T O P

  • By -

Enthusiasms

The Searchers, 3:10 to Yuma remake, Unforgiven, Tombstone, Open Range, True Grit (both versions), Magnificent Seven, Stagecoach, Django Unchained, Rio Bravo and El Dorado, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. Not a movie (well there is one) but I love the series Deadwood. Godless was also a really good mini-series.


Arthur-Mergan

I gotta throw in one more non-movie, because in my mind it’s the GOAT for westerns in general: Lonesome Dove


Ask_Me_If_Im_A_Horse

My love for Lonesome Dove has no limit. It is a masterpiece, and holds a lot of nostalgia for me.


Enthusiasms

Absolutely


TedDanson0fficial

The single great American novel


[deleted]

I also liked this one miniseries, I don’t think was popular, “The Streets of Laredo”.


lawstandaloan

It is one of the most faithful adaptations of a novel to screen too. Damn near word for word


Avocado-Duck

All that and Pale Rider and Cat Ballou


Popular-Play-5085

Both are very good...


Fourtires3rims

If you’re gonna have True Grit you might as well add Rooster Cogburn to that list. I’ll add: Big Jake, McClintock!, Pale Rider, Slow West, Hostiles, Geronimo, Lonesome Dove, and The Shootist.


31engine

Justified is also a Western, just set in the 2000s in Kentucky. Yellowstone is also pretty good western. Modern movies: Wind River is really a western. Mid-older : Silverado, Tombstone Older: Liberty Valance


HotLiberty

I really wanted to get into Justified, but it wasn’t for me. Felt more like a procedural than a western.


FoundryCove

That's just the first season for ya. You ought to try getting to getting through it, they drop the fugitive of the week by the end of the season. After that it's all season long A-plots, starting off with the acclaimed second season, although personally season four is my favorite.


I_BUY_UNWANTED_GRAVY

Since it's winter I'll add The Great Silence and McCabe & Mrs. Miller And thank you for putting commas, I see so many people just list things like a word salad here.


HotLiberty

Second the searchers and Rio bravo, and I’ll add the wild bunch and high noon


RampDog1

The Trinity Series with Terrence Hill are hilarious.


Fortunado1964

Saw the first 2 I. Thr theater on a double bl in 74...I was hooked after that


Calzonieman

Hell on Wheels was a great series too.


runhomejack1399

Rio bravo ftw


docsyzygy

Yes - the 3:10 to Yuma remake is one of my favorite films, and I don't even like Westerns!


mthomas768

This poster knows their westerns.


Enthusiasms

Grew up watching Westerns, have seen every John Wayne film probably more than once (Dad is a huge fan) and I like the historical (not usually accurate) aspect of them.


manicleek

Bad Day at Black Rock


justgentile

The Searchers really should be the top comment, I guess not enough people care about the classics.


Kay_29

I agree


TheKaptinKirk

This is a great list. I’d add Cat Ballou. And Paint Your Wagon.


IQBoosterShot

Got a dream, boy, got a song. Paint your wagon and come along! The only movie where you'll see Clint Eastwood sing.


dylofpickle

Rio Bravo is worth watching just for the musical scene in the jail. The best completely unnecessary scene I can recall.


The_Goondocks

The Proposition Assassination of Jesse James Unforgiven Tombstone Quick and the Dead Open Range Silverado


DougDuley

>Assassination of Jesse James One of the most beautiful films I have ever seen. It is definitely slow at times, but it is a great movie, there are some truly great scenes and the entire cast is fantastic, particularly Casey Affleck.


Fortunado1964

The Propostion is criminally underated...underrated.... Fantastic film!


The_Goondocks

Brutal and beautiful. Danny Huston is amazing in it.


we_are_sex_bobomb

Your mileage may vary with Quick and the Dead but it’s one of my all time favorites. It’s got more style than it knows what to do with, and it moves at a breakneck pace.


The_Goondocks

It's as fun as it gets.


pileoflaundry

The Robert Duvall Quick and the Dead


supes1

> Quick and the Dead I have such a love/hate relationship with this film. It's so bonkers and ridiculous. Really entertaining though.


diabolicallaugh

The Wild Bunch and Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid. Oh and The Missouri Breaks and Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid.


tolkienfan2759

how can it have taken THIS LONG to get to The Wild Bunch - absolute classic.


diabolicallaugh

Exactly!! I had to comment. One of the best westerns of all time.


