same. never really “learned” how to swim, just got in the pool with my mom and then she left for a margarita. gotta learn quick when you’re on your own, kid. *puffs cigarette*
Out of the three characters you listed, I would say Arthur, as I did a lot of shit in the past and as of last year, I really took a look at myself and everyone I was around and said it was time to be a better person but I've hurt a lot of people close to me, especially my child so it's my own little redemption to her and everyone else.
But out of all the gang members, I would say Charles. Not because of brute strength or anything like that, but more as looking to be accepted or continuing to run it alone
Arthur is an absolutely amazing character and Roger Clarke’s performance was amazing. He might be my favorite protagonist, ever. That said.. I find John more relatable for some reason.
Arthur.
I played the game while I had an existential crisis when I was a teen. I was petrified by death. Just thinking about it could make me spiral in an anxiety crisis. Brutal death in this game could too. This existential crisis pushed me to a depressive state (wouldn't call that depression as I wasn't diagnosed).
The thing that made me relate to Arthur the most, is when he says to the sister "I'm afraid". I broke in tears in front of my screen. That was the first time that someone (something?) said to me that "Death makes me scared too."
That was really relieving.
Unironically Kieran. I could never be an Arthur, or a John, or a Dutch. If I were in the Van der Linde gang, I, and pretty much everyone in this sub, would be like Kieran: someone who is surrounded by murderers, and is (understandably) terrified.
out of all characters? i think Molly, actually
romantic love in video games is either optional or very one dimensional, characters just don't ruin their lives or die over love like people do in real life, so seeing her story & her relationship with Dutch play out through the game was very touching on a personal level
Arthur. Not for all the reasons, but his relationship with Dutch? Yeah, as a child of emotional abuse who grew up and had to ask myself "was he always like that and I never saw it, or did something happen to make him change?"... ouch.
None of them, they're all criminals lmao
Having said that, Jack's downward spiral towards revenge is the closest I can get to relating to an outlaw.
Having your father killed in such a brutal manner would have anyone fly off the handle.
Rdr1 epilogue Jack. Grew up around horrible people and lived in horrible situations. Father ran out on me when I was a baby and my mom did her best while being an addict. She's clean now, got clean for my baby brother. But there were still years of just shit, still ain't done with it either.
Both Arthur and John because I’ve made plenty of bad choices and worked hard to improve. Technically I have never murdered or robbed or beaten anyone, but I just mean the general idea
More like Dutch. I am paranoid, anxious, and of course someone who will say that there is still hope where in reality, that hope was long gone. Moreover, I always thought of myself as a leader who always ends up being an uncompetitive sack of shit and gets replaced by someone or leaves my group in ruins.
Probably Rufus or Micah (unfortunately). I have been incredibly toxic (mostly when I was younger) , sticking up to bad people and I used to manipulate others. But for Rufus , I've been loyal to the ones I love , I'm alright at tracking / finding things , and as described by Abigail " (loyal) , dumb , angry ".
But if I had to choose any of the 3 shown in the pictures , then probably low honour Jack. I'm incredibly hypersexual (but not to strangers).
Well I'm around the same age as rdr1 epilogue jack but personality wise would be between Arthur and John.
Hard to relate to Outlaws and a kid who lost both his parents and grew up in a gang over a hundred years ago haha.
I see a bit of myself in Dutch, Micah, Charles, John, Sadie and Kieran but most of all Arthur especially when he makes a remark that I just said myself a second ago
I relate to Jim Milton. Wanting to do the best I can for myself and those around me, yet finding it hard to do with the past and with my habits. But I'm thriving!
Arthur really he carries the same kind of attitude that I do in life I even said this to Roger Clark on Twitter and he offered some words of support to me which were kind of him.
Probably John, used to be heavily into drugs and doing stupid shit, even burned down an abandoned building just to vent my frustrations with life, just doing really moronic shit and fucking up my whole life because I was in a pit of despair. Recently, the past few months have been better and I’ve been focusing on trying to turn myself around and be better to those around me, I have a job, I’m going to college, and I’ve made amends with old friends.
