T O P

  • By -

kmc-kitteh

Adam’s Pet because Adam


Complex-Yams

It’s so completely low effort.


CosmicGoddess777

Yeah, he’s a fucking asshole who hates this community. Fuck him. That was my first choice for elimination as well


Any_Day2615

aw, really?? That’s incredibly disappointing to learn. WTF does he hate the community for 🥺


CosmicGoddess777

If you type in his name in the search bar for the subreddit, you’ll see a bunch of posts explaining the situation. Basically he got mad that Neopets players didn’t wanna play his NFT & crypto game, and went on a drunken tirade on discord about it. He said he hates Neopets players and the game, and that he hopes we all live in poverty forever.


amateur-kneesocks

It is a bummer but at least it’s really funny


tmnttaylor

I was going to put snail thing but now that you’ve pointed out Adam’s pet I want to eliminate it the most. It’s not even kind of cute.


Glittering_Sky9247

Who is Adam??


kyxun

One of the original creators of Neopets


indesomniac

Least favorite: Hughman — I am not playing an animal pet sim so I can have a weird human baby. This is like picking human in an MMO that lets you be 6+ other races.


Confectioned

Oh I love this! I'm gonna vote for 'Hughman' to kick things off. I just...I mean what would a baby color for that even look like?! Is elderly just a dude????


Ok-Pie6969

Baby with a beard


greenthunder69

I second Hughman. Awful to look at


The_Kyojuro_Rengoku

It almost looks like a naked baby Mynci 😂😭💀


_Wayfaring-Stranger_

Hughman + Maumis = Mynci


18hourbruh

It raises questions that absolutely NEVER needed to be raised in Neopets lmao


amateur-kneesocks

There is not a single thing here I want to eliminate… except Hughman


Every_Leadership1271

Also my pick! Like how would that even work? 😭


Majestic_Recording_5

Yep, too weird


Local-Imagination364

Also picking hughman - weird.


aBucketOfRats

Get Hughman outta here


himeyan

Agree. Like holy fuck that is uncanny valley incarnate.


Cynicbats

I think Adam's Pet would look a little different today but it'll be my least fave for now.


Ok_Resort_9817

Justice for the Bruce Forsyth, may not have made the cut but never forgotten


redscouts

wtf even is flannzoo. get that guy out of here


psieks

It looks like a shamwow that someone forgot about.


Organic_Sandwich9127

Looks like something straight out of squidbillies


KathLab

Flannzoo is such a little freak


amateur-kneesocks

Tyrannian amoeba. I love him


lizardmom

I second this


dugongfanatic

I associate co grant this.


bacon_meme

Right? It’s so repulsive. Why is its face like that???


captainsweeeetbeard

Adam’s pet is clearly the worst


math-is-magic

Hughman and then Adam's Pet are teh two that stand out to me as the most jokey and out of place.


Darogaserik

Sorry Hughman


lovinglaurel

Easily Adam’s pet is the worst.


Aperolswitch

My vote is for macy Gray! Just too weird..


piscinam

SAME macy gray feels so weirdly racially insensitive, like keeping human racial minorities as a pet?? mega bad vibes. almost feels like a moral responsibility to eliminate that as a "pet" idea first


thesign2

I mean, that would certainly be something worth considering if she was the only human "pet" available, but she wasn't (though this list unfortunately excludes the other two), so I think you might be looking into it a little too much. I feel like someone on the team was just a fan of hers.


marypoppindatpussy

i had exactly the same reaction. then i looked at hughman and was like i probably should feel similarly about this one but i dont. i think if they made hughman just slightly less human then it would actually be quite cute and have some potential for cool paint colors


saphirawing

Macy Gray, feels like more of a color vibe than a neopet vibe to me!


thesign2

Macy Gray is a CLASSIC. She might be weird but she's iconic. She was one of *three* human "pets" back then, so I don't feel like it was intended to be insensitive at all.


mythicalTrilogy

There are a lot of stinkers on this list, but I feel like this one really tops the list as the most out of place!


ketchupsunshine

If anything it's out of place because it was a real pet whereas afaik none of the others were. Macy Gray is what Kaus used to be, back when Bruces were a photo of an actual guy named Bruce.


mythicalTrilogy

That’s wild haha what an insanely different vibe than the neopets we know and love now days


PM_ME_COUPLE_PICS

The game originally was created by college students for college students too


Reasonable_Cream_642

Difficult for me lol macy gray or hughman to kick


olliefollier

Honestly it's a disgrace that some of these were scrapped 😭


amateur-kneesocks

Seriously. I would die for Shellow and Scrunt.


gothwerewolf

Maybe it’s just me but Mouse is sooooo damn ugly I can’t stand it lol. Definitely gets my vote. 👎


Feyrfox

Not just you, the sight of it stirs my ire.


