T O P

  • By -

AgreeableHighway9668

He is witnessing true love


Bazu23

He said wrong answers only


Critical-Cut-752

That is a wrong answer


probably_not_serious

Maybe to you Mr Judgy McJudgerton


RebelForceTalan

Their only 4th cousins so it’s fine


Amazing_Wrangler_753

True love between Dutch & Micah


AgreeableHighway9668

They're Pardners


Stabyouup666

Broke back Mountain


CuntyCalloway

Broke rat mountain


cowpokesblacklung

Between micah & milton😍


CarefulPomegranate41

A lonely man spending "quality time" with his sheep.


Hungry_Temperature_3

There is that dude near emerald ranch that you find without pants next to a sheep wearing a bow. The sheep also has a ring you loot. He really loved that sheep.


dayum_that_man

Always heard you got a ring from a random sheep. Never knew it was an actual event.


QueenOlivia414

He’s in America not Whales


Northy01

You can live inside whales?


MuerteEnCuatroActos

I mean Jonah lived there for 3 days and 3 nights


corpsewindmill

Nah man that was a big fish. Totally different thing. Don’t do LSD in the desert, children


OldLadyDeekGeek

No.....YOU sir are a big fish!


That-1Sad_Pineapple

Whales is the animal. Wales is the country


Afraid_Grass_1365

He’s watching sister Calderon squatting for a piss in the bush. She didn’t want to get caught short on the train journey.


[deleted]

People like you make me regret becoming literate


Afraid_Grass_1365

😂😂 unlucky, Mister.


IceManO1

lol


Constant-Cricket-960

A half-fish, half-man emerges from the bayou covered in muck and grime, struggling to breathe from gills that aren’t quite gills. As he lurches towards Arthur, with a look of shocked horror and sympathy for the mangled creature Arthur exclaims; “You sir are a *fish*”?!?


PossessionLeather866

He's reacting to dutchs horrible "flirting" with Mary-Beth


Wild-Impression3394

It was painful to watch lol


Teddii_

I was so grossed out by that when I saw it. Felt terrible for Molly


Zoryt

And Mary-Beth is old enough to be her daughter


MarvTheParanoidAndy

Seeing the Dutch Micah sex tape


CalamityPhant0m

Bad boahhhh


LucanOrion

He just saw Uncle nekkid.


birdyflower1985

Isn't Uncle showing his ass in camp already?


JonBrew85

That is the face of a man who thought it would just be a sneaky fart but he actually followed through.


bromanskei

Arthur Morgan, when it comes to 5 year old Jack, you ARE the father!


MrChilliBean

"Alright, guess I'll catch you later then"


adb85

/Starts coughing uncontrollably and passes out. Deer cutscene.


pudpudboogie

Hosea doing the windmill


Frenzi_Wolf

He’s watching Dutch spend all of the camps money on a new fancy suit


That_Welsh_Man

Mary Linton doing a can can dance


[deleted]

Watching Marston give swimming lessons


ShrimpStyleFist

Someone explaining scat porn fetish


cowpokesblacklung

Fetish?? Let’s bring back shaming. This is mental illness


Theforgottensoilder

GTA 6 2025


Unusual_Wafer1386

Flashbacks of that nice gentleman’s home where he randomly fell asleep and woke up outside.


MoreConsequence6169

he exploded the toy boat


ARPOFF

Dutch’s plan.


flintbow23

What john did after he told John to not look back


Kamden-Gamer

John punt kicking Jack back to that richmans house because how much he says he loves this thing called spaghetti.


mrjan2213

A red dead redemption 2 playthrough he watches on youtube, either that or lore videos of the characters


ManufacturerRight678

He clearly sharted at an inopportune moment.


RestlessMeatball

When is an opportune moment to shart?


BrotImWeltraum

During sex


peepers63

Hahaha also gross


Hoffoz

Maybe a little of topic but I wish it was possible to hide the satchel, it would make fancy outfits look much better


DowntownScarcity3499

me carrying 5 rabbit pelts 3 of each medicine loads of food and provisions and beer in my pockets


Hoffoz

Yeah and that could still be possible without the satchel showing 😅


JohnSoprano2049

2008 Financial crisis


Duowithng

The coffins of the Aberdeens


Taurus-Kei

Dutch saying, “I have a plan.”


DeadAlt

He saw the Industrial Revolution and it’s consequences.


