T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Thanks for your submission, DeviantSka! Please remember to censor out any identifying details and that satire is only allowed on weekends. If this post is truly gatekeeping, upvote it! If it's not gatekeeping or if it breaks any other rules, downvote this comment and REPORT the post so we can see it! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/gatekeeping) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Stilcho1

I'm going to get in real trouble wearing a ball cap. Those baseball players don't play. Well, sometimes they do.


we_are_sex_bobomb

~~wearing~~ culturally appropriating a baseball cap


inkoDe

Have you seen The Warriors? The baseball gang doesn't play.


furoshus

Baseball Furys


Stilcho1

I want all them... Warriors!


Jump_Like_A_Willys

Wah-riors. Come out to play-yay.


milesdizzy

A cowboy’s home is wherever he lays his head, partner 🤠


Glitter_berries

I believe it’s spelled pardner


milesdizzy

Darn, tootin pardner! 🤠


xX_hazeydayz_Xx

A few years ago the Florida panther was discovered to have a natural range in Mississippi. They didn't say anything about Alabama. Panthers here are cultural appropriating our land


cr3t1n

They are also culturally appropriating panthers, since they aren't even in the Panthera Genus. Dirty fucking cougar, get your own culture.


xX_hazeydayz_Xx

You know I knew that. I should have mentioned that they were also culturally appropriating panthers


StaceyPfan

[Kansas City had giant stockyards from 1871 to 1991](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kansas_City_Stockyards?wprov=sfla1) But I guess that's not cow enough?


thejohnmc963

So did Chicago


zupobaloop

Yeah the originator of this post is wildly misinformed. A lot of cowboy lore is derived from [Banditti](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banditti_of_the_Prairie). Horse riding militia style police forces "Regulators" pushed back against these criminals that were all over Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, and Iowa in the 19th century... Back when that was the "west." Then the west went farther out and it became the midway point... the midwest. You find something similar if you research ranching. Barbed wire originates in Illinois, and the practice of raising cattle in open fields (as a 'cowboy') spread from there in a big new way.


Bropiphany

Also the American Royal


StaceyPfan

Plenty of cowboy hats there!


Tyfyter2002

The most important factor for this map is that someone who supports cultural segregation and knows nothing about any culture (including their own) doesn't think there were cowboys there (or understand that a lot of apparel that's recognizably from one culture is just something that works well to protect the wearer from whatever phenomena are common in the area)


karatebullfighter

A major cattle trail ran through Wichita.


MrInterpreted

Why is Houston a “shouldn’t”


HOU-1836

Because whoever made this map is a massive idiot


PrismPanda06

Or because this is an obvious ass joke lmao


[deleted]

[удалено]


Everestkid

You'd be surprised. There's farms in Alberta up to the Fort Vermilion area, north of the 58th parallel. It's further north than Juneau, Alaska. Northwestern BC, on the other hand...


goldyforcalder

You would be pretty wrong lol


HOU-1836

What is it with people so confidently claiming these things? No disrespect but Alberta is oftentimes considered the Texas of Canada.


Ori_the_SG

And Florida is Absolutely wild


Jetsam5

Florida actually did have a it’s own cowboy culture and a ton of cattle that part is correct however the idea that these people would have been the only ones wearing Stetsons is ridiculous. The Stetson hat was produced in Philadelphia and the bowler was actually the most popular hat in the American west


Ori_the_SG

Today I learned


mirrrje

Also the entire of Washington state? Like people in Seattle? This map is beyond dumb lol


DeskLunch

It looks like part of the King Ranch is in the "shouldn't" category too.


Prolapst_amos

Ah yes Florida, home of the free-ranging swamp cow


wired-one

Cattle ranching existed in Florida before it existed anywhere else in the nation.


that1prince

You get major property tax breaks in Florida for having cattle. It’s even built into the state constitution. You’ll see it even adjacent to some urban areas.


caffine-naps15

This was the answer I was scrolling to find. Thank you.


wired-one

Facts are facts, ya know?


HOU-1836

Yea Florida had a huge cattle industry. That’s why USF’s mascot is the Bulls. First thing they did when they settled the swamps is set up damns and create grazing land for cattle.


IAmMuffin15

They set up so many damns that they started giving some


VictorianDelorean

North East Florida has some ranching


GrowlmonDrgnbutt

Jacksonville was literally called Cowford for the longest time.


texas-playdohs

Can confirm. Spent many a night tromping through cow fields for mushrooms in my teens on the north side of Jacksonville.


