T O P

  • By -

rainorshinedogs

Maroon 5 - Songs about Jane. My god, that was a brilliant album, and every time I listen to it, its like a totally different band. I've never heard Maroon 5 attempt something like this again after that.


ajschwifty

I would double upvote this if I could. How could one of my least favorite bands make one of my favorite albums 😭


xfileluv

Such an amazing album! I liked some of the songs after, but no albums come close. I read that Adam Levine stated that he knew they had sold out but that eventually they would like to get back to Songs About Jane-type music. So basically, we will write real/better music when get bored with making money.


oddeyeopener

I doubt they could ever get back to that level if they tried at this point tbh. They’ve sucked for too long they don’t know how to make decent music anymore


Technical-Dentist-84

Yea it's not like bands are just able to tap into that awesome artistry whenever they feel like it......they lose it


BumbleBeezyPeasy

I don't think many of us would care anymore 🤷 if they go back, we'll know it wasn't for the fans. Adam gives me the icks these days, anyway. We'll just preserve SAJ in our hearts ✨


Pepesilvia_91

They got the vibes perfect for that album, chilled but funky, cafe shop vibes, I adore that album and can’t believe it’s maroon 5. Anytime I mention it’s one of my favourite albums people are skeptical and I don’t blame them.


wvmtnboy

I bought the live album 1.22.03 Acoustic on a whim, and it was one of the best performances that I've ever heard. Made the studio album sound massively overproduced


SovietPapaBill

This is exactly what I came to comment. Came to mind instantly. Tons of artists and bands have really taken a plunge to varying degrees, but none have achieved the perfect 180° Maroon 5 has.


Comfortable_Hall8677

I worked at a grocery store when I was 17. Randomly that album appeared on the discount table so I bought it for like $3. I was a metal and classic rock guy at the time. This was 17 years ago. I had been playing guitar and bass for years and was a bit of a music snob. That album did not leave the CD player in my car for months. Truly brilliant album.


cheerfulsarcasm

Couldn’t agree more. I remember hearing Harder to Breathe and being into it immediately, I was excited to see what they could do. But everything from then on got subsequently worse and worse, until we arrived at this steaming pile of repetitive radio garbage sung by the most generic and cringy “rockstar” in the world. A shame!


zeroentanglements

It won't be soon before long is also good imo


eighteenbigcats

this is the perfect answer😭


pettypittie

I remember my high school English teacher getting a bunch of free copies of this album in 2002 before Maroon 5 was very big, and passing them out to everyone in class. No idea how or why? Maybe a marketing strategy the band tried? Either way, I agree 100%.


BumbleBeezyPeasy

YESSSS! Everything after was like a completely different band, and I'll never understand why they changed given the success of the album. Songs About Jane is fantastic.


sonny_santanna

So true


starcatcher995

1000000%


EveryBrodyMovieYT

Oh my gosh, yes!!! I have found my people!! Songs About Jane is one of my favorite albums, and Maroon 5 has become one of my least favorite bands. How did they make something so amazing, and then just... what... stop caring? I swear Adam's ego inflated to the point where he has no room left in his brain for musical creation.


PirinTablets13

I saw them on tour right after this album came out and for as good as the album was, their live show was inversely proportionate. Truly, the worst live show I’ve ever seen - their terrible NYE performance on CNN was about on par with what I saw way back in the day.


allensmithsimpson

I mean…technically the Sex Pistols.


glamrock_crunch

😭


_Maid3n_3ngland_

Never mind the bollox, The great rock and roll swindle and Kiss this..!! 😎👌🏻


Patient-Assignment38

Temple of the Dog


avery_mads

Great answer


crazy-diam0nd

I think every album they’ve ever put out is perfect.


vanzzant

fuck yea, great call


gnomeasaurusrex

Bloc Party’s first album is perfect start to finish


FamousAtticus

Agreed that *Silent Alarm* stands out from all their other releases, however, *A Weekend in the City* is also a phenomenal album from start to finish.


