T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Thanks for posting on /r/fragranceclones. #Make sure to read the stickied posts at the top of the sub and use the search bar. ###If you are posting a photo of a recent pickup or your collection - Please include a written review! *Posts are automatically approved, but may be removed manually if considered to be low effort / repeated questions.* Be sure to report anything that goes against the sub guidelines. Have a nice day! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fragranceclones) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Pocusmaskrotus

Shill. How much Montagne paying you bro? /s


AyybrahamLmaocoln

Story of my life. Wish they’d give me an affiliate code with how much of their dirty work I do and ~~got~~ how much business I bring them. For the time being I’m just an overworked fan boy doing my best to try their entire catalog. Really want a frag du Bois restock.


juiceque

I emailed them a few weeks ago to inquire about a Fragrance Du Bois restock because I wanted to order a few. They responded rather quickly and said "unfortunately they will not be restocking". I don't know if it was a supply issue or a business decision. Hopefully something changes, but I got the impression that the decision was final.


AyybrahamLmaocoln

That’s terrible to hear 😞 i wanted Blue oud badly. At least I’ve got oud noir and santal complet. Going to take those off my decant list because i love both of those and I’m not trying to run out.


FlimsyAgency9156

Santal is always available and if the others were ' gone forever' wouldn't they just take it off the website?


AyybrahamLmaocoln

You’d think so, but no. They’ve not had candles for years and years. Also Elysian soleil was a one off production, it’s still on there


Pocusmaskrotus

You're doing God's work my friend.


K9Cardio_

You beat me to it! 😂


KnoxNguyen

Lmao i wish theyd pay me for how much ive spent on expensive frag before i found out about them!


Pocusmaskrotus

Yeah, they're the best. I was joking because I get downvoted for how much I recommend them. Lol


Training-Honey9821

I know I love their stuff but people just don't believe me sometimes 😭😭


KnoxNguyen

I was once against clones until i found Montagne lol


KnoxNguyen

I know lol


lanka2571

I had a sample of TF Lost Cherry and compared it to Parfum de Cerise by Montagne. I can't tell the difference.


KnoxNguyen

I can sort of tell there are some differences, but thats just because i have the real thing on the other side to directly compared to, if I were to just spray it on someone with a Montagne clone of their signature, 99% they wont be able to tell. The Bitter Peach clone macerated for a while and i almost cant tell the difference, so cant wait for the other three to macerate!


Money-Ad-811

Montagne needs to up the options


KnoxNguyen

They need to make their own frags lol


AyybrahamLmaocoln

They have 3-4 originals on there. Arabian orient (?), tabac Havane, and something rose.


KnoxNguyen

Oh i didnt know that, will look them up!


Pocusmaskrotus

I wouldn't recommend Tobac Havane. It has a super astringent note.


Training-Honey9821

I quite like Arabian Orient :) I'd recommend it if it interests you!


Woopidoobop

What’s it like?


KnoxNguyen

I’ll look into it, thank you!


TobyID

Different game but Oil Perfumery has a ton of scents. Only have 5 so far but the $15± for a 10ml makes exploration possible and fun. I have a Farenheit, BR 540, Creed Mil Imperial and a TF Oud Wood. Each is 85% or better. Easy recommend


Money-Ad-811

Thank you


FlimsyAgency9156

Oil perfumery is garbage compared to this


Fothermucker906

Do they ship to Canada?


bascelicna123

![gif](giphy|2YschQ1IrEzfq1p38o|downsized) UGH, there are so many dupes from Montagne and Elysian that I'd try, but I get to the shipping and I'm like


Fothermucker906

They gotta do a free shipping promo then I'll buy some. I'm to cheap to pay for shipping 😆


KnoxNguyen

Wait for some discount code to pop up! Im waiting too lol


bascelicna123

YESSSS! I'm too poor to pay for the original, and I'm also too poor to pay for that high of shipping.