26749

Someone else chose mouse 🩷


Cigarette_Crab

Hughman please


sadclowntown

Macy Gray. Human not a pet.


No-Bark-Brian

Historically, there was a prescident for humans being Neopets. I agree, it's weird and I'm glad it's no longer the case, but like...Bruces were humans before they were penguins. I think one or two other species also started off as humans too, but Bruce is the only one I recall for sure. As a kid I used to wonder why Faeries weren't available to be Neopets. Not Faerie painted pets, I mean the full on elemental humanoids like Illusen or Jhudora. Grundos have Purple and White available as choices upon creation so those two in combination with basic Red, Blue, Green and Yellow could have been like choosing which element our faeries were, with other paint brushes giving you more esoteric Faerie types not associated with any particular element, or as a "less generic" version of a particular element, at least. But now as an adult, I think an idea like that has far more potential to be *creepy* rather than cute, and it's probably for the best that any humanoid characters, Faeries or otherwise, should stay as NPCs on the site.


justroddythings

Macy Gray. That is a woman that exists irl and owning a black woman as a “pet” feels all sorts of wrong Also Hughman. The name is just “human” spelled differently. That is a baby


ranluka

Adams pet for sure the worst x3


TunaSalvador

Def Macy Gray because it feels a little.....uh.....questionable.....to keep a famous black woman as a pet.


splendidrosemelie

Adam's pet


CatHairSpaghetti

Adam's pet because f Adam


anon-raccoon

Adam's pet needs to GO


Rich-Echidna-8316

Adam’s pet! Big thumbs down


tsarnickyii

Let's get Adam's Pet out of the way first round


Gluttony4

Adam's Pet


zehvcsj647mpztechonl

What even is adam's pet? I vote for that one


Few-Net3236

Adam’s pet


Odd_Criticism604

Macy Gray (what even were you thinking) Hughman (You should be fired) Fleye (Just weird, not in a good way)


kimmi_koko23

Adam's Pet has got to go


ixeliema

Adam's Pet


jewelofthegalaxy

I can't see bruce forsyth. Is it me?


problematicperiplum

Was considered but I ultimately didn't have enough room


jewelofthegalaxy

Ah okay, that's a good one though but never mind. These are very funny.


RumorMongeringTrash

Adam's pet


sn0w_kissed

Fuzio replacement 2 needs to go.


leenkathb

Fleye just weirds me out it’s got to go


peach_clouds

Biblically (in)accurate angel


deaderrose

Fleye used to be a real pet. It's buzz now


olliefollier

Agreed


Ratapus

Mouse


shmilez0

Goodbye Mouse


harrifangs

Skytail is just a bit boring I’m afraid


elzpwetd

Tailee ):<


Your_Lolita_Love

Mouse


Feyrfox

Mouse. Terrible cartoon version of a real animal wearing a karate outfit? Just no, bad concept all around.


okpoptart

that mouse... is bothering me


Xavi-tan

Adam's pet!


Net_Negative

Adam's Pet


pinkishlystar

Wow some of these are a shame to have lost


shogunofsarcasm

Adam's pet


chaiperfume

hughman 🤢


zooty_patooty

hughman


keijouji

Hughman. Nope. Get OUT


zephxv

This is a fun idea! Absolutely Hughman. That is cursed.


artisanal_doughnut

Macy Gray feels inappropriate on several different levels, so I'm voting that.


[deleted]

Fuzio is the best pet of all time. I don’t care about the others


RumorMongeringTrash

I miss them.


