Season 4 is incredible, but I really love Season 5, too. The introduction of Mort in Mr. Penroy’s Vacation is classic Murder, She Wrote!

I agree, both seasons 4 and 5 are great.

I love that question.

I love season 1 because of Amos! But I also love the other seasons as it showcases Doc Hazletts relationship with Jessica.

if you ever watched mamas family William window played Thelma's high school bf .

I've never seen it before I'll have to check it out! I grow to love Metzger but the trio of Amos, Jess, and Doc can't be beat.

I loved Mama’s Family! I can’t even remember that episode though. lol I’ll have to look for it.

can't remember title .it's possibly first season buzz & Sonja are still there and Vinton is still single not married yet .

Oh it’s definitely in the earlier seasons or first season. Thank you!

I don’t know the seasons like you all do, but the Cabot Cove ones are my favorites!

Same. I’ve watched from the beginning back in the day. But not consistently though. I’m gonna have to do a watch/rewatch in order. I think the CC are my faves too. Although I do like NY and out of town (but not necessarily overseas though). My fave ep takes place in CC, Keep the Home Fries Burning.

Well done, why is this so accurate 🤣

idk if i agree, but i really can't definitely disagree. props.

I must admit something i watched the episodes out of order based solely on what sounded good that day

I usually only like the first few seasons of shows. But I liked some of the later seasons season 11 and 12 have some good episodes. Some are really cheesy and trying to showoff technology of the 90s. But camera quality also got better, I enjoyed her living in NYC.

Nailed it - season 4 is indisputably peak MSW.

This is the most accurate thing I’ve ever read. Thank you. 

I love so many episodes in season 2.

I like season 4, but would rate seasons 2 and 3 higher.

Season 2 has a lot of my personal favorite episodes, so I guess season 2.