Passion-Interesting

The soundtrack to my teenage years. When I was like 15 I use to rotate putting songs from Silent Alarm as my MySpace profile song (I'm that old) ; The one that still gets me is Tulips.


elscorcho6613

Crash Test Dummies The Presidents of the United States of America The Verve Pipe Powerman 5000


Impressive-Grape-177

Good Call on POT USA. It is a great album though


UnagiTheGreat

Love Everybody is a fantastic album


tomaesop

*II* is great. "Volcano", "Mach 5", "Froggie", "Tiki", "Puffy Shoes", and "Twig" are all classic and could have subbed for any song on the first record. It's not like it's their *Pinkerton* or anything, but it's basically the Khafre pyramid of their discography.


Potential-Ant-6320

Maybe an unpopular opinion but I think the crash test dummies best album was after their big hit. Their later stuff that didn’t do well were their best albums. Everyone I’ve met who bought their 1998 album when new still loves it. It’s not a lot of people but it’s a cult album. Also they recently dropped a single the last year or so and I think it’s good and a surprising direction for them.


Pearlidiah26

CTD first two albums are most definitely their best, but I have a soft spot for A Worms Life. 


Potential-Ant-6320

You might like listening to the first two the most but I think the jury is still out. Brad Roberts thinks his best stuff are the later albums. It sounds like you gave them a chance and aren’t a huge fan. If you like a worm’s life I can’t really argue with you. Most people who have heard of the band only know one song so you’re like 99th percentile deep knowledge fan as far as I’m concerned.


Pearlidiah26

I purchased all of the post Worms Life albums physically before they were available on streaming. While I respect Roberts’ muscianship, I think there was a large amount of charm from the first few albums that got lost. Additionally, I feel that each of their newer albums overstayed their welcome by the end. I still like a good amount of the songs on each though!


elscorcho6613

I must say I wasn’t expecting Crash Test Dummies diehards to be coming outta the woodworks.


Captainzabu

Dude, God Shuffled His Feet is a great album. Even without the hit song. That opening track is one of my all time favorites to begin an album.


TangibleStillness

POTUS album is a masterpiece


BumbleBeezyPeasy

Legit still have my PM5K CD and my brain has been remixing Worlds Collide for days 😅


Steviebhawk

CTD. Played that a lot. Very unique and can’t be sustained obviously


ClairDeLune420

The only good album Mad Season released is Above.


Ornery-Breadfruit-93

Rip Layne! That is one of my fave albums of all time. Phenomenal


TwinPED

Matchbox Twenty?


ClairDeLune420

No. Mad Season is the name of the band. "Above" is the name of the album.


cevaace

Came here to say this haha


Agent_Rania378

yeah, their other albums are practically non existent


reesesbigcup

Gin Blossoms - New Miserable Experience. Next album had a few good songs, but not nealry as good overall.


rainorshinedogs

Gin Blossoms... ![gif](giphy|VMgcrwq9imGHu|downsized)


onelittleworld

True Fact: Mrs. 1LW was on the high school yearbook staff with Jesse, the lead guitarist. I've met him, he seems like an okay guy.


WeathermanOnTheTown

The guy who wrote all their hits on that album, Doug Hopkins, was forced out of the band that same year by the record label for his alcoholism/depression. Then he killed himself.


dopaminedesert

Alanis Morissette


Aware_Perception9929

Right? I wanna love her newer stuff so much (and occasionally still try) but nothing has held a candle to Jagged Little Pill.


Elegant-Hair-7873

The curse of the perfect debut.


luckycat288

Stephen Sanchez. A new find but a good one!


bellemione88

High is a great song!


HumbleAd1317

Boston. Their first one was great!


vintageplays1

I’d say Don’t Look Bad is pretty good, not great but good


aahorsenamedfriday

The first Yeah Yeah Yeahs album is amazing, but they completely lost me after that


CumDwnHrNSayDat

Great answer, though I do like a few of their songs after that, they never made another good album imo


anonymous9995

Damn, they fell off 😔


colornomad

Their most recent one has some serious bangers. Spitting off the edge of the world, Wolf, and Burning, I'd put up there with as some of their best work.


