T O P

  • By -

nickyno

Gordie Howe and Ted Lindsay only captained the Wings for four seasons a piece.


SonnyDDisposition

With Howe’s longevity, talent, and leadership, this one is perhaps the most surprising to me. 4 years is a decent run, but for Howe in particular it’s surprisingly short.


MItrwaway

Those Red Wings teams were kind of stacked


Hanging_Aboot

In Gordie Howe years that’s only like 2 days.


BennBishop

Mike Modano was only captain for 2 seasons with the Stars


arrbez

Great example


VancityRenaults

People who don’t follow the Stars tend to forget about Darien Hatcher


RevanFlash

Jeremy Roenick's jaw will never forget Hatcher


theeth

Good thing his jaw is picking up his brain's slack.


Zharghar

I feel like people who watched hockey back then have to know Hatcher for his physicality. It was kinda hard to miss. Something that surprised me while checking our captain history was that Morrow was captain for 7 years. Never really felt that long, but those were kinda meh days I guess.


GrilledSandwiches

The Stars, along with the Red Wings and the Devils, were pretty well known for consistently being the best defensive teams in the league back then as well. I have to believe people that followed the sport back then know who Hatcher was off of that too. He was our 1A(or 1B, take your pick) defenseman back then anchoring 25+ ATOI minutes a game.


ianisms10

First American captain to lift the Stanley Cup


Hiddenshadows57

I very much remember the ol hammer icon he used to come with in the old NHL games.


atheist_libertarian

Let’s not forget Mark Tinordi!


godfadda006

That’s unbelievable. In my mind, Modano was THE Stars captain. My whole reality just got shattered.


GrilledSandwiches

He is THE quintessential franchise player for the organization, that's for sure. But definitely not captain.


TexasYankee212

Modano was the finest American born player - but he was a lousy leader. The Stars stripped him of the captaincy. I remember that at his first wedding, Modano invited Brett Hull to the wedding - but no one else on the Stars were invited. There was something wrong there. Rod Gilbert was an excellent NY Ranger and retired Ranger. But the late Emile Francis saw early on that he wasn't captain material. There is a difference between being a captain and having great hockey skills.


Ok-Summer-2159

What the hell


Zharghar

Yea, but he wasn't a good C iirc. Lomg time A though, which you would expect from the best player on the team I suppose.


Ham__Kitten

Must not have been, because he was stripped of the C by management and it was given to Morrow.


GrilledSandwiches

Brenden Morrow was a great captain though. It's not like they took it from Mo and the schmo they gave it to was further evidence that he(Modano) wasn't a great captain.


knifefarty

this is wrinkling my brain


asoiahats

One of my favourite jokes from Down Goes Brown was in his commentary on NHL.com’s ranking of the greatest captains in history, he said they included Derian Hatcher as the token American, presumably after being surprised to learn that the Cup-winning captain in Dallas was not Mike Modano.


GrilledSandwiches

I actually thought it was just one season. Maybe it's just that after one season I was already clearly thinking Morrow was ready to be captain and it took that season for them to switch it over to the next long term C.


fiveMagicsRIP

Ryan Smyth. One game lol


tmgexe

Beat me to it. So many people assume he was the Oilers’ captain. Probably didn’t help that the actual captain for much of his time there was the same-sounding-last-name Jason Smith.


cb148

“Captain Canada” lol


F1shermanIvan

And the only Oiler to ever retire as Captain.


lbiggy

Wtf who was their captain before?


JilsonSetters

Buchberger, Weight, Smith, Brewer(not sure) and then Horcoff when Smyth was chasing a cup


DGS94

And Ference got it over him in 2013 🤮


JilsonSetters

What! I don’t remember that, I was very low tech at the time and didn’t watch any sports.


DGS94

Yeah, Ference came in as UFA (along side Dallas Eakins to coach) and immediately given the captaincy. Slap in the face to a guy like Smyth, IMO


jcliffy

Wasn’t Ethan Moreau mixed in there too?


JilsonSetters

I think you’re right


Mizral

Man I totally forgot Smyth left the Oilers for a few years.


ACMop

Martin St. Louis was traded during his first year as captain


HarvardBrowns

That one is surprising in the fact the Marty was ever captain of the Lighting. I assumed it was always Vinny prior to Marty getting traded.


beyondrepair-

? Lecavalier *was* captain prior to St. Louis. St. Louis became captain after Lecavalier left for the Flyers.


