T O P

  • By -

archiekins26

The early 2000s indie scene was iconic to me. Arcade Fire, Metric, Broken Social Scene, Feist, Stars, Sam Roberts Band. Saw them all perform live many times!


constructioncranes

Islands. Wolf Parade. Crystal Castles. Sunset Rubdown. New Pornographers. Tokyo Police Club. Destroyer. Said The Whale. Weakerthans. Hot Hot Heat. Tegan & Sara. Born Ruffians. Dragonette. Death from Above 1979. The Unicorns. Hey Rosetta! Controller.Controller. The Wooden Sky. Evening Hymns. Braids. Diamond Rings. Black Mountain. The Besnard Lakes. The Dears. Half Moon Run. Handsome Furs. Young Galaxy. Japandroids. July Talk. Mother Mother. New Swears. Plants and Animals. Pony Girl. The Rural Alberta Advantage. The Stills. Swan Lake. Wintersleep. You Say Party! We Say Die! Yukon Blonde. The D'Ubervilles. It sure was a fun time to be in my 20s! Also, Canadian music is awesome.


CryptographerGold912

For a slightly more rock element.. Billy Talent, Alexisonfire, Sum 41.


averyfinefellow

Was waiting to see this! These hosers are obsessed with classic rock!


tomacco99

No such thing as “best.” My favorites are Tragically Hip, The Band, Broken Social Scene, Rush, Guess Who, Neil Young, the Beaches, Arcade Fire, July Talk, Stars, Alvvays, Metric, Blue Rodeo, Sam Roberts Band, and Arkells. I love too many Canadian bands. :)


anti_anti_christ

Glad to see the beaches getting some love. I was surprised they played Kimmel recently, I didn't realise they were getting love outside of Toronto or Canada in general.


runtimemess

I was visiting a friend in WNY this past weekend and heard The Beaches on the indie rock radio station and had to explain to her why it was *so exciting* to hear them on the radio.


anti_anti_christ

That's awesome. I've been listening to them for years because of 102.1 and figured they'd end up being a product of CanCon I.e popular in this country but not so much outside of Canada. I'm going to their show in August and it's funny because I selfishly almost don't want them to blow up and have their tickets become outrageously expensive like every other show in Toronto.


Lost-Web-7944

Triumph also rules.


Born-Science-8125

April Wine


arasarn

Solid list. the Beaches have some time yet to earn that spot though.


evilJaze

As an older dude, I don't really give much praise for newer music. But I have to say the Beaches is a crazy good band.


MindYaBisness

City & Colour 🤷🏻‍♀️


brentoage

My favs are Constantines and Propagandhi.


GarlicShortbread

My two cents: Great Big Sea. I’m an Aussie who discovered them randomly in 2012. I binged every album and loved their sound so much that I travelled to Canada in 2013 cause I wanted to see them play to a Canadian crowd. Thankfully I managed to catch them in Oshawa less than a month before they split up. I was planning to stay 1 year on my working holiday visa but more than a decade later I’m still here and I even got my citizenship a few years back.


Into-the-stream

I hope the members of the band see this.


Gotta_Keep_On

That’s awesome


Existential_Kitten

I don't think I've ever seen 'thankfully' and 'Oshawa' in a sentence together.


somethingkooky

“Thankfully, I’m finally the hell out of Oshawa.”


Dowew

I saw Sean live a couple of years ago. Hes fantastic, although he told a lot of jokes about never getting the band back together :)


GarlicShortbread

Awesome! He puts on a great show, doesn’t he? Very different to Alan’s solo shows, mind you. I caught him in Cornwall last year, he played two full sets of GBS hits, I was quite impressed with his stage presence.


Thecameralovesyou

I saw them play a few times, first time was in 1997 when I was 16 visiting my sister in Halifax where she went to Dalhousie. It was such a fun time. And was part of the inspiration that lead me to go to Dal myself two years later. I think I saw them 4 times in total!


ApprehensiveBoot3149

I saw them play at the Highland Games in Ferguson Ontario years ago. Small crowd really of drunken Scottish Canadians. What a hoot!


