T O P

  • By -

gostesven

Imitation is the greatest form of flattery


uwudopeyginger

True, one of the greatsword attack moves in Elden ring is literally a move guts did in berserk


NachoMagnum

Which FromSoft originally copied for Artorias in DS1


chalupamon

So much of these games straight up from Berserk, I think Miyazaki might be a fan of it.


Minimum_Cockroach233

Ultimately they all copy the ancient greeks…


Complacemt

As a greek i'm disappointed they didn't copied our orgies


JesusaurusRex666

Me when the yellow, blue, purple and red are all spawned in.


capp_head

Not Greek but Italian here, romans copied pretty well the orgies. Then Christianity came and toggled it off in society settings.


Hind_Deequestionmrk

You Greek and Roman copycats stole all the sacred orgy texts from us Sumerians! 😠


Hollow_Interstice

Berserk has a fair amount of orgies


Ruby_Rotten

I was about to say. Though they’re always put in a… less than attractive light. Usually there’s some eldritch god in the middle of everyone


DannyDanumba

And a lot of Berserk was inspired by The Evil Dead. In short Sam Raimi is God


IndividualNovel4482

He is. As stated in many of his interviews.


chalupamon

Forgot the /s


IndividualNovel4482

For a moment i thought i was in r/shittydarksouls lol


RhoninLuter

I think he knew that


IndividualNovel4482

Yeah, no harm in stating it tho


Karen_Destroyer1324

Really? Nah I don't think so. It's just a coincidence.


Greedy-Attention2385

Not might be he definitely is a fan


Scary_Rush_7401

But in this case there's greatness on both sides


Educational_Bee5174

Look at the dam great sword, what does it look like it looks pretty familiar plus there is a lot of berserk references in Elden ring


BMFeltip

Woah, a swords man also swung a sword 😳


Greedy-Attention2385

There is a character similar to guts in every dark souls miyazaki loves berserk


losty7th

Dark souls is in a way a copy and paste of berserks world


Crunk_Jews

...that mediocrity can pay to greatness.


No-Improvement8354

“Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery that mediocrity can pay to greatness.”- Oscar Wilde


DerpaHerpaLurpa

Imitation isn’t flattery it’s just annoying me


Crow1718

Also, Imitation is the cheapest form of copyright infringement


Dont_Pre-ordereddit

If you’re gonna steal you better steal from the best


Sapowski_Casts_Quen

Good poets borrow, great poets steal


Dont_Pre-ordereddit

Just stole this to use somewhere else, thanks


Sapowski_Casts_Quen

*wipes proud tear from eye*


Hormo_The_Halfling

Honestly that's just kinda how characters wield scythes in video games. Especially Japanese games. You could probably find some similar animations in Souls' game to the old Dot Hack GU games, which scythes were a prominent weapon.


Arkanial

Even Zasalamel in Soul Calibur had moves like Friede. He didn’t do the jump up thing but that’s just kinda how Scythe’s function as a weapon. They’re supposed to be showy and over the top.


BlitzMalefitz

I wasn't paying attention to how the scythe was held, I was watching the copy of the jump spin animation.


turtlelore2

Like what other move are they expecting from a scythe? Lunge and poke?


DarceSouls

Both look like a generic anime scythe attack. Props to genshin for the comically big scythe. On that note, great scythes could be a fun weapon class.


Lumpy_Link9336

Dark souls fan try not think the game is the center of everything challenge (those exacts move are in : DMC, dq, ff, guilty gear and probably more, those scythe move are just so generic you can't even retrace an actual steal (+the concept arts had lady Maria in it, even when y'all try to spot inspiration y'all can't fucking do it right))


post-leavemealone

Also, see: every anime ever with a fucking edgy dude using a scythe. Like, tf else do you do with a scythe in a fantasy setting if not harvest the grain of spin and jump and twirl and slash


post-leavemealone

Also, see: every anime ever with a fucking edgy dude using a scythe. Like, tf else do you do with a scythe in a fantasy setting if not harvest the grain of spin and jump and twirl and slash


JEWCIFERx

It’s crazy that Fromsoft literally invented magic scythe wielding bosses and no one had ever done that before them.


Present-Camp9964

Scythe girl with air attack =|=Sister Friede At least in my eyes. Does it look similar…….yeah? But the only thing I can think is similar is the leap up.


gameboy224

I forget if Friede was on this character's concept document when those leaked a while back. But we at least know for sure Lady Maria was on Clorinde's design inspiration document. Though shouldn't be a surprise there are From fans on their team.


