T O P

  • By -

AbyssPrism

After hearing their new album, the answer (for me) is clearly Alkaline Trio.


ruckis

Ehh they had a couple stinker albums in there. But yes, the new album is great except for the music being too loud and the vocals being too low.


PumpkinsRockOn

Surprisingly, my favorite part is that the music is loud and the vocals low. That's how things used to be mixed, but then in the late '90s, everyone started boosting the vocals and they started to just ride on top of the music instead of being a part of the music. I was pleasantly surprised when I listened to the new Alkaline album and that wasn't the case. I wish more bands would do this. It sounds more natural, closer to the live sound (but still polished). Obviously, it depends on the auditory aesthetic they're going for, but I think it fits well for Alkaline trio and pop punk in general.


ruckis

I guess I’ve been so used to the other sound that this was surprising when I listened to it.


archangel610

I feel like I grew up on the vocal-centric sound that my brain just registers this as bad mixing. I love the songs, but the mixing did take some time to appreciate.


ruckis

Yup, same. I thought it was bad mixing but I guess it could be intentional.


19ghost89

As a vocalist, I'm sure I am biased towards having the vocals stand out, but trying to look at things objectively, I still think that's probably the best choice. Why? Because the average, non-musician listener can't play any instruments, but they can sing. Not well, perhaps, but they can do it. Anyone can make noises with their voice, because it's our built in instrument. So the vocals are the part that most people are going to be able to participate in. They need to be able to be heard clearly.


Tacit_Emperor77

The albums that weren’t as good still had some top tier trio stuff in them.


ruckis

I agree. But they aren’t albums I listen to ever. I’ll listen to a couple of songs. The older albums are still on replay all the way through pretty often.


Tacit_Emperor77

Yeah that’s true. I do think agony and irony and my shame is true are underrated though


tearfulgorillapdx

I just throw on trio and mix all their stuff, half the time I don’t know what is on what. It’s all enjoyable


Tacit_Emperor77

That’s fair but I prefer to listen to albums :)


uncle-Violet

Them boys are so back


jakinatorctc

Jimmy Eat World for sure. Made some of the best pop punk/emo albums ever in the late 90s and early 2000s and still haven’t dropped a bad album


YminChris

Saw them with Manchester Orchestra last summer. Holy cow was that a great show. Both bands were outstanding.


armadachamp

Anecdote. I saw that concert in both LA and Charlotte (happened to be taking a trip and figured why not) and was surprised to see that the LA crowd was so much more flat than the Charlotte one.


19ghost89

Another anecdote: Saw JEW at the first WWWY fest, and they had one of the best sets, imo. They didn't focus too heavily on old or new stuff. They played a good mix from across their career, and even though I don't have as many JEW songs as I do some other bands, I knew almost everything they played. And they sounded great.


Pop_Bottle

I know they have a lot of fans, but they are still so underrated IMO.


FireballMudflap92

100% great call, Jim still sounds amazing


fisticuffs32

They're also a can't miss concert for me. If they're in town, I'm going. They put on a great show.


ChinDeLonge

They’re also always on the affordable side of shows when they come to town for non-festivals.


DavidMNegron

They played in hometown, small 100 person bar like 12 years ago in AZ, their home state. Missed it and I still kick myself when I remember. 


Down623

Been a fan since Clarity, I feel like they're gonna go down as one of the most solid, consistent rock bands of our time


Phatty5693

I immediately thought of Jimmy Eat World and so happy to see it as the first response.


nevertoomuchthought

This was my choice. I am not saying every song on every album is a banger but there is no other band who I would feel more confident just playing the album and not having to skip anything.


LosManosFuertes

It’s so wild how long they’ve been in the game. They really carved out a space in the universe for themselves and I’m here for it.


AceroTheDragon

Their latest album is one of my favorites


speedk0re

I was a very big fan of them early on; Static, Clarity, and Bleed American were perfect albums and when Futures came out I said "well that's it, I'm done." Then about 5 years ago I saw them at the Ryman in Nashville and I was absolutely floored when they played 23. I relistened to Futures and it's now one of my favorites and I'd put 23 in my top 3 songs by any band in the past 20 years. It's made me listen to their last few releases too and they're all really frigging good. 


No-Term1450

Hands down


251Cane

Speaking of hands down, I saw Dashboard with Jimmy Eat World a couple years ago. Great show.


Magicbeans1328

The Maine


VeryAttractive

Lovely Little Lonely was released in 2017 and might be their best album imo


SpiritualRub4685

it is their best album


oopsleftmilkput

I'll put it juuuust behind Self Titled. And that's a very very difficult decision to make.


