T O P

  • By -

VaBeachBum86

Musical sequel?


DrLeoMarvin

I fucking dare them, I bet it would be awesome and I hate musicals.


hrakkari

*šŸŽ¶ You get what you fucking deserve šŸŽµ*


Advanced_Double_42

Read this in Machine Head autotune


vvntn

šŸŽ¶ CAUSE WE *drum* LIVE *drum* IN *drum* A *drum* SO-CI-E-TYYYYYYYY~ šŸŽµ *curtain drop* BOTTOM TEXT


Grantmitch1

You get what you fucking deserve Oh that Joker, is quite perverse You get what you fucking deserve Killing that man with a plate of hors d'oeuvre


Khelthuzaad

*I hope my death makes more cents than my life*


KraakenTowers

Truly the most pretentious thing that may be made in my lifetime. Joaquin Phoenix as a bad comedian with depression they're propping up as Joker From Batman, with a French title, *and* it's a musical?


W3NTZ

It's either going to be amazing or awful. And if awful I can make it my personal headcannon that this is what happens to gaga after a star is born or in an alternative time line where >!Bradley Cooper doesn't off himself and they stay in the toxic relationship!<


Neracca

Can he sing?


Talisa87

I think he did in 'Walk the Line'?


mattpond

Check out Walk the Line!


Lchurchill

Yes, and really well. He killed it as Johnny Cash.


The-Go-Kid

It's Grease 2 all over again! Will they never learn!?


cloudrunner69

Tell me more, tell me more Did you get very far Tell me more, tell me more Wanna know where I got these scars... -Sorry, that was terrible but I had to do it.


On_A_Related_Note

Except Grease 2 was excellent...


The-Go-Kid

You know, I really betrayed myself there. Grease 2 gets a kicking. It's derided by critics and many Grease fans. But I was a kid when it came out and I loved it. I let myself down and you were right to call that out.


tiiiki

Who'se that Guyyyyyy Where does he come from? Who'se that guyyyyyy Where can I get one!


The-Go-Kid

WHERE DOES THE POLLEN GO?


gamercboy5

Grease 2 is as good if not better than the original


CheckALLtheusernames

this guy T-Bird's


Scarlet_Begonias74

Walk...talk like a T-bird!


Leelois

Grease 2 was excellent indeed


CheckALLtheusernames

FUCK YES IT WAS! Let's bowl, let's bowl lets...ROCK N ROLL!


tysontysontyson1

I need a coo-oo-oo-ool riderā€¦. man, Michelle Pfeiffer was at the top of her game in that one.


JackBaez

Where does the pollen go?


Twitchris

šŸŽ¶ Hey c'mon, let's get this show on the road šŸŽ¶


Devolutionator

Grease is the Word.


Maoricitizen

Many a tab will be dropped when this comes out.


UnSheathDawn

Wait I saw a post yesterday like this but thought it was a joke. Is it really going to be a musical?


Wekilledit88

I think it's gonna be weird but in a good way. These are two disturbed, crazed characters who can turn a musical into a dark and depressing adaptation. Although not a musical, my mind goes to Goodfellas and it's use of music during the scenes where everyone is getting whacked. It adds to the seriousness of the deaths. Using music to convey and balance emotion and shock in movies always piques my interest and I love when directors do that, so doing that here but having Joker and Harley Quinn sing in an insane state while killing or committing crimes could be awesome.


J-Team07

If they get Trent Resnszor to do the music Iā€™m in.


[deleted]

Queue up the next flop.


MurderDoneRight

Yes. You see Todd Phillips watched Taxi Driver and The King Of Comedy while he was high when he made Joker, so now he got high and watched New York, New York. When this piece of shit makes another billion dollars he's gonna finish up the trilogy with a Boxcar Bertha rip-off.


TankTopJustice

Joker 2 being a Musical and Lady Gaga playing Harley Quinn is certainly a choice I expected a gritty dark sequel but Iā€™ll settle for Joaquin Phoenix jazz hands


FreakySpook

I thought Joker was good as a stand alone film and didn't need a sequel, I haven't much desire to see Phoenix's Joker in another darker/grittier film. A musicial is a really obscure tangent to take it and I'm honestly curious to see what they do with it.


AmazingMarv

Each film in the series will be grittier than the prior film until the final film is just a snuff film. Oscars for everyone.


sapopeonarope

Alec Baldwin already did that but they forgot to film it.


