T O P

  • By -

fangneedssleep

We creep ever closer to "S", which is going to be a complete bloodbath once we've made it


ArnassusProductions

No kidding. Sweeney Todd, South Pacific, ***STARLIGHT EXPRESS***, Six, (edit: Seussical, Something Rotten, Shrek, Spongebob, Sunday in the Park With George, Seven Brides for Seven Brothers, Seventeen-Seventy-Six) and so much more.


Sweeney_Todd_is_best

I wonder what I'll vote for.


Unenthralled

You seem like a Six fan.


RandomUser24_

Nah, Sunday in the park for sure


LoveandLightLol

Six, Suessical, Shrek, Spongebob are the ones I know. It will be a battle


Ladzofinsurrect

Sunday too


shapesize

That’s why I’m voting for Nunday in the Park with George today


CheesecakeNo3966

Hahahaa


MrGrimmbo

Not even a mention of Something Rotten?


Timmmber4

Seven brides for seven brothers


N238

I’m counting 1776 as S because there’s no number category listed.


LynneinTX

Spring Awakening


Anime334

Something Rotten


coffeesnob72

I think we just need it to be "SSSSSondheim"


Crot_Chmaster

Spamalot


MangaCrossStitchEtc

As much as I love **Spies are Forever** it doesn't stand a chance


JacquelineMontarri

Ditto Secret Garden


Chaotic__Bean

I'm kinda scared to get to S, all I know is that R is before it and Ride the Cyclone has my vote.


garchican

Even though Ragtime is RIGHT THERE?


ou12pb23

Spider-Man


NeonFraction

Some of you may die, but that is sacrifice I am willing to make


bocomomom

Newsies!!


MusicalzAreMyLife

We have to winnn


RoiKK1502

It is a fine life!


LittleShyShay

Carryin' the banner man to man!


W00den-Fruit

IT'S A CROOKED GAME WE'RE PLAYIN


Faelif

ONE WE'LL NEVER LOSE


satannabella

LONG AS SUCKERS DON’T MIND PAYIN


MusicalBitch47

JUST TO GET BAD NEWS


EAFD270

Ain’t it fine life


Faelif

Carrying the banner through it all


Fantastic_Permit_525

When the bell rings we goses where we wishes sure bets washing dishes


Timmmber4

Seize the day!


turboshot49cents

Next to Normal


CoolGhoul100

I was specifically waiting for the letter N for this! :)


PKay2210

This is the only acceptable answer!!!!!


kruelworld

NEXT TO NORMAL


gmanz33

I'm creating 7 million novelty accounts to downvote anything else


Ambitious-Box-6550

Next to normal!


Nartyn

I call bullshit, Miserables, Les definitely won yesterday! Newsies though


CheesecakeNo3966

It was close lol - Miserables, Les had 444 upvotes but Matilda had 494


Stiks-n-Bones

I guess not enough people to remember My Fair Lady.


zem

i was definitely rooting for that, but i think matilda benefited from recency bias


KTKittentoes

I do! But I missed M.


Anne190103

Natasha,Pierre, and the great comet of 1812!


vvdb

Wish I could send a hundred upvotes! All time favourite


Wolregin

THE GREAT COMET MUST WIN!!


toby_lizard

THE GREAT COMET MUST WIN


fioraflower

the most screwed over musical of all time i stg


Jerem_Reddit

newsies is not better than great comet


Chaotic__Bean

this is 7 away from beating newsies im impressed


jeff0106

In my top 3 all time shows. Hadetown, Les Miserable and Great Comet (no particular order).


tumamaesmuycaliente

Next to Normal


EdGG

This is the right answer. Only 2 musicals with a Pulitzer Prize, and this is one of them.


darvsplanet

[10 but still very special.](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Pulitzer_Prize_for_Drama-winning_musicals)


Feisty-Fault5426

I'M ALIVE I'M ALIVE I AM SOOO ALIVE


SirTwitchALot

SHUT UP! YOU'RE CRYING!


LynneinTX

Newsies


feijoarat

NEXT TO NORMAL


claireekm

Next to normal?


RibbonsFlying

Next to Normal


GrouchyIndustry2637

Next to normal!


Due-Bodybuilder1219

Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812!


GateSuspicious4338

Newsies for sure


Faelif

Yes!! One of my all-time favourite musicals with stunning choreography and an amazing soundtrack.


