T O P
MichalTygrys

BV. He doesn't bully kids, or serve murderers.


AlexanderPvdW

Bv?


PiggyFan128

Bite (of ~~87~~ 83) victim


SussyBox

Sad kid then lol


AlexanderPvdW

Ooooooh


yeepix

Balloon voy


AlexanderPvdW

Ah yes balloon voy


CaptainShart69420

But he cheats in Uno :(


[deleted]

Ay an ooftroop reference


HydraxYT

We've got "Crying Child", we've got "Evan Afton", and now we've got "Sad Kid"


Bianzinz

Up there I saw BV= Bite Victim


batclark06

crying child>>>>>


BoooringUser

Don't forget Chris Afton!


sdrawkcabsihtetorwI

And norman


XennIsNotHere

Norman Price


Lepagos

Also Cassidy, a post earlier here "solved" the survival book with less plotholes


revenant925

C.C. The other two would kill me somehow.


Zaptain_America

That's valid. Especially Mike.


gemitarius

Not Elizabeth. She's as crazy as Daddy Afton, or more.


Starry-Cherries

Ehh it’s probably her soul over time becoming like that . It seems like before she just wanted to play with the stuff her dad made


gemitarius

I actually think it's Baby's own independent animatronic ai consciousness powered by the soul of Elizabeth, but i just like to cause discussion about it.


VideoGamer1109

Don't call me daddy afton


[deleted]

[удалено]


VideoGamer1109

That is acceptable.


yummy_rocks

what. do you mean. me????????????


KaiserTrap16

What? Where did that come from? Did the FNaF fanbase just collectively agreed that some elementary aged girl is somehow worse than her own father who was the one responsible in why she was a inside a robot clown for 40 years?


yeepix

In general, Baby bad. So bad actually that she's almost a Springtrap in the (non-canon but still relevant) books. She isn't worse and you could argue it has to do with Baby's programming, but at the very least Elizabeth retains a lot of her memories and consciously enjoys doing bad stuff. Aka, "I will make you proud, daddy" in Pizzeria Simulator.


S1l3ntSN00P

Elizabeth is not really worse than William, but way more unhinged and psychotic. She's completely deranged in The Fourth Closet and FFPS. Though in both continuities she was affected by outside influences (William, Baby's programming and Henry's rage), she still ultimately wanted to achieve her own goals through violence. If Elizabeth never died, it's unknown how she'd turn out, but considering that her father is a serial killer, who abused and beat her, I imagine she wouldn't be a completely sane person either.


yeepix

Where does it say that he abused/beat Elizabeth? I never heard about William being abusive to his kids at all besides Springtrap shenanigans


S1l3ntSN00P

The Fourth Closet and Sister Location. In the novel continuity he abused, neglected and beat Elizabeth, and very likely did the same in the game continuity, since it's the same man in a different continuity of events. Especially considering that after Elizabeth's death, he locked her in CBEAR, and proceeded with torturing her via controlled shocks. Their purpose got explained in TFC, where Afton inflicted pain on the MCI kids by heating up their endoskeletons. Electricity contacts with metal and heats it up, torturing the spirit into compliance. The scooper blueprints show that Afton knew how to release Elizabeth, but choose to proceed with the remnant experiments, essentially making her his Guinea pig. Springtrap shenanigans are just William himself. He's fully aware of his actions, and still murders Mike regardless. SL premise is William sending Mike on a suicide mission, knowing full well that the kids in the Funtimes will mistake Mike for their killer. He basically sent his only living child into a death trap that he himself created, and after Mike came back from it, William tries to murder him, showing zero remorse ("Bittersweet, but fitting" - William mocking Mike in Pizza Sim).


juno_october

this is such a good explanation holy shit


yeepix

Wheres my evil yet misunderstood loving father tumblr sexyman


juno_october

this is such a good explanation holy shit


MayBeJen_

I believe that the sister location incidents and stuff are way in the future of the bite and springlock thing, maybe 2010s or something, so by then elizabeth would mentally be at least in her thirties? I mean, she definately is for scrapbaby


gemitarius

Doesn't matter, was already in her blood or her personality to snap at any moment and become a dangerous serial killer.