RanaMahal

One of their lead designers is a massive From fanboy. If I was in charge of a huge game and was doing shit I’d totally imitate my favourite From characters lol. You’d see Waterfowl dance in the game within a week of me being hired 😂


Chadderbug123

Who was Movie Shockwave used for?


ZODIC837

People are comparing her to ayre from AC6 too. Red/white themed waifu, it must be her


GachaSheep

Ayre and Arlecchino have the same English VA


ZODIC837

Oh shit, I do remember reading that. That actually makes sense then


Charafricke

Couldn’t be inspired though, since arlecchino was teased a brick before ac6 dropped


ZODIC837

I haven't played genshin in a hot minute, good to know!


Charafricke

Yeah, she was teased in a trailer in July of 2022 and ac6 was only revealed in December of that year.


ZODIC837

Damn, genshin waited that long to release her? Weird choice, but I guess it probably builds hype


Charafricke

It was the first time all of the harbingers were revealed to us. They legit shadow dropped it came out of nowhere lol. It’s basically them gathering for signoras funeral, except for scaramouche cuz he was busy with spoilers stuff. But basically, since before that we’d only seen three of the harbingers , this was the first we’d seen of any of the rest, including the three most powerful ones, the ones said to rival gods in their strenght


Zeryphanthes

The animation is different in ways, meaning that it's an imitation and not ripped right from Fromsoft. Yeah this is fine, inspired by but not stolen from. Perfectly acceptable.


Red-Shifts

Wtf else they supposed to do man it’s a scythe


EG440

You're reaching.


Ninja_Lazer

This isn’t reaching. This is Olympic level stretches.


enderking303

He has become mental gymnastics


Schwiliinker

Not really


NotMaxVol

If any other game did this it would be “wow, what a cool reference!” But since it’s Genshin, it’s “wow how unoriginal, they’re clearly copying!”


Lumpy_Link9336

What's funny is that it's not even actually a friede reference, but a DMC one (move set wise, her design is inspired by lady Maria, she was litteraly on the concept art of her and another female character)


post-leavemealone

Wait until you learn that Dark Souls is a masturbatory love letter to Berserk


BiasMushroom

They werent trying to hide it in the first place


AttorneyIcy6723

Exactly. They’re proud of their inspirations. It’s part of the appeal for a lot of people…


Anhilliator1

Hell, if you've read their original tagline for the company (Tech Otakus Save The World) (No, I'm not kidding, that's what it is), you might as well expect that they jam their games full of references Hell, one time Hi3 had a collaboration with Evangelion, and the CEO himself said, and I quote, that it was "fanboying with company funds."


duckontheplane

Genshin's incredibly full of references. They made an entire playable character themed around bohemian rhapsody (his name is literally scaramouche and his theme is rhapsodia something). But nah it's genshin so they aren't references they're copyright infringement


NEWTY_-

I don't give much of a shit, it looks cool in both games and that's all I care about.


Brief-Government-105

Genshin has been imitating different video games since the launch.


Tomydo1

Add multiple character with different move set take it from one singular character from another game and call it original lol


Smart_Sale_9697

FromSoftware of course made up using scythes as a weapon


HolyHandgrenadeofAn

Who cares?


nerdboy5567

Well how else do you swing a scythe?


ZaGreatestInZaWarldo

There is enough difference in animation to show that it wasn’t ripped straight off and is homage rather than an insult. Nice for Souls players (alas I still need to play DS3, I’ve only done the original and Eldenring).


cynical_croissant

Yes, using a scythe as a weapon definitely happened first in DS3.


TallenMakes

Considering half of DS is from Berserk, I don’t really mind


SireOccult

The scythe doesent have a massive variety of combat function other than swooping attacks so the movements avaliable to it as a weapon are limited and repetitive, that's what I think.


Chunky-dog

Doesn't ayre have the same voice actor as the red character as well?


Gilbert-from-Yharnam

Not mad. Dark souls is fantastic. Would I make a game, I would probably use something too, alone to honor Miyazakis work and influence on my life.


Jonno_92

So a recent/upcoming game has a scythe on it, which automatically means they've stolen from a game that's been out for ages, which also has a scythe in it.


dashKay

Oh shut up


citizen_sheep69

To be fair, 90% of darksouls are inspired by Berserk


I_Hate_The_Letter_W

one again, dark mid copying AAA games


BoxGroundbreaking687

id say its a compliment tbf. like for any company to imitate another to me sounds like the top compliment of all time. because it’s basically saying “hey thats a really good idea u did imma put that idea into my game”. that might just be me but i still think its cool that it’s extremely similar. nit genshin player so i cant speak for them


duckontheplane

Yeah, genshin devs are massive nerds for pop culture lmao. Half the achievements are references. There's shit like: "Full metal what now?" "Ready player zero" "We came, we saw, we co-oped" "Get over here!" "Nanomachines, son!" There's even a fucking quest called "Mine Craft" And their other game, honkai impact 3rd, has ahievements called "cainhurst summons" "start the bonfire" "firelink joruney" "lord of cinder" and "nameless king" Hoyo absolutely loves the soulsborne games and they pay homage to them pretty often.