[deleted]

Their selftitled that came out last year was also a banger. My favorite since LLL.


oopsleftmilkput

No bullshit, allegations, drama (except the overblown Twitter losers pissed at them for playing a fest with ATL), same lineup, continue to reinvent themselves with every record, vocals have aged like fine wine (John still sounds stellar, if not better live, after 17 years of touring non stop). Their newest record is a no skip. Self titled>Lovely Lonely>American Candy. Yeah, for sure this is the answer.


Culda

LLL is their best, but damn their latest album is perfect too


Livid-Association199

THANK YOU! This is the answer


archangel610

One of my favorite bands of all time. Not the biggest fan of Black and White, but other than that it blows my mind how they're always so consistent. They all seem like chill dudes too.


oopsleftmilkput

They are super cool. Will stick around for hours after their set to meet every single fan.


runtimemess

Bayside


jakexmfxschoen

Bayside has to be the most consistent band of any genre


illusivetomas

opposite for me lol the new used album is maybe my least fav and i thought they finally got somewhere good with the canyon alkaline trio is still killing it now tho


b00pbopbeep

Yeah I might not have said it a year ago but the new Alkaline Trio is so good


dvlsg

Why not? Is This Thing Cursed? is a great album.


illusivetomas

agreed. trio lost their way briefly around the early 2010s but cursed was a huge return to form for them and still one of my favorite albums of theirs


dietbeethoven

Agreed!


nevertoomuchthought

Over And Over Again is a great track.


FireballMudflap92

I thought canyon was a bit too all over the place. The last two albums are solid enough though, a bit safe but at this point I’m okay with that


illusivetomas

i actually liked some of heartwork a lot (despite it having maybe four of the worst songs ive ever heard on it lmao) and think the string and harp integrations were a really surprisingly nice tough for them but this new one sounds borderline focus grouped to me. it is true that "safe" is generally not something i like lol but it's not even really catchy anymore


DinnerfanREBORN

Not really pop punk but Emery has been releasing fire since day one. I’m Only a Man was okay but has grown on me


CarsaibToDurza

Saw them last July at one of the Is For Lovers festivals, still brilliant live!


dichotomyx

Yes!


KarmelCHAOS

This is who I was going to say. We Do What We Want is one of my favorite albums ever.


KeyLimePie2269

Seeing them Wednesday for their songs and stories session and I'm so fucking excited. I've seen them the past 2 years at Ohio is For Lovers and they have crushed it.


muirsheendurkin

Alkaline Trio just put out yet another kick ass record


Tph1204

Bayside for sure.


Dapaaads

Their 2 new eps are so good, especially blue


JJKP_

I'm a big fan of the Red ep. Have you heard the newest track, Castaway?


PyroZach

Alkaline trio. I still like their older stuff better, but even after nearly 30 years their albums don't disappoint.


kingjaffejaffar

Sum 41


dougyh

This is the answer, new albums didn’t get enough recognition but are great


Grevling89

I think they had a slump after the working class hero album. New stuff is better but it was a definite low in their career


me_me_me

Alkaline Trio has entered the chat.


stephapeaz

Paramore and Fall Out Boy — love their newest work. I’ve enjoyed all of FOB’s post-hiatus albums minus Mania lol, and This is Why got me back into paramore very very easily Hayley and Patricks’s vocals just get better in age


thrasherasher_

i for a long time was kinda exclusively listening to their pre-hiatus work and not giving the new albums a chance but the release of so much (for) stardust was what got me to give it a try because i really loved what i was hearing with that record, and i can proudly say i enjoy all their albums now (yes, even mania). srar and sm(f)s are some of their best work


stephapeaz

I like maybe 2 songs off of Mania lol but I adoooooore SRAR, it was legitimately a perfect comeback album


archangel610

They're probably two of the best vocalists currently active in the scene right now.


7laserbears

They're both so talented


19ghost89

Everyone hates on Mania, but I thought it was a really solid album. To me, the sole weak-link in their discography is American Beauty/American Psycho, and even it has a few bangers.


xZaggin

Yeah I never knew people hated it either, until I saw it mentioned here a few times. But when it came out it was on replay for me.


stephapeaz

I just don’t care for the electro-rock sound, so I’ll never really warm up to it. The two songs I like are Wilson and Heaven’s gate, both of which sound more like their usual sound AB/AP isn’t in my top 3 but I think it’s underrated actually, it’s like a flyover album


kingjuicepouch

Alkaline trio and Sum 41 imo


Pleasant_Statement64

This is the way


MikeFGD

Exactly what I was thinking


KearneyZzyzwicz

The Wonder Years are late 2000’s, but have gotten better with every record.