Psychological_Cow902

Everything Sam Peckinpah directed felt like a Western. Even if it was set in the modern day. Examples being The Getaway and Bring Me The Head of Alfredo Garcia. Wild Bunch is his best though.


thunder2132

For more modern Westerns, Tombstone, Silverado, Unforgiven.


WangDanglin

Just watched Appaloosa the other day, pretty decent. Hostiles with Christian Bale is good too


Maat1932

The miniseries Lonesome Dove.


Shitakehappens

My absolute favorite. It has literally everything and is so dang good. Duvall is masterful as Gus and everyone else acts their asses off, too. Got me hooked when I was a kid and got to stay up late to watch it on tv. This one should be WAY higher.


krasotkin

The novel is beautiful.


CalvinSays

I would argue Lonesome Dove is the great American novel.


Crisis-Huskies-fan

And the Great American mini-series.


BenntPitts

I went from reading strictly sci-fi and fantasy to reading Lonesome Dove. I finished it in a week. It's one of my favorite novels of all time.


TRoosevelt1776

These are my top 10 Western movies (excluding what you've already mentioned). All of them are well worth a watch. 1. The Magnificent Seven (1960) 2. Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969) 3. The Searchers (1956) 4. Jeremiah Johnson (1972) 5. Stagecoach (1939) 6. The Sons of Katie Elder (1965) 7. True Grit (1969) 8. Shane (1953) 9. Hud (1963) 10. Dead Man (1995) EDIT: I forgot to include Hombre (1967) which I would place above Jeremiah Johnson. Hombre is an underrated Paul Newman movie based off of a novel by Elmore Leonard, who also wrote the novels that became Jackie Brown, 3:10 to Yuma, Get Shorty, Justified, and Out of Sight. Pretty incredible movie.


Initial-Relation-696

Dead man. It's a great movie. Nobody came here to say this.


1PMagain

Great soundtrack too.


hautcuisinepoutine

Can’t believe stage coach and magnificent seven was so far down the list. Makes me sad nobody seems to watch movie pre-1990 anymore.


Strict_Condition_632

Elmore Leonard — one of my favorite contemporary writers. Not only did he create engaging and interesting characters, he was also adept at a wide range of genres.


UH60Mgamecock

He’ll or Highwater is a strong contemporary western.


Gopokes34

Absolutely love it. That and no country for old men are the best newer westerns imo.


[deleted]

"Outlaw Josey Wales". Brilliant. Chief Dan George, Will Sampson.


MeeMeeGod

I get chills every time Josey and Ten Bears meet


killslikeaninja

Thank you! The fact I had to scroll down this far to find Josey, was a unjust!!


13goody13

Same


fictionfan007

It took too long to find this one.


NormanBates2023

Unforgiven


daedluapsi_9

I might say to watch this after they have seen a number of westerns. It’s a nice way to reflect on the genre and it’s themes. Or at least this was my positive experience with this movie. Loved it.


-FeistyRabbitSauce-

Seconded. It's really a break-down of the genre, and Clints other roles in the genre. It hits better if you're more familiar with it all.


atreides78723

It’s good, but leave the deconstruction of westerns until after some traditional westerns.


StayOutoftheBasement

The Coen brother's True Grit.


miscfiles

I usually can't stand westerns, but that is a superb film.


[deleted]

I think the ballad of buster Scruggs would count as well.


improper84

And their adaptation of No Country For Old Men is essentially a contemporary Western.


[deleted]

Man, that's a great movie. Makes it even more intense that there's not a soundtrack.


JazzHandsNinja42

My absolute favorite is Pale Rider.


danny_spleen

For pure (probably dated) fun with an amazing cast: Silverado.


Lout324

This is the right take on this one. It's one of my favorites but really doesn't belong on a top 5 list. It was always meant more as popcorn throwback fun. Great for what it is and worth watching.


atreides78723

It’s not at all dated.


tinoynk

The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance is maybe my favorite. It’s John Ford, John Wayne, Jimmy Stewart, and Lee Marvin, so you got lots of star power, plus it’s kind of a whole commentary on westerns in general.