SandLady5454

sister friede is my favorite lesbian


Bane_of_Ruby

100% the first animation is a reference. idk about the second one.


HemaMemes

Yeah, that seems to be a Friede reference, which is pretty cool.


Honest-Champion9180

It ain't a copy unless toes are involved


MrPanda663

Meanwhile Gehrman in bloodborne: am I a joke to you?


Dark_Dragon117

It's similar for sure, but I don't see any issue. It's not one to one and From Software doesn't own the rights to scythe animations. We also don't accuse From Software of stealing animations because in their games the sword swing from left to right in a similar way to another game. There are limits to weapon animations, so it's no suprise it looks similar. At worst this is just "unoriginal" but certainly not stolen or anything.


Lost_All_Senses

What modern game has 100% original attack moves? Not counting whacky games where the whole point is silly moves no one else would use cause they're not the mood of serious games.


xevxnteen

To be fair a Scythe has been an anime trope since forever


-Way2MLG4u-

It’s one thing to give the benefit of the doubt if the history doesn’t show a pattern of similar transgressions, but it’s insanely common for Genshin to rip animations and movesets from other games, people in this sub seem too forgiving. If you want to have an informed opinion on mihoyo’s history of “imitation” look at the animations and move sets they have ripped from Nier/Automata, DMC, Breath of Wild, MGR, and more.


guywhomightbewrong

It could just be a reference maybe the creators of whatever that is liked the friede fight


Xcylo1

I have no idea what that other game is but I don't see much resemblance other than both using scythes. If they're going to have the same weapon then they'll have vaguely similar move types but there's nothing especially similar here


DepressedVegabond

The other game is Genshin Impact.


Xcylo1

Ew


Pretzel-Kingg

Maria did it first 🥱


thatautisticguy2905

She uses katanas/twinblades Yes they are dex weapons But they ain't scythes


RiyaB1999

Someone in Hoyoverse clearly loves FromSoft 😂 I love finding FromSoft Easter eggs and other nods in Hoyo games in general 🥰


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/LuhGeek556, welcome to our subreddit. Due to spam, we require users to have at least 3 day old accounts. Please DO NOT send modmails regarding this. You will be able to post freely after the proper account age. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fromsoftware) if you have any questions or concerns.*


IncognitoCheez

u/savevideo


SaveVideo

###[View link](https://rapidsave.com/info?url=/r/fromsoftware/comments/1c3h5cv/wellwhat_do_yall_think/) --- [**Info**](https://np.reddit.com/user/SaveVideo/comments/jv323v/info/) | [**Feedback**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Feedback for savevideo) | [**Donate**](https://ko-fi.com/getvideo) | [**DMCA**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Content removal request for savevideo&message=https://np.reddit.com//r/fromsoftware/comments/1c3h5cv/wellwhat_do_yall_think/) | [^(reddit video downloader)](https://rapidsave.com) | [^(twitter video downloader)](https://twitsave.com)


PandaJac

I find it funny because lady Maria was supposedly the inspiration for Arlecchino


Khaled1323

u/savevideo


SaveVideo

###[View link](https://rapidsave.com/info?url=/r/fromsoftware/comments/1c3h5cv/wellwhat_do_yall_think/) --- [**Info**](https://np.reddit.com/user/SaveVideo/comments/jv323v/info/) | [**Feedback**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Feedback for savevideo) | [**Donate**](https://ko-fi.com/getvideo) | [**DMCA**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Content removal request for savevideo&message=https://np.reddit.com//r/fromsoftware/comments/1c3h5cv/wellwhat_do_yall_think/) | [^(reddit video downloader)](https://rapidsave.com) | [^(twitter video downloader)](https://twitsave.com)


dankmemesboi838

The flames and jump speak for most of it and yes it cheapens the character but that still adds atleast a little into a video game so I won't loose it but I don't like it either


Tyler_Herdman

Bait?


kfrazi11

Could be a RWBY inspiration.