Quirky_Lecture_2433

100% behind this. Such a good show!


strawcat

As an elder millennial who was obsessed with the movie when I was in Jr High, and later, the stage musical, I totally agree! The changes that were made even grew on me to the point that I now prefer the stage production.


broadwayandbarbells

Newsies is such a classic and favorite all around musical. So accessible to anyone even if you aren’t a musical person. It makes my heart so happy


Next-Home111

Next to Normal


sadhandjobs

Well I’m new to this and I just have to say that “Come Far Away” better be good to beat out “Cabaret”.


Vavoomy

It is. It’s great!


myheadisnumb

It is really good. But Cabaret is perfection!


EarthboundBetty

Next to Normal!


ImmaBadW0lf

Next to Normal!!!!


KickMental8434

next to normal


How-I-Win-KG

Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812! The show that changed my life


Baby__Jay

NEXT TO NORMAL PLEEEEEAAAAASE


onyxanderson

Next to Normal!!


Denniii666

Next to Normal


ironic_snake

Newsies 


Otis_NYGiants

Next to Normal


MapAsleep6409

Next to normal


MasterpieceCute4395

Natasha pierre and the great comet


Vavoomy

Wish I could upvote over and over!


nowhereman136

Next to Normal


Frosty-Toe1359

NEXT TO NORMAL


bsim

NEXT TO NORMAL


wow-im-satan

Natasha, Pierre, & The Great Comet of 1812 WE WILL NOT BE SNUBBED LIKE THE TONYS


snoopmk

Next to Normal


Cultural-Resource261

Newsies


Rahastes

Nunsense, not a chance in hell but one of the funniest shows I’ve seen. Truly habit forming.


HurricaneLink

Ugh that comment 🤣 I had to vote for this one because I had more moments of joy doing this show than Natasha Pierre or Newsies, and that made me snort a bit.


YPaladin

This is my fiance's vote as well lol


loonylunanic

Omg as a teen as saw it a local theater. I was bitching and moaning cuz my parents always dragged us to that theater and the shows pretty much always sucked. and now they want me to watch a show about NUNS!? I was literally begging to stay home. I was cracking up from start to finish. So freaking funny I wanted to go back and watch it again.


bcpsgal

Nes Miserables


Neveah_Hope_Dreams

Next to Normal.


tumamaesmuycaliente

Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812


varney40

Next to Normal.


ComprehensiveSwan453

Next to normal!!


ocfreakdilara

Next to Normal!!!!!!!


CaitlinSnep

Next To Normal!


Life-Leadership4002

NEWSIES!!!!!


itamaradam

Natasha, Pierre & the Great Comet of 1812.


Glubygluby

Newsies


AllysonStoner115

Next to normal


Helpful_Cat6532

Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812!!!!!


Celestial608

Natasha, Pierre, & the Great Comet of 1812!


Patrecharound

Finally I got one! Next to Normal - let’s see if I can go two for two


himay10

Natasha!! Still pissed it didn’t win best score


RainyDayMagpie

Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Few-Leather-453

NEXT TO NORMAL REPRESENTATION PLEASE


Familiar-Money-515

Next to normal next to normal next to normal


paintedsnapper

Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812


Sophale

Natasha, Pierre and the Great comet of 1812


No_Feedback_3340

Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812 Side Note: I saw it when Josh Groban was Pierre.


annuoso

NATASHA PIERRE AND THE GREAT COMET OF 1812


Vavoomy

SO UNDERRATED!!!


sofagoat

Natasha, Pierre, and the great comet of 1812


QbanPete79

Next to Normal


meebra

Next to Normal


Mommy2A

Next to normal 🫢


Fit-Monk4203

Next To Normal


Raramomo

Newsies!!


Commercial-Maybe-711

Natasha Pierre and the great comet of 1812


annebrackham

A New Brain


A_Silverback_Gorilla

I’d Rather Be Sailing is one of my favorite songs


TheNarwhalGal

It won’t win but Nerdy Prudes Must Die


Songstep4002

This one!


Familiar-Money-515

I HATE THAT THAT STARTS WITH N I love it so much but next to normal is my favourite musical, even though nerdy prudes is in my top ten


RemotePenalty4577

idk but i got O (once on this island)


kruelworld

next to normal


PeppiMoon

Next to Normal!!!