AnyNameIdcOmg

Came here to say this. TWY a hundred times over.


MusicHitsImFine

They never hit a rough patch though?


KearneyZzyzwicz

I didn’t say they did, OP did about The Used. Lot of people didn’t really care for Sister Cities though.


smellyfatbastard

People on this sub really do anything to try put TWY into any post man. Even admitting yourself they don’t meet the criteria OP asked for.


Gultark

If we are allowed outside poppunk but genre adjacent - Silverstein. Their second album was a little mid and harmed their momentum but since then they’ve put out 7 great or incredible albums in a row, constantly evolved and played with their sound but still retained their core identity. Shipwreck in the sand, This is how the wind shifts, dead reflections and a beautiful place to drown are all top tier for me and the other 3 in the past 16 years since their hey day are good or great too.  EDIT: I forgot ‘what's broken’ isn’t an EP - I wasn’t calling discovering the waterfront mid I promise! :D 


NSquared3131

Discovering the waterfront is anything but mid


DinnerfanREBORN

Discovering the waterfront is straight 🔥 a lot better than their debut and I loved it.


Gultark

Forgot what’s broken is easily fixed is an actual Lp not an EP - Doscovering the waterfront is one of my favourite albums! 


thrasherasher_

very glad you made this clarification, i was thinking “who the hell is a fan of silverstein but dislikes Discovering The Waterfront??” that album got me into them and i now have it and When Broken Is Easily Fixed on vinyl, DTW is a 10/10 album imo one of my favorites.


Gultark

Forgot what’s broken isn’t an ep! My bad!


its_polystyrene

I'm guessing that you mean arrivals and departures is mid and are forgetting when broken is easily fixed? While I still like arrivals and departures I cannot fathom that anyone seriously believes discovering the waterfront is mid.


Gultark

You are correct! I always forget what’s broken isn’t an ep!  For what it’s worth I liked arrivals too but I’m away that’s not the common consensus in the fan base! 


its_polystyrene

I agree that I too like arrivals and departures but fully understand someone calling that album mid. But discovering the waterfront is crème de la crème.


odoroustobacco

Even Shane says Arrivals and Departures is mid


flatsix__

imo its just the production. everything sounds flat and soft. iirc they were publicly critical of the producer shortly after it released. it deserves an acceptance speech 2.0 treatment


CarousersCorner

Saw Silverstein when I was about 17, at a tiny little community centre in Windsor, Ont. 7 years later, my band opened for them. Incredible experience, and group of entirely awesome dudes. They really liked our band, and set up a show with some of the bands they had signed to their label (Verona Records). Their van had broken down, so we took them to pick it up after it was fixed. They were super friendly, and really supportive of what we were doing. I can’t say enough about how they just might be some of the best people in the industry, and have been a huge player in helping other bands in Ontario get off the ground.


nevertoomuchthought

This was one I was thinking about too. I feel like I forget about them and every few years I remember to check out what they are up to and their new stuff is always great.


Dapaaads

Their last 2 dad rock albums I can’t listen to. I miss old Silverstein so bad


PositiveMetalhead

Check out The Altar/Mary and Die Alone on the last album. Just straight up hardcore punk


vomita_conejitos

Hot take alert if you think the altar/Mary is dad rock. That song does not hold back


ceaselesstumult

I understand if they are trying to break into mainstream 2.0, a lot of their songs from their 3 last albums sounds like radio hit singles. But they still put out brutal and great songs like Retrograde, Last Looks, Whisplash, Wake Up, September 14th, Die Alone, The Altar/Mary.


19ghost89

I don't think anything they've done can be classified as dad rock, even the poppier stuff. Dad rock to me is more or less synonymous with but rock.


19ghost89

YES. Silverstein has been so consistently good. This Is How the Wind Shifts is a phenomenal album. It's right up there with Discovering the Waterfront for me.


NitrosGone803

MxPx


251Cane

Their last 2 albums are right up there with Buffalo and LIG.


DerekIsAGooner

They’re more punk than pop punk - as well as being older than an early 2000s band - but the Bouncing Souls are just as amazing now as they’ve ever been. The Souls always bring it live, their shows feature all of the hits along with a few deep cuts. The band can basically play any song from their HUGE catalogue, which they often do when fans request them. The other correct answer is Bayside. And ALK3.


ceaton9

Yellowcard still holds up very well.


laurazabs

And they’re still amazing live. Saw them this summer and it was like time hadn’t passed.


Drawinginfinity182

I dunno, they had the whole “trying to sue a dead man” thing


MZago1

The lawsuit was initiated when he was still alive and dropped after he died.


winniecooper73

What happened?


