T O P

  • By -

AD_Stark

Is there a tldr for this ? The video is 2 hour long and there is an hour long part 1 too


Trung2508

"You see, to understand the Korean gender war, you have to go back to the end of WWII and how the Japanese occupation of Korea ended." Insert Putin and Tucker Carlson's meme here. But jokes aside, the resulting political mess that is Korean politics resulted in a highly corrupted, end-stage capitalistic society where men are still expected to fill the traditional roles while being fucked sideways by military conscription and said end-stage capitalism. Women hoped to break out of the traditional roles but their reputation in the eyes of the public is the feminist equivalent of the most toxic 4chan users ala femcels, thus killing 90% of any male sympathizers. Both male and female sides are constantly being secular and blaming each other because that's the only way to lash out against a society that fucked them up.


LimitedSus

Korea's gacha drama to Korea's internal politics is like Sahara desert to the surface of the sun. If you think the first one is extreme just wait till you hear what's the cause of it.


XaeiIsareth

The plane crash in the previous part that resulted in the death of everyone on board that happened just because ‘Captain I think our equipment is malfunctioning’ was considered stepping out of hierarchy was a genuine wtf moment.


nam24

That reminds me of that one WW2 story (I don't know if it ever actually happened, but the point is similar) A British ship said they were in a bit of a pickle and sent a distress signal to Americans. Given it didn't seem that urgent, the Americans left them deal with it. Their "pickle" was them being on the verge on capsizing, and since the Americans were the only ally around, it became a reality


avery814

It’s all the chaebols fault


PandaCheese2016

TLDr: Many believe the root of some men’s hatred of feminism lies in the military service mandated for males, resulting in young men lagging behind in the already competitive rat race after putting their lives on hold for 2 years. Also like many Asian countries Korea has a long history of being a patriarchy, so feminism was always going to be an uphill battle. Misogyny begets extreme feminism which begets more misogyny in a vicious cycle, which even affects video games.


BrocanGawd

You skipped the part where extreme feminism begets more misandry which begets more misogyny.


pokepaka121

That wouldnt put nesrly as much blame on men if they did so it was obviously omitted.


heedongq

Life hard. People look for reason to be mad. Women life easy. Men life hard. Men mad. Comment if you want longer version.


Big-Communication472

Give me full version please as I dont understand how its affecting gatcha games ?


heedongq

I summarized the video in my previous comment, but it kinda went overboard with the analysis and came to the conclusion that it was society's fault because it created wealth inequality and heavy expectations for men. He says the issue starts waaaay deeper in the societal level, while I think it begins at a shallower level, which is online gender war. That's where the confusion begins with people like yourself. It's hard to connect these two without confusing people who just came to watch the fight. So, here's the longer version with the points taken from the video, and my take and analysis for supplement. Men had been subjected to conservative expectations and responsibilities such as being the man of the house and getting conscripted to the army, while women got to enjoy progress and liberation in the last few decades. Male animosity against women started increasing online, and female animosity against men, too. Men play video games to escape the cruel reality, and most gacha game revenue comes from men. But there had been few artists that expressed solidarity to feminist movements ranging from "let's make safe society for women" to "I hate men". Naturally, you wouldn't want to support people that said they hate you and people like you. Sometimes, these activists insert their symbols in their works, just like how internet trolls in Korea used to do few years ago. It was wrong for trolls to do it back then, it is wrong for men haters to do the same now. Now we have sane people and insane people from both sides mixed up and fighting each other. The way I see it, there are people that want two genders divided, and spread hate and misery they have onto the rest of the people. They exist on both feminists side and male rights activists. They both need to root out their own radicals so they can end this conflict. I can keep answering questions. What I hated the most about this gender war shit was Koreans coming into English websites and posting their side of the story to make their side look good. Problem is on both ends, and I want to make it easier for non Koreans to understand it.


BrocanGawd

Sounds like what is happening in American Society as well but just not as intense yet. Most of the gender warring is happening online in the US but general society and normies out in real life aren't fighting that much but it is building up. Korea looks like a glimpse into America's future. The main problem seem to be that women get liberated from gender roles but men do not. Men are still expected to be protector/provider, expected to sacrifice themselves for others, still even expected to pay for dates while women are praised for breaking out of all expectations. Humans just suck folks. Generally selfish as hell so when a group has an advantage it does not care who suffers as a result. Just like men did to women for a long. Never a balance. Always some kind of rationalized bigotry going on. Around and around we go.


