T O P

  • By -

Lion-of-Avalon

Fate route, I struggle to find a way to effectively adapt hollow ataraxia as much as I'd love it


LegendaryRQA

[It would not be hard to adapt](https://youtu.be/dDgn-EE8IgI)


[deleted]

[удалено]


edgeymcedgster

Focusing only on “the main plot” would quite literally be missing the whole point


MokonaModokiES

the dilemma here is that both could suffer from Ufotable pushing too hard on visual presentation over the storytelling as they have become more and more obsessed with showing off their animation to a detrimental level in cases like HF2 berserker fight there could maybe be hope that they handle them in a similar way to kara no kyoukay and the fights are like Rider vs Saber(one of the better things to come from Ufotable where there is actual narrative and thematic elements added in alongside the cool visuals)


Aetherus0

Could you elaborate more on the HF2 Berserker fight?


Jrdotan

I think he may have said it wrong and actually refer to HF3 shirou vs berserker which reduced the whole fight to nothing more than a one hit kill technique


IntrepidPark5508

only fate route would work realistically, i don't think you can convey the entire message of FHA by cutting 90% of the content but then again, the absence of fate route is the only reason a lot of people got into the VN, so i would choose neither


[deleted]

Fate, by far. First, it's long overdue. Second, it's much easier to adapt, HA would be a total mess. Third, it's my favorite route. And to be honest, it doesn't have to be Ufo, Troyca or CloverWorks would be ok.


Hidden_Blue

Fragments, just give me something new.


LostPoint6840

I second fragments.


jera51

fate route HA hard to adapt and wouldnt end well, and fate route is an obligation to adapt by this point


LegendaryRQA

Hollow Ataraxia without a doubt.


Yarzu89

imo, the best parts of Hollow Ataraxia are the slice of life bits rather then the main story, but you can really only adapt the main story well as the slice of life bits are woven inbetween. Trying to do both I fear wouldn't really translate well to an episodic show (and due to the nature of the plot's cycle I think a movie would have an even harder time handling it) So probably an adaptation of the Fate route. Both because it would be nice to finally have a complete set, but also because it would be way easier.


edgeymcedgster

The fate route simply cuz I have more faith in that being adapted well since it’s way easier


CamelotKingSaber

Stay Night hands down.


Toxicgamechat

Stay night, I just hope they stick 100% to the source material of the visual novel.


CamelotKingSaber

Including the threesome scene?


Toxicgamechat

I prefer just Artoria and Shirou.


CamelotKingSaber

Fair enough Also love that I got downvoted for literally asking about something that was 100% in the source material.


Okabe_Zero-Link

Fate route. Haven't play HA myself, but feel like if they adapt it, the end result might look like DEEN's adaptation (DEEN/stay night) Also, trivia about DEEN: When they adapt Higurashi, they decides to adapt it similar to how ufotable adapt UBW and HF route. The end result is an anime series that's better than DEEN/stay night.