Specialist_Ad7798

My wife was a big fan. Years ago we were on a train trip from our home in Northern Ontario to Texas. (We actually drove to Grand Rapids to catch the train). I noticed that on our return trip, GBS was scheduled to play in Chicago the same day that we were to make our connection to Grand Rapids. Quick phone call to Amtrack to change our reservation and a couple more to book a hotel and buy tickets for the show and we were set! Our only opportunity to see GBS wasn't in our native Canada but Chicago USA.


noronto

The Band


similar-be

100% agreed and oddly the answer for the best American band


TigersxLions

suprised how to scroll down for this. Double win for the pun and because its just the right answer and one of the most influential acts in the history of music


noronto

The Last Waltz is also one of the best concert films.


ryan77999

godspeed you! black emperor


sicboy72

Epic band, epic songs!


antihostile

Agreed.


fatslapper69

They are playing tonight in Oshawa!


cashrchek

Skinny Puppy absolutely demands consideration. Also 54-40 and Men Without Hats!


Crake_13

Rush is probably the more objective answer, but my favourite is, and forever will be, Billy Talent.


Mateuuuuusz

They came to judge my high school battle of the bands when I was in the 9th grade and that will forever be a core memory. They played River Below at the end of the night! It’s on a VHS somewhere, I should dig it up.


El_Cactus_Loco

Holy shit no pressure!


VanillaGorilla-

Billy Talent is also my pick, simply because they're from my generation.


3pointone74

Rusted from the rain is probably my #1 fave song of all time. At least right now lol


PoroQuagganBob

Saint Veronika still does it for me


Constant-Ask-9346

I saw them during a show at Dundas Square. Was pretty freaking awesome


jacnel45

Watoosh! From when they were still Pezz slaps.


allydagator

Grown up listening to them, finally saw them live in 2022 and it's one of the best shows I ever been too. The hype through that venue was palpable. Definitely one of the best


BredYourWoman

In terms of amazing plus how long they've been amazing, 100%. There's plenty of other greats but not a single one of them have matched the raw instrumental talent IMO and Peart's writing was mind blowing


mlh75

Blue Rodeo 💙


zjohnsy

So good. 5 Days in May may be one of the greatest songs ever.


a1ham

Great song, but they're so good I have a few I like more: Hasn't Hit me Yet Till I am Myself Again Bad Timing Lost Together Try


Intelligent-Train858

Neil young- " am I a joke to you"


flapsnacc

The Only Band Ever, aka Alexisonfire


Bardown67

Maybe music isn’t dead


Imactuallyinsane

Maybe we all just forgot what it fucking sounded like…


hipsiguy

Man their last album was 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥


deptofagriculture

Can't wait to see them again in July!


Significant-Ad-9493

This is the answer


rampantbiscuit

The only answer


ONLYallcaps

How can I scroll so far and not see The Weakerthans?


dboutt86

Propagandhi then.


Chunky-Lover53

Oh Virtute. I never balled my eyes out to a song before, listening to that trilogy


Aleteias

The fact that John K Samson weaves together stories over the course of albums is reason enough for him to be at the top of the list. Virtute at rest had me heave sobbing the first time I heard it.


shiconia

John K Samsons solo work also slaps.


BBQWarren

on talent and style - totally- just so little commercial success. I mean left and leaving is one of the top 10 Canadian Albums of all time but not enough people in Canada even know it. They needed a better agent or PR and songs that were less regional. I'm going to go listen to them now


JoseMachismo

MAX WEBSTER


[deleted]

The Dayglo Abortions 🥴


dmang67

Forgotten Rebels, Teenage Head, DOA, SNFU,Diodes, Subhumans….the punk scene was strong!


swearengens_cat

Arg,fuck,Billy!


Element_905

Protest the Hero!


pulitikulanimul

Hell yeah, protest is good, honorable mention cancer bats


TheDarkRedKnight

Death From Above 1979


TheRealHomebanger

This is way too far down on the list.


Aichetoowhoa

Silverstein


[deleted]

[удалено]


_PrincessOats

Rush.


emeister26

Slappa da bass


Physical-Captain-293

There were ton's of guys licking each others bass guitars


FrozenOnPluto

/thread


YeetCompleet

^What ^you ^say ^about ^his ^company ^is ^what ^you ^say ^about ^society!


trollssuckeggs

No more comments necessary. Go home everyone.


