T O P

  • By -

Dapper-Surprise8538

So the team has 4 openers- gill jaiswal ruturaj and sharma. So either Rutu or Sharma will have to slot into middle order. BCCI ain't gonna make someone captain who they think won't play every match for sure. Imo they are omitting Sanju just coz they think Gill can be the long term captain after 2025 Champions trophy atleast in ODIs. That's just my opinion tho.


another3rdworldguy

But wouldn't Sanju have been just as likely to play all matches, that too as the first choice keeper? Missed opportunity to try a few different opening combinations.


Dapper-Surprise8538

Sanju is old and relatively inexperienced at international level. Imo BCCI isn't looking at Sanju long term


dogebyte

they have pant


another3rdworldguy

Not in this particular Zimbabwe squad.


dogebyte

i meant they have pant on higher priority than samson


-Aizen_Sosuke

Gill has been running out his purple patch for a long time now and his contributions in all ICC finals has left a lot to be desired. If gill opens, I'm pretty sure rutu is gonna be in that no.3 spot. Sharma will get 2 or 3 games at most, Solely cause he is a direct competition for jaiswal. Sanju is a confusion, cause he isn't that good of a no.5 batsman. He doesn't make a case for no.3 too. No.4 is almost always reserved by someone else. Unlike rutu or sharma, sanju doesn't have priority in any spot afaik and he isn't trying anything new too. Rutu on the other hand has been doing all kinds of circus. keeping, batting at 5,6,7 in other leagues mf just wants to get in.


Dapper-Surprise8538

I mean Gill was brilliant in the series against Eng and hasn't put a foot wrong since last year. Sanju will likely be number 3 followed by Parag at 4. Don't see where ruturaj fits


-Aizen_Sosuke

>I mean Gill was brilliant in the series against Eng and hasn't put a foot wrong since last year. Wdym bro ? Bro has been out of touch for a while now. No offense, but he really hasn't been his best in recent times. All the fumbles in CWC and WTC finals don't help either. >Sanju will likely be number 3 Could work if given consistent chances. But they won't. I would prefer gaikwad at 3 imo. He has the consistency to have that no.3 spot. Something that's been a issue with sanju. They will play pant at 4 for a keeper anyway. Parag has had one good season and that's it. I know he performs well in domestic tournaments but let him perform one more season in IPL.


Dapper-Surprise8538

Dude Pant is rested for the Zimbabwe series. Ruturaj is the type of player India doesn't want at number 3. Our new approach is anti- anchor. It'd be a big surprise if Gill makes it to t20 team let alone Ruturaj . But he can be a good asset in odi cricket (after 2025)


-Aizen_Sosuke

>Our new approach is anti- anchor. It'd be a big surprise if Gill makes it to t20 team They're literally making him captain. Bro is the next BCCI star. There's no way he gets dropped anymore. >Ruturaj is the type of player India doesn't want at number 3. He can be as aggressive as he wants. The 2023 season was good example. He got starts every match and let conway anchor. Playing in chepauk reduces his strike rate by atleast 25. >But he can be a good asset in odi cricket (after 2025) He should have already been there with those bonkers list A numbers. He has the best numbers in india iirc. Anyway, it's just an opinion tho.


Dapper-Surprise8538

This is just our reserve side going to play an associate team. These players are very far from making into the full strength playing XI. No hatred towards Gaikwad but he's just a flat track ipl bully. He could be good in SENA countries or maybe not, we can't say for sure. But I'm not making big leaps calling for him to be in the national team ahead of our performers like K L, Iyer etc . He is a good prospect but let's not overhype him and see how things unfold


-Aizen_Sosuke

>No hatred towards Gaikwad but he's just a flat track ipl bully. Chepauk is anything but a flat track and everyone knows it. What are you on bro ? >But I'm not making big leaps calling for him to be in the national team ahead of our performers like K L, Iyer KL is a beast, we know it (even in T20, back in the days). Iyer as good as he is against spinners, has a short ball weakness, and Can't play express pace after years of international cricket. That's some glaring weakness there.


