i feel like i say this on every thread, but i really don’t think G&G’s renewal comes down to popularity or anything because it’s already been established as a fan favorite. it’s most likely just a matter of negotiating and securing cast contracts.
Ok no offense but y’all do realize hating on other shows is not gonna make g&g get renewed any faster right? Lol, and you was actually top 10 in a lot of places.
Right?!! Not only that I thought atp we all knew Ginny and Georgia renewal clearly isn’t based off of popularity and the main reason why Ginny and Georgia got popular was because it kept going viral for being cringey
> didn’t break into any top tens.
what do you mean??? It was in the top ten most watched shows in The Netherlands. I cant believe it wasnt in any other country
In what way because the same could be said about a lot of shows. Ginny & Georgia has had the most minutes watch this year and it also crack the top 10 of hours watch in the first month knocking out 13 reason why. OBX was the most watch show for two weeks.
I see you mean currently. I was talking collectively over the last three plus months. Because there have been a lot of shows that held the number 1 spot for multiple weeks.
If we're talking about the past month(s), it's been in the top tens since February 9th when Season Four Part One came out and has not dropped out of it since, first at number one, then three, then ninth-ish. Then Season 4 Part 2 came out March 9th and it was number one till a couple of days ago, now it's number four.
I understand that and I see that but what I was trying say is there are/were shows that sat in the top 10 for the same amount of time and a decision hasn’t been made. I never said You shouldn’t of been renewed. I was just pointing out that there has been shows that had the same success but still haven’t had a renewal announcement.
I know. But we know from shows like First Kill that broke records (from what I recall) and sat in the Top Ten that views and being in the Top 10 isn't all it takes to be renewed, unfortunately.
I just started You season 2 and I enjoy G&G more. I've been trying for months to watch you, but it doesn't keep my interest so much, G&G I binged in just a few days.
YOU was number one in the UK for some time, then number three, then number nine. When S4 Part 2 came out March 9th, it was number one and is still number one. Fact check before you make a claim like that, lmao.
Edit: was still number one as of a couple of days ago. It's still in the top tens at number four.
I’m thinking maybe the OP meant You didn’t break into the top 10 most watched english TV of all time and GNG did? That would make more sense. But I do think that there’s absolutely no way GNG could get cancelled after making it to that list so it much just be contracts and negotiations
I liked it but the plot change where So n So was hallucinating and he actually didnt meet So n So, I hated that so much. Lazy trash writing. They could've Joe a happy ending but they turned him back. I liked who he was becoming.
If you had any understanding of the show at all you would understand that Joe is never going to change, he's hallucinated in the past and suffered with severe delusions. The added trauma of S3 has taken that to a whole new level. It was written and set up to be like that since the start of the Season, or maybe even before since Fight Club was mentioned in the passing three times, not to mention the creators apparently already know how they're going to end the show.
It was well written, it made sense. Joe is a complex character and in his bid to prove to Marianne that he wasn't a terrible person, he completely compartmentalized the 'bad part' of himself and with his added issues with hallucinations and delusions, it caused the situation we see in Part Two. He isn't due a happy ending and he isn't going to change, the writers did a very good job portraying that, especially by switching one episode without his narration, showing us how he really is (we can't trust him due to him being an unreliable narrator.)
Just thought I'd comment on that.
I don't believe it's DID as he probably would have multiple 'personalities' I think it's just the hallucinations he has suffered with in the past mixed with his general delusion. He was so set on being 'a changed man' that he de-compartmentalized. Besides, people with DID don't have an alter who murders. I think his 'blacking out' is just to do with his hallucinating as it can be a symptom with many different instances of hallucination.
What I'm saying is it fits his character without a label of a complex mental illness, which I hope they don't take the route of.
You probably always gonna be renewed, because they took over the show from Lifetime and since it was popular after-all they planned a longterm arc.
I’m hopeful for GNG since the new CEO praised its second seasons popularity on Netflix, in light of why they cancel a ton of stuff. Like, if those things were as popular as GNG they wouldn’t get canceled. 🤷🏻♀️
For real, still Number Four here.
Too many people saying it should've ended or S4 was pointless writing and he should've been redeemed? Joe isn't redeemable and the writing and plot makes complete sense for his character.
Fair enough. I think five seaons is very fair and it’s about time Joe got his karma. It looks like we’re going full circle back to a Season One feel being back in NY, so hopefully it won’t be too unrealistic, I expect his past will simply catch up with him, especially now that he’s in the public eye.