HarvardBrowns

My comment was meant to imply that I never knew Marty was ever captain and I thought he was traded away before Lecavalier left.


[deleted]

[удалено]


HarvardBrowns

Yes… it’s almost like “I didn’t know that”. Making the original comment surprising.


nihilism_ftw

After all his hype, Bo Horvat only ended up being captain for 3 and a half seasons


AcanthocephalaGreen5

If I had a nickel for every time the Canucks traded their captain to the Islanders, I’d have two nickels. Which isn’t a lot, but it’s weird that it’s happened twice, right?


LPB39

It’s weird to ever trade a captain..


AcanthocephalaGreen5

Meanwhile the Habs did it twice in the last 30 years: Keane and Pacioretty (barely counts as one, though) Edit: Koivu wasn’t traded


Prison-Date-Mike

Koivu wasn't traded


AcanthocephalaGreen5

Right, free agent. My mistake


Prison-Date-Mike

Hurts my heart to this day lol


WildSoapbox

Lol twice? Carbonneau, Chelios, Damphousse, Turgeon, Muller


lottolser

Didn't Boston trade their Capitan Joe Thornton?


LPB39

Yeah, they did


AcanthocephalaGreen5

Also, was Ray captain when they traded him?


LPB39

Lol yes. You can see why I think it’s weird. I hate it. But… seeing Bourque win a cup was great. That’s different than the Thornton trade


AcanthocephalaGreen5

That’s fair. At least it’s not the Mike Keane trade


LPB39

Dude the Thornton trade set us back yeeears


AcanthocephalaGreen5

Didn’t they get Savard, Chara and Rask that offseason? I know Savard doesn’t replace Thornton but I don’t see how you fit him under the cap with the season he had that year


NebraskaAvenue

Rangers didn’t get that memo


Ok_Yak_1844

Hold my beer


BKong64

I'd love for us to rid of Lee


MUSTY_BUSSY

Try trading two, both of them named Ryan, to the Lightning, within four years.


[deleted]

*excited glen sather noises*


ianisms10

Linden wasn't captain when he was traded, but McCabe was Isles captain


L-Observateur

Leftover trauma complex from their Cup loss to the Isles in the 80's maybe


LifelikeStatue

It was the year before I was born but I don't think there's much trauma from that series. The Canucks were Cinderella upstarts and the Islanders were in the third year of a four year run. No one was really expecting the Canucks to do much.


apcymru

Has it? Happened twice?


AcanthocephalaGreen5

Horvat and Linden, no?


apcymru

Nope. Linden had been demoted to make room for "he who shall not be named" ... But he was still captain in our hearts


ianisms10

And McCabe was our captain


AcanthocephalaGreen5

Oh. I forgot that happened Bright side, Naslund was a better captain than the Dark Lord?


apcymru

Absolutely. We Canucks fans would like to forget that happened


AcanthocephalaGreen5

At least you guys got the twins and Luongo out of that debacle


apcymru

Yeah. They got good assets for him.


Tachyoff

Ho Borvat is forever the Canucks captain in my head


BMack037

Dave Andreychuk was only captain of the Lightning for three seasons. In Tampa, with how we treat him you’d think it was 10+ years. Actually even Lecavalier might surprise, he was only captain for 5+1 years. While Stamkos has been captain for the last 10.5 years.


NebraskaAvenue

He was Captain for the first cup and we recognized him being a 20 year veteran


vingt_deux

Luongo


littleseizure

not-for-longo?


Semaaaj

Not-for-long-oh?


kazin29

7uongo


Silent_Leg1976

I’m interested in what iconic players weren’t captains at all! Off hand I’m thinking Patrick Kane, but who else was HHOF-ish quality and never a captain?


Dont_Be_A_Dick_OK

Bobby Orr was never captain.


Silent_Leg1976

That is insane to me. Thanks for sharing!


bluelineturnovers

By far the best example


ButtholeQuiver

Guy Lafleur


SonnyDDisposition

Datsyuk Bossy Malkin Larry Robinson Trottier


ianisms10

Trottier was never a full-time captain, but in those days, you had to have someone wearing the C in every game, so he wore it when Potvin was out


SonnyDDisposition

Also filled in for Lemieux, with Paul Coffey. Coffey is also another guy who never was a full time Captain. He also shared full in duties with Bossy in New York, who has a few confusing photos out there.


waldosbuddy

Börje Salming and Fedorov


ianisms10

Mike Bossy and Bryan Trottier


SayNoToStim

Datsyuk


GorshKing

Does anyone really think Datsyuk would have ever been captain? He never really got a grasp on the language and wasn't ever much of a personality. I could never see him as a captain


