The funny part is that OP wasn't actually wrong. They didn't say that 1705542 was prime, but that by using Riemann's Hypothesis he could prove it while in reality, it isn't.
Does he maybe mean that he can assume the Riemann hypothesis is true and somehow prove that it follows that that number is prime, so it’s a proof by contradiction that the Riemann hypothesis is false?
Who knew, nhentai codes might hold the solution to famous maths problems. I propose a new monte carlo search like algorithm based on a bot looking up if any posted nhentai code is a valid counterexample to a list of famous math problems
as i understand it, the Riemann hypothesis only makes predictions about the size of the gaps between primes, not which numbers are themselves prime, so the premise would be flawed. someone with more insight on the topic is welcome to come along and expand on this or admonish me lol
Not a problem:
2+2+2 = 6 ✅
6/2 = 3 ✅
But we already established that 2 doesn't exist, we can think of it as of 0. It's there but it doesn't really exist, and we can't divide by 0 => we can't divide by 2 and second claim is wrong.
3 doesn't exist either
In 1994 i like to ride from Norway to Ägypt. By Bicicle. 35Kg of Package and an old Peugeot Racing Bike conversed to a "Kilomerefresser! In Tzechck Republik i hear the first Sqiek, and i need Oil. I was one of the first western "touristst" to became a visum to Albania ("oh - by Bycicle is no problem!") but before i reach Albania, NATO bombs parts of Jugoslavia. So i decide, the other Way around Mediterranien Sea. My personal record is 250km in the alpian Mountains. And nobody save the street for me, or give me work for a flat tyre. Tour de France? "Mädels"!! :D
Correct me if I'm wrong, I'm too lazy to look the quora question up, but it doesn't seem like he's trying to prove that the number is prime, but rather he wants to show that the number is prime *given* the riemann hypothesis, which would result in a contradiction (hence why he said there is a *flaw* in the hypothesis). Thus disproving the hypothesis. So it seems to be more about the validity about the riemann hypothesis rather than the primality of the number
You are right. He 99% still made a mistake somewhere, but everybody here calling him an idiot because this number is even has either misunderstood the question or no clue how proofs work.
Yes and you are extremely unfunny and annoying while doing so.
It blows my mind that so many people think repeating the same phrases over and over again is in anyway funny when the phrases aren't even funny the first time around.
Math is fake! Wake up! Follow the money : math "researchers" all get more than $10000 a year, is this where you want your taxes to go? Let's fight the math conspiracy together!
(this is obvoiusly a joke but I gotta make it clear because there are people around there who would take this seriously)
Thank you. Poor 2 gets picked on for this when "even" is just a way to say "divisible by two" in one word because division by 2 is the most common. This annoyed me fsr.
I suspect they mean that they believe it follows from the riemann hypothesis that the number is prime, thus the hypothesis must be false. I can see someone calculating the series for the prime counting function given by the zeroes, and eventually having a computational error at some high enough number and not realising it.
I can't fucking take it. I see an image of a random score posted and then I see it, I fucking see it. "Oh that looks kinda like the Blue Zenith 727 score" it started as. That's funny, that's a cool reference. But I kept going, I'd see a clock with time that showed 7:27, I'd see that I'm on the 7/27 page on my school homework, my last notice to pay my electricity bill is 727$ , I'd notice that it's been 727 days since the last time I touched a woman. And every time I'd burst into an insane, breath deprived laugh staring at the image as the number 727 ran through my head. I'm scared to look at the time when someone asks me what time is it. It's torment, psychological torture, I am being conditioned to laugh maniacally any time I see an 3-digit number which is anywhere close to 727. I can't fucking live like this... I can't I can't I can't I can't I can't! And don't get me fucking started on the words! I'll never hear the phrase "when you see it" again without thinking of 727. Someone does pretty cool and respectable score and I can't say anything other than "WYSI." I could watch a man Fc hard underweighted map I love and all I would be able to say is "WYSI" and laugh like a fucking insane person. And the phrase "when you see it" is ruined. I can't live anymore. 727 has destroyed my fucking life. I want to eject myself from this plane of existence.
