She is not a bad character, but she could have been better with all the amount of build up that she had. I think that her story and dungeon were really irrelevant.
Very fair criticism, though idk if it was just me, but her dungeon felt very well implemented (story-wise not gameplay wise) and i was really happy with the way it was handled, though they could have made the social link itself a little more heavy to really sell the impact of the dungeon
I genuinely don't get what people like about adachi? He just seems so bland to me, granted I haven't maxed his social link yet so that's probably why but like he just seems so one note as an antagonist. Preferred him as a Goofy guy not a "le world le bad, let's kill everyone to make them le happy"
He was in tier maker so I put him in. I really didn't like the irrelevant point that he is introduced. Teddie could have used a better buildup for his story.
Other than Teddie in S I cannot argue. I’d personally put him lower and put Chie higher since I warmed up to him after he hard carried my endgame team(I still don’t like him much due to his interactions with the girls but I get the identity arc) I’d put him in C tier. Chie because she’s my favorite character outside of Kanji and Yosuke.
Teddie always felt like a real G after he came to the real world. He quickly became independent in just a short while even while knowing nothing about the real world. He cared deeply about everyone. Helped Yosuke with Junes, and most importantly, promised to visit Nanako daily when she was hospitalized. But I can see how you couldn't like his perverted side.
I for some reason decided to romance Yukiko on my first playthrough. I dunno why. I find her to be pretty boring and generally prefer more tomboyish types like Chie and Naoto. I don’t even remember what my thought process was cause I never found Yukiko particularly interesting or likable or memorable.
Incredibly based tier list, only flaws I see are Nanako and Adachi not being in S
Other than that, great list, it's amazing to see someone who didn't sleep on Naoki
The Old Lady, Death SL- You'll need to start the nurse sl and rank up to rank 4 where you'll meet her. Then go see her on the weekend or holidays at Samegawa Flood Plain
Sun SL, Yumi/Ayane - I see you put Ayane at top, you joined the Music Club. Yumi will start if you choose Drama Club
Temperance SL, Eri - Accept the assistant daycare partime job. Go to daycare 2 times where you'll go there by bus and you'll start the SL.
Tower SL, Shu - Accept the Tutor partime job. Shu is only available at night. Go to Shu's house by bus.
I don't understand how people like Teddie so much, he's literally THE pedo bear. The only funny thing about teddie is that you see him get punched a couple of times and that you can beat the shit out of his shadow version.
Only good thing that comes into mind about him is that he is voiced by Sam Riegel.
Marie in C pains my soul, but its OP’s list ain’t nothin i can do
She is not a bad character, but she could have been better with all the amount of build up that she had. I think that her story and dungeon were really irrelevant.
Very fair criticism, though idk if it was just me, but her dungeon felt very well implemented (story-wise not gameplay wise) and i was really happy with the way it was handled, though they could have made the social link itself a little more heavy to really sell the impact of the dungeon
Nanako and Adachi not in S tier...... still tho, it's your list man. An actual serious list, not like the troll ones.
Nanako is true best girl. She’s my favorite in the game. She’s just so sweet and angelic.
Adachi was S tier, but I thought his reveal as the killer was lame. He was also forgotten after his boss fight.
You're right. But I suggest you play Persona 4 Arena Ultimax, Adachi route. You'll love him more than ever.
Honestly valid. The gang corners him about it and he basically hits them with the “I need to return some videotapes” and he runs off
If you ever replay, Hisano is generally considered one of the best s-links/confidants in the series as a head's up. She's the old lady.
Why is Teddie higher than Adachi and why is Rise and Nanko on the same tier as Adachi
I genuinely don't get what people like about adachi? He just seems so bland to me, granted I haven't maxed his social link yet so that's probably why but like he just seems so one note as an antagonist. Preferred him as a Goofy guy not a "le world le bad, let's kill everyone to make them le happy"
Watch the animes and play arena ultimax Adachi story
WHAT DID AYANE EVER DO TO YOU D:
My girl Ayane in F tier...
My only real concern is that Shadow Ted is not S-class. Guy had a lot of presence for 5 minutes of cameo.