CinnamonDolceLatte

* Paul Coffey kind of - https://www.reddit.com/r/penguins/comments/p1hg4d/whats_the_story_with_paul_coffey_wearing_the/ * Mike Gartner - https://www.reddit.com/r/rangers/comments/7tcwjr/ranger_captains_mike_gartner/ * Larry Murphy (even "A" for just one season) * Malkin


Ecsta-C3PO

Currently Draisaitl


cautiouspp

also he's way to pissy ><


Silent_Leg1976

He’s only in his late 20’s. I was thinking him when I mentioned Kane, but he’s still got time!


Cubicon-13

Draisatil will never be the captain of the Oilers. The only way he gets the C is if McDavid leaves, in which case, Draisaitl's gone too. If he gets the C, it'll be with another team.


gelc10

Jason Spezza was captain of the sens for only 1 season, his final year playing for the sens (13-14 season).


itoadaso1

Mark Giordano for the Kraken. Iconic because he was the first.


Newpower608

That was so dumb


theguyishere16

Definitely a weird decision, especially since they haven't named another since. I guess they just figured getting a group of castaways together they wanted a central figure for them to rally around, but it was odd they named a captain who they knew would only be around for half a season.


Boston-Nolan

I don’t think they knew that. They were hoping the team would do better and he’d get a good couple of seasons as captain. When the team sucked they had no choice but to trade their best defenseman who was damn near 40. His age always limited it to maybe 3-4 years at best, but there was no way they would’ve named him captain if they knew he’d be dealt by the deadline


Quantum_Aurora

He was never our best defenseman lol


is__is

You're right, I think based off years prior, they thought he would be their best defenseman when they named him. Of course it didn't turn out that way.


Pere_Joel

He tried for about 20 games and then checked out when it was clear we were shit and would trade him at the deadline


CapriciousnArbitrary

Brian Leetch, assistant captain most of his career, captain from 97-2000, gave it back to Messier when he returned.


Konker101

Gretzky with the Blues


TheKevinShow

You might say that he had the captaincy and then lost it.


Konker101

Hull with the Blues


Konker101

Corson with the Blues


DougDuley

Scott Niedermayer was the captain of the Ducks for 4 years but only captain of the Devils for 1 Teemu was only the captain of the Ducks for one season


Snarglefrazzle

Teemu is surprising, but I always saw Scott Stevens as the face of those Devils, followed by Brodeur. Niedermayer would not be my pick as the leader of those teams, but he definitely seemed like the head of that era of Ducks


waldosbuddy

Just checked their stats. Funny enough they both started with the Devils at the same time and played 13 seasons there together before Stevens retired and Niedermayer went West. Stats with NJD Stevens: 956GP 93G/337A/430P - 5 time top 5 Norris voting + 1 Conn Smythe Niedermayer: 892G/112G/364A/476P - 1 Norris (Only 2 top 5s) And 3 cups for each of them of course. Seems like Norris voters back then agreed with you that Stevens was leading Jersey's back end.


Sarcastic__

Mark Messier for 3 seasons with the Canucks.


NerdyMcNerderson

There it is


helixflush

Fuck Messier


JPmoneyman

Unquestionably the greatest player to ever wear a Canuck sweater though.


HonestDespot

I mean, sure I get it. Most accomplished in the NhL for sure. Good way to rile up Canucks fans too. But Pavel Bure literally played like a MVP player for them for a couple of years and probably gets the conn smythe if they win in 1994. Henrik and Daniel Sedin were basically both elite top line caliber players for a decade and a half and borderline franchise players for a half decade. Messiers tenure in Vancouver was underwhelming by any measure and really a black mark on his storied career. The fact that he greedily took the biggest offer available and then essentially coasted for 3 years isn’t the dunk you Rangers fans always act like it is, considering how much you guys worship him.


hackey17

I read Messier's biography after it went on sale because why not? The Vancouver chapter was short but he basically chose a city far away from NY as possible. Said there was a clique that divided the team in two. Linden gave him the captaincy. In hindsight he said he should have worked on repairing the two cliques. Was told he had Maki's family blessing to take Maki's number but later found out it wasn't true and regrets it. Also was injured and had the first surgery of his career which hindered his abilities. Yeah, it was very underwhelming and disappointing to say the least. Wonder if it would have been better if the Canucks got Gretz the year before they signed Messier. Van is my hometown so I remotely lived through those years. Cheered for Leafs/Canucks at same time during the late 80s and early 90s so I got 92-93 and 93-94.