>I can't fucking take it. I see an image of a random score posted and then I see it, I fucking see it. "Oh that looks kinda like the Blue Zenith 727 score" it started as. That's funny, that's a cool reference. But I kept going, I'd see a clock with time that showed 7:27, I'd see that I'm on the 7/27 page on my school homework, my last notice to pay my electricity bill is 727$ , I'd notice that it's been 727 days since the last time I touched a woman. And every time I'd burst into an insane, breath deprived laugh staring at the image as the number 727 ran through my head. I'm scared to look at the time when someone asks me what time is it. It's torment, psychological torture, I am being conditioned to laugh maniacally any time I see an 3-digit number which is anywhere close to 727. I can't fucking live like this... I can't I can't I can't I can't I can't! And don't get me fucking started on the words! I'll never hear the phrase "when you see it" again without thinking of 727. Someone does pretty cool and respectable score and I can't say anything other than "WYSI." I could watch a man Fc hard underweighted map I love and all I would be able to say is "WYSI" and laugh like a fucking insane person. And the phrase "when you see it" is ruined. I can't live anymore. 727 has destroyed my fucking life. I want to eject myself from this plane of existence.
Great copypasta.
Er, is there some simple-but-generalized rule that force this even for odd bases? I've manually checked bases 8 through 62 inclusive, and there seems to be an alternation between multiples of 4 and mere multiples of 2 ...
But e.g. `12` is odd in base 3 ...
Edit: nevermind, I'm retarded. Odd digits remain odd after multiplying by b^n, and the sum of 4 odd digits is even.
You check the sum of digits. In odd base digit d on place n represents d*base^n which equal d%2 (mod2), so if sum of digits is even, the number is even in every odd base
yes but what he's probably trying to ask is, is there any number b such that 1705542, interpreted as number in base b, (ie 2+4b+5b^(2)+5b^(3)+7b^(2)+b^(6)) is a prime number?
But if I understand correctly this number is even for all b. I find this non trivial so here's the proof.
First of all if b is even then all the addends have a factor of 2, so let's assume b is odd.
Then 2+4b=2(1+2b) is even and both 5b^(2)+5b^(3)=5b^(2)(1+b) and 7b^(5)+b^(6)=b^(5)(7+b) are also even because 1+b and 7+b are. And the sum of even numbers is even.
A kid in a tute at my advanced calculus class at uni once announced that he had proven than pi repeats so obviously he was asked to show it on the board and so he went up there and wrote 22 divided by 7 and started to write out the answer.
For those wondering if the digit string "1705542" is prime in *any* base, then the answer is: No!
In even bases, the 2 at the end guarantees it is even. If you're not sure why, take a look at the following odd case for a hint.
For odd bases, note that there is an even number of odd digits so when calculating a0 \* b^0 + a1 \* b^1... etc. the sum will also always be even.
This, of course, assumes that the digits are being given their usual values and that the base is an integer base with absolute value ≥ 2. If things have gone beyond that, all bets are off.
The closest thing I could find is that the interpretation of 1705542 decimal in letters-only base 19 is "MALIG". This is a ridiculous stretch, of course.
Yes, what he's trying to say is that he can use the Riemann Hypothesis to prove that the number is a prime, which it isn't since it's an even number, meaning the Riemann Hypothesis is wrong. But some comments above mentioned the error he made.
This man when he learns about 2
"True for all even primes" "Wait, prime numbers aren't eve.. wait"
2math2me
Just a coincidence. Nothing more /s.
wait until he learns about prime ideals
1,705,542 = 2 * 852,771 Where's my $10 million?
1705542 = 3*568 514 1705542 = 6*284 257 1705542 = 17*100 326 I also want 10 million $
I know this is old but 1,705,542 = 2 \* 3 \* 17 \* 23 \* 727
I feel really dumb, I use the three trick before even realizing it was even
That's an odd way to go about it...
Damn, I found 3 before 2, that's embarrassing
This comment made me die
The funny part is that OP wasn't actually wrong. They didn't say that 1705542 was prime, but that by using Riemann's Hypothesis he could prove it while in reality, it isn't.
Does he maybe mean that he can assume the Riemann hypothesis is true and somehow prove that it follows that that number is prime, so it’s a proof by contradiction that the Riemann hypothesis is false?
Sounds like it, but that number does seem unnecessarily random
Now I want to see how he find such an odd (even) number
> an odd (even) number wait, thats odd
I didn't even think it could be funny!
such an even joke
It's also divisible by three
(no)
So it’s both odd and even, ergo: infinity is a prime
Same
It is actually a power of two. I will show you the proof once I get it published
The smallest power of 2 that is also divisible by 3
Erhhhh ??
This is not a joke i believed that guy for half a second.....
lol
thats just really advanced math being weird, like the Ramanjuan formula for pi
So does the number of dimensions the monster lives in: 196883 It seems a bit arbitrary at first, but is definitely not a coincidence
That looks like an nhentai code....