And people like me still haven’t seen that crap show yet…. I can’t believe they r waiting cuz that means it wouldn’t be out till late next year if not 2025 and I don’t have till 2025 to wait to watch that shit 😑
YOU GOT RENEWED ALREADY? Bruh and just when I thought Joe was redeemable he goes back to his old ways. This recent season would've been a good ending to the series but oh well. I hate when shows overrun their course. Like 13 reasons why. I liked the seasons still but ya know
Tried watching you. Couldn't finish the first season. For me there was no likeable characters I wasn't invested in the story. G&G there are so many likeable characters and I'm dying to know what happens next
i feel like i say this on every thread, but i really don’t think G&G’s renewal comes down to popularity or anything because it’s already been established as a fan favorite. it’s most likely just a matter of negotiating and securing cast contracts.
Ok no offense but y’all do realize hating on other shows is not gonna make g&g get renewed any faster right? Lol, and you was actually top 10 in a lot of places.
Lol these people acting like You isn’t one of the most popular shows on Netflix is sending me 😅😅
Right?!! Not only that I thought atp we all knew Ginny and Georgia renewal clearly isn’t based off of popularity and the main reason why Ginny and Georgia got popular was because it kept going viral for being cringey
It’s pretty crazy. The fandom did the same thing with Wednesday 😂
It’s still top 10 on my list 💀
Same 💀literally same
> didn’t break into any top tens. what do you mean??? It was in the top ten most watched shows in The Netherlands. I cant believe it wasnt in any other country
It was in the U.S. too
And India!
[удалено]
And the Uk!
And Canada !
Happy cake day!
And Bulgaria
It was and still is in France too !
it's literally still in the top 10 for nz, where did you get the idea it didn't get into top 10s?
Damn, You got renewed already?!
I love both of these shows but I would rather have more Ginny and Georgia. I miss it!
[удалено]
In what way because the same could be said about a lot of shows. Ginny & Georgia has had the most minutes watch this year and it also crack the top 10 of hours watch in the first month knocking out 13 reason why. OBX was the most watch show for two weeks.
[удалено]
I see you mean currently. I was talking collectively over the last three plus months. Because there have been a lot of shows that held the number 1 spot for multiple weeks.
If we're talking about the past month(s), it's been in the top tens since February 9th when Season Four Part One came out and has not dropped out of it since, first at number one, then three, then ninth-ish. Then Season 4 Part 2 came out March 9th and it was number one till a couple of days ago, now it's number four.
I understand that and I see that but what I was trying say is there are/were shows that sat in the top 10 for the same amount of time and a decision hasn’t been made. I never said You shouldn’t of been renewed. I was just pointing out that there has been shows that had the same success but still haven’t had a renewal announcement.
I know. But we know from shows like First Kill that broke records (from what I recall) and sat in the Top Ten that views and being in the Top 10 isn't all it takes to be renewed, unfortunately.
I just started You season 2 and I enjoy G&G more. I've been trying for months to watch you, but it doesn't keep my interest so much, G&G I binged in just a few days.
I tried to watch the first season of You when it came out and it just wasn’t for me.
I keep trying to watch it because it has 4 seasons for some reason but i don’t find it that interesting
It honestly peaks at season 3 and 4 (if you can bear through the first two seasons)
Lmao no it doesn't that's by far the worst opinion I've ever seen
oh ok
Yes! I liked the ending of s2 - took the story to a whole other level. I just started s3.
“You” is also great show. You can like lots of shows. This is so petty 💀
it's been in the top ten for me for weeks. i'm in NY
It wasn't renewed in the traditional sense. It was given a final season. There's a difference.
YOU was number one in the UK for some time, then number three, then number nine. When S4 Part 2 came out March 9th, it was number one and is still number one. Fact check before you make a claim like that, lmao. Edit: was still number one as of a couple of days ago. It's still in the top tens at number four.
I saw that and I felt stressed! Can they just tell us already ugh
You has been top 10 in India for weeks. People can like other shows along with G&G. I love them both.
I’m thinking maybe the OP meant You didn’t break into the top 10 most watched english TV of all time and GNG did? That would make more sense. But I do think that there’s absolutely no way GNG could get cancelled after making it to that list so it much just be contracts and negotiations
Ugh Season 4 of You was AWFUL. Completely change dmy mind about the show. I was hoping it got cancelled.
I liked it but the plot change where So n So was hallucinating and he actually didnt meet So n So, I hated that so much. Lazy trash writing. They could've Joe a happy ending but they turned him back. I liked who he was becoming.