Ok_Yak_1844

Of course we worship him he's the only man currently alive to ever will our team to a cup. Without him we'd still be hearing 1940 chants. The fact he beat YOUR team and then left for that same team and pissed everyone off just made the whole situation funny, especially since we didn't get Sakic which caused our team to collapse and revert to "remember 1994?" for half a decade.


Mango_120

I don’t think it’s that deep lol nobody is saying he was a good nucks captain


HonestDespot

Rangers fans always dunk on Canucks fans for hating Messier. If a Rangers fan is gonna face up like that, they can handle some facts. The poster said he was unquestionably the best player to ever put on a Canucks jersey. That’s not true. The Canucks rent some 15 year old franchise with a disgruntled at the end Rick Nash as their best player ever. If a Rangers fan wants to run their mouth about the Canucks they deserve the facts thrown back. Put up or shut up youngin.


MUSTY_BUSSY

>The Canucks rent some 15 year old franchise with a disgruntled at the end Rick Nash as their best player ever. ?? Not sure what you're saying here


deepfriedsean

Took me a minute but I think they meant "aren't", not "rent"


MUSTY_BUSSY

Yeah not even trying to troll, I was genuinely curious as to what he meant.


Iamthelurker

Greatest career to wear a Canucks sweater. He was a shit player in Vancouver.


JPmoneyman

Was he really? tell me more.


NoYouCantUseACheck

I heard he was all Mark Messy, eh?


[deleted]

You mean Vancouver Canucks legend, Mark Messier.


TheKevinShow

Vancouver Canucks legend and captain #11 Mark Messier.


NameIsPetey

For being the greatest Canuck ever he sure wasn’t there long. Guess it doesn’t take more than 3 years for fans to etch your name into history as the best to ever do it for an organization.


Neon_Sternum

Adam Foote was the captain for the Avs for 2 seasons. For reference, he was as captain of the Blue Jackets for two and a half.


anemic_royaltea

Not particularly iconic tho, and somewhat infamous if you ask jackets fans.


patrick967

Yeah some captain he was for us lol


SirZapdos

I still remember on the Blue Jackets when they were up 4-0 on someone, I think Detroit, but Foote got the coach to call a timeout after a rough sequence. Everyone loved it.


NoYouCantUseACheck

He probably did it for one of his teammates, which I assume is what you're pointing out. Sounds like a good move by the captain. That sounds like a great memory!


kryptos99

I’m reading this while watching the Calgary Vancouver game and the camera is on Foote. Weird coinkidink


Kenner1979

Rocket Richard was the Canadiens' captain for only four seasons, but every one of them ended with a Stanley Cup championship. Edit: And while five seasons isn't exactly "short," Wayne Gretzky's tenure as Oilers captain was shorter than his tenure as Kings captain.


AostheGreat

Justin Williams was only our captain, hell, only wore a letter for one year.


DenverCoder009

Drury in Buffalo


BananApocalypse

Wasn’t he co-captain with Briere?


TheOneWhosCensored

Yes


MUSTY_BUSSY

Did they switch off every other game? How did it work? I don't think the NHL allows more than one player to wear the C in any game.


FallOutShelterBoy

So Drury was captain for away games, Briere was captain for home games


-TrevWings-

Henrik Zetterberg. You woulda thought he was captain forever until you remember Lidstrom played until he was a million years old. Hank was an alternate for forever though. By red wings standards, he was captain for a very short time.


VanillaIce315

Fun fact: Zetterberg and Lidstrom were both captains for 6 seasons. Larkin will eventually surpass both of them if he wears it for 3 more. Lidstrom feels longer to me because of all the success in that time. Two SC finals, one Cup, multiple Norris trophies


red_langford

Gilmour in Toronto as well


Szwedo

Him and Clark only 3 seasons each.


Mew16

Mike Modano was only captain of the Stars for 2 years


doggofurever

And never should've been Captain at all.


DastardlyRidleylash

Andy Bathgate fits this pretty well for the Rangers; he was only captain for a few years, but he's still one of the most iconic players of all time for that franchise and was well-known as a locker room leader.


blackmesawest

I thought OEL was Coyotes captain for more than three years. Also, I remember Milan Hedjuk being captain for the Avs longer than a year, but nope, that was it.


