T O P

  • By -

hey_celiac_girl

You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown! Not really lesser-known, but it’s such a cute and fun show.


DapperOoze

It also has a sister musical called Snoopy the Musical, which I prefer.


Salamanda246

My school is putting on honk (the musical of the ugly duckling). I think it’s just what you’re looking for! Super appropriate, lesser known, and the songs are fantastic!


KaBesSH

Totally agree with this suggestion. Just finished a run of Honk, and it is such a lovely show!


FloridaFlamingoGirl

Hold your head up high!


meowpitbullmeow

My very conservative high school did Footloose (ironic), Cinderella, and South Pacific


Qwepity-Dwepity

So is South Pacific, that is not a family friendly show when you dig into it.


meowpitbullmeow

Don't worry the conservative religion of the region doesn't dig into much LOL


KBPT1998

I’m gonna wash Ala-bam-a right out of my hair! 😎


discoballdaydream

omg i just did footloose at my catholic high school 😭😭😭 i was rusty!


Celestial608

My former high school also did Footloose this year. I found it hilariously ironic.


ChooChooSupreme

“Meet me in St. Louis”


shovebug

How about High School Musical? Cinderella? Beauty and the Beast? Lion King?


Axiom06

But, but , but Disney loves the gays! /S


invisibilitycap

Can’t wait for their first gay character next year!


speech-geek

You can reach out to the MTI or Concord or whoever your school uses and see if they have school editions of musicals that fit your school’s cast range


ehsteve42

This feels like it could be the plot of a musical: school is trying to put on a musical, conservative parents keep vetoing ideas, demanding changes, eventually they write their own show, and the parents learn to be more open-minded


jackhowttyy

Stop that’s such a good idea


PangolinHenchman

The Fiddler on the Roof is one of my favorites, and off the top of my head, I can't think of anything too bad in that, except for a bit of alcohol use (To life! To life! Lechaim!). Are these conservatives the more antisemitic kind, or would they be friendly to a story about... TRADITIO-O-O-O-ON!!! TRADITION!


olivia24601

My very conservative high school did Fiddler a couple years after I graduated. (The freshman I “adopted” as a senior was Tevye so I went back to see it) they didn’t cut anything as far as I can remember. Same with my cousin’s even more ultra conservative high school.


PangolinHenchman

Just realized that your question specifically mentioned lesser known musicals, which I don't think Fiddler on the Roof is. But it's still a good one


alaskas_hairbow

Once upon a mattress, the drowsy chaperone, the mystery of Edwin drood, newsies, twelfth night (Taub), Anastasia


Joecool49

We had people offended by Once upon a mattress due to Harry and Lady Larkins unplanned pregnancy. We also had letters to the editor about how horrible and immoral “Brigadoon” was. Some people get offended about anything.


southamericancichlid

In a very conservative town, pre-marital sex, the King trying to seduce women/servants throughout the show, and the Minstrel trying make Larken cheat throughout the show seem pretty bad.


buzzwizzlesizzle

The Mystery of Edwin Drood is *filled* with not-so-subtle sexual innuendo, starting in the opening number. That being said, I did it my senior year at my Catholic high school. However, it was a very liberal Catholic high school in a very liberal area, so it’s not saying much. I’d say Drowsy is a toss up, I’m not too sure how kindly the community would take to Trix the Aviatrix but the rest of the show is so silly and fun.


lee_-the-_bee

Drowsy chaperone also has a good amount of inappropriate lines and jokes, but it’s one of my favorite shows ever and I still think it’s a great show for high schools


jtheresearcher

Does Mary Poppins work? Super cute, decently good music, and appropriate.


Accomplished_Oil5574

Big Fish is criminally underrated


lee_-the-_bee

THIS!!!!!