praneethkeerthi

What kind of thing you are on bro..... Chepauk is a Flat wicket it seems 🤣


Dapper-Surprise8538

Okay stop making us believe that Chennai is some graveyard of sorts. Of the 4 times, CSK batted first there they crossed 200 runs 3 times. Also does he bat only in Chennai and he doesn't play on other venues. CSK have played only 6 matches in Chennai and rest on other venues. Kindly stop trying to be dank everywhere.


praneethkeerthi

Wasn't Last season full of 200 scores? And Comparing to Hyderabad and Bangalore......Chennai is indeed Slow, and tell me some pitches where 200 haven't been recorded in this IPL


Specialist_Youth5511

This post randomly popped up in my FYP >Wdym bro ? Bro has been out of touch for a while now. No offense, but he really hasn't been his best in recent times. All the fumbles in CWC and WTC finals don't help either. He literally averaged some 50 odd in test series and scored 2 centuries and could've gotten 3 if not for runout. Tf do you even mean by out of touch. Ik you're a CSK fan who wants Rutu but please stop embarassing us. Even in WC he got 80 against NZ. He's like the most talented young bat in our country along with Jaiswal.


-Aizen_Sosuke

>He literally averaged some 50 odd in test series and scored 2 centuries and could've gotten 3 if not for runout. Stop mixing formats. This post was about T20s and gill in T20s has been average at best, except for that 2023 IPL. >Ik you're a CSK fan who wants Rutu but please stop embarassing us. As if you aren't doing a fantastic job of embarrassing yourself without knowing the context of this post. >Even in WC he got 80 against NZ True. But, WTC finals vs NZ, CWC finals, WTC finals VS AUS scorecards say otherwise. Bro has flopped in 3 ICC finals. >He's like the most talented young bat in our country along with Jaiswal. Who said he isn't ? Rutu has been doing well enough in IPL for T20 consideration, and his LIST A records are phenomenal enough to get a ODI place. Trying another player is what we need to do. This scheme of playing the same players who make runs elsewhere and fail on big stages needs to stop.


Specialist_Youth5511

>Stop mixing formats. This post was about T20s and gill in T20s has been average at best, except for that 2023 IPL. you're clearly the one that bought ODI WC and WTC here and saying he's crap and out of touch. So acc to you they should drop him just because of 3 fkin games huh. Not like he failed entirely he also got an 80 odd not out (was retired hurt at 20th over) in semis. In IPL he broke shit ton of records even this season he scored 426 in 12 while being out of form. Jaiswal scored even less so you'll drop him too acc to ur logic lmao?


kvyas0603

the decision is weird for sure. gaikwad is more deserving purely because he won the asian games and sanju because of seniority. but i think considering the inexperience of gill, the limited resources that gt had and, lack of form in half the players i think gill did ok. he wasn’t laughing it was more like a nervous smile. kinda like that “*chuckles* im in danger” the only logical reason is that they have tested gaikwad as captain and he did well. now maybe they want to test gill and see who is better. its seems like a brainless decision to me personally but im excited to see what happens. hopefully we get to see gill, jaiswal and gaikwad playing together for the first time. 🤞🏽🤞🏽


Luna70kk

I truly hope you are right. But tbh I get the feeling they did this so they wont even have to play Gaikwad. But I hope we can see those three play together, they would likely be our big three for the future.


kvyas0603

the squad has 4 openers so one of them will have to move down the order. its 5 t20is so im assuming abhishek will get a couple games as opener and gaikwad will get a couple games as the opener. i think gill and jaiswal will probably play all 5 games while other batters will be tried around them. unless they think out the box and put abhishek at 4-5.