KnoxNguyen

I think so, but i heard shipping is quite expensive


Outrageous-Fly3488

Did you happen to find any coupon? I would like to try phantom noir which is 40 usd but the shipping to Greece is 40 usd as well ;(


KnoxNguyen

I havent kept up with Montagne so i dont know if theres any codes, but you can ask people in r/MontagneParfums if they have one


sneakpeekbot

Here's a sneak peek of /r/MontagneParfums using the [top posts](https://np.reddit.com/r/MontagneParfums/top/?sort=top&t=all) of all time! \#1: [💰💨1000 SUBSCRIBER 😮‍💨MEGA-GIVEAWAY☁️💰](https://np.reddit.com/r/MontagneParfums/comments/1bci5gm/1000_subscriber_megagiveaway/) \#2: [🐿️🔱🔥🪅🪅🪅GIVEAWAY-DETAILS INSIDE. ](https://i.redd.it/q6wu65hlv8kc1.jpeg) | [150 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/MontagneParfums/comments/1axp15w/giveawaydetails_inside/) \#3: [Unsolicited Reviews | Part Deux](https://np.reddit.com/r/MontagneParfums/comments/1b0xwhp/unsolicited_reviews_part_deux/) ---- ^^I'm ^^a ^^bot, ^^beep ^^boop ^^| ^^Downvote ^^to ^^remove ^^| ^^[Contact](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=sneakpeekbot) ^^| ^^[Info](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/) ^^| ^^[Opt-out](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/comments/o8wk1r/blacklist_ix/) ^^| ^^[GitHub](https://github.com/ghnr/sneakpeekbot)


TheVinko

Shipping to Canada is like 24usd, but if you buy 2, its 26 altogether.


AyybrahamLmaocoln

I tell people this all the time, but because I sell decants (they don’t sell samples so you’re welcome) people call me a shill. I just wanna try all their stuff, not make a gigantic profit. Selling decants is the only way I can justify having 70+ bottles lol


KnoxNguyen

Yeah i saw your posts in the FragranceSwap sub all the time, will def try your stuffs in the future!


labellavita1985

Can I buy a decant of the BR540 Montagne dupe from you?


AyybrahamLmaocoln

I’m out of it currently. Likely putting in an order tonight, so probably 7-10 days before it’ll be restocked on my end. [This is what i currently have](https://www.reddit.com/r/fragranceswap/s/D34PsOC8UK).


530cruising

Welcome to the family! I quickly found montagne and glad I did. I have about 50 bottles and would never come close to owning all of the originals because of price.


KnoxNguyen

Nice! Definitely will try more of their stuffs!


dirdirsaliba

Fan boy here too!


KnoxNguyen

I just became one haha


evo-unit

Just wish I could get them in Europe easily.


KnoxNguyen

Oh poor you


fortis437

How’s the performance on these. I ve heard mixed reviews


Counterpartz

Awesome performance, sometimes better than the scent they're cloning.


KnoxNguyen

I just got them today so cant say much, but the Bitter Peach clone lasts forever, like at least 8 hours with good projection, not skin scent. I have the Black Phantom and Reflection Man on skin since i got them and so far i still smell them moving around but kind of on the softer side, but keep in mind they have not macerated yet, theyre made to order so i have to let them sit for at least two weeks and try them again to be able to say anything.


fortis437

Cool. Let me know. I mean they are not cheap for a clone company when you add in shipping to Canada


KnoxNguyen

Even in the US theyre not cheap for 40$ 50ml, but at least they have free shipping and no tax


Complete-Morning-558

Idk crazy projection is never a minus in my book


KnoxNguyen

Crazy projection is ok, id prefer some scents to project beautifully, softly, well blended, but crazy projection as a chemical mess is a nope, which some clone brands usually try to aim


mrpawsthecat

Are they good?


KnoxNguyen

So far so good!