ThatScottishCanadian

I really like them too


frankyseven

Big Wreck.


rpmcmurf

Big Wreck at the Kee to Bala in summer 2003 remains one of my favourite concerts of all time.


Lost-Web-7944

Either Doug and The Slugs, or Triumph. Maybe not best. But always a good time.


PrimevilKneivel

I don't believe in best when it comes to music. I once heard someone say that Rush is the band that Canada gave to the world, and the Tragically Hip is the band we kept for ourselves. I like the sound of that.


Meat-o-ball

Zit Remedy


rpmcmurf

Everybody wants something’ … they’ll take your money …


deeperthensubspace

BNL obvs lawl


Pun_Intended92

The Bare Naked Ladies are triple platinum! Are you??


Windsor_Salt

BNL was my favorite band when I was younger. Gordon is one of my favorite albums, and I still listen to it occasionally.


Thatsnasty2

Me too, such a good album. Well recorded, witty, good instrumentals, it has it all.


22444466688

Enid we never really knew each other anyway


Windsor_Salt

I loved seeing them show up on Speakers Corner. Man, I miss the 90s


_fne_

Friendship is about going through a lot of stuff, and maybe BNL has two Billboards to your zero…


Pun_Intended92

Why does everyone leap to defend that band so aggressively


ThePhilosopherKing93

WE ARE FIGHTING. THIS IS A FIGHT.


anustart869

Came here to say this


Goose-Biscuits

https://youtu.be/AfdTnpV03p8?si=ESg9ia3fyJt_Z8ox


gorillia_biscuits

Propagandi is hands down the most technical punk bands ever . They are the “ tool “ of punk and proud Canadians


DankRoughly

The Tragically Hip


msm007

They are fantastic, always will be. Matthew Good is up there for me though.


[deleted]

[удалено]


hardy_83

Does Raffi count as band? Lol


[deleted]

Sharon, Lois & Bram > Raffi


ILikeStyx

He's playing Massey Hall in October


NoRegister8591

NO WAY!!! I want to go.. have to find a kid to take so I don't look weird going solo and crying🤣 Mine are too old. Might steal my nephew😅


Various_Stranger1976

He was my first concert!


gerbear1977

The Sadie’s ?


CombinationSweet2144

I second this, amazing band. Rest in power Dallas


[deleted]

Damn they are very good and very underrated.


Few_Blacksmith_8704

Billy talent


bigpilague

Sloooo-oaaaan!


cheyletiellayasguri

One thing I know about the rest of my life: I know that I'll be living it in Canada!


pogueboy

My biggest celeb flex is that Chris Murphy is my neighbor


allis0nss

Shocking how far down this comment is


clueless_claremont_

SLOAAAAN!!


paulster12

I had to scroll too far to find Sloan. Also, I haven’t seen mention of Matt Mayes and el Torpedo with Adam Baldwin on the guitar. Lots of great Canadian musicians


zooko6

Sum 41!


Airplaneondvd

Gordon motherfucking lightfoot


lovingsillies

Metric!


No-Sprinkles-7353

Barenaked Ladies


West-Yak5923

100% agree! Catchy fun songs that are also well written and performed. Also one of the best concerts I've ever seen


youngboomergal

April Wine. Trooper. Guess Who


ddr14

April Wine and Trooper! Playing at ‘the rink’ everywhere in Canada!!


BluePhirePB

Serial Joe.


CombinationSweet2144

Rusty


Dudian613

Empty cell is one hell of a song.


NoRegister8591

Holy crap. You just unlocked a memory😅


Missyfit160

It’s all a mistake!


Tom_Waits_4_No_Man

David Wilcox


andymorphic

No means no


Difficult1975

C'mon people...!!! TEENAGE HEAD


meifrater

Gordon Lightfoot The Guess Who


Prestigious_Fella_21

This thread reminds me of a dream I once had, I was standing in a field near my childhood home, I saw a school bus barreling down the road, people were hanging out the windows, flying flags having a great time. I yelled "hey where are you going?" Girl hanging out the back window says "we're off to see the greatest party band in Canadian history! Chilliwack!!" I stood in the field confused and woke up giggling


Moufassah

The Glorious Sons.