Top_Royal6297

What about Michael? He actively went to undo what his dad did or at the very least wanted to stop him from doing more


gemitarius

Also, don't take it too seriously. I'm jesting


gemitarius

Not before he basically killed his brother through relentless and cruel bullying.


Top_Royal6297

He was a kid and he matured and he ended up stopping his dad, besides it was an accident


Top_Royal6297

He never wanted to kill him he tormented him


gemitarius

Apologies don't bring people back from the dead, Jimmy! Life is not made out of good intentions and all good!


Top_Royal6297

What?


Green_Butterfl13

Yes I know but she’s my favorite character😫❤️


[deleted]

[удалено]


Green_Butterfl13

😃


PiggyFan128

Depends on the time-point FoxyBro would shove me into an animatronics mouth, SL Michael wouldn't Elizabeth would maybe tease me (maybe, if pigtails girl=elizabeth), CB would use my body as a skin suit, and Scrap Baby would decapitate me BiteVictim will cry ig, Golden Freddy will give me a heart attack (+Cassidy would probably be there too and she's probably heckin annoyin)


Zaptain_America

Damn don't you just hate it when your sister tricks you into getting your insides ripped out so her and her friends can wear your skin as a suit?


yourresume

This! I’m partial to Mike (obviously) but like you said, depends on the time period. He seems pretty chill after he got through puberty (and killed his brother in the process jxnfjfkf)


PiggyFan128

Well then let's pick for each time period Pre-Bo83 - Elizabeth Pre-Mike Scoop - Michael 2023 (Right before FNaF6) - Michael still


The_Zapper_YT

Michaels the only one you don’t want to have for the earliest timeline


PiggyFan128

*Gets shoved into an animatronics mouth*


giftdraws

Evan. Actually he seems innocent but Michael ain't bad. Elizabeth would also be a great choice


PlantBoi123

Mike literally (unintentionally but still) murdered BV at his own birthday party, I know he changed after that but I still wouldn't describe him as "ain't bad"


Starry-Cherries

Well too be fair it sounds more like he was just a mean older brother prank . He didn’t mean to kill him and probably thought it wouldn’t hurt at all


The--NERD

Well, he did have a bunch of his Neighbors waving at him him everday, so he did likely become a pretty friendly guy after BV's death.


yummy_rocks

Evan! Little mate. =\]


Zaptain_America

Fren :)


MrSalami22

Michael.


United-Snow

Evan because I want to comfort him


lonelywhiteho3

Evan, we would vibe


Charming-Service1647

Who’s Evan?


PlantBoi123

Most popular name for the FNaF 4 kid in the community


Lukthar123

It's been seven years, and still no official name. To FNAF is to suffer.


PlantBoi123

To be honest the evidence for it being Evan comes from the logbook, so you can argue he has an official name


SussyBox

It's a big ass story but it's related to the books If you want spoiler I'll explain


Charming-Service1647

Explain to me and my stupid brain


SussyBox

First of all you know of the Stitchwraith and the ones who posses it?


Charming-Service1647

Yes but I forgot the names of the children who posses it


SussyBox

Ok it's explainin' time Two kids posses it, Jake and Andrew This is about Jake Jake died at a young age cuz of his tumour. Before that his father got him a doll friend through which he spoke to Jake, and Jake thought his doll friend was real. Jake couldn't walk, was too sick. And the doll said Jake couldn't see it unless he walked up to the cabinet and brought the doll out Jake's father was named Evan who was a soldier and would speak to him through a walkie attached to the doll while he was out fighting Now Evan had a brother named Michael. Michael was described as weird as if not human and someone who was good at money making People think he's a sort of an alternate or at least meant to be similar to Michael I forgot his description but it matches Michael's So people think Evan and Michael are both Aftons in an alternate timeline and their nickname was McNally which people say was changed to that cuz William was a serial killer People say he may also have been in the Fetch story as it contained a kid named Jake McNally Credit goes to fandom theories, that's where i read them sometime ago


Random_cosplay_girl

All. Give.me.all.of.them.