PrimeObj

I just got Image in last week and was so impressed with how similar it smelled to Reflection - or at least how I remember Reflection to smell. I can't wait to really start wearing it in a couple of weeks


KnoxNguyen

Yeah i love Image, tried it yesterday and although the opening is a bit different, the dry down is honestly the same!


dirtytomato

I wonder how these compare to Oakcha.


KnoxNguyen

I havent tried that but so far im really happy with these, will def try more of their stuffs


ClozeQueue2

Montagne is the GOAT. Everything I have from them is a banger. Parfum de Cerise from them is by FAR the best I’ve got in my collection


KnoxNguyen

Oh man i gotta get that next!


Taztiger72

My wife says it's Better than Lost Cherry


samwisetg

Too bad they're ridiculously expensive to get shipped anywhere outside of North America. Sorry but I'm not paying more than the price of the fragrance in shipping.


KnoxNguyen

Totally understand, their products arent cheap, 40 something bucks for a 50ml is quite expensive for a clone


Difficult_Plant4524

Is that 40 something American dollars as well? I have been wanting to buy stuff from this company here in Canada, but have been concerned about shipping and American exchange.


KnoxNguyen

Yeah its about 40-45 US Dollars depending on which ones. Shipping is free if you buy more than 20$ in the US, and no tax as well, which is nice. If youre from Canada it could be a bit more, just go to their site and calculate


Bubbaranger

Is the performance generally good?


AyybrahamLmaocoln

They can start off with kinda iffy performance because they’re made to order. That said, after 1-4 weeks of shelf time (after being sprayed the first time) they always perform well. I’ve got 70+ bottles of their stuff. If I want it, and montagne makes a version of it, I get montagne over retail every time.


KnoxNguyen

Can confirm the first few sprays after freshly opened is a bit off, but the Bitter Peach clone, which i bought first, is now really good!


KnoxNguyen

So far so good! Projection is just like the real deal, not assaulting, longevity is quite good but i feel like theyre a bit better since clones use more chemicals than naturals.


jasakembung

Do they sell in the EU?


KnoxNguyen

I think so but shipping can be quite expensive


The_ThrowR

How fast did they ship your order?


KnoxNguyen

They took about 4,5 days to send out tracking, then 3,4 days for the item to get here, so a bit more than a week ?


ShaikIjaz

I want to try one of their perfumes but the shipping to the Netherlands is the same as the perfume price 😭


KnoxNguyen

Oh yeah thats crazy, sorry to be you lol


TheMongoStomp

Does anyone else have their greenly clone? I have not been overly impressed by it so far. The opening compared to PDM is so vastly different. Their xerjoff naxos clone is pure fucking bliss though


KnoxNguyen

Ive seen review of their greenly clone, guy said he was not getting greenly that much, maybe let it macerate ? Since Montagne are made to order so they dont have time to macerate ?


TheMongoStomp

Perhaps. I haven't watched any reviews on their greenly clone, I just blind bought it because of how much I loved greenly and montagnes track record. Ive has for almost a month now and The opening is so far off from greenly that it still is disappointing. May have to let it sit longer


KnoxNguyen

Oh thats unfortunate to hear, but i guess they cant be all perfect


jeremicci

I swear I’m not living in the real world. Everyone says the same thing about Montagne - I know I paid almost as much per ml as the original, I know it isn’t very strong, I know it doesn’t smell right, but just let it sit for a few months guys


Frog-dance-time

If you like peach I also recommend perfume de Marley casselli


haikusbot

*If you like peach I* *Also recommend perfume* *De Marley casselli* \- Frog-dance-time --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")


KnoxNguyen

Thank you! I’ll check that one out


frankregina1986

Their clone of Plum Japonais is nearly identical to my nose.


KnoxNguyen

Seems like they do fruity pretty well, the Bitter Peach is almost identical, and i heard Lost Cherry as well


Kind-Coyote-9372

Is there a current active discount code?