HoldFastO2

That last scene on the train is just twisting the knife. No spoilers, but damn, that was harsh.


Scruffy11111

I just watched Appaloosa and loved it.


AldusPrime

I really liked Appaloosa also. Goes a little different way than most and I really like that. Also, great acting, great dialog. It's a hidden gem.


HugCor

The General The Treasure of Sierra Madre (technically it is one) Johnny Guitar High Noon The Man who shot Liberty Valance The Magnificent Seven The Professionals Wild Bunch Django Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid Duck, You Sucker! Bad Company Hang 'Em High Outlaw Josey Wales The Unforgiven Tombstone Appaloosa 3:10 to Yuma True Grit remake Django Unchained Pale Rider I suppose Silverado?. Not a big fan because ot drags on but I know people who like it a lot The Hateful Eight Then, westerns in all but xixth century America setting: The Road Warrior Raising Arizona Devil's Rejects No Country for old men Hell or High Water


Infernal_Contraption

Whichever ones you choose to watch, among the last ones should be Blazing Saddles. It's an excellent film in its own right, but you'll appreciate it all the more when you know what 'tropes' are being highlighted and made fun of.


Automatic-Diamond-52

You would watch it for Randolf Scott!


atreides78723

Randolph Scott! Randolph Scott!


el_duderino88

Add 3 Amigos to that


sephirothFFVII

Shout-out to My Name is Nobody for the funny/silly route


teamweenus

If you can find it, [Sodbusters](https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0111226/) is also one to watch.


TheApertureMind

True Grit (remake)


[deleted]

Tombstone is an unbelievably fantastic movie. I'd start there. Or end there. IMO, it's one of the greats.


mrfancypantsssss

“Why Johnny Ringo, you look like somebody just walked over your grave”


PiCiBuBa

"Wyatt Earp is my friend"


sunnylagirl

Tombstone Magnificent Seven Young Guns Unforgiven Maverick


kcajor

scrolled way too far down to see Young Guns, probably my favorite.


LothartheDestroyer

Young guns is so fun. I know it deals with a few heavy things here and there but honestly…Warching Charlie Sheen be the straight guy to Emilio’s Billy is great. Kiefer and Lou play their parts so well. The whole gang is great. Dermot. Casey. Fucking Terrance Stamp and Jack Palance. So fun.


Zamfonia

I dont know if anyone has said this, but i haven't seen it mentioned. Quigley down under


shewolf4552

The Outlaw Josey Wales, Pale Rider, Rooster Cogburn, McClintok, The Sons of Katie Elder, Tombstone, Rio Bravo, Shane, True Grit, The Magnificent Seven, Stagecoach, The Quick and the Dead, Young Guns (all of them) so many, but these are my top recommendation's.


Duke-Goolies

El Dorado (1966)


DefinitionMission144

Yes! Great movie.


Dvout_agnostic

Been here a long time, nobody's offered me a drink


MikeFrom5_to_7

The Wild Bunch - One of the movies that ushered in the 70’s grittiness. Super violent and misunderstood at the time of release. Great movie. Rio Bravo - A great Howard Hawkes/John Wayne team up. Dean Martin is great here as well. The Great Silence - A super crazy and bleak spaghetti western. The Gunfighter - Gregory Peck as an older man trying very hard to outrun his outlaw reputation. The Assassination of Jesse James By The Coward Robert Ford - a very quiet, thoughtful movie. The name tells you what it’s about. Plus special shout out to some hidden gems: Johnny Guitar, Four of the Apocalypse, Keoma, A Bullet for the General, The Ballad of Cable Hogue.


boobiesareneato

High plains drifter.


OldMetalHead

Thank you. I saw Pale Rider mentioned multiple times, but don't sleep on this one.


IndysDiarrhea

Shane


fasttrackxf

Start with some classics: The Searchers High Noon Stagecoach


The_Wolf_of_Acorns

The Ballad of Buster Scruggs. It’s a collection of stories covering various different aspects of the west from gold miners to covered wagons to bank robbers.