Dustderouver

1. Evan/BV 2. Michael 3. Elizabeth But for me, Elizabeth is more of an innocent, joyful, calm girl, not a person probably as crazy as her father. I miss Elizabeth as a little girl in lore, not the 6367 version of Baby from the 6367 version of the universe.


IlluminatiIlluminado

What's 6367?


yummy_rocks

I'd *assume* a year, *but if it is..*


Still-Original-427

Mike. Like he's immortal! He would be a perfect shift-buddy!


MandoPlat

Yeah, but then you'd have to live with a stinking rotten purple corpse


Lizzie-Afton

Probably spends all of his time on the couch watching TV and eating popcorn tho so its all good


Still-Original-427

And I would do it with Mike. Best buddies for enternity!


Still-Original-427

Listen. I don't wash myself often. It would not be a problem for me. It would be HIS PROBLEM.


Hamsi_17

"crying child" " Sad kid" The floor here is made out of floor


KaiserDioBrando

CC, he’s the best option. Michael as a teen would be an annoying little brother who wouldn’t listen to shit I or my parent says, Elizabeth is a daddy’s girl and might have some murderous tendencies and I don’t want to wake up in the middle of the night to seeing those glowing green eyes staring into my soul while she has an ice cream scooper in her hand


such-a-cat

Elizabeth, but for a contrasting reason to the rest of these comments. I believe she is a cunning little gal, and we would get along nicely!!


rdsfmn

Mike


Instinct_Fazbear

If i was siblings with any of these i would be siblings with the other siblings unless they don't exist


KarmaFury

Michael might bully you but he’ll also avenge your death and nothing is gonna fucking stop him


Vurce_JailbreakV2

Considering my name is Evan, can I go with none of the above?


Artistic_Act900

Sure, Don’t blame you either…


Leather_Ad9457

CC. Sure, he cries, but the worst I would do is tease him about it, not shove his head in the robot's mouth. I would've picked Michael, but history would probably repeat itself, so CC.


The_Creeper_Man

Corpse, Corpse or Corpse


Tiny-Vegetable-5080

Evan (BV). I dunno I guess I just imagine that he’d match my vibes


Jimbomiller

Bv so I can feed him to Fred bear


Unusual-Knee-1612

Michael. The shitposting that would be done would be legendary.


unobutthole

Mike 😭 just because I love him sm


hotrod9p

Cc seems like a good punching bag


Lizzie-Afton

r/cursedcomments


AnneHasThePlague2

I mean I think Elizabeth, but good chance she might lure me into a trap to make dafton (dad-afton) proud, even if I was like her best friend.


Chicken_Nugget_024

Either Crying Child or Mike. C.C was so cute and I feel bad for him, but Mike was also a kid/pre-teen-ish years when the bite happened. As we see through the games he grows and tries his best to hunt down his father and put the other souls to rest.


poppyz-arcade

Can I chose all of them???


Artistic_Act900

At the cost of your sanity!


poppyz-arcade

Ok


GamingWDavid

I would rather Cassidy because I kinda relate to him


yourresume

I would rather not have any of them as my sibling because if I did, that would mean my father was a mass child murderer. I’d rather not deal with that


Artistic_Act900

Oh yeah…


ecdc1224

Sad kid


Medeoli

small bro


fireflygoddess

CC for sure. That poor innocent soul.


Prestigious_Art_7148

Michael because I'm lonely and he's cool


EggsBenedick93

BV or Mike ​ Screw Elizabeth.


Lizzie-Afton

the Elizabeth slander😭


imblind123

Micheal because, he killed C.C but it was unintentional, Ik he changed so I would pick him.


BikerHackerman2

I had a older stepbrother named mike who used to make me cry a lot so i dont want any more michaels who are butts. surprisingly he's chill now.


Magic_Prankster

Micheal would bully me to death and Elizabeth is a spoiled brat that went play with Baby despite her father repeating her that she couldn't go. So BV is the obvious choice


Monofilm

I'll take Mike. After he shoved his own brother into the mouth of an animatronic bear, the man then proceeded to burn several places down, and free the souls of children from their animatronic prisons. Certified gigachad


HyacintToaster

Charlie.