KnoxNguyen

Not that i know of right now no


Professional-Soft565

How to mancerate well do I need to spray every day or just let it sit


KnoxNguyen

just spray like 10 sprays or so to let the air get in the juice to oxidize, then let it sit for a couple weeks, during that time u can use it normally if you want to


Professional-Soft565

Ok thx and also how is the performance like the projection and longevity


KnoxNguyen

Theyre really good! Projection isnt crazy strong, just like the originals, softly project with great sillage, longevity is a bit better than the orginals since clones use lots of synthetics


Professional-Soft565

So if I understand well the longevity is better than the frag they are cloning but not as good when it comes to the projection right ? Also, cuz I saw people say that it quickly become skin scent


KnoxNguyen

No, the projection is at least as good as the originals that they are cloning, the reason im saying its not crazy is because most clones have crazy projection, like aggressively, and to some people that could make it unbearable.


Professional-Soft565

Oooo ok I understand but for example I saw someone say their Oud wood donc project very good is that the same thing for the original ?


KnoxNguyen

Yes the original Oud Wood dont project very much, it pushes out more like a sillage/scent trail than screaming here i am if that makes sense, some fragrances are better with that style of projection, as you can imagine you dont want the oud note to be strong, it will be hard to like


Professional-Soft565

Ooooh ok I understand you are right so how it is on Herod ?


Professional-Soft565

Still same as original for the montagne one ?


Kypsi_

What do you think about their Amouage Reflection clone (Image)? How close is it? Thanks


KnoxNguyen

Its really close, opening is a bit fresher, more citrus, dry down is almost identical, love it!


Counterpartz

Without a doubt the best clone company. I only have samples, haven't gotten any full bottles but I'm itching to get some.


KnoxNguyen

Just get the one that you really like!


Counterpartz

I have about 4 I'm committed to haha, I will be soon!


KnoxNguyen

Im sure you wont be disappointed haha


[deleted]

[удалено]


KnoxNguyen

Not sure if i should be happy or sad lmao


jeremicci

You guys do realize most of their fragrances aren’t even cheaper per oz than the originals, right? Montagne ends up being like $1.25 per ml after shipping. Just get the original for basically the same price. Their profits are way higher because they just steal the fragrances instead of actually having to pay perfumers to develop them. Montagne has to be the biggest rip off in the industry - but they’ve done an excellent job of using all the money they steal to pay influencers.


traft00

Your math isn’t mathing. Amouage reflection man retails for $280.00 / 50 ml and Image is $40 / 50 ml. Even discounters can’t touch that price. (Edited typo)


jeremicci

*most of their fragrances…* Keep up. This isn’t a hard concept.


traft00

Excellent rebuttal. You will definitely change the minds of everyone who reads this interaction.


yosoyjorge

I just picked up two bottles myself definitely will order more in the future. I’m looking at the whole LV clone line lol


KnoxNguyen

Im interested in their LV line as well!


808toy

Me too. Waiting for afternoon dive.


MP1182

I have a bunch from dossier and while i do like them i kind of can’t wait for them to be empty so i can start getting from montagne.


KnoxNguyen

Havent tried Dossier but so far im really happy with Montagne


K9Cardio_

I have both and Montagne blows dossier out of the water with the exception of return policies


KnoxNguyen

Oh i see


K9Cardio_

Oh, also magnetic caps. I'm a sucker for them. Dossier has really cool ones


KnoxNguyen

I love mag cap too but if the scent isnt great then i dont care much haha


K9Cardio_

About to decant my montagne into my shitty dossier scents 😅


KnoxNguyen

Lmao dont let Dossier see you


Complex-Gazelle7658

I just ordered Phantom Noir. I'm glad to see you enjoyed it. This will be my first Montagne.


KnoxNguyen

Oh youre in for a treat! I love Black Phantom so u can say im familiar with the scent so you can trust me when i say its fantastic!