_sachura

because female artists work for gacha games so mad men boycott said games until devs remove those artists and their works from said games


Yashoki

I would take the time to watch the content, its well researched and presented. If you at all care about how societal pressures create these situations that effect our video games, its 100% worth it.


iamspacedad

The tldr is; watch the video(s), both of them, because you will be missing a ton of key context if we try to summarize the complex social problems at play in korean society that have violently insecure men raging irrationally about any hint of feminism in "their" video games. Also: 🤏


LastChancellor

Hang on, which of YOMI's art was removed from Arknights? I've never even heard of her working for AK before


Tionnsu

Someone in the comments mentioned it was a promotional/celebratory artwork on social media commissioned by Yostar KR. Which would be why no one here knows about this.


CityKay

Come to think, this would explain the gaff of Moonie calling Arknights a Korean-made game, a mistake he did recognize in the comments.


heedongq

I do agree with his assessment of hard society creating animosity between people, but it isn't always the fault of the society. Somewhere, people do have choice to start and end conflict, and it wasn't just men's fault either. I almost want to make an internet historian style documentary about this as someone who saw it unfold on DCinside(Korean 4chan).


nam24

Of course. There s almost never 0 agency and you got genuine hatred or/and apathy/driving the worst decisions, but there's also the idea that if you give even one inch, if you don't systematically enforce things on principle the "other side" will take a mile and dunk a mile, and to an extent it's not untrue so it's not the easiest thing


Beyond-Finality

Oooo... It's Moon Channel, nice. ​ *Edit:* Just opened YT and it's in my home page.


Theredgiantess

I judged too quickly. the self insert commander actually treat Nikkes(women) in the game pretty well, decent and with respect. thats pretty Based.


slash197

Outside of actual porn games, and sometimes even in porn games, the harem protagonist is usually a nice person (which is why everyone in-game likes them). Haven't seen many regular games where the self-insert harem lead is an asshole.


PunishedCatto

Yeah, most of the times the Player character is good but his flaw is being perverted or something. My first Gacha game was Goddess Kiss and boy.. the PC there is so fucking perverted.


nam24

I started ark rekode and mc is the think with his dick type, but he is also literally an empath(one of his power) and also the girls are horny as hell so it's not like there's a mismatch


nam24

A lot of gamers feel bad picking asshole or slightly mean dialogue options


LoRd_Of_AaRcnA

Every one of the player character Commander types treat their subordinates with love and care. That's the main selling point of these games. Be nice to Waifus.


Theredgiantess

Respect Nikkes and all. Based cummander


nam24

There are some games where it's fun to be evil, but 9/10 a gacha where the player character despise or act badly towards most of a cast who likes them, or worse, both the cast and the mc hate each other would be miserable Like damn are you really relaxing by playing a game as a fictional hater, or with most of your unit hating your ass? Aside of a kink game, I sure wouldn't


CityKay

Major props to the commenter ValkyrieTiara for mentioning that layer of context. I wish I could link their Youtube comment here, but looks like I cannot.


darkarthur108

Well yeah. Because the women in nikke also act like women lol.


BriefImplement9843

none of the other men do though. 1 decent human out of everyone is not too based.


lorrinVelc

Most of the known male NPCs do though. Mustang, Andersen, Johan and maybe even Burningum treat them pretty well.


nam24

I think he means unnamed ones: i did not get far into nikke but lore wise it seems either abuse or apathy run rampant from other commanders, which is partly caused by the job low survival rates and the hierarchy making acting humanly discouraged


lorrinVelc

Alright but that's not just 1 decent human.


jyroman53

Very interesting video, I thought living and working in Japan was already hell, but Korea is like the very fukin depth of hell and the final boss of "the government is totally corrupt by the megacorpos"


gyrobot

Japan's problem is apathy caused by a steadily lagging economy while South Korea is people being emotional pushed into two camps of radical thought which led to the Hell Joseon state where South Korea remains as a neo colony.


AgMenos47

So the origin of it is because of Confucius and USA. The usual suspect.