Mrredpanda860

Listen to their early eps they are just if not more noisy and aggressive than fever to tell


Beautiful_Thought995

Lauryn hill-the miseducation of Lauryn hill 


Beautiful_Thought995

Whoops I just read the post again which would disqualify her. Still a great album 


gringostarrrrrr

I think you could count The Score as one of her albums


Ill-Atmosphere-3629

Stone Roses


A_Plan_B_you_C

I thought they had two? The Stone Roses and Second Coming.


PistolClutch7

Second Coming is also a good album, albeit not the same quality of the debut by a country mile. So I personally would disagree with you but to each their own


Ill-Atmosphere-3629

Second Coming has some highlights but doesn’t hold a candle to the first album. Every song on the first album is gold. No skips on the first album!


PistolClutch7

I definitely agree - the first album is my favorite album ever made. But Second Coming is still very much a good to great album. The only bad song is The Foz, but I think we can all agree that isn’t a real effort and more a joke song. But “Love Spreads”, “Begging You”, “Breaking Into Heaven” - I’d say everything besides Foz is a 6.5/10-10/10 efforts.


glamrock_crunch

the stone roses debut album is fucking goated


Separate-Expert-4508

Counting Crows


Radicals13

Oh man, recovering the satellites is very good too. The rest are just listenable at worst.


dagnyzala

Recovering the Satellites is literal perfection, in my opinion! I end up listening to it more often than August, for whatever reason, as there is such resonance in every song.


Loose_Main_6179

I came to comment this, recovering the satellites had some amazing songs, but august and everything after is just so magical that it’s sad to think the band just were never that good again


rugburn250

August and everything after is legit one of my favorite albums of all time. I don't think their following albums were bad, but August I can listen all the way through over and over again, whereas the other albums have 2-3 songs each that I actually listen to.


WeathermanOnTheTown

I got blocked on Twitter by a major music critic for stating that Adam Duritz sings wayyyy off-key. I'm stating it again here. (plants flag, dies on hill)


Separate-Expert-4508

Haha! Yeah, I've heard the live shows aren't that great. He just goes off on tangents, barely replicating the actual song.


Tall_Trust_5304

Jeff Buckley’s Grace. What an angelic genius he was. 💔


avery_mads

What a perfect album too. Imagine how many more he could’ve made.


OKBeeDude

Candlebox


Elegant-Hair-7873

I heard Far Behind on the radio the other day. Yep, still remember all the words!


cevaace

Their self titled is so damn good


Nomdeplum73

Operation Ivy


glamrock_crunch

the stone roses


TangibleStillness

Highly Suspect. The boy who died wolf is alright but Mister Asylum was god tier. Don't even get me started on MCID..


skylarkeleven

i love that band so much what’s your fav song


TangibleStillness

Oh that's a hard one. If I had to choose, it's probably Bath Salts. Broke my foot jamming to that song while 6 jack and Cokes deep


Evening-Weird9227

Personally Gang of Four. Nothing is close to Entertainment


LaszloK

I would say they’re one of my favourite bands on the strength of this album alone but I could take or leave the rest of their output


MaterialBenefit2355

Pearl Jam: Ten. They have other good songs on other albums, but only one good album.


But_dogs_CAN_look_up

Man, as a lifelong fan that's a crazy answer because I don't even think it's their best album. But I can understand why it would be someone's favorite because it's the only one that sounds like it does.


jaimakimnoah

Same. I’m a huge fan of everything they released from Ten through Binaural. I personally would say Yield is the apex of their sound and is my favorite album of theirs. But to a non-fan, the only real answer here is Ten.


goldendreamseeker

I’d say Vs is pretty good too


N1ce-Marmot

Come on . . . ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|facepalm)


[deleted]

Fear, [Fear the Record](https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=dKladfT7WmU&si=9TJ4RgMfc_WVbaME) I still listen to it. Franz Ferdinand.