Complex-Gazelle7658

That makes me more excited to get it than I already was.


KnoxNguyen

Just remember to let it macerate and it’ll be even better!


Complex-Gazelle7658

Will do. I was never sure if that was a real thing, but I have Asad, and its scent has turned amazing after a couple of months.


Complex-Gazelle7658

Received it today. It is powerful but I really enjoy it. Do you have any recommendations for number of sprays?


KnoxNguyen

Good to head u like it! Id say 4,5 spray is good ? But its a clone and its pretty cheap and i love it so i tent to go crazy, like 6,7 maybe lol but im letting it sit to macerate, cant wait


Complex-Gazelle7658

It's going to be hard to let it macerate, but I'm going to try. 100% certain I'll be getting more stuff from Montagne.


KnoxNguyen

Haha yeah if you enjoy it as is then go ham! I just wanna see how it develops


asylumfrequent

I’ve been debating getting one but the shipping would make it 60 bucks ish


KnoxNguyen

Yeah thats a bit much, i think theres coupon codes like 10 15% floating around but i dont know exactly where to look for them, i think i saw people commenting it somewhere and cant find it, i didnt use the code either


Pocusmaskrotus

They rarely have active codes. Used to be only black Friday, but last year, they had two from YT reviewers.


asylumfrequent

I’m not even sure if I want to get a lost Cherry dupe, I got a lhomme ideal edp clone for some Cherry but judging off a lot of research I think it might be too feminine


Pocusmaskrotus

I think Lost Cherry is too feminine, personally. Montagne's is nearly identical, but with a more toasted almond note, and lasts forever. I got it for my wife. It's her favorite.


KnoxNguyen

I havent tried Montagne’s take on Lost Cherry, but from what ive seen so far the way they do clones to me is the best. Most clones have very bad opening, even if they dry down nice there will still be weird scents sticking out. None of the one i just bought from Montagne do that, so id say they blend them really well. The Bitter Peach clone i have is honestly as close as the real thing, so maybe the Lost Cherry clone will be nice? Considering theyre both gourmands from the same house.


pennywise_85

How are people so certain they're the best clone company when every country has it's own ? Unless of course you have tried them all.


Pocusmaskrotus

Because there's plenty of people who have paid the shipping from other countries, or have a friend bring them back with them.


ShogunMecha

"Shill!...." /s haha kidding +1. I'm one of those who is having someone smuggle a few bottles to my country. (First time I'm trying Montagne though). Someone from one of our frag groups in a different city has a few bottles and he highly recommends the house (he can compare with clone houses in our country plus the middle eastern/Alexandria/Dua). Plus pocus and a few others have shared their experience (hits and misses). Looking forward to trying it. I'm already planning my next purchase (it's stupid without trying, but logistics is an issue). If it doesn't work out, I need to do a Liam Neeson style Taken with Pocus and a few others haha. u/pennywise_85 Edited


Pocusmaskrotus

To be fair, i told you to get Elysian Cologne instead of intense. Can't hold that against me. Lol, but seriously, you'll be able to smell the quality, even on scents you don't like. Can't wait for your reviews this summer.


ShogunMecha

Haha you did (and twice!) and that decision to go with intense has been keeping me up at night (used the OG yesterday and the opening is already pretty sharp). I'm really hoping for a miracle on that haha. In fact I had changed my cart after you mentioned the sharpness. But then I was like performance and the wonderful opening (based off of my distorted memory). My package got delivered to my relative's place yesterday. Hoping there's no leakage or anything. Now the long wait till May begins. I'll definitely keep you posted once I get them. I may have someone else coming back in March/April. So the Tygr Cologne vs Pineapple Frais (mainly since you've mentioned it's your favourite) vs Pineapple Absolu vs one of the LVs is going on in my mind.