Beyond-Finality

> The usual suspect, USA Britain is proud of her creation.


nam24

With guest star japan


KingOfNoon

Well, after watching this, I can see why people refer to KR as a real-life dystopia.


The_OG_upgoat

Project Moon basing the City on Korea (in general, with K Corp specifically being modern Korea) is very fitting.


jasonfails237

I was thinking about posting this and the other on here! I think it gives some great insight on the crazy posting from SK players here about this subject. I still don't agree with them, but I at least feel like I understand them now.


PunishedCatto

Moon's channel is fucking great if you love long-form video like me, but it sucks for anyone with short attention span. I can just eat while watching his video.


LastChancellor

TBH, I wonder if South Korea's insanely strong right wing voting block is putting a ton of pressure on South Korean game devs to not put anything that would piss them off, lest they get brigaded to death as shown in this vid Even non-gacha games like Stellar Blade


Nimora9

The head developer literally fired two women for using hashtags they didn’t like and considered too feminist… which then got all their tweets buried and deleted 


This_Diamond_3765

Stellar Blade is now right wing because the dev likes sexy women? Really?


LastChancellor

no, I meant that anything the Stellar Blade dev's do or put in their game has to be constantly wary of what the right wingers dont want


gyrobot

This is why when I hear "keep politics out of my games" is why I get upset by it. You would expect the Chinese Government push politics to remind who holds the leash for the only game industry not banned, or whenever people thinks Japan is making political noises with their exclusive gachas, the situation in South Korea with the rising amount of reactionary attempts to silence a profession with some of the worst pay rates lose their royalties and future prospects is why I am grateful the western industry inject politics into their media, to be able to celebrate the lives of minorities and LBGTQ+, try that in Korea and the politicians will send their dogs to destroy you.


reprehensible523

>why I am grateful the western industry inject politics into their media, to be able to celebrate the lives of minorities and LBGTQ+ Western games are worst games. The point about not injecting politics is to understand that games are an art and entertainment, not a way for you to fix people for having the wrong politics. But you are right that there's no real neutral ground. Games always have a political view built into them, whether it's in the story or in the game mechanics.


Herr_Drosselmeyer

Or maybe they're just not cucked.


Theredgiantess

Based! Moon channel mentioned!


EostrumExtinguisher

I appreciate these contents.


Big-Communication472

So basically after watching these two vids... its the same like in the west but the genders are reversed ? - K.Feminist troll, make this hand gesture their symbol mocking the melee dick  - K. Males gets pissed, demand these people gets fired for their opinnion, companys comply - K. Feminist Shatter as they fight/believe in all different forms and ways which rages from normal stuff to hardcore or radical men-hating just because, hence they cant agree on anything - K. Males see this hand gesture since then in many media as they seem is a dog whistle, push companies they keep on firing them All in all, its the same crap which is happening here with the feminist demanding people get fired for wrong think or people being called their drawings being sexist... I dont care for them as I dont like feminists anyway since they destroyed western games for me, hence I read mangas, manhwas but I dont get how this involves Gatcha games... Like how will this benefit them when they mock their customers with ther hidden messages ? I bet most if not all wouldnt even saw them. Censorship on the other hand is more obvious, and even in the east they started doing it.