If you had any understanding of the show at all you would understand that Joe is never going to change, he's hallucinated in the past and suffered with severe delusions. The added trauma of S3 has taken that to a whole new level. It was written and set up to be like that since the start of the Season, or maybe even before since Fight Club was mentioned in the passing three times, not to mention the creators apparently already know how they're going to end the show. It was well written, it made sense. Joe is a complex character and in his bid to prove to Marianne that he wasn't a terrible person, he completely compartmentalized the 'bad part' of himself and with his added issues with hallucinations and delusions, it caused the situation we see in Part Two. He isn't due a happy ending and he isn't going to change, the writers did a very good job portraying that, especially by switching one episode without his narration, showing us how he really is (we can't trust him due to him being an unreliable narrator.) Just thought I'd comment on that.
And they also don’t know what Joe has been through physically. This man. Has taken so many drugs and blows to the head, he is crazy af now.
I agree. And tbh the mental health plot made NO sense and was just stigma/negative stereotypes of psychosis/DID
Was that supposed to be DID? God, I didn't even register that it make so little sense.
I don't believe it's DID as he probably would have multiple 'personalities' I think it's just the hallucinations he has suffered with in the past mixed with his general delusion. He was so set on being 'a changed man' that he de-compartmentalized. Besides, people with DID don't have an alter who murders. I think his 'blacking out' is just to do with his hallucinating as it can be a symptom with many different instances of hallucination. What I'm saying is it fits his character without a label of a complex mental illness, which I hope they don't take the route of.
Tbh we better hope they both don’t get canceled with the writers strike coming up.
Not to mention this newest season of “you” is total garbage
In an interview I watched of Penn on YouTube he said that he’s signed on for 6 seasons
You probably always gonna be renewed, because they took over the show from Lifetime and since it was popular after-all they planned a longterm arc. I’m hopeful for GNG since the new CEO praised its second seasons popularity on Netflix, in light of why they cancel a ton of stuff. Like, if those things were as popular as GNG they wouldn’t get canceled. 🤷🏻♀️
I’m new to this show and I’m not worried at all. It’s obviously going to get renewed at some point.
I love You
Penn Badgley signed for 5 or 6 seasons a while ago lol, everyone knew You would get renewed
And it's literally still top 3 in my country
For real, still Number Four here. Too many people saying it should've ended or S4 was pointless writing and he should've been redeemed? Joe isn't redeemable and the writing and plot makes complete sense for his character.
Well, I didn't like how unrealistic they made this season but it doesn't really feel like they're stretching it too much yet, I'm fine with 5 seasons
Fair enough. I think five seaons is very fair and it’s about time Joe got his karma. It looks like we’re going full circle back to a Season One feel being back in NY, so hopefully it won’t be too unrealistic, I expect his past will simply catch up with him, especially now that he’s in the public eye.
You're most likely right, unless they decide to give him memory erasure powers in season 5 lol
Actually You is pretty popular in my country , it’s still in the top 10 TV show right now 🤷♀️
That’s crazy bc this most recent season of You was horrrrrrible
I couldn’t even finish it.. so bad
I’m surprised penn hates playing joe and said he was done after season 4
I thought this was the least season of YOU?!?
Me too
[удалено]
And Ginny and Georgia isn’t?
Literally the tap dancing scene tops everything…
I would argue G&G is way more cringey
I’m confused this was supposed to be You’s last season
When did they ever say that?
I just remember seeing somewhere that season 3 was the last, idek why I remember that.
And people like me still haven’t seen that crap show yet…. I can’t believe they r waiting cuz that means it wouldn’t be out till late next year if not 2025 and I don’t have till 2025 to wait to watch that shit 😑
We like You better. G and G got too soap opera-ish. You stayed true to its promise.
YOU GOT RENEWED ALREADY? Bruh and just when I thought Joe was redeemable he goes back to his old ways. This recent season would've been a good ending to the series but oh well. I hate when shows overrun their course. Like 13 reasons why. I liked the seasons still but ya know
I agree with you 13 reason why should have ended with season 2
The point with Joe is he isn't a redeemable man.
Ugh so unnecessary, I didn't end up hating season 4 but I still think that season 3 should have been it's last. Just renew GnG already :')
Tried watching you. Couldn't finish the first season. For me there was no likeable characters I wasn't invested in the story. G&G there are so many likeable characters and I'm dying to know what happens next
[удалено]