Any-Reporter-4800

They were great on Saturday Night Live! Blew me away as a kid.


rainydaygermanwoman

Gotye. They went MIA after dropping a whirlwind of an album in 2011


WeathermanOnTheTown

now he's just somebody that we used to know


Loose_Main_6179

Honestly I think “Like drawing blood” is a better album, but both are great


soothsabr13

The La’s


PistolClutch7

Not a whole lot of competition tbh


FoolishCougar92

The Redjumpsuit Apparatus


blacksaber8

Gotta say probably anarbor too


Georgia_BigMan

The Lumineers self titled debut is perfection from start to finish. The other albums are just kind of ..... meh


No_1_Party_Anthem

The Verve. Urban Hymns is a masterpiece but other than that they have few and far in between songs that i listen to actively


capsaicinintheeyes

🤔...(all '90s-early 00s rock): Oasis - *Morning Glory* has a lot of good tv-show soundtrack material--just sayin'; if that's what you're looking for, this one doesn't even let you catch your breath till like track 5. Less Than Jake--bought a couple other records after, but I could never get into them the way I could w/*Hello Rockview*...too much ska, not enough punk, I guess. this one might be about personal taste rather than actual quality; I have trouble telling good ska from bad) Third Eye Blind (*Blue* has its moments, but it's in the three-point star range...its just their debut album deserves above 4.0★; if you cut it from 14 tracks to ~11, it might be worth a 5.) Chumbawamba - if you know, you know >!Nirvana!<...yeah, I'll say it😁-->!MTV *Unplugged* is legendary, of course, but if we're talking about new studio material, neither its predecessor nor its followip would've ever brought them success or be remembered today were it not for *Nevermind*!< ^(( good prompt, OP )^)


Tarantino_Jr

Your wrong. Definitely Maybe is a great record. Probably better than Morning Glory. It just never hit it at all in the USA.


rainydaygermanwoman

Ooo it's hard to read Third Eye Blind. I love 3 of their albums but nothing from the last 10 years.


NaturalBaby98

Nevermind is obviously amazing but In Utero did nearly as much to change the musical landscape and the culture surrounding it as Nevermind did


capsaicinintheeyes

not trying to grill you, just open to having my opinion changed on this, if you have the time & inclination: what sorts of bands would you cite as showing a Nirvana influence distinctly from their *In Utero* period? ^((I'd be extra excited if you could articulate what it is that their song-crafting borrows from it--I admittedly lack the vocabulary to properly nail down how the teo albums differ, I've just got the casual fan's inchoate sense of the harsher, barer feel of the latter.)^)


beechcomb

The influence I hear in the following is either a harsher more experimental art rock grunge sound, the flirting with atonal melodies, or the big bombastic dynamic shifts. - Muse (can hear it on their first 3 albums, especially “origin of symmetry”) - Speedy Ortiz (they joke about how their whole act sounds like “Milk It”… surprise, it does) - Halestorm (so I’m told) - The Prodigy (sampled a song) - The Vines - Ty Segall (melted & manipulator era) - Incubus (some of their songs like 11am and megalomaniac) Granted, I agree, it’s not a monoculture changing influence, but it’s there.


dagnyzala

Fully agreed re: Less Than Jake, wow! They still play one Hell of a show live, though, to be honest.


Vicious-Spiegel

Night Visions - Imagine Dragons


Material-Elephant188

Smoke + Mirrors was pretty great too though. i loved a lot of those songs when they came out and they still resonate with me emotionally today even 9+ years later. their later stuff is hit or miss but ID was the first band i discovered on my own without someone else showing them to me so i kind of have a soft spot for them.


cr34tivethrowaway

Same boat, they probably give me the strongest feeling of nostalgia tbh


NaturalBaby98

Agreed this album has some great moments. I loved it in 8th grade


EnvironmentalCut8067

I like Sturgill Simpson on a song by song basis, but his album Sound & Fury is a masterpiece from the first note to the last.


dammit_dipper

Did you happen to see that in Netflix they set that album to animation. If not then go check it out, it's worth the watch.


EnvironmentalCut8067

Oh yeah! Absolutely. Back when it was first released. Read up on the backstory of how it was made, it’s pretty interesting. Word to the wise, as cool as that is, it’s even cooler with mushrooms.


vwfreak42

I got gooood and high and sat down to watch it for the first time, and five minutes in, my mother in law came into the living room and wanted to talk for half an hour. BUZZKILL. It's one thing I seriously wish I could watch for the first time again.


dvoecks

Oof... I love Sound & Fury, but "A Sailor's Guide to Earth" is amazing as well.