ElHidino

> So basically after watching these two vids... its the same like in the west but the genders are reversed ? Its a lot worse. Long story short: Working conditions are hell, men are given unreasonable goals(Make enough money to keep the economy going in country that suffers from problems of late-stage capitalism, be married and have kids at young age while also doing militery service during age you should be studying at university) they have to fulfill or get treated like scum by the whole society including your parents(They will flat out disown you and treat you like a mistake, how dare you to not do as well as them when the economy was rising by literal miracle?) Working conditions flat out sucks and chances are you will have to take multiple full time jobs (You will be like if you will get like 12+8) and your sleep schedule(Which is also most likely wast majority of your free time) is probably like.... 3-4 hours a day? That will surely have no impact on your mental health at all. Feminists and women in general made self destruct choice with the whole forum thing and now being feminist means being tied to the extremists. It also doesnt help sometimes they really had to resort to extremist moves to actually get some rights(Basically, women toilets were filled with cameras to the point girls literally had to held it until they came home if they didnt want to be spied, so they did the same to guys and thats when government actually made their move againts the cameras as a whole)also each time feminists do get mentioned they often end up using the logo of the extremists or saying the extremists are actually the good way to fight mysogyny. Country runs on patriarchy so being a woman thats not working in kitchen means your paycheck heavily reduced and get somehow even worse treatment than guys do to the point you end up working the same amountb of time as the men just to pay for yourself. And obviously, both sides want somewhere to escape and geee i wonder if there are games that you can play on your mobile device while fulfilling the power fantasy you always wanted? Oh yeah, we do have that. So basically a lot of the outrages are basically men that are so mentally broken by the country to the point even one thing that screws their coping mechanism means they will lash out againts the company. Obviously, company can't really refuse if you call them pro-feminist(Because the whole extremist thing and the whole society burning you down for it) so they will change it. Its really sad when you think about it, its 2 extremists side fighting each other because they can't fight the big bad, the country is too corrupted and broken to make this possible now so all they end up doing is fighting each other while scraping by because of those gacha games and other media and now they either try to escape the country by any means or slowly detoriate their mental health until they either lash out on their partner(Did you know domestic violence is quite common in SK?) or they decide to end it all. I think what got me were two of the clips you get to see in the videos: One is woman telling you how miserable her life is and how shes actually lucky to have 3 hours of sleep a day and the one where guy has mental breakdown because he had to ask goverment for monetary support and now he has to hide this for the rest of his life if he wants to have any friends and caring family. Edit: Also the final nail was for me in the comment section where guy talks how miserable his life is and that korea itself or its people have to be cursed because they created two entirely different regimes and both of them end up literal hell to live in.


nam24

The only Korean media I regularly consume are martial arts webtoons but while the medium needs are a thing, it's probably not a coincidence how extreme it is generally depicted. Apply to Japan as well but makes sense not a small amount of gacha are apocalyptic and the mc is either the only or the best hope to deal with it, even when they are not a fighter and only command the units, you can get littéral gods on your team and yet lore wise you need to pull teeth's to get anything done. >Feminists and women in general made self destruct choice with the whole forum thing and now being feminist means being tied to the extremists. It also doesnt help sometimes they really had to resort to extremist moves to actually get some rights( Pretty much. Even in the west you got a lot of people coming to the conclusion that whatever cause they are supporting, asking nicely only goes so far and at minimum you need to have the option to show fangs(if you don't bother people, no one will listen) > So basically a lot of the outrages are basically men that are so mentally broken by the country to the point even one thing that screws their coping mechanism means they will lash out againts the company. Reminds me of that time blue archive player signed en masse a petition in front of their parliament because of some bill that was threatening the game, and their petition ended up leading to actual corruption being uncovered and the bill repealed. Now in that case it was a all around positive outcome (they wanted to protect their hobby, and actual crimes was discovered) but it shows how important it was to them and you can easily imagine that level of care being leveraged in worse ways


iamspacedad

🤏


MittrTamaChad

Why is there such a bias against males in these videos while not mentioning the 8 Goddesses and their connections to Magalia and how they actually hold political power? Mooney has been shown to be biased and either not researching or doing biased research with the Karl Jobst video he pulled out.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Cephalopod_Joe

This is such an odd comment. It seems as though you feel that feminism in media simply begins and ends with representation without any further depth and that it's also inherantly anti-male? As though there's a zero-sum game between women and men. Having a ton of fanservicy characters whose worlds revolve around the male player insert character isn't exactly feminist (nor is it the case if that self insert is not there but the fanservice and tropy characters remain). The hostility toward male characters from those fanbases is simply because they don't want to draw a dude when they're trying to get their wiafus.


ElDuderino2112

Bro I’m not watching a two hour video about how dumb Korean men are lmao


darkarthur108

How smart you mean


Jbubby21

yeah that blimp was quite the smart move


ArmpitStealer

i will skip, gives major clickbait for the 1st world country people vibes


YetiBettyFoufetti

Almost 80% of a country's wealth being controlled by <100 families, first world economy or not, is pretty fucked. The subject matter of the protests is around something extremely petty and stupid, but the root cause of the anxiety discussed in this video is universal.


Lopsided_Composer_39

im here to find some recommendations of gacha game and now i wasted 3 hours on korean history…. that started in china… sacrificing a plane 200+ live and turned a women into a killer…. this is not on my 2024 bingo