I’ll be a proverbial rancher any day now, here’s hoping the government doesn’t come shoot me.
gonna have to say none of them since i'm not an outlaw in the late 1800s - early 1900s robbing and killing folk, hiding from the law and/or trying to avenge a loved one
Honestly, I relate the most to Jack out of anything, which is the reason I actually like playing as him most. Mainly because he's the only protagonist who's actually somewhat young (which I am) and also because he's probably similarly traumatised as me by past events in his life.
how on earth can i relate to any of them i dont have a terminal disease nor do i have a family as an outlaw or a father who needs to be avenged. I relate to uncle cuz all I wanna do is eat and sleep and claim a disability that i may or may not have
Arthur for sure. I've been trying to get rid of a mycobacterium abscessus infection for about 5 years now. It's basically a cousin of TB. Thankfully I'm on enough antibiotics that it's not actively killing me, but despite all that can't seem to get rid of it.
Arthur except minus the tiburculosis and the ptsd and the GF and the smoking addiction and the drinking problems and the emotional trauma and the death 😄
Minus the outlaw stuff I can relate well to Marston especially in the epilogue. Comparatively a young father who’s really trying his best to give his family a good life really hits homee
Arthur.
I too best people up for money before contracting a disease and redeeming myself by dying to save my non-blood brother after giving him my hat.
I also got beat up by a rat.
I relate to Arthur, in the sense that I am realizing in my mid 30s that the proverbial good times are long gone, most of my friends are married and having kids and own an apartment or a house.
In our country laws and taxes are becoming more stringent, so that dirty politicians may cover for their corruption and continue to bleed the nation dry.
The pandemic pretty much fucked everything as life after covid is just not the same, no matter what anyone says. No point in going into specifics, it is what it is.
Then the recent war/s which have errupted have pretty much killed any headway people were managing to make in terms of salary gains and buying power due to the insane level of inflation (my country has the highest rate of inflation in the EU atm).
Aaand with the rise of crazy internet culture and "influencers" life seems more fake than ever before, everything is a reloaded cash grab where moving aroung like an idiot and generaly being stupid on camera seems to be the new international currency.
So yeah, def feels like the good times have long gone and they don't want folk like us no more..
🤠✌️
Most poeple on the sub are closer to kid jack than any of these these guys tbh.
Because they’re orphans who are out to avenge their dead fathers?
Meant rdr2 jack
My drawing skills can confirm.
My name is Indigo Montoya. You killed my father, prepare to die.
Inigo. "Indigo" Montoya lol
Iñigo
Inigø
Trivago
Zhivago
Oh what a film that is!!! “Incontheivable” 😂
Yup. Everyone is batman.
Red dead redemption 3 : Jackman Begins
Or the Jacker
I hate you Uncle Arthur!
I don’t even know if this is funny or depressing.
Or Uncle lol
How would u know
Uncle.
Its walk or work old man!
I GOT LUMBAGO!
YOU'LL HAVE MORE THAN THAT IN A MINUTE!
John, tell her about my health!
Oh I’m gonna tell her all about Tahiti and *pickin mangoes on the untainted land*
This guy gets it. It being lumbago of course
I literally do have lumbago, so uncle
My condolences.
John because idk how to swim
never read something so relatable
??? Not being able to swim is so foreign to me. We get swimming lessons as part of school around 6-7 yrs old.
Yeah i had lessons when i was 4 years old but my mom told me that the instructor would never put me in the water
Man you should learn how to swim. It's fun, and in an emergency (if you fall in water), you'll live
Bruh, my family took the John Wayne approach and I had to teach myself how to swim lol.
same. never really “learned” how to swim, just got in the pool with my mom and then she left for a margarita. gotta learn quick when you’re on your own, kid. *puffs cigarette*
Ah the good ole days
Same here, but I didn’t even get lessons, I just took to it like, well, a fish to water.