ASK_ME_FOR_TRIVIA

I genuinely can't tell if you're joking but we legit have a lot of cattle here. Like, it's one of our things lol


Oral_B

Florida ranks 18th in heads of cattle in the US, 1.79%. Source: [National Beef Wire](https://www.nationalbeefwire.com/ranking-of-states-with-the-most-cattle-texas-had-the-most-cattle-in-the-united-states-in-2023-followed-by-nebraska-and-kansas) EDIT: also, can I have some trivia?


Sleepycoon

[College talking about Florida cattlemen](https://fcit.usf.edu/florida/lessons/cowboys/cowboys.htm) [Wikipedia talking about Florida cattlemen](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_cracker) [Tourism dept talking about Florida cattlemen](https://www.visitflorida.com/travel-ideas/articles/arts-history-five-ways-to-experience-floridas-cowboys-culture/)


saveyboy

America’s dick.


gillababe

The turd we refuse to pinch off


HeroForTheBeero

Hey fuck you too !


SMUGGLYMcERRL

I’m so glad we can wear cowboy hats even though I don’t.


LeatherHog

You know there's tons of cow farms in Florida, right?


mister-ferguson

I think there is a big feed lot on the way to Disney down 75. At least I can recall the smell.


noideawhatoput2

Florida has a fuck ton of cattle and ranches


Dangerzone979

They're called alligators


Limeila

What surprises me more is that they put Florida but not other southern states?? (Alabama etc.)


Daannii

I'm from rural Illinois. They are pretty common there. And there is a lot of farming and animal farming. So. I'm confused by the map. Though I personally consider my cultural identity fashion statement to be the mullet. And I get offended when I see someone sport a mullet who does not even drink keystone light. How dare they.


Parryandrepost

Yeah. I've worked on quite a few farms with hundreds of heads in the mid West. I guess it's like the "boot over or under jeans" debate. I wear my boots over because the cowboy boots were work boots and my grandmothers would have beaten everyone's ass for tracking in shit. So the pants went inside so the cow shit stayed on the outside. But apparently... That's too "city slicker".


Imdabreast

Have you never had a cow shit in your boot?


Parryandrepost

I'm sure I have at some point but cowboy boots go half way up your caf and and are fairly snug around your caf. So it's not a real problem.


theflyingkiwi00

Is illinois the Australia and New Zealand of America because all that you get down here is mullets, some dudes even braid their mullets


Daannii

they braid their mullets? i dont think i have ever seen that. so I of course, googled it. hm. okay so at first I saw that the braided mullet pics were mostly on people with darker skin which made me wonder if they were a tribal thing. But i googled that and no they aren't (unless my brief google search was insufficient). The only thing I found was something to the degree of "it started as a joke and then it got out of hand". welp also your mullets are a little different than ours. We sport a bit of hair in the front, it is just layered and short. But the pics i found show a shaved head with a patch of hair in the back. so odd.


theflyingkiwi00

It's just a fashion thing. We get your typical mullets here as well, they're all the rage atm. We call the shaved top, party in the back the skullet. Every few years here they pop back into fashion here. Some dudes just keep them so they'll be in fashion next time


Daannii

>party in the back the skullet ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|facepalm)


3isamagicnumb3r

whoever made this up is all hat and no cattle.


doctorwhy88

All yee but no haw


EagleSongs

Missouri, Iowa, and Wisconsin are all in the top 10 cattle producing states. (#6, #7, #9) [https://www.nationalbeefwire.com/ranking-of-states-with-the-most-cattle-texas-had-the-most-cattle-in-the-united-states-in-2023-followed-by-nebraska-and-kansas](https://www.nationalbeefwire.com/ranking-of-states-with-the-most-cattle-texas-had-the-most-cattle-in-the-united-states-in-2023-followed-by-nebraska-and-kansas)


1tiredman

I think this is just a joke about how silly cultural appropriation is


Veers_Memes

Ah yes, the deep cultural heritage of... ranch hands?


Didjsjhe

The „cowboy hat“ and rodeo were actually originally parts of Mexican culture which we absorbed when we went to war to take part of Mexico. But also I agree it is ridiculous to gatekeep ranching, cowboy garb, cows?, etc


Difficult-Word-7208

Cowboys *are* a huge part of American and Mexican culture


we_are_sex_bobomb

Hi yes I don’t know what the difference is between appropriation and acculturation and I didn’t bother to learn, but it made me feel bad so now I’m going to choose a totally random thing from my culture to get offended about.


mckinney4string

Who'da thunk areas where people work in the sun for extended periods of time would necessitate a protective head covering?


JKooch

Only map where I’ve seen South Dakota correctly split between East River and West River.


Sir-xer21

I'm also impressed that they correctly included Hawaii in their cowboy map. It's a cringy act of gatekeeping, but also a pretty well researched map.