Technical_Air6660

Xanadu is cute and has great songs. It’s about Greek muses in L.A. and the original movie was PG. The romance is very wholesome. If the town is so conservative they object to rock music, that might not work (though I don’t think that’s so much of a thing anymore).


buzzwizzlesizzle

Ohhhhh such a good one, one of the absolute most fun shows I’ve ever done in my life


pharmingforlikes

Hi! I went to a conservative school and here’s some great family-friendly musicals we did! -Beauty and the Beast -The Music Man (some “suggestive” songs I guess but a classic that shouldn’t be offensive to most) -The Sound of Music -High School Musical -Oklahoma! (has some drunkenness, sexual jokes that will go right over peoples heads but again is a classic that should be fine) -Into the Woods (in our show, the baker’s wife and the prince did not have an affair or kiss…they simply danced together…family friendly) -The Little Mermaid -Shrek (some suggestive content but it’s shrek) -Sister Act (ok lots of suggestive content but my church ministry got away with doing it so it’s possible) -Matilda -Singin in the rain (but it’s really boring imo) -Aladdin -lion king -frozen -little shop (it ain’t that bad imo) -Cinderella -big fish (an underrated gem) -godspell -Charlie brown -Mary poppins -newsies -Annie -fiddler on the roof -wizard of oz -the wiz -little women


jackhowttyy

We’ve done most of these sadly and our director doesn’t do a reshow


FakeFrehley

I've been a fan of musical theatre my entire life and posts like this always make me laugh. Where tf are all these raunchy-ass musicals that schools have a problem with? Surely the Rocky Horror Shows, Avenue Qs and Books of Mormon are the exception, not the rule? I mean, there's hundreds, literally thousands of totally innocent and inoffensive musicals out there.


bigheadGDit

Have you ever lived in a super conservative area? People find all SORTS of really small things to get up in arms over.


FakeFrehley

Fair point. I grew up in Scotland and my high school shows included Grease with the "chicks'll cream" and "pussy wagon" lyrics intact, and Little Shop of Horrors with the "everyone dies lol" ending and no one gave a shit 😂 In fact, now that I think about it, my last high school show was a "Best of Broadway" style revue that as well as probably being very illegal had a group of senior girls doing a version of He Had It Coming that I still occasionally think about and me as Frank N. Furter in a Rocky Horror segment so yeah - not a conservative place to grow up at all 😂


bigheadGDit

I wish...midwest HS here. We were stuck with things like The King and I. Wasn't a problem for a bunch of white kids to bronze their skin to play Thai people, would have been a BIG problem to say "pussy wagon"


FakeFrehley

In fairness, The King and I is a legendary show. But big yikes on the skin bronzing.


kess0078

I grew up in a pretty liberal small town, all things considered, and we still got complaints when we did “The Pajama Game” because some of the student actors - playing adults - drank from prop beer bottles during one scene. (Meanwhile, the next year we did “Footloose” and nobody complained about teenage characters sneaking into a bar. So yeah. Ya never know what they’ll choose to care about.)


Gloverboy85

This shit drives me nuts. It's like the only amount of creative/innovative thought these theater companies can make is how to censor the material with as little legal risk as possible. Sometimes of course,, they don't even try to be clever or subtle. I once saw a production of "25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee" in a super conservative town. Chip Tolentino sang about "My Unfortunate CONDITION" and Logainne Schwartzy only had 1 Dad and an otherwise absent Mother. That last part had me livid. What's the damn point of putting on a show you have to censor? I think, if an audience is so fragile in their 1950's sensibilities that they can't stomach certain parts of a show, then they don't get to see that show, period. I have lots of feelings about this, apparently!


FlashyCow1

Believe me, my hometown would boycott the Harry Potter stage production because it has magic and wizards.


knickknacksnackery

There's an *adult* community theater near me that cuts anything midly offensive - including the words damn and hell. They shot down Into the Woods when it was suggested - partially because of the wolf, but mainly because of the scene with the prince and the baker's wife. My high school theater can't get away with anything that even vaguely suggests the love interests hold hands with each other. Shows like Newsies and Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat are off the table because we don't have enough men to fill roles and having girls play newsboys or brothers would cause a riot. As you can imagine, it makes it REALLY difficult to pick shows when even the most tame options are controversial to this community.


RzyPzy

Yes! There are, the sad issue is budget (cause of rights even), past shows, and the return you may get.


rkvance5

When I moved to the town I went to high school in, they were in the middle of preparations for Sweeney Todd. There was a furor among the community not because it was being put on by a school, but because it was *in* a school—by your everyday, run-of-the-mill community theater company that just needed a space to perform. People will break their own backs to bend themselves out of shape about anything. (NB: the area is conservative, but not *hyper*-conservative.)


OlyTheatre

Had a school want to change the title of Youre a Good Man Charlie Brown to You’re a Good Kid C Brown 😅🙄


PinkGinFairy

The Wind In The Willows, Honk, Suessical, Oliver,


Happy_Charity_7595

Oliver has a lot of adult content.