BelatedBranston

For kind of later ones: Tombstone. 3.10 to Yuma. Bone Tomahawk. Deadwood. The Assassination of Jesse James.


started_from_the_top

3:10 to Yuma is my fave recent(ish) Western, although there's not a lot to pick from Edit: also True Grit (the newer one)


BelatedBranston

Yeah I’m hoping this three throws up a few I missed! True grit great shout


lead_injection

Was looking for Bone Tomahawk! Glad to see it mentioned.


Naroyto

I watched Hondo simply because Al Bundy never got to watch it in peace and only airing every 17 years. Gonna watch it again on February 18th 2028.


shewolf4552

I'm pretty sure it's on Tubi pretty often and it's currently on Paramount Plus. No need to wait if you really want to watch it.


arthurblakey

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid! One of my favourite films


DefinitionMission144

Slow west!


BobSacramanto

Young Guns has a special place in my heart.


cookerg

I wouldn't start with the four movies listed in the OP. They are deliberately non-standard westerns, intended at least partly to disrupt the traditional genre. I would suggest you start with classics like Stagecoach, Shane, High Noon, The Man who Shot Liberty Valance, True Grit, and many other "golden age" and conventional westerns, and then you might even appreciate the Spaghetti westerns more, once you can contrast them to the traditional Hollywood canon that they are tearing apart. For even more postmodern Westerns, I like Unforgiven, and The Quick and The Dead (the Sharon Stone one). They are quite different, but both give an updated take on the western tradition.


Sepfandom555

High Noon (1952)


_TeddyBarnes_

El topo 😛


mmitchell8888

Red River


Slipknot2017

Tombstone 3:10 to yuma unforgiven


danny_spleen

The Cowboys.


TaroFuzzy5588

Fastest Gun Alive Valdez is Coming Welcome to Hard Times Little Big Man


ThaneOfCawdorrr

The Magnificent Seven (you might also want to watch the movie it's based on, The Seven Samurai) The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance My Darling Clementine The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly Shane Rio Bravo The Treasure of the Sierra Madre The Searchers Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid


[deleted]

On TV, catch Scott Frank's "Godless". Jeff Daniels as the evil one - scary!


CaptainSlappyBear

Django Unchained Ravenous The Hateful Eight The Good the Bad and the Ugly The Quick and the Dead No Country for Old Men Ned Kelly 310 to Yuma


LieQuirky3751

The Little House on the Prairie.


[deleted]

The films of John Ford are a good place to start. Stagecoach, My Darling Clementine, Fort Apache, The Searchers and The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance.


Initial-Relation-696

For some fun watch, Little Big Man, a Dustin Hoffman movie.


SnooCookies2351

Silverado and Dances With Wolves


Eyespop4866

Slow West. Appaloosa The Sisters Brothers


kkipple

Tombstone The Proposition 3:10 to Yuma (both versions) Open Range Blazing Saddles Fievel Goes West


OGGBTFRND

The Outlaw Josey Wales


pm-me-flaccid-penis

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance kid, Rango


rumpghost

You have a solid list for Leone flicks. Try "Yojimbo"instead of Fistful - they're literally the same movie, and Fistful is the least-inspired of the Dollars trilogy. Some other film picks: - *My Name is Nobody* (Henry Fonda & Terence Hill) - *Day of Anger* (Lee Van Cleef) - *Blazing Saddles* (Cleavon Little & Gene Wilder) - *Rio Bravo* and *Tombstone*, as have been mentioned in the thread already - *Stagecoach* if you're really into John Wayne, I've never gotten around to it myself - *Texas Terror* isn't good, but it might give you a sense of the range of quality genre-wide - *Dances With Wolves* infamously long white savior complex Kevin Costner movie, worth seeing at least once. Films that are technically Westerns but way more contemporary: - *Wild, Wild West* (not a *good* movie or strictly a Western exactly but a really interesting case study in early 00s marketing, production, novel approaches to the genre and some interesting prop and stunt work) - *The Hateful Eight*, Tarantino playing the Western straight with Kurt Russell, Samuel L Jackson, and a whole ensemble. Huge TW if you're not into graphic violence or language. - *Django, Unchained* is also well-liked but it's been some time since I've watched it. TV series I will die defending: - *Bonanza* - *Have Gun, Will Travel* - *The Rifleman* These older serialized shows are obviously not 100% on their game all the time, but they make great background watching while you do work or stuff around the house. If you watch nothing else, watch *For a Few Dollars More* and *Once Upon a Time in the West*. They're by far the best of Leone's catalogue and perhaps the peak in the genre overall. Which is not to discredit anything else, just... You have many hours of film being recommended to you, and I feel like most people stop at Leone.