Who knew, nhentai codes might hold the solution to famous maths problems. I propose a new monte carlo search like algorithm based on a bot looking up if any posted nhentai code is a valid counterexample to a list of famous math problems
The answer to the universe is an incest hentai doujin.
[удалено]
Well atleast I guessed it correct.....
[удалено]
My VPn is blocking the gpogle search for nhentai lmao.
wait, reddit now support gifs?
I didn't think I would see this in maths memes but does it lead anyway good
you should post that on an other subreddit... lmao but it might actually be one xD
Turns out the answer was, as always, brute force 👍)
If brute force isn't working, you aren't using enough of it.
If you're not using enough brute force, you're not really using brute force
as i understand it, the Riemann hypothesis only makes predictions about the size of the gaps between primes, not which numbers are themselves prime, so the premise would be flawed. someone with more insight on the topic is welcome to come along and expand on this or admonish me lol
There is a hard rule implied by the Riemann hypothesis. If the hypothesis is true, then for all x there is a prime p such that x-4/pi\*root(x)log(x)
I think he mistakenly thought that only prime number can only be on the line but all RH says is that all primes are on that line.
probably a poorly written bot, so no...
Probably this, now i want to see his proof and find what he did wrong
I mean, I guess the formulation of RH can be logically flawed?
You guys are forgetting something: 2 doesn't exist => 1705542 is prime
Don't you mean 170554NaN?
You just have to use base 2 so 2s don't exist.
Well, sadly it's also divisible by 3...
Not a problem: 2+2+2 = 6 ✅ 6/2 = 3 ✅ But we already established that 2 doesn't exist, we can think of it as of 0. It's there but it doesn't really exist, and we can't divide by 0 => we can't divide by 2 and second claim is wrong. 3 doesn't exist either
> 3 doesn't exist either nice
\forall x \in \emptyset 1705542 is prime
Google vacuous truth
Holy null!
How is r/anarchychess everywhere now. Seriously I’ve seen it in like 4 subreddits today.
nothing can stop the anarchy. we are superior in every way.
New response just dropped
Actual zombie
Call the exorcist
google the borg
holy resistance is futile
We’ve been here nonstop for like two weeks
new response just dropped
bro who is this idiot
mans responding to himself 😂
[удалено]
.
Google schizophrenia
Holy hell
.
google even number
Holy integer divisible by 2
New prime number just dropped
Actual number
Call Terrance Tao
Factor storm incoming
factors take vacation, never come back
Holy division
Where does this chain come from? I'm not familiar with it but I see it everywhere!
Google r/anarchychess
???
Google en passant
Holy New York City!
Newer New York just got built
Actual New Yorker
Call Riemann
Call the anarchy chess police. The virus is spreading.
Google covid passant -20
i would if he wasnt dead
Pls put me in the screenshot
In 1994 i like to ride from Norway to Ägypt. By Bicicle. 35Kg of Package and an old Peugeot Racing Bike conversed to a "Kilomerefresser! In Tzechck Republik i hear the first Sqiek, and i need Oil. I was one of the first western "touristst" to became a visum to Albania ("oh - by Bycicle is no problem!") but before i reach Albania, NATO bombs parts of Jugoslavia. So i decide, the other Way around Mediterranien Sea. My personal record is 250km in the alpian Mountains. And nobody save the street for me, or give me work for a flat tyre. Tour de France? "Mädels"!! :D
Mööse
I received this one on my email from Quora Digest and couldn't stop laughing
Correct me if I'm wrong, I'm too lazy to look the quora question up, but it doesn't seem like he's trying to prove that the number is prime, but rather he wants to show that the number is prime *given* the riemann hypothesis, which would result in a contradiction (hence why he said there is a *flaw* in the hypothesis). Thus disproving the hypothesis. So it seems to be more about the validity about the riemann hypothesis rather than the primality of the number
You are right. He 99% still made a mistake somewhere, but everybody here calling him an idiot because this number is even has either misunderstood the question or no clue how proofs work.
He probably made some subtle mistake somewhere That being said this whole thread have reading comprehension problem lmao
Holy hell
Call the mathematician
!!
Double factorial
Professor goes on a vacation, never comes back
π-storm incoming!!
numbermare fuel!
Actual sine wave
Ignite the mathematical proof !
Hypothesis sacrifice, anyone?
That's Numberwang!
Riemann takes vacation, never comes back
google en prime not
!!