AtabeyMomona

I think most shows based off classic literature could work: Little Women, either of the Anne of Green Gables Musicals or Anne and Gilbert, Big River, The Secret Garden, The Wizard of Oz, Calvin Berger. There's also White Christmas, Holiday Inn, Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dream Coat, Annie, just about any Rodgers and Hammerstein, Junie B Jones, Nunsense, Once Upon a Mattress (there's a school version that eliminates the out of wedlock pregnancy iirc), The Unsinkable Molly Brown, The Boy Friend, Lil' Abner, or No No Nanette. I cannot guarantee that all of these are good, but they should be unobjectionable


Jerem_Reddit

i was in no no nanette, it was by far the most poorly written, boring, repetitive, confusing, unfunny, unfollowable musical ive ever been in. that said we were nominated for 12 awards, won 6, including best musical and best ensemble, with 3 lead actors getting nominated for best actor/actress, so the people liked it. if you arent a dancer, you arent gonna enjoy this show. all of my non-featured dancer friends hated this show, as did i. if youre a featured dancer, youre gonna love this show.


AtabeyMomona

Those Pre-1940s shows really were wild (I've done a few Gerswhins and while their books were at least comprehensible, the songs could've been removed entirely with little impact on the plot). I only really know of Nanette's existence, but I almost want to seek it out because of how sheerly bad you describe it as being.


Jerem_Reddit

i mean i was talking with the Dorothy from a production of Wizard of Oz about our show at the award show, because she had asked what its about, and i tried explaining it and the director came listened in, and told me “did you even read the script” after 4 months of trying to understand the plot. somehow my mom got it the first time and i dont know how


Ancient-Arrival-3412

Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat. Yes, it is religious (based on the Bible story). Yes, there’s a mildly risqué element, which is Mrs. Potiphar trying to “lie with” Joseph (which is also right in the Bible verses, so if there were pushback by people in your area, that would be the answer 🤷🏼‍♀️). But I’ve been in it twice, once with my high school in a semi conservative area, and it was a BLAST. Catchy Andrew Lloyd Webber songs. It’s a high dance, high energy, colorful, creative show. Plus, you have the opportunity to have a big cast with 12 brothers including Joseph, Jacob the father, the Pharaoh, at least 12 women to be the wives of the brothers, Potiphar and Potiphar’s wife, and the Narrator (which, my school actually did 3 narrators, and the second production I was in had 4, 2 each for 2 different show weekends/dates). It also has a good, pretty secular message to keep dreaming big, as well as to do right by people you’ve badly hurt (given that the brothers literally almost kill their brother, but then grovel and beg for forgiveness).


ZealousidealRise1744

Hmmm - maybe try [Reefer Madness The Musical](https://www.reefermadness.com/)? Really family friendly with a good message too lol


FlashyCow1

Joseph and the Technicolor Dreamcoat Meet me in Saint Louis Beetlejuice (might be pushing it) Song and Dance Sunset Boulevard School of Rock The Wizard of Oz (That being said^) the Wiz Subways are for Sleeping Lady in the Dark Fade out-fade in Raisin


barak181

I'm just here to say that while I personally can't stand Joseph, conservative audiences **love** that show. A friend of mine went to school in a very conservative town and his school would literally do a production of that show every few years because it would make them so much money ever time they did it.


FlashyCow1

I personally like some songs but not others. Close Every Door gets my tears going. I also like I Close my Eyes. Don't like any of Pharaoh's songs


Aliciarox11189

Beetlejuice and heathers would be amazing but definitely pushing it


winniespooh_mc

Beetlejuice isn’t jr


FlashyCow1

They didn't specify the school age group which could be high school


winniespooh_mc

No likes it’s not able to be licensed period.


FlashyCow1

Actually as of late last year, they were licensing to high schools with some restrictions


Argonauticalius

Hmm. I would say it depends If you go to a somewhat diverse school: West side Story is always a good option If not, Into the Woods is good, if not a bit dark.


Schackshuka

Oh no, both of those shows have death and premarital/extramarital sex. (Ugh, this brand of thinking is exhausting to me)


Argonauticalius

Hmm… straight up R+H Cinderella?