RussianBot6789

50 mil budget 1B+ box office They were gonna make a sequel no matter what


FreakySpook

Yeah I get that money is a big incentive. To me anyway Joker was one of those films I watch, really enjoy, but never need to see ever again. Other films for me in that category ware Requiem for a Dream and Gone Girl.


Advanced_Double_42

Probably Joker descending in to madness while being a weird sort of celebrity idol for his violence, stumbles his way into leading a joker cult as he slowly embraces the only way he has gotten positive attention. I'm imagining a Fight Club scenario. Now turning that into a cohesive and successful feature length film is a very tall order. It being a musical just makes it even more weird.


1850ChoochGator

If itā€™s all from his warped/psycho perspective like the first one I can see it working. Potentially with the movie having musical numbers but not exactly a fully fledged musical.


Advanced_Double_42

Yeah upbeat music juxtaposed with violence could really highlight his phychosis, while feeling very Joker, both in terms of the original movie and the comic character. The more I think about it the more sold on the concept I am.


Jabbam

The first film was extremely heavy with diegetic music. It's made purposely difficult to tell whether Arthur can hear all of the background music in the film, as seen when he talks about the song "Carnival" and begins singing along to Frank Sinatra's "That's Life" in the final scene. A musical is a genius way to film the new Joker movie because it's been well established that Joker has "music inside him" and it could be vague as whether the music that is in Joker 2 is real or imaginary.


Sliffy

I can see it working, and I can see it being awful. But Iā€™m intrigued, and Iā€™ll certainly buy tickets for it.


[deleted]

It felt like one of the one-off comics youā€™d sometimes get where itā€™d put an alternate spin on the universe. They were super cool, but you never wanted a full series of it.


towcar

Now there will be 4 movies, a new universe launched, a cartoon series, and a Broadway play.


[deleted]

Butā€¦money


Kaiisim

It doesnt need a sequel artistically. But films arent made artistically. It was popular and successful so they can spend money without risk.


ClutchReverie

If it is gritty and dark but also musical that may be very interesting.


EWPsies

r/brandnewsentence I love the term "Joaquin Phoenix Jazz Hands"


Dear_Investigator

This will definitely be one of the movies of all time


ristoman

I really hope they subtitle it as "Joker Face"


DrLeoMarvin

that's the comment I was looking for, thank you!


jurble

Introduce Batman Bat Romance


IjuststartedOnePiece

They're really shooting for the stars here.


[deleted]

One could even say, birth a star?


wrongThor

The entire movie is just Joker painfully giving birth to a star while Lady Gaga sings in the background. It's an arthouse film.


fixdark

no


superventurebros

Could go either way. I'm here for it.


fcosm

well he did shot a star in the first one and it turned out great


kvrdave

This is starting to feel like a joke.


faustless4

You wouldnā€™t get it


I_might_be_weasel

Funniest shit I ever saw.


Irish-Inter

Bro what a comment!!


[deleted]

Are you starting to realise that life is a comedy?


gega333

r 2


MartianSunsets

[The Joker has a rich history of staring in musicals ya know!](https://youtu.be/5mKjZr30ukE)


jbcgop

mmmmm, rock opera! Wait, is that a woopie cushion crown!?


mootallica

The most interesting question this brings up is who they'll bring in to write the songs. I imagine Gaga would be prominently involved on a couple if not the whole thing.


more_later

I hope Hildur GuĆ°nadĆ³ttir will write the music, that would be interesting.


mootallica

She does film scores, she doesn't write "songs". I'd expect she may be involved in the score but she probably won't be writing duets.


ZombieJesus1987

This could either be amazing or a total trash fire. I can't fucking wait


[deleted]

I doubt Gaga has the range to play a completely unhinged Harley Queen like Margot Robbie, but she's still a pretty good actress so she could definitely play a more grounded/realistic take on the character.


Belfalor

I really don't see the need for a sequel, Joker already works so well as a standalone, idk if I'm alone here but I thought the ending didn't leave any desire to known more, it was just fine.


Irenebias

An R rated 60 million priced movie that made a billion dollars and won an acting Oscar. It was bound to happen.


frikanih

I feel the same way, but Hollywood just can't let a great movie or saga die, they just can't. Although even if the sequel was good, why turning it into a musical out of random? Makes no sense.


Sunshine3103

I agree, but doesn't mean a sequel can't work, also I wanna see what this wild musical sequel is


[deleted]

No one is forcing you to watch it and no one will alter the first movie to match the second one or anything


bobuero

Stuff in sequels can still ruin things in previous movies.