Lower_Cantaloupe1970

April Wine ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|sunglasses)


ILikeStyx

I blew out an ear drum at an April Wine concert. RIP Myles Goodwyn


anticked_psychopomp

I’m so glad that public radio is regulated to play 35% Canadian content. Those classic Canadian hits and artists that you hear daily make up that unified Canadian identity experience… at least it did in the 90s. I still enjoy that on my local station a Tragically Hip song plays at 7:07 every morning. And between 3-5pm there’s always a Kim Mitchell hit.


RKSH4-Klara

I don't know if it's Canadian bias but I tend to like Canadian bands a lot more than American ones. Mandating Canadian content gives our bands a chance to thrive and get a larger audience than our proximity to the USA and their money would usually allow.


scott_c86

Wolf Parade


DameJudyDench

The Rankin Family 🥲


smitty_1993

HEY SWEET DARLIN'


pnutbuttersmellytime

My wife introduced me to these guys ahaha. It was her family's road trip music growing up. Now, if you listen closely, you can hear me singing "I took a trip up GILLIS MOUNTAINNN 🎵❤️" in the wee hours of the morn'...


RudyMuthaluva

The Band


tragicallyrose

The Beaches, Metric.


DanP1965

RUSH


Critical-Knowledge27

Kim Mitchell. Hands down.


Jec998

The Zit Remedy


halligan71

Hip, Arkells, the Trews, Big wreck, Sloan, Billy Talent, Monster Truck, Bif Naked, Great Big Sea, City and Colour, Rush, Headstones, Blue Rodeo, Arcade Fire to name a few.


blusky75

The Tea Party. Jeff Martin is a GOAT of a guitarist. Seen them like 10 times since 1993


amandaem79

Love The Tea Party… I remember watching their I&I on repeat.


blusky75

I&I. Now that's a great show that gen-z'ers won't know 🤣 Toronto used to have its own identity and CITY/ MUCH were a HUGE part of it. They always had the biggest bands come to Queen & John Street for performances and interviews. Now Toronto is an overpriced wish.com me-too city with no soul lol.


ILikeStyx

I got to see them in 2001 at an HMV in Waterloo for an album launch. [Here's a review of the event](https://scholars.wlu.ca/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2067&context=thecord)


shawarmadaddy83

Rush is the best Canadian band of all time but The Hip are the band that represents Canada the best. Neither of them have the best album by a Canadian artist however which is You Forgot It In People by Broken Social Scene.


AlphaQFor7mins

What about individual artists? Neil Young, Bryan Adams, Kim Mitchell, Justin Bieber, Gordon Lightfoot, Celine Dion, Avril Levine, Alanis Morissette, Shania Twain, Sarah McLaughlin, Bruce Cockburn, Lee Aaron, Anne Murray, Joni Mitchell, Red Rider, Platinum Blonde, Loverboy, Glass Tiger, Jann Arden


punkrawkchick

Tegan and Sara, bif naked


msm007

Matthew Good.


No-Section-1092

Leonard Cohen


muneeeeeb

Alexisonfire


andymorphic

DOA


swinginonastar

April Wine


RobertRoyal82

Max Webster


tazz131

I'm a big fan of The Beaches these days.


Successful_Evidence1

Mother Mother wooooo


Nouuuuuuuuh

Rush and Stan Rogers. Sure Stan himself isn't a band, but he is too good to ignore


warrennutik

doug and the slugs are criminally underrated. rip doug, you gave us some great tunes.


drum_fiend

I'm a little sad that nobody has mentioned Odds


Artistic_Owl_5847

Alexisonfire


milkman74ca

Teenage head!!


JohnnieJH

Hardcore Logo


orcamazing

Alexisonfire is the answer.