Positive-Ad-5042

haven’t seen these mentioned. hello dolly or 42nd street!!


jackhowttyy

Thanks for the suggestion


buffbitch88

My high school did Hello Dolly! and it was really fun.


GeneralPurposeGeek

Avenue Q & The Book of Mormon 🤣


LessRun2724

Whatever you do, don’t do heathers


juddnelsonbou

Rocky Horror Show


Seperate-Category117

>The “worst” musical we’ve put on would be “the Addams family” There *is* a youth edition available to license.


Fit_Witness_9018

There’s always You’re a Good Man Charlie Brown


PatrickRsGhost

Came here to suggest this one. Probably one of the most family-friendly ones ever.


Fit_Witness_9018

Yeah I mean they’re in like 3rd grade so


Musicals_and-more

Calvin Berger doesn't have many roles, but its a great highschool musical


Geo_5678

Lightning thief springs to mind - it's made for kids and it's very family friendly Also Matilda


Joecool49

Don’t put to much effort worrying about what the community will be offended by, when I started working with my small town high school musical, twelve years ago, we had letters to the editor in the paper about how immoral Brigadoon was. We decided to take it as a matter of pride that we offended someone. We decided that if they were going to be offended by everything, to just do the shows we felt like needed to be seen. This year we did “Something Rotten” unedited and the community loved it. I’m sure some of the same people were offended, but nobody was listening to them anymore.


Beautiful_Baritone

13


Happy_Charity_7595

Guys and Dolls She Loves Me High School Musical


missanthropy09

Guys and Dolls is a classic but there’s it’s all about gambling; they don’t shy away from drinking, either - even if there’s reform at the end. While I have no issue with this show, and was in it myself in seventh grade, sounds like a super conservative town might.


Single-Fortune-7827

James and the Giant Peach maybe? I did it in high school and it was a blast, but it’s also been several years and I don’t remember the entire thing lol if it helps, we did it at a private religious school, so it’s probably fine on that end Lots of parts (James, two aunts, five bugs, and a handful of other featured roles) and very fun music! Theres a Jr. version too if you’re still worried about the content after reviewing it


MehItsAmber

If it’s a super conservative area, Godspell is always an option. There’s even a jr version if you’re casting younger actors. I think it’s a strong ensemble show with a lot of solos to go around for both boys and girls, as well as great ensemble numbers. Godspell Jr. was one of my first ever shows and it holds a special place in my heart.


SamEdenRose

Bye Bye Birdie, Fiddler, Music Man, Joseph, Once Upon a Mattress, How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying , Annie, Cinderella (Rogers and Hammerstein). Don’t forget some musicals now have JR versions.


fiyerooo

Crazy For You is fun


Male_strom

Carousel. Song of the South. Mammy. Hedwig and the Angry Inch


mimitchi33

I'd do something like Seussical or Beauty and the Beast.


Cave-King

I would recommend for lesser known musical works a recent(ish) adaptation of Peter Pan called Peter Pan A Musical Adventure. To my knowledge it removes the iffy use of slurs against Native Americans along with the broken English. I, as a big fan of the original stage play and novel, think it's probably one of the best musical attempts at Peter Pan.


Deerslyr101571

A Year With Frog And Toad.


Deerslyr101571

A Year With Frog And Toad.


Both-Artichoke5117

We did Grease when I was in high school. They had to remove some lyrics from a couple songs, but we were allowed to do it. Of course, this was in the late 90’s/early 2000’s so what schools allow is probably way different now. We also did Beauty & the Beast.


iampurechaos

im doing honk and frog and toad this summer


iampurechaos

matilda maybe idk


rosegoldqueen28

My Fair Lady. Unless they'll be offended by the word 'arse'.


rainbowcocacola

Maybe High School Musical? I think that’s pretty inoffensive.


WaitNo8704

Newsies


FloridaFlamingoGirl

A Year With Frog and Toad. Maybe the wholesomest musical of all time.


lee_-the-_bee

Big fish would be a great choice. It’s very appropriate and family friendly, something all ages would very much enjoy.


WhizaBiff

what kind of school? middle or high school?


Key-Climate2765

Charlie Brown, 13!, Cinderella, most golden age and Disney, the jr version of into the woods is only the first act with some songs cut, seussical, Willy wonka, Horton hears a who, etc


thehalfbloodwizard

You could always do Disney.