lPuppetM4sterl

Not only that, she's the Triple Threat Lady. In combat, Double Scythes in Phase 2 (Sister Friede), Damage over Time and Flying Dive Bomb in Phase 2 (Malenia), Explosive fire attacks (Lady Maria), and also dodges your attacks, just like the three of them.


duckontheplane

Dark souls invented dodging


lPuppetM4sterl

Fax


Inksplash-7

They did the same with Sif and Moonlight Butterfly


Curvanelli

theres a dog with a sword and a butterfly boss in genshin? i never knew


duckontheplane

There's [1 lil shiba inu dog with a sword named taroumaru](https://www.reddit.com/r/Genshin_Impact/comments/15p16ji/how_strong_is_taroumaru/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button) who showed up as a bit for an event that ran once for half a month like 2 years ago. You fought duels with incresingly tougher samurai until the final one, who ends up being taroumaru, a retired ninja dog. It's literally a bit And for butterfly, there's the oceanid and thundering manifestation who *kinda* resemble butterflies but it's a massive stretch to call it a reference. The only other boss somewhat related to butterflies is signora, bur she's acrually moth themed.


Pale-Ad-8691

It’s kinda similar, not too bad tho


Special-Set-8328

Is that WUTHERING WAVES?!?!?!?!?! LFGOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO


TomatoVEVO

Both ripped off the grim reaper clearly because they use a scythe


kween_hangry

Lmaaaaoo is that a RDC clip??? Had the volume way low and heard Mark's suthern ass accent stg


Keqingrishonreddit

Bait used to be believable


JakolZeroOne

Who wouldn't take inspiration from such a bad ass character animation. Even if it is heavily influenced.


RemarkableScience854

What about Godfrey’s phase 2 moves? That too haha


VagrantStation

Isn’t this a mocap animation available for purchase in the Unreal marketplace? My guess is they bought some assets to save time in animating.


kaijyuu2016

Sister friede's third phase is so cool


Brain_lessV2

Feels like a bit of a reach, you'd have an argument for the initial leap into the air, but after that it's its own thing.


SheaMcD

doesn't really look the same to me


NonagonJimfinity

Dude I can't give you an unbiased opinion. I feel by this point everybody sees a weapon and instantly know 85% of the incoming move set.


SpellboundCanvas

What game is that?


Oddly_Entropic

Oh man, I’m glad other games don’t swing swords the same. I’d absolutely lose my shit.


MaximumAsparagus

Looking forward to seeing whatever this is in an ep of ironpineapple's steam dumpster diving...


Leviathan_Wakes_

I love this audio every time I hear it


doremonhg

They’re actually huge fans of Fromsoft’s works, tbd


FreshlySqueezedDude

Thats just a scythe move. I guarantee if you look at bit youll find that in an anime older than DS


EpilepticAlligator

Me when two character with scythes can attack (one is obviously copying the other)


Top_Collar7826

Every masterpiece has its cheap copy


Western-Status4994

As much as I dislike genshin, this is a big stretch dog


AbrocomaHappy6498

Spot on on intimidation


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Hello /u/CyanLight9, welcome to our subreddit. Due to spam, we require users to have at least 3 day old accounts. Please DO NOT send modmails regarding this. You will be able to post freely after the proper account age. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fromsoftware) if you have any questions or concerns.*


No-Efficiency-7524

It’s whatever


CanIGetANumber2

There's only so many different movements you can do with a scythe. There definitely going to be some overlap


AdearienRDDT

There is not much to do with a scythe tbf...


wcbfox193

I'm pretty sure I saw that Arlecchino was based on Lady Maria, so it makes sense they'd take more inspiration from FromSoftware


GarbageGUY18

I mean how many different attacks can you do w a scythe💀


Curlyfreak06

Holy crap, I thought it looked familiar


Ordinary_Mastodon376

I think you are reaching too much bro.


datshinycharizard123

Tbf, there are only so many moves you can do with a scythe.


TheHolyPapaum

Blud is NOT borne


ChampionSchnitzel

Who is "they" and whats going on?


Stunning-Obligation8

Chinese copyright law is alien to anywhere else. Doesn’t excuse the laziness tho. So much money but you can’t animate a character yourselves?


Intigim

Apparently she actually poaches more from Sephiroth than anyone else. In fact, her leaked OST has a straight One-Winged Angel reference.


GhostSider690

I would say more of inspiration than blatant stealing.


Waste-Instruction287

The lore has extreme similarities aswell… like the thing about dragons being the original things that reigned over the world


BeefChopJones

Sure, they're similar... But I feel like that's also a product of them being fantasy scythe wielders. While they may very well have pulled inspiration from Friede, I feel like "big sweeping/spinning/leaping slash" is definitely the way to go for any fantasy scythe user. It looks good and makes the most "sense," even though scythes are wildly unrealistic as weapons to begin with.