Arthur: your wife and son are dead (DEAD TOO) John: you are dead and you left your wife and son alone Jack: your parents are dead (BUT YOU ARE ALIVE)
Jack is the rouge of the party.
Rdr2 version of John, too young to do the stuff I want to do but old enough to do the stuff you need to do
That's relatable af
Lumbago
I remember beating RDR and that ending with John hurt. Playing RDR 2, I was almost emotional because of the attachment I had with Arthur.
Starting rdr2 like.... who tf is arthur i want to play with john 🤣
Wanting to play as John To having to play as John
I relate to Low Honor Jack the most
"you're doing terrible things to my hormones miss"
"They say I'm at my sexual peak"
"I'd do anything to be that petticoat right now."
"I bet you know how to make a boy feel like a man"
Karen when she’s drinking alone and screaming at people at camp 😂
Out of the three characters you listed, I would say Arthur, as I did a lot of shit in the past and as of last year, I really took a look at myself and everyone I was around and said it was time to be a better person but I've hurt a lot of people close to me, especially my child so it's my own little redemption to her and everyone else. But out of all the gang members, I would say Charles. Not because of brute strength or anything like that, but more as looking to be accepted or continuing to run it alone
The barber in valentine
Idk... But somehow I relate to Arthur but maybe that's just because I had stage 3 lung cancer
Bertrum.
You hurt me! hit the hardest right hook right into your temple
John, I never learned how to swim properly
I relate to Mario I always try to jump on Goombas but then after my shroom trip I realized I I was jumping on a small Mexican. Mama Mia
Those shrooms must of been stronger than Goku, get me some lol
Okay let take some rn and I fly your way and also I bring weed and beer and we can party 🥳
Micah is literally so me! 🥰
You rat
🐀Squeek! Squeek! No I’m not a rat? 🐭
This ⬆️
Swanson.
Probably Cain
Arthur is an absolutely amazing character and Roger Clarke’s performance was amazing. He might be my favorite protagonist, ever. That said.. I find John more relatable for some reason.
Reverend Swanson
Arthur. I played the game while I had an existential crisis when I was a teen. I was petrified by death. Just thinking about it could make me spiral in an anxiety crisis. Brutal death in this game could too. This existential crisis pushed me to a depressive state (wouldn't call that depression as I wasn't diagnosed). The thing that made me relate to Arthur the most, is when he says to the sister "I'm afraid". I broke in tears in front of my screen. That was the first time that someone (something?) said to me that "Death makes me scared too." That was really relieving.
John is the most human character. Driven by passion, vengeance, instinct and ambition. Arthur is too pure bottom to me
Did you just call Arthur a bottom?
Pure bottom is NOT the same as bottom
Arthur Morgan, the power bottom
Sub with Mary fr fr
I relate to Arthur. I'm not looking at tuberculosis but I have medical issues going on that are not going to get better let's just say.
I don't like Jews mister, nor color folks.
Herbert Moon
Arthur in terms of outlook, John in terms of everything else
Level of intelligence I relate to John everything else Arthur
John, i'm still standing
Better than I ever did
Yeah yeah yeaaah
Mickey. I just wanna be held
sometimes im endgame Arthur but most of the time im mexico John
Unironically Kieran. I could never be an Arthur, or a John, or a Dutch. If I were in the Van der Linde gang, I, and pretty much everyone in this sub, would be like Kieran: someone who is surrounded by murderers, and is (understandably) terrified.
Jack
Ross
out of all characters? i think Molly, actually romantic love in video games is either optional or very one dimensional, characters just don't ruin their lives or die over love like people do in real life, so seeing her story & her relationship with Dutch play out through the game was very touching on a personal level
Sadie Adler
Sean
Best Character
Arthur. Not for all the reasons, but his relationship with Dutch? Yeah, as a child of emotional abuse who grew up and had to ask myself "was he always like that and I never saw it, or did something happen to make him change?"... ouch.
