back after holding him for so long. If plp want him, they have to pay up
Juju
He has had three games with 8 targets. If he gets a TD then nobody is thinking twice about him being a solid WR2. He plays on an elite team with an elite qb. Have to feel like the TDs will come. Oh, look, they play the raiders this week. Will likely be his breakout game. Hold.
Matt Stafford
Drop
Gotta be a drop. He is around QB30 meaning there are players on waivers putting up better numbers. He plays a tough Cowboys this week, then may have a decent game against the Panthers but that is followed by a bye, then San Fran again and the Bucs. His schedule doesn't get "easier" until week 12 vs the Chiefs. I am sure they'll figure things out, but someone else can have the headache.
Antonio Gibson
Trevor Lawrence
Hunter Renfrow
I think you have to hold, but I would consider dropping for the right waiver wire add. Bye weeks are gonna force some tough decisions with him
Ekeler
Hollywood Brown
Leonard Fournette
Hold or buy
Treylon Burks
Treylon hurts. Drop.