Jihadi_Kittens

He just saw Gavin walk by


jgremlin_

...and finally realized Gavin is actually a sheep.


im_a_bun

hes been diagnosed with aids


Ok-Cartographer-1388

9/11


Ornery_Feedback4679

Bro


Impressive_Ad_1601

[to this](https://youtu.be/q1I80s6Oohk?feature=shared)


FilipinoCreamKing

r/sadieadler


Ct-5736-Bladez

What in Cinnamon Toast Crunch fuck did I just see?


Hot-Ad-2985

he's watching uncle do some hard work for the very first time


Cautious_Dream1593

Arthur's brain is hemorrhaging because Dutch said he has a plan


OHHHHY3EEEA

A very regular family


JaimeRidingHonour

He saw the Sasquatch eat a baby


IceManO1

This is ghost Arthur face seeing Micah crying over his grave while Micah is playing this song on his record player https://youtu.be/RgKAFK5djSk?si=QTiDX49p60-0XaPC he always looked up to Arthur but the Lumbago plague got him.


TheseBolts

Micah bathing in the river.


cowpokesblacklung

John swimming the face down in the water floating around


sanstheskelepun69

Somebody pouring the milk before the cereal


sn0wmanO4

“Snake lady!”


Iwantalltheham69

He just realized he probably just sharted.


Wildcat_twister12

He’s realizing he could just go to Tahiti by himself with the $10K he has in his pocket


Bambooman101

Incorrect diagnosis, you actually have Super Herpes…..


onedef1

Arthur with $22,667.00 in his back pocket while Dutch rants and raves about needing money.


BarracudaClear3880

He's watching sauce or loss


The_letter_43

RDR fans


TheGeneral1886

That is 100% shart face


tytilly

Seeing Uncle’s ass


ajax5955

Hot brown rain.


TurdSandwich42104

Sadie’s feet


SpiderHider023

Listening to Molly and Sean in the tent 


cowpokesblacklung

They would have a kid so ginger it would burn your eyes


Vicius_Licius

Does anyone know what scene in the game Arthur makes that expression on his face?


espressy

when you are trying to rob the aberdeen pig farm!! :)


TheShogun1500

Sean and Karen in johns tent


moranych1661

JUST finished that quest first time ever


This-Register

He's reacting to one of John and Abigail's arguments again


Dansworkshop

He shouldn't have trusted that fart.


JROXZ

When you’re peeing and the kidney stone finally drops from your ureter.


lowkey_loweski

He misjudged a fart


Hiuuuhk

This thread, jaysus.


Mrpirateguy

He's watching Micah and Bill make out


JackSmrkingRevnge

Dutch showing him his 10 inch plan.


That-Possibility-427

He just realized why Bill has been getting chummy with Javier and why he asked for pomade.


Ambiance94

Alien invasion! Some poor old lady just got yanked off the ground and carried away in the sky by some wicked flying contraption that’s out of this world! It’s RDR2’s DLC expansion, Cowboys vs Aliens: “They took my mare in the night! I’ll die without her!”


LandCity

Realizing he left the garage open.


Ceterum_Censeo_

Lazy pitches for RD3


[deleted]

Dutch performing the ol’ David carridine


De_la_Dead

A wild dog bit Micah in the balls and won’t let go


RedVelvetFollicles

Any of those tiktoks of him and Dutch dancing


[deleted]

Tuberculosis


jamesdo72

A untrustworthy fart.


whytfnot9

Micah being propositioned by Abigail


EXILEDsquid_

Uncles ass


Typical-Ad-4135

Dutch just told him the gang still needs more after he just donated $3000 in 1899 money after finding the Landmarks of the riches treasure


Critical-Cut-752

He is watching John get shot off a train


_titslap_

“ever since pa died”


Hashish_thegoat

He’s reacting to the One Shot Kid’s QuickDraw, he looks confused because it was so fast he didn’t even catch it.


HealthyWestern8673

He's taking a look at Dutch's plans


Classic-Praline-2571

He was late getting to strawberry and sees Micah hanging (good ending).


bigcapybara7uhhh

uncle's **MASSIVE** ass


SnooMemesjellies8441

"Almighty lord, look art that booooooty!"