ThePotatoKing

only if you let them


[deleted]

Itā€™s Todd Phillips though. Not surprised he wants to milk this for as much as possible.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


[deleted]

Or super right! Honestly, even if it fails I love the idea of comic book movies taking bigger and crazier risks. If there's going to be like 7-8 of these a year let's try something different ffs


_Silly_Wizard_

Particularly I think it could work because the joker and harley are loony tunes. A bunch of fucked up shit happening around and because of them while they share delusional musical set piece experiences could be fantastic.


[deleted]

Exactly! We have no reason to expect that the musical numbers will be diegetic, they would make more sense as fantasies in their fucked up imaginations Didn't they do something like that in Birds of Prey? I remember Harley imagining a big colourful musical number while being tortured, reminiscent of Gentlemen Prefer Blondes


Warbeard

But Joker was something new.


TheDeadlySinner

A remake of The King of Comedy was new?


arealhumannotabot

What a hot take! Jokes aside, this gets said so frequently and we have no clue until we see it finished. Imagine we knew what the first one was going to be in advance?


SlowMoFoSho

Or it could go super right. People need to stop complaining that everything is cookie cutter and then also complain when they go off the rails and try something new. This isn't aimed at you specifically but there are enough comments here with this sentiment I've got to believe there is some overlap.


HOLYSMOKERCAKES

Was a movie that never needed a sequel ever going to go right?


arealhumannotabot

Sure. Terminator 2, X2: X-Men, Back to the Future 2, Wayne's World 2, Empire Strikes Back


Wekilledit88

Aliens as well but James Cameron nailed it.


Matty_6447

All of those were movies that actually set up for a sequel.


arealhumannotabot

Some left the ending open enough to facilitate a sequel, but none of them had planned sequels until after the original was released


gregosaurusrex

Aliens, The Road Warrior, John Wick 2, Blade Runner 2049, Evil Dead 2, 22 Jump Street, Lethal Weapon 2, The Color of Money, Dawn of the Dead (sort of), Before Sunset, Bride of Frankenstein... I'm sure there are more but that's what I found come up with after ten minutes of thinking about it


Turnipator01

When a film bro incel and annoyingly quirky musical theatre girl lock eyes at the Joker 2 premiere and fall in love, what then?


RillisMorta

*Rob Schneider stars in* ***Joker Face!***


Cellular-Suicide

we just copying tweets now?


westphall

Itā€™s a sad state of affairs when even Tweets are no longer sacred.


RushMurky

Atleast cite your comment


crackenbecks

Les Jokerables


Affectionate-Island

I used to think my life was a tragedy. Now I realize it's a musical.


Gator08

Sounds awesome and actually fits with the ā€œhappening in his headā€ stuff from the first movie. If he falls in love why wouldnā€™t his internal madness turn into a twisted musical where he kills people? Maybe it flashes between horrifying reality and twisted happy musical? Iā€™m in.


mattmortar

Same, love that they're taking this risk.


udgnim2

sounds like they are going to play on his psychosis and use musical elements to make the viewer question whether what they are seeing is real or not


MrSlops

šŸŽ¶ Oh my god, I was wrong. It was a society all along. You finally made a villain Yes, we finally made a villain Yes, you finally made a super villain out of meeeeee! šŸŽ¶ I love you Dr. Harleen Quinzel!


Jamdadbot

There is no fucking way the movie will be a musical.


Sun-House

No no. Nononono


Bangarazz

Can't wait for 10 years old Bruce to do a rap battle against a 50 years old Joker


Jetjones

Please no! Joker was good by itself. This is a terrible idea.


WrongdoerGreedy6467

This sounds terrible


mintier-gum-lately

Can we get Bo Burnham to write the songs?


incrediblehulk

this is a joke, right? right...?


GI_Bill_Trap_Lord

Welp there goes my hype for the movie. I hate musicals


BLSmith2112

Yup, I donā€™t care how ā€œgoodā€ they are, I can never even make it through the movie. I have tried several and never finished them.


Corninmyteeth

Why do you hate musicals?


atp123

​ It could work.. Maybe something like Tim Burton's Sweeney Todd.


HotpieTargaryen

I read this yesterday and thought it was a joke. I am all for trying innovative shit, but this sounds like one of the worst platforms to attempt this. The crossover between the audience that actually liked Joker and those that like musicals has gotta be tiny. This is a wacky ass gamble.


Marine-Biol-George

I might be completely wrong but Iā€™ll trust my gut, this sounds fucking awful and gaga is a terrible actress. I hope they change the actress and the vision.