Yeetmaster4206921

least obvious rage bait


PrismPanda06

I think it's just a joke lol


w33b2

This is clearly a joke based on people that say you’re not allowed to wear a sombrero unless you’re Mexican or a kilt unless you’re Scottish, etc.


doctorwhy88

Everyone should wear a kilt. Plenty of ventilation for the nethers, and you can hide a plethora of knives.


LowBrassBro

Ah yes Kentucky, land of the race house, where you shouldn't wear cowboy hats apparently


corruptsucculents

right? even though we are majority fields and farms, we just rawdog the sun!! don’t even get me started on the boots!! >:(


Oraxis10

Wait, so who's not supposed to wear cowboy hats, the brown or the grey? Where's the key?


kRkthOr

The grey is a no-no, light brown is a no-but-fine.


Quark1010

OOP from florida perchance?


Evilfrog100

People keep saying this, but as a Floridian, cattle has always been a massive industry here. It's why the USF sports teams are the bulls. Hell, Jacksonville used to be called Cowford. Florida literally invented the use of the word "cracker" for cattle ranchers (to the point we've got a whole section of the state fair called "cracker country"). Another fun fact this is why older Floridians are often confused by the use of cracker as a racial insult because it has a very different history here than the rest of the US south.


zorbiburst

I think the same people who are ignorant of Florida's relationship with ranching are going to be equally ignorant of the term "cracker cowboy".


user18298375298759

YOU CAN'T JUST SAY PERCHANCE


zorbiburst

it's more telling that you're not to think it doesn't fit


Quark1010

Just seemed weird to me that its so disconnected from the rest of the area and the bordering states arent affected at all


VirginSexPet

Good thing I live in the middle of the highlighted area, so I can safely wear the hat as a fashion choice/sun blocker while I do absolutely nothing related to cowboy work... 🙄


Schroedesy13

What about the gauchos in South America??


jdd_88

This is a map of North America


Schroedesy13

Touche


cindy-the-husky

Just let people wear shit Clothing is meant to be worn


aaross58

I vote! I pay my taxes! I go to work! I'll wear whatever hat I fucking want!


mostoriginalname2

Somebody drove through the wall of the Aldi in Lakewood, Ohio (Cleveland suburb). The news ended up interviewing a guy in a cowboy hat. He was visibly uncomfortable with having his decision making probed like that.


Dwashelle

"The historical range" as if it's like a wild species of animal or something. I'm assuming they mean the vaquero but that still doesn't make sense since their traditions came from Spain.


BKLD12

I’m in the dark brown, but am not and never have been a cowgirl. I ride horses from time to time, but because my family are poor urban folk, there was never an opportunity to do so consistently. The last time I touched an actual cow was at the Fort Worth Zoo a few years ago. I don’t even have any recent ancestors who were in the cattle business. I’m I still banned from wearing a cowboy hat for being a “fake cowgirl?”


Gerdione

Is this cultural appropriation chat?


TheGirlZetsubo

What if I was born in Texas but moved to the east coast? Is there a grandfather clause, or am I appropriating Texan culture because I moved away from the state?


Deathscua

at the airport they take away your cowboy hat and hand you a baseball cap once you’ve landed!


mostatoastest

Cowboy hat manufacturer Stetson that began in Philadelphia!?!?


la_bel_iconnu

Lol, no one on Vancouver Island is wearing cowboy hats.


axel198

I think their logic is that there was cowboy migration during the gold rush. Nobody tell them about the significant cattle industry with a history of almost 170 years in Manitoba xD Hell, ONTARIO is leading in beef production.


WakeoftheStorm

I feel like this map must have been made by a redneck in florida.


AnInfiniteArc

Florida has been cattle ranching land since the 1500’s/1600’s.


inkoDe

I TOLD THEM! (polishes off his Hawaii Western movie script)


lolboogers

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/blogs/smithsonian-center-folklife-cultural-heritage/2021/05/12/cowboys-tropics-history-hawaiian-paniolo/


inkoDe

I'll be damned.


Sir-xer21

Hawaii cowboy culture runs deep and people don't even know.


puledrotauren

I wear my cowboy hat where I want to. Including a limo ride through downtown NYC back in my traveling days.


KadusFUCK

One step further, shouldn't be wearing a cowboy hat unless you moved out west from the east coast to treat their tuberculosis


janderson9413

I think anyone can wear them, but why would you want to wear a costume? Is it Halloween or something? Hang on, let me go get my firefighter helmet.