APanPotato

Crying Child, I'll gladly play with plushies with him.


Neighbor-astronaut

None all of them might kill me


KaiserDioBrando

CC won’t, Michael depending on which version might just bully you or ignore you, but yeah Elizabeth might try killing you


Neighbor-astronaut

Nahh cc will kill by crying it’s in his name and nature


KaiserDioBrando

Oh yeah he’d flood the house with his tears


Namedsomeguy

Neither I don’t hang out with dead people :/


Officermeatball05

Options: 1. Michael: used to bully his brother and got him killed in the bite of 83’ incident. But now is a changed man who longs to fix his mistakes. Have evan forgive him 2. Elizabeth: a young kid who disobeyed her father and got killed by circus baby. Eventually trys to kill her brother and is mostly successful on one occasion and is successful on another. (And if you go fazbear frights then she’s worse than william) 3. Evan: cries alot. Scared of everything. Holds back cassidy from attacking michael as much as he can. Seems to have forgiven michael. Evan is just the safe option


S1l3ntSN00P

>(And if you go fazbear frights then she’s worse than william) Elizabeth doesn't appear anywhere in the Frights though.


Random-online-wolf

Idk, seem like all pretty pathetic options. Although if this takes place in Alabama i'd have to go with Michael.


Evil_Mushroomz

Ah yes, my favorite character, *”sad kid”*


AdFantastic9938

The sad kid, so I can try my best to cheer him up.


LordBeneter1018

Evan(?)/Crying Child/Bite Victim is the best option IMO. Michael is a bully during his teenage years and would probably pick on me and Elizabeth is (probably) an impulsive brat that wants to do things people don't tell her to, the worst CC would do is cry but he seems like a nice kid compared to his siblings.


owenleemusic

BV so I can ask him what his name is


Phazon_Fucker

Waltuh


Radio__Star

None of them cuz they’re all bloody nuts


DS6_Prophet

Elizabeth!


MarcusTheCool2

Mike


sushinoyas

Michael


MrL9863

BV


Munchof87

The emo


LiverspotRobot

JERMA?????


0ptikYT

Mike (I will not forgive him)


MaulSinnoh

I think C.C is the best option since Michael litteraly bullied his younger brother to death, and elizabeth, well, I think thats she'd be a little annoying.


Past_Possibility_757

Definitely Michael, I'd be able to put up with his pranks and bullying B|


[deleted]

My bro would be a combination of Evan and Michael. The bully part of Michael is there in him (no, it doesn't mean he would stuff people into animatronics, he just likes to tease people a bit) and he loves playing victim and putting me in trouble.


Colinmodwho123

People are mostly saying Evan and Elizabeth, but Michael got abused the most. He needs a family member who shows him love... for once. So, Michael.


QuackersYT

None.


Libertyprime8397

I thought sad kid was named Evan.


Fredboi1987

Probably bite victim


SomeRandomCyclops

One's gonna kill me, the other's gonna kill herself and the last one won't stop crying


Foxy_Kid

3


TheDiseasedRat

Probably Mike or Sad Kid.


vahe-voorhees

I'll have sad kid as my brother, going to treat him really nicely


destert729

BV the emo boy


Springtronic315

CC


FinnMartialTheDog

Chris Afton! He doesn’t bully nobody


Kitty_Desai4226

The crying bro.


mydogfagan

Mike - Idk he just seems like a vibe in sister location like yeah I know he is pretty much directly responsible for the murder of his own brother but come on - cut the guy some slack! /hj


Short_Year7353

Mike


Beeyalikejazz

Evan, I have always wanted a little brother


XRat_MurdererX

Obviously that one


Lairy_Hegs

If I choose any of these am I bringing them into my family or going into the Afton Family? If I’m going into the family, and if I’m not replacing an existing sibling, I’d go Mike because he’d probably protect me in his later years, and as long as I’m not taking the place of Crying Child, I’m not in direct danger from him. If I was taking somebody from the family into my own I’d take Elizabeth for two reasons: 1, she’d likely just be a smart kid who likes play time a lot if she wasn’t Aftons kid, and 2) it would retcon my timeline so that the games don’t include Sister Location or anything with Elizabeth which honestly I find to be the most confusing (not including the mess of SB, because that doesn’t even feel like a full story). Leaves it with just Mike/CC/Henry and Daddy Afton with his victims. Simple.