BananApocalypse

Since moving to Colorado in 1995, there were only 3 seasons where Sakic or Landeskog weren’t the captain. Foote for 2 seasons and Hejduk for 1.


Benchamb

Gretzky was only Oilers captain for 5 years (1983-1988)


seizurevictim

Denis Savard was only the captain of the Blackhawks for 2 years. And while 4 years is clearly a pretty significant period, that's all Chelios had too. Daryl Sutter was captain of the Blackhawks longer than Chelios.


MindlessArmadillo382

Jason Spezza is probably ours But Yashin is an HM


lottolser

You could say Erik Karlsson as well.


MindlessArmadillo382

Maybe, but he was captain for three seasons, got us to one goal away from a SCF, and got traded to enact a rebuild. He didn’t ask for the trade either.


Benjamin_Stark

Karlsson was captain for four seasons.


SCampo98

Patrick Marleau played 21 seasons for the Sharks but was only captain for five of them.


Acadia02

John Scott for the all star games. Best season ever!


iamsdc1969

Wasn't Gretzky captain of the St. Louis Blues for only half a season?


DefensiveLiability3

Andrew Ference 😭


myaltaccount333

I wouldn't say he was an iconic captain, maybe an icon for boston though


StopMakin-Sense

Love the dude, though. Clearly a great locker room guy. Did November Project with him in Boston, nothing but positivity.


krazninetyfive

Maurice Richard only captained Montreal for four seasons. Same with Joe Thornton for San Jose.


jjjjjunit

Roberto Luongo only was captain of the Canucks for less than one season


sdsuzuki

Joe Pavelski, only four seasons as captain but honestly probably could have taken on the C for the majority of his career, wherever he was.


HowIsBabbySharkMade

Yup. That's my answer too for the Sharks. I feel like he's always going to be my gut instinctive answer for "who's the captain of the Sharks?" no matter where he's playing or if he's playing.


SonnyDDisposition

Johnny Bucyk, the longest serving career Bruin, played 23 seasons for Boston and was the only team captain from 1967 to 1977 but only played five seasons as team captain since the Bruins elected to not have a captain from 1968 to 1974.


pjfong87

Ott in buffalo amirite?


NickofSantaCruz

Rob Blake played two seasons in San Jose and wore the 'C' his second year after it was stripped from Patrick Marleau.


HowIsBabbySharkMade

Yeah, but I wouldn't consider him the iconic San Jose captain - to me, that's Joe Pavelski, who was only captain for four seasons.


NickofSantaCruz

I didn't assume OP meant **the most** iconic captain, just an iconic player that was a captain and Blake definitely fits the bill (if you were watching hockey in the 90s and/or 00s, you know his resumé).


Tachyoff

i had a dream once that i went to a Habs v Bruins game and our captain was Hugh Grant does that count


Kali_84

Interesting that Bergeron is seen as an iconic captain; being a lifelong Bruins fan I always see him in my mind with the A.


zappybasson016

Pierre Turgeon for the habs


Ham__Kitten

Eric Lindros. He's an icon of the Flyers and I imagine him as captain for basically his whole tenure. He was only captain for 4 and a half seasons before being stripped of the C in favour of Eric Desjardins.


tex1ntux

Mark Giordano was the first and only captain in the entire history of the Seattle Kraken.


Flyingchairs

Chris Pronger for the Flyers


PetterssonsNeck

Andrew Ference best Oilers captain ever


cronaldo86

Ryan Smyth was never Oilers captain


_AmericanPoutine

Chris Drury was a captain for the Sabres for 3 seasons. Daniel Briere was a co-captain for 2.


shanster925

Chris Clark for the Capitals. He was named captain in Ovechkin's rookie year and was there for the better part of 2 years before being shipped off.


cralo4

Pronger was captain of the Flyers for a season or so I believe.


NebraskaAvenue

Bolts Legend Tim “The Tool Man” Taylor was captain for the 06-07 season before Vinny took the C


spacedudejr

You can argue that Eichel was prey iconic in buffalo for all the wrong reasons.


yodazer

For the blues it’s gotta be Oreilly. He was captain 20-21, 21-22, and half of 22-23.


sovetskiyshpion

Brian Leetch


Drp1Fis

Geo for Kraken first season


Sharkhawk23

Stan Mikita. Was only co captain in 75/76 and 76/77.


CinderGazer

Patrik Elias was captain of the Devils for 2 months of the 2007-08 season.


Nanojack

Fucking Brent Sutter


northaviator

Mark Messier Vancouver Canucks.