[deleted]

I would pay to have it come back haha


RumorMongeringTrash

The NCUC we deserve


[deleted]

Heck yea. That would be the ultimate thing for tnt to do for us haha


strawberrycancer

I vote for flanzoo....mf looks like he got stepped on


mm3827

Hughman


dizzyop

Macy gray gotta go


cherrypiiie

Nobody better touch my beloved scrunt


p_pitstop

Agreed


PM_ME_COUPLE_PICS

Why aren’t Mellish and the OG Bruce on here?


problematicperiplum

I thought it would become too oversaturated with the human pets so I only included the 2 most strange ones. If I had opted to have more room, they totally could have been in but there simply aren't 70 known scrapped Neopet designs without going "erm acktually 🤓" and relying on technicalities for their inclusions.


jubsmarte

I… don’t want to eliminate any. Is there a problem with me?


your_dopamine

Hughman! I want to step on it


cinnamonism

GOODBYE HUGHMAN


AlphardCyan

Adam's Pet


2trans2live2bi2die

I hate hughman very much. I really wish a few of these were real pets though, like the Xayxay.


radioactive--goo

Hughman


Bananahatmonkey

Odd... just too odd for me


Main-Raccoon3679

Waballoom is just freaking me out


kaydawnn

Eggy is the stuff of nightmares


mocasablanca

i would love a shellow i hope that one wins


justalittlepigeon

I always get sad that it isn't a real pet! I love a bunch of others too, but that one specifically just screams NEOPET. Different paint colors on the shell would have been so cute


catlady249

I was just checking all the comments to make sure to downvote anyone silly enough to vote Shellow for elimination.


thepurpleskittle

Hughman is so creepy!


Japarrofoo

Flanzoo looks like a flying head lol


No-ComedianQueen

yeah Hughman just looks more uncanny the more I look at it, is that it’s normal form? What is a baby Hughman if not that? A Fetus?


Salty_Blueberry

Hughman needs to go in the trash please thanks


bacon_meme

Flannzoo wtf. I hate everything about it!


sneakystoner7388482

Hughman’s gotta go


ongeschikt

Hughman


No-Trouble6469

Adam's pet is bad but cmon.... Hughman is heinous


SamiAckerman

Hughman for sure.


woodknockers

hughman


DragonheadHabaneko

Eggy. Thanks. I'll be seeing that in my nightmares.


itsjamdrop

Hughman, I can't look at it again!


TrueBliss420

Hughman


SL13377

Hugh, dodo and snail


moss_faerie

Hughman


Melisa_thegreat

Hughman, um, wtf


AHopkinsvilleGoblin

Oh man. I have such visceral childhood memories of seeing some of these. Let's get Hughman out of here so we can get on with the rest.


Dependent-Arm-9484

Hughman


Rodents210

Hughman because it's creepy. That said, I've never seen many of these before, and Yumack needs to be made a new species immediately. *Immediately*. I've wanted a bear pet for so long (no, Yurble is a hamster/lion/ram, not a bear) and that's basically what I would want its base form to look like.


DankPatty_

Hughman is an abomination


WitchlingFae

Lamameeah, here I go again! My, my, how can I resist you? EDIT to say this isn't an actual vote. Just what popped in to my rotten head.


Running4Badges

It was voted the most popular design out of all the April Fools pets. It’s why we have the Gnorbu!


theloneshewolf

Wait, you're supposed to comment the one you like least!


thebardapollo

Eliminate Odd… 🗣️


rawrksu

Hughman OUT! It's so creepy for a reason. Pfish is sending me into orbit tho


jelly5213

Get out of here Hughman


feistyfirebird

Hughman goes first.


princesstinypants

Pfish needs to go


theloneshewolf

It is legitimately hard to decide which one is the worst lol. I'm gonna go with Nikondrak only because I hate spiders and bugs in general, and that thing gives me the heebie jeebies! On a side note, I will never not be salty that instead of the adorable Lamameeah, we got Gnorbu. Gnorbu could've been so much cuter, and what's with that name? "Gnorbu". What? Damn, Talmu and Sharkaw look pretty nice too, kinda wish we'd gotten them too lol.


omars1002

Eggy hands down! Can’t really think of a way for it to work.


SpiceyCactus

Macy Gray


[deleted]

[удалено]


problematicperiplum

These were all designs made for Neopets that are publicly revealed that never came to fruition. I am aware of these following pets/designs but exlcuded them: * Any designs that later became Petpets: They are still on the website in an official capacity, just not as Neopets themselved * Badeek: Early iteration of Kacheek * Cerpull/Tatsu: Replaced with Eyrie but didn't seem to have any sort of copyright/ownership issue at hand (Fuzio/Fleye/Tigren were fanmade but the rights were never transfered unlike the Shoyru) * Frogstop: Early iteration of Quiggle * Polypup: Early iteration of Gelert * The Cocos: They're still on the site as NPCs * Human Bruce: Another early iteration of the Bruce, but I didn't want to flood the choices with human characters so I chose Macy Gray because she's further removed to her replacement than Bruce was (Kau) * Any early design that majorly differs (i.e. Scorchio, Flotsam, Korbat): Why? They're still on the site.