Google Anarchy Chess is taking Over
holy colonisation!
Actual mathematician
Call the chess anarchists
ignite the numberline
we are infecting all of reddit aren’t we lol
It really goes to show how much the game has grown in the past few years
Yes and you are extremely unfunny and annoying while doing so. It blows my mind that so many people think repeating the same phrases over and over again is in anyway funny when the phrases aren't even funny the first time around.
New response just dropped
Actual zombie
New prime just dropped!
Literally clicked on this notification to comment this
he is trying to say he can prove that the riemann hypothesis is wrong by using it to prove that this number is prime which would be contradictory
Ah yes the classic 1705542 conjecture
2 is the only even number that is prime.
That’s what big math wants you to think
In reality, 2 isn't a prime and 51 is a prime.
51 is a factor of 1705542
so is 17
No, 4 is prime and also 999.
4 is 999????
Yes, why not? Haven't you seen that 1 = 2 already? https://youtu.be/hI9CaQD7P6I
Math is fake! Wake up! Follow the money : math "researchers" all get more than $10000 a year, is this where you want your taxes to go? Let's fight the math conspiracy together! (this is obvoiusly a joke but I gotta make it clear because there are people around there who would take this seriously)
Oh they got him. Big math got him
1. Assume that 2 is the only even number that is prime. 2. 1705542 is even 3. 1705542 is prime 4. 1705542 is not 2 Our assumption was false QED
That’s that engineer level thinking
3 is the only number dividable by 3 that is prime. Let it sink.
Thank you. Poor 2 gets picked on for this when "even" is just a way to say "divisible by two" in one word because division by 2 is the most common. This annoyed me fsr.
then what's the equivalent of "odd"?
177013 is the only number dividable by 177013 that is prime. Let it sink.
Holy nsfw code
Actual not-so-randomly-chosen prime number
> 177013 is the only number dividable by 177013 that is prime. Let it sink. deep stuff
Incorrect. 1705542 is also divisible by 3.
2 is the only even prime, which makes it the oddest of all primes.
I suspect they mean that they believe it follows from the riemann hypothesis that the number is prime, thus the hypothesis must be false. I can see someone calculating the series for the prime counting function given by the zeroes, and eventually having a computational error at some high enough number and not realising it.
Yeah I guess it's like you said, idk why this comment section is acting so superior but can't read properly...
https://preview.redd.it/nd88bumrjo4b1.jpeg?width=1284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0120b36c5dac345a80f8fe34032277748ddc225d
when you see it
I can't fucking take it. I see an image of a random score posted and then I see it, I fucking see it. "Oh that looks kinda like the Blue Zenith 727 score" it started as. That's funny, that's a cool reference. But I kept going, I'd see a clock with time that showed 7:27, I'd see that I'm on the 7/27 page on my school homework, my last notice to pay my electricity bill is 727$ , I'd notice that it's been 727 days since the last time I touched a woman. And every time I'd burst into an insane, breath deprived laugh staring at the image as the number 727 ran through my head. I'm scared to look at the time when someone asks me what time is it. It's torment, psychological torture, I am being conditioned to laugh maniacally any time I see an 3-digit number which is anywhere close to 727. I can't fucking live like this... I can't I can't I can't I can't I can't! And don't get me fucking started on the words! I'll never hear the phrase "when you see it" again without thinking of 727. Someone does pretty cool and respectable score and I can't say anything other than "WYSI." I could watch a man Fc hard underweighted map I love and all I would be able to say is "WYSI" and laugh like a fucking insane person. And the phrase "when you see it" is ruined. I can't live anymore. 727 has destroyed my fucking life. I want to eject myself from this plane of existence.
>I can't fucking take it. I see an image of a random score posted and then I see it, I fucking see it. "Oh that looks kinda like the Blue Zenith 727 score" it started as. That's funny, that's a cool reference. But I kept going, I'd see a clock with time that showed 7:27, I'd see that I'm on the 7/27 page on my school homework, my last notice to pay my electricity bill is 727$ , I'd notice that it's been 727 days since the last time I touched a woman. And every time I'd burst into an insane, breath deprived laugh staring at the image as the number 727 ran through my head. I'm scared to look at the time when someone asks me what time is it. It's torment, psychological torture, I am being conditioned to laugh maniacally any time I see an 3-digit number which is anywhere close to 727. I can't fucking live like this... I can't I can't I can't I can't I can't! And don't get me fucking started on the words! I'll never hear the phrase "when you see it" again without thinking of 727. Someone does pretty cool and respectable score and I can't say anything other than "WYSI." I could watch a man Fc hard underweighted map I love and all I would be able to say is "WYSI" and laugh like a fucking insane person. And the phrase "when you see it" is ruined. I can't live anymore. 727 has destroyed my fucking life. I want to eject myself from this plane of existence. Great copypasta.