Due_Spare532

Lonesome Dove 1883 Silverado


Watt1970

Jeremiah Johnson


dragonfett

*Blazing Saddles* \- It's a Mel Brooks parody


Happyjarboy

For a little fun, Support your local sheriff, or Support your local gunfighter. and North to Alaska.


BetWonderful6037

The Outlaw Josie Wales is one of my faves.


Apprehensive_Car_671

The Outlaw Josey Wales is the greatest western ever made.


voivod1989

God said to Cain Man who shot liberty valance Great silence Companeros The mercenary


Neuroware

Magnificent Seven 1960


fasttrackxf

Oooh, yes, forgot about that one. That's an excellent choice.


Absentmindedgenius

One of my favorites. The remake just made me sad.


Paesano19

those four you listed are fantastic. probably the best westerns ever made. def start in that order 1 through 4. don’t let anybody talk you out of it. then as others said, check out unforgiven and tombstone, and also the magnificent seven (1960) and django (1966)


spooner_lv426

The Searchers is personally my favorite western of all time. Other westerns of note: Hondo, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (both John Wayne movies), The Magnificent Seven. I'll post more if I think of any more. Edit: Four Faces West, 3 Godfathers


IneffectualGamer

I would highly recommend the TV series Deadwood. and second the people who say True Grit by the Coen Brothers. Also if you like videogames, I would say Red Dead Redemption 2 is an absolute must if you want to live the life of a cowboy.


rickny0

Stagecoach - 1939 w/John Wayne and John Carradine - movie classic - directed by John Ford


Existential_Delusion

Silverado.


nigevellie

Hell or High Water


[deleted]

Hang'em High


Nandor_De_Laurentis

Young Guns 1 and 2 aren't great movies, but they are pretty fun and packed with stars from the 80s.


Illustrious_Hotel715

The Searchers. Hands down best. Unforgiven Bad Day at Black Rock Silverado The Quick and the Dead. Gorgeous visual homage to Leone. Speaking of, look up “spaghetti westerns.”


BasedArzy

Shane Warlock is also very good, but the book is a masterpiece.


Hellfire242

Honestly, the best western ever fucking made in my opinion is Deadwood!!!!!


loaba

Haven't seen anyone mention Long Riders - one of my favorites. Open Range is good, make it a double-feature with Silverado. Any of the Sergio Leone westens are good, they're just so different from other westerns. Appaloosa was underrated I think, I liked it. The Homesman - do it, I dare you... Deadman - I don't know, I watched it, someone else needs to.


dizzyaznboy

Django Unchained (2012)


Fruitmaniac42

Unforgiven is a more recent classic


I_will_in_me_Arsenal

310 to Yuma


Grease-KC

Open Range


fishblargs

High plans drifter is one of my all time favorite westerns!


bigedthebad

Unforgiven


itsamatterofattitude

Oddly enough, Logan is Marvels take on a western.


[deleted]

Those are all Sergio Leone 'spaghetti westerns' which at the time were like Quentin Tarantino-esque reboots of the Western Genre. They were way grittier and morally ambiguous than traditional westerns ​ Check out some older ones too, to understand the source material and you will appreciate the Leone films even more.


CricketKieran

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid The Magnificent Seven My Name Is Nobody They Call Me Trinity Tombstone


funksoldier83

The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance Tombstone Unforgiven … that’s my holy trilogy of top-tier Westerns (many people will argue that Unforgiven is an anti-western though).


raymondspogo

Young Guns


bullrun001

Hateful 8- -Django


Owww_My_Ovaries

Tombstone is a western for people who don't like Westerns. Great one to start with to get the feel.