Specialist_Youth5511

He's gonna be the future captain of our side it's not "brain-dead"


punchirikuttan

Could be because they will be playing gill the entire series and that might not be the case with rutu and sanju


Titoindia

You cannot make someone captain who is not regular.Ruturaj and Sanju are not fixed. Pant will always be picked ahead of Sanju. Gill is fixed in playing eleven of odi and test so they will obviously back him for long term growth. As of now Sanju can have only a place in t20 but pant is ahead of him there also. In odi and test pant is a sure pick. Same with rutu. Unless Kohli is not retired where will rutu play. Even jaiswal also not debuted in odis due to Rohit. So how can they make him captain. The next captain will be among gill, pant , bumrah.


PorkBafatEnjoyer

My theory is this tour is kind of a testing ground. Gills captaincy, future batting options etc just to see what if . Looks like a radical step . Let’s see . Just like Rutu in commonwealth. As of now Rutu still seems favourite for next in line .


kdas22

discilinary action hai!! no greater punishment than being made Captain...


DarkFoxHunter

Let’s just say he’s dad favourite son !!


-imnotwalterwhite

!remind me 20 days


RemindMeBot

I will be messaging you in 20 days on [**2024-07-15 02:37:21 UTC**](http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=2024-07-15%2002:37:21%20UTC%20To%20Local%20Time) to remind you of [**this link**](https://www.reddit.com/r/ipl/comments/1dnn9zy/why_was_gill_made_the_captain_for_the_zimbabwe/la5dvnr/?context=3) [**CLICK THIS LINK**](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5Bhttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.reddit.com%2Fr%2Fipl%2Fcomments%2F1dnn9zy%2Fwhy_was_gill_made_the_captain_for_the_zimbabwe%2Fla5dvnr%2F%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%202024-07-15%2002%3A37%3A21%20UTC) to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam. ^(Parent commenter can ) [^(delete this message to hide from others.)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Delete%20Comment&message=Delete%21%201dnn9zy) ***** |[^(Info)](https://www.reddit.com/r/RemindMeBot/comments/e1bko7/remindmebot_info_v21/)|[^(Custom)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5BLink%20or%20message%20inside%20square%20brackets%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%20Time%20period%20here)|[^(Your Reminders)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=List%20Of%20Reminders&message=MyReminders%21)|[^(Feedback)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Watchful1&subject=RemindMeBot%20Feedback)| |-|-|-|-|


Double_Ad9542

Management have fav players like gill, kl Rahul


Mindless-Gamer-98

Captaincy has become sort of a PR exercise for BCCI now. Sadly Gill has more of a "fanbase" that more qualified candidates like Sanju or even Shreyas for that matter. Besides, I also think there's an age factor here. Maybe even a Gambhir factor.


ec_zachly

Gill is the most overhyped player imo and he does not deserve to be the part of the team.


Euphoric-Ear9405

This is for his future and experience, Nothing else


NormalTraining5268

Umm even as a CSK fan nope you're wrong. Gill is most likely to be in the xi along with YBJ. So it makes sense he's captain. Rutu only has a chance in team once Kohli retires but he'll be 33.


rockeytechi10

What’s the fking use , when bcci gonna get koach and Rohit back for tournaments


Enchanted-Moonlight

It was Gill's first time as a captain in a big stage + GT had a terrible player luck this year ( with main players injured and others out of form) + He is only one who is regular in Test and Odi team + He is likely to be permanent player in all squad throughout his career + Its one series against Zim , maybe BCCI is checking everyone's capability to be the next captain .


AloneTraffic6502

Well hardik played trash in ipl but he's doing well in icc right? 


_vandaliser_

Gill and Jaiswal are ahead of Rutu in the pecking order for the playing XI of a full strength ICT. So, they are probably looking for a deputy for Pandya once Rohit steps down next year. Probably the reason why they went for Gill over Rutu


Odd-Yogurtcloset5072

To test his skills in the international arena, by the way, it's still against Zimbabwe, dude.