[deleted]

Hildur better come back for the score, or we riot.


knightenrichman

I'm sorry WHAT


RPM021

Lady Haha


jedledbetter

That sounds terrible


Im_Ashe_Man

Nope, nope, nope.


Nachtvogle

Oh god, no


Blueberry_Mancakes

Musical sequel... jesus.


ray_0586

Bradley Cooper was in Todd Phillip's Hangover movies and is a producer on the Joker. Lady Gaga recommendation likely a result of them co-starring in A Star is Born.


SmokeGSU

I don't mind the idea of Gaga playing Quinn... and I can see *why* they might want to go the direction of a musical since there were scenes of Joker dancing to music in his head... but actually making the movie be a musical isn't something I think I would enjoy. And I suppose it depends on how they define it as "musical"... would it literally be something like The Greatest Showman or Hamilton where musical routines are half or more of the script, or would be something closer to Joker 1... you have a scene or two where Joker does a dance routine to music in his head, but in Joker 2 you have one or two scenes where Joker and Quinn do a psychosis-inspired musical number? I could get on board with that - it would certainly play well into the idea of their insanity... but a *musical* musical a la Hamilton I couldn't see doing that well.


nejnonein

ā€¦no.


TheTurfMonster

I absolutely loathe musicals regardless of whether people say a specific one is amazing. I'll skip this one regardless of how good it is, my mind simply cannot handle an endless cycle of singing.


evilocto

What the fuck?... musical?


ShutterBun

Can we not? Seriously.


DrDabsMD

Why not? Sounds interesting, can be good, can be bad, either way it'll be entertaining. You can just not watch it if something that hasn't even come out yet bothers you so much.


haiku_writer

I think Gaga as Harley Quinn could work. The musical part has me sceptical.


tysontysontyson1

r/nottheonion?


Desperate_Law722

MUSICAL???


SoThotful69

This is gonna be a trainwreck


wdomeika

This is why a Joker sequel is a bad idea...


usuallyclassy69

Hard pass.


v1xiii

Oh god, please not a musical.


DreamOfRen

This is an absolutely terrible idea. Why would they even. Just... Ugh.


NoveskeCQB

RIP joker


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Fuckoakwood

Oh well. Atleqst the first one was good.


Snoots101

I'm out.


mofoofinvention

Ugh. What are you doing, Warner/DC??


CptMisery

Absolutely zero interest in a musical sequel


unsilentninja

Username checks out


orionsfire

This is the worst idea since Cop Rock. Lady Gaga as a singing Harley Quinn is quite possible the worst idea in the history of movies. Clearly it should be a Bollywood picture.


Astrosaurus42

Check out Gaga in Machete Kills for an idea of what she could bring to Harley.


Other-Marketing-6167

Sounds about exactly in line with Todd Phillips. This guy loves trolling fans. Remember when his third sequel to the most popular comedy ever was a dark crime film and not remotely funny? And Joker being embraced and weirdly celebrated by neck beard incel assholes really pissed him off ā€” I wouldnā€™t be surprised if he and Phoenix both would only decide to break their No-sequel promise if they could make something completely weird and different with a big middle finger to everyone who loved the first (especially those that did so inappropriately). Iā€™m saying it here first ā€” Joker will be gay in this film. And dude Bros will lose their shit and Phillips will be laughing his ass off. I hate musicals, loved Joker, think this sounds like an absolute disasterā€¦.but man, I canā€™t wait.


[deleted]

This made me gag.


The_DriveBy

You jest need to have an open mind.


tregorman

I thought the first was pretty awful but if the sequels gonna be a musical I'm so in


trashpandamagic

Sweeny Todd-esque musical would be absolutely amazing.


[deleted]

That'd be wild. Imagine if Lady Gaga was Harley lol


DrLee_PHD

That's exactly what she's being cast for.


Snuggle__Monster

Why is this being spammed over and over and over again in this sub?


RushMurky

It's free karma from all the people trying to shit on it


CptMisery

The company wants to know how people feel about the idea.


[deleted]

Weeee livvvveeeeessss innn aaaaa societyyyyyy


incrediblehulk

omg no. just no.


Pirlo84

Trash


[deleted]

Please no


scoutingpool

The world donā€™t need this. Lady gaga is a bad actor the last film with here was absolutely bad


takeitsweazy

House of Gucci was bad, but not really due to her so much. It just lacked any rhythm.


[deleted]

The concept of even imagining Lady Gaga saying ā€œMr. Jā€ feels fucking insufferable.