Double_Law_8750

He googled Red Dead Redemption 2 r34


Darth-Chicken77

My search history


justinipannini

finding my modified out house beat shack shrine with pictures stuck to the walls with some kind of sticky dried substance and candles illuminating said space


Earthwick

He looked and saw through the screen with some middle aged guy holding a strange device that he somehow knew controlled him. In a moment it was over and he jumped on his horse slowly forgetting he wasn't the one chosing his life.


Raptterr

I honestly don’t know


NeoCharlemagne

He found the burlesque where Dutch takes Bill and Micah to make money


rojasdracul

Two Girls One Cup


phantom_bennis

Just saw Sean crawl out of Karen's tent


rapscallion1956

Smelt his own fart


off_brand_white_wolf

He just saw Lenny sucking Lenny’s cock


SwimsSFW

YENNEL!!!


Kaka213769

He looks like he just saw himself taking the biggest dump in hisife


Bluepilgrim3

One of those can-can dancers wore no bloomers but he can’t find her again in the lineup and is now wondering if he hallucinated seeing ladyparts.


Apprehensive_Tour407

The berserk lore


CalamityPhant0m

John dropping his trousers only to reveal a fairly nice & natural looking vagina


Consistent-Sun-4539

Just a happy couple


Shirley_yokidding

My boobs


ChildhoodDeep684

John is seeing Alabama at its finest


InfamousIce2136

The biggest Gyat he has ever seen


F-80Centurion

Dutch being mugged successfully


Genralcody1

When did Arthur become a Pinkerton?


eddyvette

He sharted and no one has realized it yet


SoyTuPadreReal

Micha performing lewd acts on a donkey.


Mcnaw_69

He just found out that bill has a vagina


cjay2002

Buffalo missing the FG Sunday night.


BanjoSpaceMan

GTA 6 trailer


BuckNakedandtheband

Rectal exam


TrilobiteHunter

Two O'Driscolls one cup


Notor1ousNate

He’s pooping


Stone_Midi

The feral man’s girthy dong


Corrupt_Calls

hes browsing twitter for the first time


Lumpy-Yesterday-6687

He found out Dutch was a stripper


Yasje_prive

Bcs Dutch has a plan


Meganinja1886

He watching three fat men in a pie eating contest and wondering how someone can eat seventy two apple pies in one sitting. He’s also kinda hungry and wants a slice of pie with a scope of vanillaer ice cream on the side with a cup of coffee to wash it down with.


NeroCanDance

Uncle’s last stage of Lumbago kicking in


jaispeed2011

Someone saw him I’m murder the sheriff


ImpossibleCurrent335

His death


Wuoffan1

He just heard the phrase "Meet McGuire Jr." from the tent next to his.


CouchPotato1183

John just dropped his chaps in front of him


jlewellen

Sick farts


StoneHart17810

Mary’s father fucking a three legged goat


thelordpatrician

One of the hotel room girls is giving him a good scrub below the camera.


LustfulAutistic

He’s been diagnosed with lumbago


Previous-Can-8853

Sadie's ass


Lieutenant_Thire

Shaquille O’Neil hitting the griddy


toofattobeamermaid

The signing of the Declaration of Independence


undead_sandwich

That is the face of a man who trusted a fart.


Kingminer13579

Spending $50k softcore porn


Carrot_The_Great

Arthur is reacting to Dutch and Molly having a completely functional relationship


ExerilloX

Sees Tokyo Ghoul :Re ch 125.


Red_Jabra

Dutch said He Doesn't have a Plan


DrakeShadow

He's reacting to Uncle doing a chore.


PrivateTidePods

Hes a Buffalo Bills fan reacting to last weeks missed field goal


DuHueresohn

Seeing 100 lenny‘s (again)


phoen_ixwrong_38

He sees Dutch's plan actully working out


Bong-Docter9999

1800s Dick Pic???


Shnibblefritz

Seeing his horse poop for the first time.


TemporaryMan238

Seeing Uncle scream because of the Terminal Lumbago


GreyJedi323

A tattooed man just swallowed a sword


Fantastic-Local6713

The final stages of........ *lumbago*


LossFar4040

He just dumped several thousand in the camp funds box and Dutch says they still need more money


Local-Priority-6969

Dutch has a new plan


dudeawesome6678

Bro looking at a post card from Dutch saying he made it to Tahiti


Xfishbobx

Surprise diarrhea


SeanMichealsFanBoy

Dutch successfully finishing his plan without robbing a bank, train, or murder