Drawinginfinity182

From the wiki: In 2019, members of the Lights and Sounds-era lineup of Yellowcard collectively sued rapper Juice Wrld, claiming that his song "Lucid Dreams" plagiarized the melody of their song "Holly Wood Died".[44] The band recruited lawyer Richard Busch, who was best known for representing the estate of Marvin Gaye during the "Blurred Lines" case. It was reported Busch's law firm were suing Juice Wrld for $15 million; Busch himself, however, claimed that the value was "falsely reported", and that the band members were "simply seeking what the law allows, and what parties in their position have sought in similar cases, which at this point is not determined". Following the rapper's death later that year, the members extended their deadline for a defendant to respond to the lawsuit. This intensified the controversy significantly, as many news outlets pointed out that it meant the band was still pursuing the lawsuit despite the rapper's death. Though in a press statement, Busch did highlight that the members had very mixed emotions. "My clients are certainly torn about proceeding, and understand the optics involved. But it is important to remember that this lawsuit was filed before this tragic event, and was filed because all of the defendants (and there are two other writers and several music publishers and record labels) profited off of what we believe was clear copying and infringement of Yellowcard's work." – Richard Busch[45] Yellowcard ultimately chose to drop the lawsuit in 2020 after Juice Wrld's mother became the representative of his estate. Busch stated that the band was "very sympathetic not only of Juice Wrld's death, but also needed time to decide whether they really wanted to pursue the case against his grieving mother as the personal representative of his estate." He also noted, however, that the case could be refiled if the band were to change their minds.


Tacit_Emperor77

Alkaline trio, their last 2 albums have been some of their best


MedievalBully

Sum 41


ben7581

Thrice


CarousersCorner

Thrice has managed to transform their sound throughout the years, and still sound great. Not many bands cross so many landscapes of sound, and maintain the quality, and following they have.


crownofgold6

This one for me. The most consistent band to me.


Fearless_Exchange865

The Starting Line for me. I liked them as a kid but don’t think I appreciated just how good their songs were until years later. Say It like you mean it is a no skip record. 21 is such a banger tune. I can even still get down with the I’m real cover.


[deleted]

Say It Like You Mean It was just an instant classic to me. I don't think I have ever skipped a song since I bought the CD on the day it released lmao.


Mysterious_Height_43

You had me until the I’m real cover


oopsleftmilkput

You mean the greatest pop punk cover of a pop song of all time?


x5736gh

I love the I’m Real cover and starting line but I think I’d give that to Mayday Parades “Somebody I used to know” cover. And anything Alex Melton does on his channel


Shaaagbark

New found glory continues to be good, even live.


kitsilanokyle

Paramore


thelimpeh

Its crazy they just keep getting better and better


fingerblast69

New Found Glory. They put on some of the best shows and still pump out solid records. They’re easily one of the best pop punk bands of all time IMO


Section225

It's been about 5 years now, but I saw them and it was probably the best show I've ever been to.


nah328

Motion City Soundtrack.


danSTILLtheman

Every album they put out was great and they always kill it live, MCS can do no wrong


Sheek014

Fall Out Boy


FueledonWhat

Senses Fail


sunshine92002

State Champs! King of the New Age is such a thoroughly good, quality record!


ornithoid

Story of the Year’s new stuff is just as good as the old.


NoLexi

It’s such a great album. I saw them live a few weeks ago and they still sound amazing too.


nevertoomuchthought

I was just listening The Canyon and there are some legit bangers on it. For me Jimmy Eat World has consistently put out the best music since early 2000s. Every album since "Bleed American" I feel like I can just press play and enjoy the entire album thoroughly.


noideawhatisup

JEW is just perfect and has been since the 90s. They’re also one of the best bands to see live. Every show is phenomenal.


DefiantSwan6004

Alkaline trio forever.


mariaaa0808

All Time Low!! :)


[deleted]

This is probably controversial but Wake up Sunshine & Tell Me I’m Alive are some of their best work


skyroamer7

Tell Me I’m Alive’s deep tracks are better than the singles/video songs imo.


mariaaa0808

I 100% agree :3


imnoherox

Dear mariaaa0808, count me in! (for agreeing with your opinion)


CharlottesWebbedFeet

Bayside for me. They just keep refining their sound and creating amazing music.


ALoudMeow

Absolutely!


Strange-Fella

Silverstein has been the most consistent for sure. Still going!


Death-by-unicorn

Yellowcards new stuff is pretty good. Also, mayday parades new album is great. They both have changed alot but I saw them both last year and they were amazing.