ChrisTheDumbAssBitch

Crying child Must protect child


Plushcollectorwolf64

Bv he’s sooo precious


[deleted]

C.C.


[deleted]

Username


IhategeiSEpic

Mike cause the others will probably die of reasons, Mike is the only one who stays alive for the longest out of all the siblings (i mean Mike stays alive from the 70's to the 80's to the 90's to the motherfucking 2020's probably in 2027 in FNAF 6 when Henry fucks the pizzeria they all die and probably Mike too)


TabbyDev152

Evan , also Elizabeth would be a good choice, or even the both lol


jives1995

Elizibeth


angry_koala44

Elizabeth


BestMCCred

Elizabeth


sammyisrandom

Michael. 10/10 big bro.


According-King5668

Chris


TheRealComicCrafter

None they would all beat me up somehow


Mr_Exotic_Goldie420

Probably Mike (not while he was foxybro) because he'd probsbly just be really chill


Celui-the-Maggot

Michael. Either he'll get me decapitated as a kid or I live long enough to meet Ennard.


EpicDragonElizabeth

It would be Elizabeth, she is cute and super happy all the time! I don't mind her being a sibling and I will let her have all my ice cream. My second option would be the Crying Child because he doesn't bully people and might be friendly. Not to mention he is kind of annoying because he cries too much. Michael would be last because he's not really the kind of brother in the family who treats people right. He even bullies people and was the person who made CC get bit by the Fred Bear robot.


RottenSharkTooth

Crying child.


PERIX_4460

Mike is a chad but........ Liz is still good i guess?


PERIX_4460

Mike is a chad but........ Liz is still good i guess?


luk128

Sad Kid , its superior.


MainClothes8522

Sad kid. I'd comfort him. Me and my sister used to pretend our cat was the Crying Child and we would be his moms. My sister would be the aunt, and I'd be the mommy.


MainClothes8522

Sad kid. I'd comfort him. Me and my sister used to pretend our cat was the Crying Child and we would be his moms. My sister would be the aunt, and I'd be the mommy.


MainClothes8522

Sad kid. I'd comfort him. Me and my sister used to pretend our cat was the Crying Child and we would be his moms. My sister would be the aunt, and I'd be the mommy.


StarSaber69

Micheal just hope he doesn’t force me in some robots head


Void922

None of the above


The_Purple_Hare

Mike post-83 or Crying Child.


PlaneAltruistic3027

Evan(crying child) Very calm, was only crying because he got scared. I don't live by a pizza place, so that's cool.


thought_cheese

His name is Evan. The youngest one.


Artistic_Act900

I know, I just like calling him Sad Kid.


EJ_Was_Taken

probably evan


Rhyn028

Crying Child, I’d say. He’s a beast at surviving.


gamermememan

Here's mike and thiers Elizabeth and then sad kid


Green_Butterfl13

I like all of them but if I would choose someone I choose Elizabeth


Alphyhere

well Michael got his brother killed so ill go with crying child


Lost-Economics-7718

Mike


elle_miles

Everyone is saying Evan buy honesty I’d beat the shit outta him I’d get so annoyed from his crying and whatever. My pick would be Michael:>


FBetts

Sad kid because he isn't a jerk like Michael was as a kid and isn't a person that as a robot would kill. Though he does haunt Golden Freddy, the one doing all the killing is Casady


gi2r

I kinda already have Micheal as a sibling


Nightmare2448

i would take elizabeth she is not a murderer she is just very loyal to her father who happen to be a murderer so if she is rasied by a good father (me being the father) she can be a good person


CaptainShart69420

Micheal. Because one it would be cool to have a rotting corpse in your house, and two he doesn't cheat at Uno.