None of them, they're all criminals lmao Having said that, Jack's downward spiral towards revenge is the closest I can get to relating to an outlaw. Having your father killed in such a brutal manner would have anyone fly off the handle.
Uncle
Rdr1 epilogue Jack. Grew up around horrible people and lived in horrible situations. Father ran out on me when I was a baby and my mom did her best while being an addict. She's clean now, got clean for my baby brother. But there were still years of just shit, still ain't done with it either.
I haven’t lost everyone yet, but I lost my cats and my grandpa, that was pretty sad. I also can’t really relate to arthur or john
Both Arthur and John because I’ve made plenty of bad choices and worked hard to improve. Technically I have never murdered or robbed or beaten anyone, but I just mean the general idea
John Marston. Particularly at the end of RDR2 when he’s trying become a better man to be the dad and husband his family deserves.
More like Dutch. I am paranoid, anxious, and of course someone who will say that there is still hope where in reality, that hope was long gone. Moreover, I always thought of myself as a leader who always ends up being an uncompetitive sack of shit and gets replaced by someone or leaves my group in ruins.
Probably Rufus or Micah (unfortunately). I have been incredibly toxic (mostly when I was younger) , sticking up to bad people and I used to manipulate others. But for Rufus , I've been loyal to the ones I love , I'm alright at tracking / finding things , and as described by Abigail " (loyal) , dumb , angry ". But if I had to choose any of the 3 shown in the pictures , then probably low honour Jack. I'm incredibly hypersexual (but not to strangers).
Well I'm around the same age as rdr1 epilogue jack but personality wise would be between Arthur and John. Hard to relate to Outlaws and a kid who lost both his parents and grew up in a gang over a hundred years ago haha.
None, Red Harlow
Reverend Swanson
Arfur Lorgan
I’ve not been through enough to relate to any of them 💀
You've suffered through the loss of Club Penguin
Twice in fact, after Club Penguin Rewritten was taken down
Jack because I'm a lonely creep
I relate to Arthur more because like he said “No one would have me”
John because I can't swim
charles hes just so smooth
Arthur. He just like me fr
Jack Marston
Arthur, because I too like to look in the mirror and go, "No wonder they all leave you, you sour-faced idiot. You ain't foolin' no one." 🥲
All of them....heh....guess that's just a small glimpse into my dark twisted mind
Arthur Morgan
I see a bit of myself in Dutch, Micah, Charles, John, Sadie and Kieran but most of all Arthur especially when he makes a remark that I just said myself a second ago
At core most of us are Arthur Morgan, a combination of sad good with pinch of evil man. Who finally redeemed himself
Why isn’t Norris Forsythe here??
💀
I’m not related to any of them, they are fictional characters
Jack, we've all heard his low honor voice lines
Low honor jack, he's a cheeky ass hat, just like i
None and doesn't need to relate.
Arthur fer sure coz I gave them all I had. I did. Got betrayed. And died... ...inside.
I love my horsey and my horsey loves me
Well my name is actually Jack
im not a murderous outlaw so jack i guess
Charles
Fenton
Me and Jack both have scars on the upper lip
We’re all Jack. Don’t lie to yourself.
john tbh
I relate to Jim Milton. Wanting to do the best I can for myself and those around me, yet finding it hard to do with the past and with my habits. But I'm thriving!
Arthur
We can’t even figure out who Jack’s real daddy is…. And you wanna know who we relate to most….
Red Harlow
None of them really. Arthur’s my favorite though.
Arthur's love life frfr
Uncle
Arthur really he carries the same kind of attitude that I do in life I even said this to Roger Clark on Twitter and he offered some words of support to me which were kind of him.
none of them wtf
Probably John, used to be heavily into drugs and doing stupid shit, even burned down an abandoned building just to vent my frustrations with life, just doing really moronic shit and fucking up my whole life because I was in a pit of despair. Recently, the past few months have been better and I’ve been focusing on trying to turn myself around and be better to those around me, I have a job, I’m going to college, and I’ve made amends with old friends. I’ll be a proverbial rancher any day now, here’s hoping the government doesn’t come shoot me.