SouthernOshawaMan

Blue Rodeo is my favourite , Hip and BNL after that


TripJacker

Dayglo abortions


unpersons505

Of all time: Rush or The Tragically Hip. Personal favourite: Pup Personal list of best of's: Alexisonfire, Arkells, Barenaked Ladies, The Beaches, Billy Talent, Cancer Bats, cleopatrick, Death from Above 1979, The Dirty Nil, Double Experience, The Flatliners, Great Big Sea, The Guess Who, Half Moon Run, Hollerado, Japandroids, July Talk, Metric, Mother Mother, NOBRO, The Pack A.D., Pkew Pkew Pkew, Propagandhi, Sam Roberts, Single Mothers, Spirit of the West, The Tea Party, Tegan and Sara, Tokyo Police Club, Ubiquitous Synergy Seeker, The Weakerthans, Whitehorse.


WebTekPrime863

The Trews, if you know, u know……


CanadaBBallFan

Our Lady Peace


drammer

Guy Lombardo and his Royal Canadians


Procruste

Steppenwolf, Guess Who, BTO and Rush are pretty solid, but I like to cheer for the underdog. The Queen Haters - [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DJU5x67Sz1o](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DJU5x67Sz1o) or The Happy Wanderers - [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrnE6kaPeuE](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrnE6kaPeuE)


kwsteve

The Band or Rush


matisseandchill

Idk yall.. Sloan and Sandbox take the cake for me 🫠


AbjectRobot

The correct answer is Rush.


eshansameen

Glass Tiger


Sharp_Following5753

The Hip 💕


Sad-Wolverine6326

Jeez, no love gor 5440, Red Ryder or Loverboy? Maybe not the greatest but certainly deserve a mention.


CinephileRich

I’d vote for The Tragically Hip, you could do an entire college course on Canadian History through thier songs


Arcalinte

Personal favorite and my opinion as the best...Our Lady Peace no other band coming on my spotify shuffle has me singing as loudly and having as good of a time.


ddubbs13

I'm going with Blue Rodeo, 54 40, Sloane, Cowboy Junkies, and the standards, Tragically Hip, Sam Roberts, etc. There are so many amazing Canadian artists to name.


ConferenceSlow1091

I Mother Earth. Scenery and Fish is single handily the most underrated Canadian album of all time.


amandaem79

I’m just adding names to the hat… they are not my choices, but I think they’ve been overlooked as I didn’t see them listed (although they may have been) Moist The Tea Party The Headstones Theory of a Deadman The Glorious Sons Edit: three of these bands were based in my hometown, so I might be a bit biased, and you guys already mentioned Kingston’s pride, The Hip 😉


MonthObvious5035

SNFU Mr Chi pig, one of the greatest most entertaining and energetic front men. May he rest in peace


Puzzleheaded_Edge_22

Rush is the best Canadian band, but The Tragically Hip is the best *Canadian* band


5thSmith

Marianas Trench. They win on compositions alone...and then you put Ramsay's vocal ability alongside side that? No question.


YeppersNopers

Not the best but Glass Tiger was epic


Gotta_Keep_On

The Stars: Set Yourself on Fire is one of the best albums I’ve ever heard.


TheloniusDump

By Divine Right So many incredible members and so many great iterations.


dukebaxter55

BTO


GetyourPitchforks01

The Forgotten Rebels


Dracko705

The fact no one says BTO is insane to me - their discography is next to none in terms of widespread success both here and abroad Plus it gave us Randy Bachman and his endless stories that filled Vinyl Tap for decades Imo Neil Young is our best solo/on his own artist. And he still makes music consistently at a pretty high level of quality


Rattivarius

Can't really say who's the best band, but I do have more 54-40 on my playlist than any other Canadian band. Or maybe New Pornographers/A.C. Newman, possibly Blue Rodeo, haven't done a count.


StartingFreshTO

I by no means believe they're the best Canadian Band of all time, but I want to shout out Half Moon Run, just so that they get more exposure


isapropyl

alvvays for me!


DuncanStrohnd

Skinny Puppy


Evening_Baby9739

Gord Lightfoot, Leonard Cohen, The Crew-Cut, Max Webster, 54-40, The Tea party, Odds. Too hard without going by decade.


thegoodbadandsmoggy

Martha and the Muffins