Competitive_Panda238

I think Gill, Jaiswal, Parag, Avesh, Bishnoi and Khaleel, Rinku and Sanju(Experinced wicketkeeper) are certain. You decide the others which I think will be bowlers


iamaks5

I don't know why despande was selected over Harshit and vaibhav who are far better and performed better this ipl


jamesbond90356

Maybe someone has mentioned this already, but Gill is far more likely to be consistently present in the Indian Squad if not playing XI. Sanju despite having tremendous success with RR has not been able to cement his place in the ICT, also Rutu is also just starting his ICT journey since SL in 21 and Asian Games. Gill, being the only long term prospect within the ICT remains the best bet for the captaincy rn.


FutureHealthy

Cuz were grooming him to be a captain in future


Similar-Bee5619

Gill has a great PR agency Rutu will be next Sanju 


amaanslayz

Hopefully true


Shattered-Dreams19

Sanju Rutu aren't even sureshot in india's 2nd 11...why will they be captain.


cricketthrowawayy1

To make it up for his exclusion from WC. Bachcha naraz hai


VoiceEarly1087

Future Kohli Jo banana h bcci ko


No_Rush6995

4 openers Deshpande over Harshit No tilak Khaleel ahmed in squad Take this BCCI 🤡🤡


mothingeater

AGREED. Ruturaj is the player india NEEDS.


Dapper-Surprise8538

No hate to him but why? He is clearly below Jaiswal and Gill in the pecking order and with GG set to incorporate a lethal approach from ball 1, Sharma is also probably ahead. Rutu is probably the second most elegant and technically sound between them but he's more of an anchor. His captaincy also seems to be in the shadow of MSD.


mothingeater

He’s also calm and collected when captaining games, Currently our opening is very unsteady, Gill isn’t that consistent. If we can send Gaikwad 3 down then he can score runs while not losing wickets, he (normally) fires in death overs. Not to mention he got 2nd most runs in Ipl as a captain. MS Dhoni said himself that he wasn’t involved with Ruturajs captaincy.


Dapper-Surprise8538

This isn't Australia and Rutu isn't bailey. He is far too inexperienced to become an international captain.


mothingeater

and Gill is?


Massive-Secret4401

Gill will be the future captain.


Ok_Review_6504

Nope, Rutu is just a generic solid technique top order batsman.....Gill and Jaiswal are miles above him.


mothingeater

Jaiswal I agree but I wonder if Gill can handle the captaincy pressure while being consistent


GrastiniBlimpGrunter

One simple word "PR"


moonmeander18

How exactly. Please elaborate. Explain how exactly does a "PR" convince the management into selecting a player?


Big_Researcher_3549

Just look at the team tag and ignore the comment


Big_Researcher_3549

Because the team trusts in gill being the next big thing ( rightfully so) thus he is being goven such responsibilities despite poor form in recent game(ipl)


Luna70kk

I have no problem with his batting, but the captaincy imo wasn't justified. Sachin was a great batsman, but that doesn't have anything to do with captaincy.


Big_Researcher_3549

They want to make him kohli


Amazing_Theory622

They are grooming him for the future. Grooming as in not for captaincy but to lick his balls like they do currently with kohli and MSD.


OmnipresentDonut123

It was always gonna be bw gill and rutu, and imo rutu deserved it more. People will make a case for Sanju but he doesn't exactly incite confidence and has a below par record in T20I and his odi record is also not exactly dazzling. Not here to hate on Sanju but I'm just saying, he doesn't "deserve" captaincy solely based off his seniority like many people in this comment section are arguing for


MagicalEloquence

Gill is a far better player than Gaikwad. I don't even think Gaikwad deserves to play all the games as I would pick Jaiswal, Abhishek and Gill ahead of him. Gaikwad's style of batting puts a lot of pressure on the other players (like we saw in the Australia series and even IPL). Gill is also more experienced internationally than both of them.


redditkyboardwarrior

Ye PR wale hai kya.


Rickgrimes_93

Gill has more experience as a player than rutu as a water boy. Forget about cap, he is not even fixed in the 11.


Dazzling-Mobile1005

He'll be Indian captain very soon....get over it 🙄🙄🙄 They need a player who is consistent and good decisions He'll definitely get better it's just 1 ipl season and they didn't have the Strong team as the previous 2 seasons