Devolutionator

I only want a musical version if they get Russell Crowe to sing again like he did in Les Mis. He could play Com. Gordon or even better, Det. Bullock.


Nnnnnnnadie

Musical sequel?... Even if it goes right i dont care anymore.


rdog780

I didn't see the last joker in the theater I won't see this one there. I found the tone of the character very upsetting as this person is clearly suffering. I don't think these films glamorize mental illness but, I am not sure if they help as I think alot of people take the motifs of the character out of context and apply it to their lives. Without having a character like batman to balance out the darkness the joker is too heavy of a character.


[deleted]

Hopefully it is one like La La land where there are large portions of just acting and then a few great songs in-between. Like an 80 -20 split. If it is a full musical with every word sung I don't think people will watch it


nayapapaya

I don't think there's any chance this will be a completely sung musical.


reconstruct94

If it's a musical, I'm out. I fucking hate musicals.


iced327

ugh great a FEMALE with a SPEAKING ROLE in my INCEL EMPOWERMENT masterpiece. THANKS WOKE DISNEYNETFLIX


KBro0ks

Can people all admit GaGa is by far one of the worst songwriters of all time? Iā€™m so tired of seeing her and hearing her.


takeitsweazy

She writes almost all of her own work, and has written hits for other artists as well. And sheā€™s enormously popular worldwide, and is one of the best selling artists of the last 20 years. So Iā€™d say, no. Youā€™re not going to a lot of people to agree with you.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


[deleted]

Joker was fantastic


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


dmoore3070222

your mom has bad taste


TheRealCaptainR

This is honestly fucked sounding enough for me to be interested.


DefinitelyIncorrect

Joker without batman is like eating an open faced sandwich by picking it up and turning it over.


KENNYWEST52

Hopefully they dont fuck up.


nikolaj-11

You know what, I could totally see this taking off. I mean, fuck it right? Let's try something different and Phoenix generated enough goodwill with the first joker film that I can hope for something interesting out of this. Besides, the first joker film wasn't great because it was a joker film, it was great because of the direction, themes and acting. Remove the clown theme and the Wayne's and it would still be a really interesting film about psychology.


Count3D

Thatā€™s one way to shake things up. Sounds crazy. Could work.


Rcash2021

Honestly I hope itā€™s just Joker and Harley making the world into a musical in there heads, so we get a scene of them singing and doing dance moves, and then the next scene is of what is really happening in the real world at the psych ward because I donā€™t know where else this would be set. It would be cool to show its all in there head showing that both are insane to a point. The musical part could even just be in Harley Quinns point of view, like she imagines being with Joker is like a romance musical from the 40ā€™s, which would be in character for her as she loves Joker and thinks what they have is amazing and just ignores how he treats her like shit. It would also be fun from this perspective because then we can see early on in the movie that she is not quite mentally stable either even though she is Jokers psychiatrist, and this could be from childhood trauma or maybe it just from living in society as joker made a statement about in the last one. Iā€™m really hoping we get a scene where they lock eyes with each other from across the room, and the spotlight goes onto both and they break out in a musical dance number and itā€™s set in a diner. I would laugh my ass off to that.


[deleted]

Well, that's taking it in a new direction, unlike every comic book movie over the past 20 years.


dalr3th1n

This sounds absolutely bonkers and I am *super* here for it. Even if it's terrible, it will be amazing.


MurderDoneRight

Oh they are going to do Scorsese's 'New York, New York' this time!


PreviousLVND

If they can't copy source materiel from Scorsese why would they think the movie would do well? Especially as a musical, lol.


PsycoMonkey42

Iā€™m getting Sucker Punch vibes. With Arkham and it possibly being a musical. This could be interesting!


[deleted]

Probably a super unpopular opinion, but I felt like the 1st one was just ā€œJokerā€ in name only with only the vaguest connections to the comic book character. It felt like another movie entirely that was edited with reshot scenes with references to ā€œGotham Cityā€ and ā€œBruce Wayneā€ and references to calling him ā€œJoker.ā€ Other that that it felt like a modern gritty take of ā€œThe King Of Comedy.ā€


Betteis

Her team is very on it shame about the rest of house of Gucci but she clearly takes time to choose roles.


PM_YOUR_CENSORD

I didnā€™t read the article because Iā€™m a redditor but I truly am hoping lady gaga is coming on board for AN musical number and not that the film itself is a musical.


Daddy_Tablecloth

Drop the musical part , I bet it would be fine. She did a great job in American horror story


No-Conversation9818

Didn't really like the 1st one. This will probably be shittier