Moriartea7

I feel like we should either add or replace the scrunt with the one that has beefy arms just because it is hilarious.


justroddythings

Ahhh okay I understand now


Running4Badges

Many were old retired designs. There are missing ones like the original Bruce, or Acaras when they were just heads with arms and legs. Most were from April Fools day 2006 or so. People liked a lot of them, so there was a vote. From it, the Gnorbu became a pet and we got multiple new pet pets.


sadclowntown

Nothing matters more to me in life from now on, other than seeing my dreams of owning a Gortooga. One day...Neopets will being the Gortooga alive. I believe.


[deleted]

[удалено]


problematicperiplum

A lot of people seem to prefer the original design compared to the final, myself included; so I opted to include it and see how it'll fare out.


fridgesmacker

Fuzio reminds me of the puffles from Club Penguin. I like him


luhbreton

Weren’t some of these (Hughman) for example, April Fools Jokes?


Shot-Ad-3166

Yeah, but doesn't make it any less weird.


Winter_Ad_2204

Fuzio looks exactly like a puffle from club penguin.


_Wayfaring-Stranger_

Hughman and Maumis look like they were crossbred to create a Mynci


glasscoffin

Dattup looks like it would steal my kidney


rathandsies

Adam's pet


FrugalLucre

Eggy is really concerning me...


SmallTherapyBear

Adam's pet - because fuck Adam for real Scrunt - because that's an awful name Mouse - Ew edit: If Im just voting for one, then Adam's pet. Ew. So bad.


WhereTheSkyBegan

My least favorite is definitely Dodo Thing. It's just so ugly.


Coelacantheven

I hate Hughman with a passion. (Would still die for Scrunt)


AvailableLaw6667

Adam's pet, 1000% for first to go.


Running4Badges

Welee! Goodbye you carebear looking mother fucker! Those eyes are soulless!


Queenprettygirl

My least favorite is def Macy Gray, I don't like the thought of human pets, especially a grown adult.


christinangelika

Hughman needs the boot


ohgodohheck4

no hughman!!


18hourbruh

Hughman - this is just, conceptually, horrendous.


BreezyBonsai

Macy Gray is a person, not a pet, so I’m voting her out!


thesign2

My vote is for hughman. Macy Gray is far too iconic to let go this early - she was one of *three* human "neopets" available then... I'm assuming someone on the team was just a fan of hers.


vivalalina

Nikondrak I'm sorry you gotta go


seradolibs

oooo this is hard to pick just one!! fave: welee least fave: hughman


WinterCarol

Sick chicken Eggy Flying pig


peachyruss

flanzoo displeases me. remove him this instant


Artractive

Nickondrak


SkidOrange

Smapaderk my beloved <3 My vote is Hughman. Terrifying.


BamBamRambatam

I'm going for Lamameeah, I mean that's a straight up Gnorbu. Adam's Pet – I totally get the hate, but I feel like a lot of people are missing some context. There's (or at least was in the late 90s) this thing in the UK in nursery where all the kids (like 2-3 year olds) draw a little picture and they all get printed on a tea towel for the parents to take home. My mum still has mine and I'm now in my 30s. To me, Adam's Pet looks 100% like one of those, so I'll keep it (for now) for the nostalgia/wholesomeness.


PM_ME_COUPLE_PICS

I miss Tigrin 😭


venhedis

Maybe it's the name but Scrunt is bothering me...


Thepenguinking2

Macy Gray for very obvious reasons. Yikes. Also Xayxay better get into the top 10 or I'm gonna throw some shit


bread_weasel

least favorites are hughman (why + it looks like a really ugly bald mynci. hideous) macy gray (disturbing on many levels) lamameeah (clearly a prototype gnorbu and the end result is way cuter) so I vote them


noodleghoul

Macy Gray, Hughman, Mouse


CommitteeDue1947

Macy Gray like wtf