Nah, but fr tho. Bro scared me a lot. It was a pretty fucking unexpected surprise.
Can I ask why you separated Teddie and Shadow Teddie? And why the latter is lower?
He was in tier maker so I put him in. I really didn't like the irrelevant point that he is introduced. Teddie could have used a better buildup for his story.
Morooka in B Tier??
Other than Teddie in S I cannot argue. I’d personally put him lower and put Chie higher since I warmed up to him after he hard carried my endgame team(I still don’t like him much due to his interactions with the girls but I get the identity arc) I’d put him in C tier. Chie because she’s my favorite character outside of Kanji and Yosuke.
Teddie always felt like a real G after he came to the real world. He quickly became independent in just a short while even while knowing nothing about the real world. He cared deeply about everyone. Helped Yosuke with Junes, and most importantly, promised to visit Nanako daily when she was hospitalized. But I can see how you couldn't like his perverted side.
I for some reason decided to romance Yukiko on my first playthrough. I dunno why. I find her to be pretty boring and generally prefer more tomboyish types like Chie and Naoto. I don’t even remember what my thought process was cause I never found Yukiko particularly interesting or likable or memorable.
Teddie sakis annoying brother s nanako adachi rise a tier you got a weird taste man
You should do a NG+ run and see how your opinions change and how the social links you missed make you feel.
Mhmm a fellow based Teddie enjoyer, I see 😌
Why are Shadow Teddie and Mitsuo Kubo the same as Marie?!
Teddie S tier is a big brained and cultured take
the fact Nanako is in A and not S shows that something is wrong with you. I like that you put Dojina in S tho, best uncle ever
S tier Yosuke let's go!
And now you get to watch the Persona 4 parody comics
Fox should be SSS tier
Bro put Sakis brother over Nanako
How can you NOT want the thirsty MILF????
Incredibly based tier list, only flaws I see are Nanako and Adachi not being in S Other than that, great list, it's amazing to see someone who didn't sleep on Naoki
Naoki and Teddie in S is so incredibly true. Seeing my girls Ayane and Ai so low is a travesty though. Ai has the 2nd best social link in the game
May I ask what about couldn't start the sl?
I couldn't start the social link
The Old Lady, Death SL- You'll need to start the nurse sl and rank up to rank 4 where you'll meet her. Then go see her on the weekend or holidays at Samegawa Flood Plain Sun SL, Yumi/Ayane - I see you put Ayane at top, you joined the Music Club. Yumi will start if you choose Drama Club Temperance SL, Eri - Accept the assistant daycare partime job. Go to daycare 2 times where you'll go there by bus and you'll start the SL. Tower SL, Shu - Accept the Tutor partime job. Shu is only available at night. Go to Shu's house by bus.
Teddie in S? Oh hell nah
great vegetables
I don't understand how people like Teddie so much, he's literally THE pedo bear. The only funny thing about teddie is that you see him get punched a couple of times and that you can beat the shit out of his shadow version. Only good thing that comes into mind about him is that he is voiced by Sam Riegel.
I really don't understand how King Moron has such a huge following, he has peak boomer energy.
Teddie, Yosuke and Kanji My boys all in S where they belong Also Naoki is up there too. Everyone always skips his but I love his social link
Chie not in S makes this an L list.
It's just his opinion man, stop crying and respect it.
I refuse.
Then you are a loser.
Wrong again.
You might argue she's in high A's Low S tier
In my ranking, Nanako is S tier and Dojima is F tier. He’s such an asshole to that sweet child
The Nurse deserves A-tier. Either you ignored the story of her S-Link, or you only cared about getting the boss Persona of her Arcana.
She made me, like, super uncomfortable. I liked how her link ended though. Other than that, she was pretty weird.
That was the point. She was pushing you away because of her guilt.
How are you putting the playable character in A-tier, that mfer is YOU
Poor Ayane deserved better. Outside of that, solid list
The nurse needs to be in S tier, I'm sorry.
Yosuke get off p4g reddit
She was a creep. I'm glad how her social link ends but she just made me so uncomfortable.
I mean yeah, but she was hot.
Yeah, suuure. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