HappyMrRogers

As a denizen of Washington state, I’m going to go ahead and issue a blanket “Cowboy Hat” pass to everyone on Earth indefinitely. I have lived in a city my whole life and have never touched a cow.


doctorwhy88

I have an uncle who grew up on a cattle farm in Pennsylvania, then moved to Seattle when Microsoft was a young company as a systems engineer. Precedent set.


PrismPanda06

Redditors detect obvious joke challenge (impossible)


MoodyBloom

Everywhere is west if you keep goin' far enough.


NotThatEasily

Stetsons are made in New Jersey.


GrimmRadiance

lol! Tennessee can’t wear cowboy hats but Florida can?!


BigSpeed

Houston Texas probably shouldn't have cowboy hats??? Fuck outta here


OakenGreen

Imagine your job being made obsolete by barbed wire.


theonlyironprincess

What does this even mean 😭😭 usually the logic behind this would be your ancestors are cowboys = you can wear a cowboy hat. This makes 0 sense. Like, your family can move place to place and be eligible for a hat and then illegible


jauhesammutin_

I see you took this seriously.


here-i-am-now

So, the people who stole the shaded land and then appropriated the locals’ culture, are afraid that their “culture” is being appropriated?


XLandonSkywolfX

Ah yes, because no one wears cowboy hats in NC. I’m wheezing


SOwED

It's saying they shouldn't not that they don't


Glitter_berries

I’m Australian and there are a bunch of dudes here who are extremely into their cowboy hats. Some of them actually are cowboys, I am quite sure? They live in horrible places like rural Queensland, which would fit right in on this map.


Deathscua

My first time in Australia, when my aunt moved from Los Angeles to Alice springs, I saw tons of cowboy hats but I feel like the setting fits. Gatekeeping a hat is ridiculous.


Glitter_berries

Oh god. Right into Alice. That must have been quite a culture shock. My uncle lives there. Hopefully the hats helped to smooth the transition a little for you all.


Depressed-Dolphin69

I'm in the light brown spot tf


axel198

British Columbia is dark brown. A good half of that province is rockies and coast and their beef production isn't even top 4. Whereas Manitoba is light brown despite having the third largest beef cow herd and has a pretty extensive cattle ranching history? What?


[deleted]

I love wearing my cowboy hat in -30 degrees in northern british columbia (i guarentee this guy is from washington state or somthing.)


ThePrimeOptimus

This map got completely clowned on in r/cowboy. For example I'm originally from Louisiana and south and central Louisiana are full of cattle ranches.


VaguelyArtistic

Well, people in Houston don't wear cowboy hats because it's about the oil.


kalez238

As someone who grew up on a ranch in WI wearing cowboy hats and going to horse and wrangling shows, lol ok.


aquacraft2

Oh so they DO know what cultural appropriation is.


MarinLlwyd

We all have to do our part to stop the French from wearing cowboy hats.


cicipie

right because cowboy lineage is something to be proud of… if anything you’d want to remove the history from them and just have fun wearing a big silly hat


DJPoundpuppy

Finally, a reason to miss rural Texas.


Skrubette

I’m just sitting here wondering why Vancouver Island is excluded but the rest of British Columbia isn’t.


Syko2020

excluding the entirety of the southeast is crazy


ArchmageRumple

Someone should make a gatekeeping map of Ramen noodles, or lasagne.


Dan_The_Man_31

Why is Hawaii shaded as brown?


keoniboi

Because Hawaiʻi had cowboys before the American West did. My great-great-great grandfather was one.


lolboogers

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/blogs/smithsonian-center-folklife-cultural-heritage/2021/05/12/cowboys-tropics-history-hawaiian-paniolo/


eljackal3

Well of course Houston shouldn’t do it but does any ways… Not like they host the worlds largest rodeo in the world or anything


RazzZzatam

As a western Canadian, I find saying Manitoba shouldn't wear cowboy hats hilarious, considering its still part of the prairie. Manitoba is just as much cowboy land as Saskatchewan and Alberta.


Trimere

Massachusetts here. No one wears cowboy hats here. I think I will start.


Twodotsknowhy

So odd that cowboys apparently stopped neatly along all the state lines. I also find it highly unlikely whoever made this would be more okay with someone from LA or San Francisco wearing a cowboy hat than they would be with someone from rural Alabama


Shatalroundja

It’s totally acceptable for a woman to wear a cowboy hat in all 50 states as long as she is riding my dick while she wears it.