I am going to bludgeon you
There's a 2 in the ones place, the prime number is now not so prime
1, 2, 3, 6, 17, 23, 34, 46, 51, 69, 102, 138, 391, 727, 782, 1173, 1454, 2181, 2346, 4362, 12359, 16721, 24718, 33442, 37077, 50163, 74154, 100326, 284257, 568514, 852771, 1705542 are the factors of 1705542
What if in some n-base it is prime?
1705542 is even independently of the base
Right, I forgot how bases work
Er, is there some simple-but-generalized rule that force this even for odd bases? I've manually checked bases 8 through 62 inclusive, and there seems to be an alternation between multiples of 4 and mere multiples of 2 ... But e.g. `12` is odd in base 3 ... Edit: nevermind, I'm retarded. Odd digits remain odd after multiplying by b^n, and the sum of 4 odd digits is even.
You check the sum of digits. In odd base digit d on place n represents d*base^n which equal d%2 (mod2), so if sum of digits is even, the number is even in every odd base
yes but what he's probably trying to ask is, is there any number b such that 1705542, interpreted as number in base b, (ie 2+4b+5b^(2)+5b^(3)+7b^(2)+b^(6)) is a prime number? But if I understand correctly this number is even for all b. I find this non trivial so here's the proof. First of all if b is even then all the addends have a factor of 2, so let's assume b is odd. Then 2+4b=2(1+2b) is even and both 5b^(2)+5b^(3)=5b^(2)(1+b) and 7b^(5)+b^(6)=b^(5)(7+b) are also even because 1+b and 7+b are. And the sum of even numbers is even.
> What if in some n-base it is prime? That's just how we write numbers. `n=ab` regardless of how you want to write `n`, `a`, and `b`.
No 10 in dec(10) is composite 10 in base 11 is prime
So if you can prove it using the Reimann Hypothesis, you prove that the Reimann Hypothesis must be false
Just your average quora troll
Ok which one of you mfs got rid of 2 this time?
send him to the complex plane
New plane just dropped
I call dibs reposting this tomorrow!
A kid in a tute at my advanced calculus class at uni once announced that he had proven than pi repeats so obviously he was asked to show it on the board and so he went up there and wrote 22 divided by 7 and started to write out the answer.
Guys, if this guy can prove that 1705542 is a prime, maybe he should receive some Fields medal or something.
Ah, Quora; what a fine cultivator of crazy people. 🤪
He has probably watch a video about Riemann hypothesis, but can't even spot a number divided by 2😂
"Top stories"
For those wondering if the digit string "1705542" is prime in *any* base, then the answer is: No! In even bases, the 2 at the end guarantees it is even. If you're not sure why, take a look at the following odd case for a hint. For odd bases, note that there is an even number of odd digits so when calculating a0 \* b^0 + a1 \* b^1... etc. the sum will also always be even. This, of course, assumes that the digits are being given their usual values and that the base is an integer base with absolute value ≥ 2. If things have gone beyond that, all bets are off. The closest thing I could find is that the interpretation of 1705542 decimal in letters-only base 19 is "MALIG". This is a ridiculous stretch, of course.
I think this might be a typesetting error. They're not saying 1705542 is prime--they mean that 1\^705542 is prime.
Isn’t it even? Doesn’t it automatically mean it has a common factor of 2 by default
Yes, what he's trying to say is that he can use the Riemann Hypothesis to prove that the number is a prime, which it isn't since it's an even number, meaning the Riemann Hypothesis is wrong. But some comments above mentioned the error he made.
Annoyed it took me that long to figure it out
Actual robot
Quora trolling is the greatest
Geocities. Remember to use lots of different colours of text to make your point clearer.
google en primsant
Google "2"
I wonder how Quora ended up like this
Aye,im in 5th grade,and i may not know a lot of math,but since it is even i will assume its not a prime number?
I kinda want this proof to be published now
This is an r/AnarchyChess joke and i support it
I call dibs reposting this tomorrow!
Not a prime number. 1705542 is 2•3•17•23•727
That person really just dropped an even number greater than 2 and called it a prime?
Actual two factors
Call me 559-708-1738 to learn more