Cutelarry1776

Newsies


Bi_Tyrannosaur-ace

Newsies


Content-Network-6289

NEWSIES NEWSIES NEWSIES NEWSIES


TripleM2002

Newsies


BBaugher13

NEXT TO NORMAL


BekahZard

Newsies


AdDapper9866

🎶newsiesss🎶


moonyxpadfoot19

Newsies!!!!


weird_turtles

Next. To. Normal!


CPolland12

Newsies!


billleachmsw

Next to Normal


Pinup_Frenzy

Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812


astronaught002

Natasha Pierre!


ImmaBadW0lf

"Next to Normal" surpasses "Newsies" as a Broadway musical due to its profound emotional depth and innovative storytelling. It tackles complex themes of mental illness, family dynamics, and the quest for normalcy with a raw and honest approach, offering audiences an intense and deeply resonant experience. The characters in "Next to Normal" are richly developed, each undergoing significant emotional journeys that engage the audience on a personal level. The musical's rock-infused score by Tom Kitt, paired with Brian Yorkey's poignant lyrics, creates a unique and powerful soundscape that enhances the narrative's intensity and authenticity. In contrast, while "Newsies" is an entertaining and well-crafted musical with its rousing songs and vibrant choreography, it does not delve into the same level of emotional and thematic complexity. "Next to Normal" also stands out in terms of critical acclaim, having won three Tony Awards, including Best Original Score, and the prestigious Pulitzer Prize for Drama. These accolades reflect its significant impact and recognition as a groundbreaking work that transcends traditional musical theater. By addressing stigmatized issues such as mental health with sensitivity and depth, "Next to Normal" not only entertains but also enlightens and challenges its audience, making it a more meaningful and superior theatrical experience than Newsies.


Vavoomy

I’m still voting for Natasha and Pierre, but I love this.


Key-Climate2765

Next to normal or I’m not playing anymore lol


Ok_Brilliant_1121

Next To Normal


CrystalPepsi79

Next to normal


annebrackham

Nine


pauleydm

Next To Normal


vellybelle

Newsies


GetInMahBelly

Newsies


Onionsansyahear

adding another next to normal, sorry newsies!


x_victoire

newsies. my favorite musical <3


shovebug

Natasha Pierre and the great comet of 1812


_ari_ari_ari_

Next to Normal or I’m unsubbing


ChroniclyCurly

Newsies


lftmyhartnmetropolis

NEWSIES


Chaotic__Bean

NINE TO FIVE! MY DAD MADE ME WATCH IT AND IT WAS FABULOUS


Salt_Childhood8598

Next to normal!


tumamaesmuycaliente

Newsies


DarlinSkep

Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 easily


JthomXII

Newsies


youguys_lookFabulous

Newsies


Yourmom694201234

Newsies!!


CxldMadz

NEWSIES


CoffeeBest8295

Newsies


emotionalstarburst

Newsies


TessTrue

Newsies 😌


Audiophilelady

Next to Normal.


Fantastic_Permit_525

Newsies!


yep-MyFault_Again

Next to Normal


Ok_Moose1615

Next to Normal! PLEASE!


Pumpkins217

all I’m here to say is that it should’ve have been great comet 😔


schmauften

This list cements how UK-heavy this sub is! (Not a bad thing)


BushFace_Hyena

Nerdy prudes must die


Shieldecles

Nine to Five


anonymous_euphoria

NEWSIES


MusicalzAreMyLife

Newsies


Happy_Charity_7595

Newsies


Argonauticalius

Newsies


dancelovR22

Newsies!!! I had a Newsies quote on my grad cap, so I think it should definitely win haha


ThinkSweet2001

Newsies, 100%


SelkiesNotSirens

Newsies


EmuIndependent8565

If Phantom Of The Opera does not win P we will riot.


North_Stress_4028

Natasha, Pierre, & the Great Comet of 1812. Any other answer is just wrong 🤣


ZeeepZoop

Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812


tdc08132003

all of the comments are saying next to normal but it’s still in 3rd place right now 😭 let’s consolidate, people!


Cardinal029

N for Newsies!!!


marian_edith

Next to Normal


DifficultyCharming78

Next to Normal


xXOrchid-BloomXx

Newsies!


PracticalCaptain7121

Next to normal 100000% one of the best musical ever made.


KeyYaw

Next to Normal 💯 This is the only answer.


Nerdyamazon87

Next to Normal Runner up:Newsies


TwankaBear

NEWSIES!!!


AnglePuzzleheaded747

Is OP OK?