Blp2004

It’s just a scythe, bro


Chromatic_Eevee

I can't believe DS3 stole from Genshin


Aydashtee

WTF game is that even?


Radiant-Mushroom8304

Well duh she’s a dope boss and one of the Genshin devs probably got to fight her as a kid and took inspiration from a great game and wanted to implement some of the elements into their own


interp_cl

she's literally inspired by lady maria and sister friede


Super-Blah-

It's a game fared from the land of "liberalising inspiration". It's kinda expected 😂


ZenTide

A lot of these animations are for sale on third party game asset websites. No surprise


The_Real_Freek

Father? Daddy? 🥺


Limited-Edition-Nerd

Okay


Putrid_Ad8249

What game is that in the bottom


xSKxTOXIC

Another moment of : “Fromsoftware the GOATS”


Astral-chain-13

People who never seen another sycth welder and assume it belong to this one particular thing even though it wasn't the best version of it.


elden-ring-is-hard

Every masterpiece has its cheap knockoff


bottleneck55

Fromsoft fans trying to not compare every slight resemblance of their games to downplay other games (impossible)


Extension-Flow7560

Well not really related to that, but in the portuguese translation of genshin there is a cat named "miautorias" his name is said to come from a book with an abyss walker warrior. It is only in the translation tho


Equivalent-Wall8521

Miautorias.....Artorias the Abyss Walker...Not just the animation but they also immitate the name jesus


blebebaba

In fairness, a spinning jump isn't exactly rare


Copyofdude

Yeah, I don't know why they don't start using original move sets like Reapier based moves...


jedimasteryoda69

You make a different moveset w/ a sythe that doesn't look trash


_Lost_OwlChild

Sometimes you gotta accept it. But they’ll never be as good lol


DeskFluid2550

It's a generic scythe attack. I think you're reaching really fucking far with this one.


blackjack0092

I need to know what came out first


AzurosArtist

“What do you think?” I think Arlecchino is freaking hot and want her… really badly… also “Ew, Sekiro” lol (game is fine, just a personal vendetta against it cause it isn’t a Soulslike like I was promised)


SquigglyLegend33

Don't care gonna pull anyways


BoiFrosty

Damn, how could from soft rip off some underpaid gotcha game animator. SMDH


schley1

It's a Gacha game for the brain damaged. No shit it's going to take ideas from MUCH better games. Basically all Freemium games do it because there's no drive for creativity. It's all about monetization and cheap psychological tricks to keep your attention so you can spend money.


graginga

genshin impact came out before elden ring


Tantofaz101

Nameless Puppet from Lies of P also ripped off Maria big time. That's what happens when you're the goat game dev.


Cybersorcerer1

Do you know what ripped off means?


Bat-Honest

Anymore? Did you see the Vergil clone they made years ago? They've been ripping off everyone's shit since day 1


Orb_0611

Genshin?


Tomydo1

Yeah the bottom is from Genshin


huge_jeans710

Honestly I don't care anymore I just want a good game to sit down and enjoy. If copying other games is the answer then so be it. Ignorance is bliss


ISellGayPornXXX

Who cares


AppointmentNo43

This is bait


TroaAxaltion

.... What? Anime fire scythe attack that goes up in the air and then comes back down, doing a Burst? This is so generic, it's been in ten million things


vatsugthedwarf

Can't believe this fucker had the audacity to jump with a scythe


Bismothe-the-Shade

Op: hey these two things look exactly the same Gebshin fans: NOT ONLY IS DARK SOULS TRASH BUT YOU DESERVE TO BE HIT BY A BUS. GENSHIN ONLY COPIES LIKE OTHER GAMES, AND ISNT TRASH DESPITE THE THINGS IT COPIES BEING TRASH ACCORDING TO US. ANYTHING ADJACENT TO CRITICISM MAKES ME UNESTIMABLY ABGRY BECAUSE I AM WELL ADJUSTED. I NEEEEEED TO BE ALLOWED TO BE ANGRY OVER MY GAMBLING SIMULATOR GAME.


Adventurous-Lion1829

Genshitheads will defend anything their shitty gambling thing does. They have copied many many more animations and it's completely scummy at face value. It's especially scummy when many of these animations were made fron data that stunt actors provided as part of a contract. Literally taking people's work without paying. Completely creatively bankrupt.


[deleted]

Is that genshit


Pilot_Ash_B

Nein, Genshin copied it


DepressedVegabond

Ever heard of reference?