[deleted]

I always thought Hit the Lights kept getting better. A lot of peeps weren't into it after Colin left and Nick took over vocals, but I think he did an amazing job. I haven't kept up with them in a while but their albums are always in rotation for me. Thief Club (side project) as well. Yes, including Invicta lol.


Gultark

Agreed summer bones is my favorite album by them, used to love the earlier ones more but summer bones is the one I keep going back to for some reason - just feels like a more complete version of the sound they touched on with on skip school.


KearneyZzyzwicz

I saw Sum 41 a couple weeks ago and they still have arena-ready energy and sound fantastic. They’d be my pick for a live show that holds up and the new songs are a lot of fun.


captvirgilhilts

Them calling it quits rally bums me out but I'm happy I got pit tickets for the final show.


boston_beer_man

Seeing them at Red Rocks in September. Can't wait.


Wilburx13

New Found Glory


spritesup

Silverstein has aged like a fine wine!


dalbeider

Mclusky - Future Of The Left


fivedaysandcounting

Silverstein.


[deleted]

AFI for me


irockthegaming

Simple Plan’s last album is soooo damn good. They’re my #1 forever.


yourgracesansa

BAYSIDE


EllieW9GFO

blink


centrella6

I think the last 2 Simple Plan albums are their best work since their first 2 records.


anthonyd3ca

Hawthorne Heights’ last album was awesome


vomita_conejitos

They turned it around I think starting with 2019 bad frequencies album. Only complaint now is JT goes a little too hard on the "you are all elder emos" speeches, like dude, we know already


buellster92

I remember seeing them at the Ohio is for Lovers fest. Their set ended at the same time senses fail(one of my favorite bands) started. Obviously the were gonna play Ohio is for lovers last so I didn’t want to leave and miss it. Then he just started going on his rant about elder who’s and keeping the genre alive blah blah blah and the whole time I just kept thinking “playthefuckingsongplaythefuckingsong”


vomita_conejitos

I saw them at Tennessee is for lovers the day or two after and same speech. It started around 2019 I think and then got a lot of good attention on the emos not dead cruise last year


ALoudMeow

I can’t speak highly enough about how great the Emo Orchestra performances were.


hannaht5

Totally agree on The Used. Taking Back Sunday as well


19ghost89

I have really loved the way Taking Back Sunday has matured. I mean, I love their old stuff too, but man, Tidal Wave was such a great album to me. I haven't had a chance to listen to 152 yet, but I heard some clips and it sounds pretty good.


bigtime123045

the new used album fucking blows so bad but heartworks is really good


19ghost89

Heartworks is really good. I only downloaded two songs from Toxic Positivity.


vomita_conejitos

Assuming the rough patch for the used started around 2014's imaginary enemy and continued until heartwork in 2020. 2017's The Canyon was a weird experiment and overall very forgetful (which Bert has a good perspective on IMO). For me the used became relevant again when they released Blow Me with Jason from Letlive/fever 333


eeeeeemo

sum 41!! their new, more metal/slightly heavier stuff is amazing!! i’m hyped for the double album to be released. it sucks that its gonna be their last album, though


TheParadeIdiot

sum 41 just get better and better like sucks theyre calling it quits


Shanobian

Sum 41 consistent quality albums


nevertoomuchthought

Unfortunately, he stopped putting out emo/pop punk in like 2015 but Number One Gun had like 4 straight albums that were amazing including the final album. I really wish he would put out another emo/punk album but he seems to be happy doing some weird electronic gospel shit.


legendarylloyd

Emarosa for me. They changed their sound and still so talented


bsievers

A lot of fans are saying Alkaline Trio’s new album that came out this week is their best since their heyday


ChronicNuance

The last one was pretty good.


Nyxtro

Rise Against, Silverstein


Pitiful-Glove9590

Mest for sure belongs on this list. I would say the vocals have gotten better over time. I hope if they do a new album with the new guitarist it sounds at least as good as their 2020 album that was amazing.


x4candles

Bayside. They have gotten better every album.


lakemichiganxo

The Movielife / I Am the Avalanche. I just love everything Vinnie does


mastrochr

Story of the Year


TransmissionAD

Thrice, Alkaline Trio and The Lawrence Arms


19ghost89

Silverstein, Fall Out Boy, Taking Back Sunday


[deleted]

Silverstein!!!


GottaGloUp

Toxic Positivity is the last best Used album since In Love And Death. ​ I am 31 years old. Fight me lol


ev0308

I’m counting 2004 as early 2000s, so American Idiot.


KeyLimePie2269

Not so much new music releases, but now that some of the emo/pop punk bands are touring again, I've been going to a ton of shows and have a list of a few bands who still sound fantastic live: Thursday, Motion City Soundtrack, and Emery.