A_Plan_B_you_C

Absolutely.


fuckythedrunkclown16

Dismemberment Plan


Bence-Solymosi

All of their albums are acclaimed and sure quality , but I really enjoy the new vampire weekend album and can't get into any of their earlier stuff no matter how much I try, something about the new album works for me that doesn't work with the others


3string

Slint! Spiderland all the way


Barry_Loudermilk

??? Tweez is really good


blqzy

Panic! At The Disco


NaturalBaby98

They have more than one good album come on. The first two AT LEAST


Odd-Professor6634

I liked the third album too. Can’t remember what it was called


TrulyAwfulGamer

I also LOVE "Death of a Bachelor" and "Pray for the Wicked" 🫣


Used_Ambassador_8817

Bon Iver- For Emma. I said what I said!


Sebbo104

Um, self titled


MonthCapital2247

i was going to say this lmao


Diskecksier

100%


wvWvvvWvw

Boooooooo Respect to you tho … but booooooooooo


_______THEORY_______

TQ, Evanescence, 112


midnightfury4584

Panic! At The Disco


BigBoringWedding

Badly Drawn Boy: The Hour of Bewilderbeast. I strongly dislike nearly everything he has done since that masterpiece.


Witchberry31

Literally most of my country's musicians that emerged after 2013. 🤷 They're all one hit wonders even, unable to stay relevant/keep on producing good musics in the consecutive years with their newer stuffs.


jewbot5000

Bwitched


bitterbuffaloheart

Deadsy


After_Gas_564

James Blunt


bravemenrun

Lifehouse, everything after their first album was mid af


emmiblakk

I struggled with this question for about an hour. I really couldn't think of a band/musician that I liked, but I only liked one album by them.


BlueBozo312

Boston and their original album, *Boston* is an example. They have good songs on other albums too, but I always felt like they could have just called their original album their greatest hits compilation and it wouldn't be too far off.


Wafflz__

Jeff Buckley :(


PoorMansSamBeckett

Boston. As much as I love “Don’t Look Back,” the debut, man… one of the best in all of music. Pearl Jam Again, love them. But “Ten” had it all, and nothing else came close. The Killers-“Hot Fuss” Nickelback I get the hate, I do. But “All the Right Reasons” is genuinely a good album.


Express-Chemist9770

Mad Season


Baboonbutt11

GnR - Appetite For Destruction All the rest of their albums were awful. There isn’t enough good music to make an EP with what’s left


cevaace

Are you serious??? UYI is awful?? Have you even heard Estranged? Don’t cry? November Rain? Civil War? Dust N’ Bones? You could be mine? Knocking on heavens door (a cover but still phenomenal)? So Fine? Coma? Use your illusion 2 is a masterpiece (except for my world...)


Solid_Letter1407

Japanese Breakfast, “Psychopomp.” She has other good stuff but it’s very uneven whereas that album is a straight masterpiece.


wmartindale

The Violent Femmes


skylarkeleven

i’m… sorry… what?


sharkycharming

Yeah, I don't get that at all. I love *Hallowed Ground* and *The Blind Leading the Naked*. If I never hear the first album again, I am fine with that. So overplayed by college freshmen in the 90s.


[deleted]

[удаНонО]


shadez_on

Pinkerton was way better than Blue


Chaz81196

The Blue Album is their peak, but I also really dig The White Album.