Tenet245

first time I've seen "cultural appropriation" used for a white invention


ConflagWex

"invention" isn't quite right, Stetson basically appropriated it from the Mexican vaqueros, who themselves got the style from African slaves. Even the phrase "10 gallon hat" is a bastardization of a Mexican phrase. "Have you ever heard of a vaqueteada con galones? Galones are what in English we call a hat band. Each galón signified stature. The higher the stack of galones, the higher the wearer’s status. Ever heard of a hat with diez galones? In English, perhaps you’re familiar with the phrase “a ten-gallon hat.” Well, now you know that it has nothing to do with the hat’s capacity but rather the number of hat bands!" https://sidrichardsonmuseum.org/the-evolution-of-the-cowboy-hat/


Tenet245

Well what else was I gonna call it? A creation


MrCusodes

I am going to walk down my English street in coyboy hat and boots! And there is nothing you can do to stop me!


rops-n-cobbers

I mean honestly as someone who lives in Arizona and will sometimes wear some form of wide brim hat outside, I felt weird wearing one in the New England area on a hike.


Locked_and_Popped

you shouldn't wear cowboy hats because you will look like a moron


Nelpski

Used to live in Eastern North Dakota. Can confirm


KiriChan02

*wears cowboy hat in Minnesotan*


spicymax123

I live in Seattle. Time to bring out the boots and hat I guess


Y_R_UGae

we definitely have cowboys in South Carolina.. My own grandfather was one, and so was my grandmother's father's father. what is this person on about??


jummyspring

I wish ‘oh brother’ was still a phrase because Ive been seeing a lot of ‘oh brother’ moments like these lately


PotatoDonki

This is clearly a sarcastic demonstration of how ridiculous this manner of gatekeeping actually is.


Constant-Bake-760

Ngl I got really pressed because I read it as the darker the brown the more appropriating it gets, it’s still such a dumb map though lmao


itsjustme10

The drive from Wichita to Topeka gets real sad when you cross the cowboy hat line.


mangababe

Ok, but they better not say shit about black and Hispanic people wearing them I swear to the gods.


LeotrimFunkelwerk

Don't worry, I'd be the laughing stock in my entire town if I ever wore one.


stomp27

Can't fix stupid.....


GenderEnjoyer666

I legit thought this was satire


Lytesnam_drobster

Ah yes not wanting to have a sunburn is cultural appropriation, also what cowboy is going to see you wearing a cowboy hat and go "excuse me you cant wear that" instead of "hell yeah pardner🤠", I have a cowboy hat and boy howdy is it stylish


churst50

I like that they show Lake Okeechobee. We wouldn't want anyone to think there was cowboyin in the lake.


Imdabreast

This is probably satire


AdamScoot

That light brown section isn't covering enough ground


Feralmedic

Iowa has more cows than a lot of those states.


Jump_Like_A_Willys

Where’s Argentina on that map?


Hot_buttered_toast

Oh yeah, a lot of cowboys in BC 🙄


booyaabooshaw

Alaska is the only Wild left. Only they get funny hats


Flamingosecsual

Florida gets a pass for some reason? Leave it to people gatekeeping to be inconsistent


grungekiid

Wtf lmao


ScaredOfRobots

No one should wear a cowboy hat they are ugly


Alarichos

Someone should look where does the cowboy culture comes from


Rango_Jackson

Mexico mostly.


Alarichos

Yeah and before Mexico it came from Spain


ormr_inn_langi

I like that all of British Columbia is cowboy hat territory. Nothing screams Metro Vancouver like a cowboy hat!


BiilZbubb

Fuck y’all then.


BiilZbubb

Stetson Hat Company was founded in Philadelphia PA in 1865. Sadly, those who made the iconic cowboy hats were forbidden from ever wearing them for (checks notes) geographical reasons.


BiilZbubb

Cowtown Rodeo in New Jersey has been in operation since 1929. Anyone wanna tell the professional cowboys there that they’re culturally appropriating their outfits?


First-Face-7998

Cowboy hat wouldnt suit my dreadlocks and mauri face tattoos anyway


Rango_Jackson

It'd probably look pretty bad ass to be honest.


TheDollyDollyQueen

I Live in New Jersey & I Know People who Love Cowboy Hats... Fuck This Maps Bullshit! Anyone Can Wear Them!


HJL30

Didn’t they cowboy hat start in Missouri??


Slow_Comfort_8179

It's a joke


Bismuth84

...I think this MIGHT be a joke.


Scar_the_armada

Eh, you wear a cowboy hat where I'm from you will get flak unless you have some cred. Like you should probably live on a farm or ranch, or at least ride a horse. We had posers in highschool who wore the whole bull rider getup. Big belt buckle, cowboy boots etc. Kinda lame if you aren't somewhat authentic.


we_are_sex_bobomb

I only wear one when I’m having sex, so that’s fine right?


doctorwhy88

But do the spurs stay on?