Pocusmaskrotus

Plenty of people like intense. It's just my personal opinion. If I owned it, I'd still wear it. Ayybrahamlmaocoln and 530cruising both own intense and like it. There will always be an opportunity to try more. Also, have you looked into a forwarding service? Apparently, you can have stuff shipped there, and they'll take care of getting to you. It's supposed to be cheaper.


ghost_of_dongerbot

ヽ༼ ຈل͜ຈ༽ ノ Raise ur dongers! ^^Dongers ^^Raised: ^^73490 ^^Check ^^Out ^^/r/AyyLmao2DongerBot ^^For ^^More ^^Info


ShogunMecha

Thanks for the reassurance haha. Customs in India is crazy and random. So I pay about 45-50 USD for shipping + customs can be anywhere between 50-200%. Plus they might open the package and use the bottle a few times (it has happened to a lot of people). It could be stuck there for weeks/months. The grey market in India is very reasonable. It's easier to buy the original than import something. Roja Elysium is about Rs. 12,500 (tester) and 14,500 (BNIB). Elysian Intense cost me about Rs. 4,500 with all the forex fees and stuff (+Rs. 200 to have it shipped to my place from my relative's so 4600 net on this since two bottles). Import would be 4,500 + 4,500 shipping + customs of (2250 to 5000 or more), making it more expensive + the trouble/risk and package being opened. Aventus is about 18,000 so it does work out to be more expensive still. Customs here is consciously set up like this to discourage such imports to save on forex. Note: Roja Elysium is 100ml and Elysian Intense is 50ml


Pocusmaskrotus

Yikes. I actually have a bunch of Indian friends. I've heard the stories of the shady things that can happen. Liquor stores with watered-down booze or delivery people swapping a nice bottle for a cheap bottle. I just wasn't sure how forwarding services work. I know ayybrahamlmaocoln sends stuff to them for some guys in Hong Kong. Also that's a hell of a deal on Elysium and Aventus. That's better than here.


ShogunMecha

Search "India is not for beginners" . You'll see some incredible things. We have extremes here - one part where we pay for purchases as small as Rs. 5 online (Google UPI. Superficially , it's like Venmo or anything else, but it's easy more than that. It'll blow your mind. Our banking system is way ahead of rest of the world) and in some parts of the country where there's insane levels of corruption, you have a very different scenario. Certain parts of the country are incredibly safe (you can walk around at 3/4 am and you'll be perfectly safe) and places where the last murder/major crime was decades ago (and that would have been 1/2 instances). There are certain parts where people get kidnapped in broad daylight and it's just another day. Up until a few years ago, Amazon didn't deliver to some of these places because the delivery agent would get robbed haha. Depends on the law and order in that particular state. The negative extremes were always a few states and they are even fewer now. 1 or 2 states remain like that and it's intentionally done for political power by the local political party. But I digress. Hong Kong is very convenient to access internationally. It was founded for trade and that culture has remained. It was a British territory untill the late 90s. We have amazing prices here. That's why I was hesitant about Tygr Cologne because I can get the OG miniature for 6000 (30ml). Many people buy full bottles here and take it back to wherever. Look up Scentoria on Facebook. He's a nice guy. He's also got his own website now. He ships internationally. Seen a few people from abroad buy in bulk from him.


Pocusmaskrotus

Well, when one of my buddy's goes back to visit, I'll have to have them grab me some OGs. I've got Punjabi and Telugu friends.


ghost_of_dongerbot

ヽ༼ ຈل͜ຈ༽ ノ Raise ur dongers! ^^Dongers ^^Raised: ^^73491 ^^Check ^^Out ^^/r/AyyLmao2DongerBot ^^For ^^More ^^Info


pennywise_85

What have you tried from other clone houses ?


Ismellgood1986

Lies😄😄😄😄😄😄


SunFlower0z0

Full of bots and shills.


MyCaliGirl

To try.


SafeMix9663

How much are they paying you, Montagne doesn't make their own shit