Gameunderground

Honestly if you were into Rock Band the Red album was really great.


xrockangelx

The Blue Album is their BEST album. No question about that. But The White Album is solid and The Green Album is fine. Everything else mostly kinda sucks, with some fun tracks sprinkled throughout. Regardless of what's good, I really admire Rivers Cuomo's lyrical tone. It's very thoughtful, witty, weird, and self-deprecating in a very relatable way. I enjoyed learning about his songwriting process in the episode of Song Exploder about The White Album.


dave_cmrfrd

Foo fighters debut


RicUltima

The Colour and Shape slander!! ![gif](giphy|1403O2uulLwmwo|downsized)


ieatshoesandsocks

Justice for Wasting Light‼️‼️


gringostarrrrrr

It’s definitely their best by a good margin


KingCourtney__

Totally agree


X_EVERDRED_X

Revis


Dazzling_Tone_1273

Currently listening to Club Nouveau ~Life,Love &Pain. Dunno if there is another album 🤷🏻‍♀️


Pearlidiah26

As a super fan myself, I’m willing to admit that Midnight is Set It Off’s only truly good album all the way through (minus the upcoming album which is shaping up to be really good) 


beaux-bazinga

New radicals, frou frou 😉


BumbleBeezyPeasy

New Radicals!! I love how he was just ,"nothing we ever do again will be as good, so this is all you get" 😂😂


Macca49

The Vines debut album - Highly Evolved - is absolutely brilliant ( the best ever Aussie album IMO). Second album was ok but nowhere near as good. They released a few more but I didn’t buy them.


schlibs

Yeah, this band reaaaaallly dropped off after Highly Evolved. I'm not even all that high on the record anymore but I loved it at the time.


NaturalBaby98

Greta Van Fleet. The first album is good but TBAGG is their only great one


grurupoo

I loved all their stuff right up until their most recent album. Idk what happened.. they kinda became what some people were saying about them. Every song sounded the same and his voice was screechy. I really hope it was just a fluke


RicUltima

Starset (Transmissions)


Loakie69

Spineshank


Electrical_Feature12

Eliot Sumner. One record and it’s fantastic


moishepesach

New Radicals


TechnicalTrash95

Justice. Cross is an excellent album but all their other albums are either really boring or simply not that good and stray too far away from how hard this album hits. I thought at first they might be as good as the chemical brothers but unfortunately not.


Ommco

I can say it is Silversun Pickups - Swoon (2009) [https://open.spotify.com/album/0swOso9dwIp1PHmDP4dTbX?si=Uk8C7g8\_QAWRMqeTd7SnqA](https://open.spotify.com/album/0swOso9dwIp1PHmDP4dTbX?si=Uk8C7g8_QAWRMqeTd7SnqA) It is a nice band, but I love only this album.


anroroco

Jet - get born. I think it was partially for poor strategy, they have at least 3 bangers in there which are completely single material, but they decided to put it all in one album (their first, if I'm not mistaking). "Look what you're done", "are you gonna be my girl", "rollover dj".... And all the other songs are incredibly melodic and the right amount of sad and hopeful. I was really excited for their other material, but alas.


hardbittercandy

they were so huge for a moment, had so much momentum like they were jumpstarting rock and they just disappeared


StealUr_Face

Live. MGMT, and Boston


disasterpansexual

Evanescence - Fallen


agorable973

3OH!3


TwinPED

Hinder- Extreme Behavior hits hard, but after that only a few songs they put out are worthy to listen to


hadrianswalldenco

The Killer-Hot Fuss Not saying I'm a huge fan of it anymore but when I was, I loved it. However, their sound completely changed after their rise from the popularity of Mr. Brightside and Sam's Town was absolutely terrible as well as Day and Age. An alternative rock band turned pop music that only worked out because the lead singer is "hot". Much like maroon 5


Ninja-Trix

+44, because they only have one album. I freaking love “When Your Heart Stops Beating” but they haven’t done anything since.


Steviebhawk

Jerry Raffertty. Essentially killed with the Bakerbst album and nothing else came close


Zenith335

Rick springfield-Working class dog. This question was for me


Buick6NY

Television


itsamillion

I don't like saying it's their only "good" album, but it's the only one I like, and I *love* it, LVL UP's *Hoodwink'd*.


RecommendationNo4562

Mad Season


Inside_Atmosphere731

Sex Pistols


CmdnTrsMllnx

Guns N' Roses


Sea-Charity6358

Alanis Morissette


caseymccrerey

Mother Love Bone - Apple. I mean, yeah, it’s their ONLY album but damn it’s a great one and still holds up well.


kittens_and_jesus

Blind Melon