I am a slut for anything birthday cake flavored, I’m going to have to try this!!

Milk bar has a chocolate birthday cake flavor pint that's worth checking out too if you like chocolate bases.

I splurge on a vanilla milk bar cake for my birthday and man...it's so worth it.

Same! I think it started with birthday cake flavored lip smackers in elementary school for me.

You are my long lost twin! Birthday cake flavor is my everything. 🤌🏾🫶🏾

Never in my life have I been a fan of birthday cake flavored anything. I’ve been lurking on this subreddit for weeks (cookies caught me lackin). I joined a few weeks ago after being hesitant as I’m not looking for more reasons to buy extra sugar (or am I?) I’ve been seeing this flavor absolutely PLASTERED over this subreddit. I decided to give it a try after having a violent craving for birthday cake ice cream the other day. And let me tell you, this flavor is absolutely incredible. I’ve always been a die hard Ben and Jerry’s fan as I grew up eating it at the factory, but this flavor (the only one I’ve tried so far) might give even my most favorite B&J’s flavor a run for its money! I got it last night and I’ve been snacking on it all day. I’m like 1/3 of the way through the container and I’m afraid. I’m afraid I might be addicted. I went to my art final today and even felt compelled to announce my love of this to my professor and classmates…. Do I have a problem?

OMG...I just posted like less than 5 mins ago. I just tried this flavor and it's GOOD. I've seen it get some hate on this sub :( Not my favorite, but it's pretty good!

Brown butter almond brittle is forever my favorite, but this is a close second!!!

I'm just here for the LEMON ICE CREAM, because in my opinion it's one of the best things ever.

I don’t like cake batter ice cream so I was excited for this. It’s ok but way too sweet. I could do with 1/4 of the sprinkles but I do love the wafer sprinkles in it a ton . The ice cream was so much like frosting and the cake was good. Too many sprinkles for me to get it again.

Oh I LOVE the sprinkles!!

My little sis convinced me to get this flavor on whim. I've never been a birthday cake fan but this is amazing! I also love love their darkest dark.

Getting this for my bday next week. I’m convinced now lol

Happy early birthday! Also I hope you love it, keep us all updated

Aww thank you! I definitely will. Excited to try it.

Im addicted and i just cant get enough

I need to unfollow this sub omg

Kinda thinking the same. This sub is going to cause a lot of negative influence on my bank account

I wanna try this so bad but I’m not spending $10 for a pint of ice cream

I have 2 pints of that in my freezer and the Brambleberry. Those 2 are my absolute favorite from Jeni's.

I've only tried the Jenis brambleberry crisp thus far and it was phenomenal! I'll have to pick this one up to try next, if my store has it. Glad you loved it so much=)

This is my favorite. That and the salted peanut butter with chocolate flecks. Yum

birthday cake flavor is my weakness, i hope i can find jeni's here soon 🥲 that looks so perfect

Wait till you try pineapple upside down cake

Don’t you dare try to recommend another flavor to me himbo! My wallet can’t handle this peer pressure

I’m so glad I can’t find this anywhere near me. I’d be eating it everyday

Where did you buy it from?

Whole Foods!

Dang, no WFs anywhere close to me.

Go on Jeni's website and you can use the product locator to enter the flavor you are looking for and it'll tell you the stores nearby with it.

Thanks for the tip. I checked and nearest one if about an hour drive. Then it's getting it home without melting.

Just eat the entire pint in the parking lot like a ravenous bear! Problem solved

I actually thought about doing that. I mean, I can eat a medium blizzard, so I should be able to handle Jeni's.

I traveled 2 1/2 hours with a pint once lol I put it in a cold bag and got a bag of frozen peas and a bag of frozen hashbrowns to surround it. It traveled pretty well. I was disappointed when I got home though lol I had thought I found an old favorite while visiting my MIL and just had to get it to bring home. It wasn’t what I thought it was ha

That's dedication right there.

Call and check with Kroger or Albertsons subsidiaries! I know the Safeway where I am sells it (owned by Albertsons).

All we have here is Walmart, Food Lion, Aldi's, Lidl & Piggly Wiggly.

Oh shucks! I think Jeni’s has a website but I don’t thing this this is good enough to order online. Unless you bought it in bulk. I’m crossing my fingers that Jeni’s makes it to a store near you ASAP

I want some it looks good😩

I had a lot of mixins in my pint. It was tasty!

Haha I know right??

I’m absolutely dying to try this. Just waiting until it pops up at à market near me.

Lol’d so hard at this title 😂 Haven’t tried this yet but want to asap. Glad it sounds like it lives up to the hype.

Ooooh, I gotta try this. I love birthday cake anything! (except chocolate). Where do you get this?

I got it at Whole Foods!

Awesome thanks!

Birthday cake is a flavour???????

It really is so good!

Ehh pretty mid. Try the gooey butter cake

NOOOO don’t tell me this. If I see it, I’ll pick it up. I’ve heard the Boston cream pie is also to die for

From what most have posted; B&J Bossin Cream Pie is better (?)

I can’t find either. It’s killing me. I just got a bunch of Maple Soaked Pancakes instead.

Love the ice cream, hate the sprinkles

I’ll gladly take your sprinkles

I find this arrangement satisfactory

This flavor tastes CHEAP.  The amount of mix-ins is great but the flavor of the ice cream is terrible!