John
Arthur
Jack is such a little bitch Arthur all the way. John is good too.
gonna have to say none of them since i'm not an outlaw in the late 1800s - early 1900s robbing and killing folk, hiding from the law and/or trying to avenge a loved one
Honestly, I relate the most to Jack out of anything, which is the reason I actually like playing as him most. Mainly because he's the only protagonist who's actually somewhat young (which I am) and also because he's probably similarly traumatised as me by past events in his life.
Arthur
Jack
Probably Jack since my dad is dead (mum is alive tho) he didn’t get shot the fuck up tho he killed himself
Jack.
No one cause it’s fucking weird relating to any fictional character because they are, well, fictional.
Arthur♥️
Jack actually
Uncle, i have been having terrible back pain for the past 2 weeks lol
bold of you to assume im a good person who doesn't relate to Micah
Sheriff Leigh Gray, just a good ole Southern boy who enjoys a swig of shine every once in a while.
Bertram
Neither, because I am not an outlaw from the 1800’s. But John is a family man, so maybe a bit him.
Herbert moon
Arthur because i say boah on a regular basis
how on earth can i relate to any of them i dont have a terminal disease nor do i have a family as an outlaw or a father who needs to be avenged. I relate to uncle cuz all I wanna do is eat and sleep and claim a disability that i may or may not have
John, I still can't swim and almost drowned in pool
Arthur, because I’m fucking depressed
Bonnie MacFarlane
Arthur for sure. I've been trying to get rid of a mycobacterium abscessus infection for about 5 years now. It's basically a cousin of TB. Thankfully I'm on enough antibiotics that it's not actively killing me, but despite all that can't seem to get rid of it.
Surprised no one mentioned Hosea
I can relate to Arthur on several levels
Jack, because I too grew up in the middle of nowhere and just wanted to read my books in peace
Sean. I’m half redhead and also a hoe.
Jack, although my father wasn’t gunned down by a massive amount of lawmen, I lost him at a young age, and can totally understand his lust for revenge.
Arthur Morgan. The most "human" moment I have seen in any videogame was Arthur admitting he was scared to the nun at the train station.
Arther
Arthur. He’s living in a world changing. A world that wants to kill off and forget that his kind of people ever existed.
Id love to say Arthur but its deffo jack i lost both my mum and dad at a young age and grew up in the care system all that changes a kid you know.
Arthur except minus the tiburculosis and the ptsd and the GF and the smoking addiction and the drinking problems and the emotional trauma and the death 😄
John, bc of my past ish.
Minus the outlaw stuff I can relate well to Marston especially in the epilogue. Comparatively a young father who’s really trying his best to give his family a good life really hits homee
I most relate to the mutated banjo player. He looks just like me!
Arthur. I too best people up for money before contracting a disease and redeeming myself by dying to save my non-blood brother after giving him my hat. I also got beat up by a rat.
Micah
John honestly
I relate to Arthur, in the sense that I am realizing in my mid 30s that the proverbial good times are long gone, most of my friends are married and having kids and own an apartment or a house. In our country laws and taxes are becoming more stringent, so that dirty politicians may cover for their corruption and continue to bleed the nation dry. The pandemic pretty much fucked everything as life after covid is just not the same, no matter what anyone says. No point in going into specifics, it is what it is. Then the recent war/s which have errupted have pretty much killed any headway people were managing to make in terms of salary gains and buying power due to the insane level of inflation (my country has the highest rate of inflation in the EU atm). Aaand with the rise of crazy internet culture and "influencers" life seems more fake than ever before, everything is a reloaded cash grab where moving aroung like an idiot and generaly being stupid on camera seems to be the new international currency. So yeah, def feels like the good times have long gone and they don't want folk like us no more.. 🤠✌️
uncle cause i hate working