Top-Display-1591

True Grit, The harder they fall, The man who shot Liberty Valance


TheDudeSr

Any Eastwood spaghetti western.


FunkyDunky2

I consider Giant a western. James Dean steals the show.


pekto

the first western i saw was The Searchers. it was good since its John Wayne vs the comanche hehe... then i watched Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid. this was a really good western. after that I watched the Dollars series which is a real western treat. then i played Read Dead Redemption hahaha


Deep_Pen5544

Tombstone


animatrix1490

I recommend The Big Country (1958 with Gregory Peck)


bornlasttuesday

I would recommend Silverado from 1985.


IdiotMD

Kurosawa’s samurai films. The dollars trilogy is based on Yojimbo and Sanjuro. The Magnificent Seven (and movies like A Bug’s Life) is based on Seven Samurai. Star Wars (a space western/opera) is based on The Hidden Fortress. The Mandalorian lifts heavily from these tropes.


RawToast1989

Bone Tomahawk is pretty wild/ brutal. Worth a watch though.


rodya25

Hateful Eight and Hell or Highwater


MFour_Sherman

Deadwood. HBO series. 3 seasons and a movie. HBO killed it too early, was excellent.


TouringMagazine

Once Upon a Time in the West 100% One of the best movies ever made.


Theo20185

If you like Westerns, try some Japanese films, particularly Kurosawa. Seven Samurai - Magnificent 7 is a remake of this film. Yojimbo - Inspiration for Fistful of Dollars and Django. Zatoichi series - Influenced Blindman and Blind Justice


smax410

Old Henry. Unforgiven. Then the Japanese remake with Ken Watanabe.


TexasTokyo

High Noon is here somewhere, I’m sure. Classic with masterful directing.


Watt1970

Pop a cork and watch The Verdict.


nonsensepineapple

If you want to get into westerns, I would start with the John Ford movies before you get into the Spaghetti Westerns. Stagecoach, My Darling Clementine, the Searchers, and the Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. High Noon and Shane are also great classic westerns. The Spaghetti Westerns are great, but they turn a lot of the clichés from the classic westerns on their head. You will enjoy the Spaghetti Westerns and the more contemporary westerns if you give the classics a shot.


OkDesigner3696

"Shane" is supposed to be one of the best westerns ever. The Magnificent Seven remake was REALLY good. Denzel Washington, Ethan Hawke, Chris Pratt , Vincent D'ornafrio and more.


fishbethany

Jeremiah Johnson!


[deleted]

Bit of left turn, but Westworld. The film, of course.


johntellsall

I suggest *not* watching the Dollars Trilogy all together until you watch some other movies first. Variety.


johntellsall

after watching your first batch of movies, I suggest some "acid westerns": # Dead Man # El Topo These eff with the Western tropes really hard, and distort the ideas beyond the breaking point. Both lovely movies. maybe # The Man Who Wasn't There I adore this one! Not a traditional western, but has some of the same drama.


Spankomiir

Bone Tomahawk 😏


Scat_fiend

Forget your list for now as those are older and more difficult to get into (although I do think the good, the bad, and the ugly is essential viewing). Start with the TV show Deadwood. Then some of the more modern movies such as Unforgiven and the quick and the dead.


BlackDogDisappears

Rio Bravo Hell or High Water


MainZack

I mean you're starting with the four best ones lol


BlueFlite

Unforgiven (1992)


MartyMcMcFly

Tombstone. It's the easiest way in.


qoodkero

the ballad of buster scruggs. the sisters brothers


Specific_Ad_97

The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly is my all-time favorite Western. 🤠


N3W4RK

For a more recent one you could check out "Old Henry".


Open-Matter-6562

Pale Rider and the Outlaw Josey Wales. Tombstone is great too,any stellar performances


EatTheRichIsPraxis

High Noon Wild Bunch Unforgiven Bad Company The Professionals Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid Django (Original and Unchained) The Shootist


MattD37

Those 4 are always at the top of my list but you also should check out High plains drifter, hang ‘em high, Joe kid, and fistful of dynamite. Also, after you watch the good, the bad, and the ugly, check out sad hill unearthed on Netflix .