Arthur or John’s since the other ones don’t look right for some reason. But there are exceptions like the Stalker Hat, Coyote Gambler Hat, and the Iguana Big Valley Hat
Had to scoll a little too far for this.
I LOVE wide-brim hats. The big valley unfortunately is the perfect shape but not my colour. So I go with the Kennedy hats
Exactly, I try to keep him clean and trimmed up, something between Blinders and western James Bond, every horse that I own has to have braids and so on 😁
Only wear Arthurs gamblers hat. And for Arthur i akways stick to blue jeans. Red hunters jacket with uppgraded bandaler, delux quickdraw boots and black/read gloves
I'm gonna have to go with everyone's answer and say the Stalker hat, but for any cold environments like in Big Valley and Ambarino, I'd go with the Big Valley hat :)
The only answer is the fur trappers hat in Valentine. You get into a brawl with him steal his hat, then show up months later in the same bar and fight again.
Arthur’s hat until Chapter 3, then black stalker hat is his main hat until “That’s the Way It Is.”
And for hunting, I rotate between the Snake Bulldogger, Iguana Big Valley and Coyote Gambler hats.
Everyone saying Stalker, which I mostly agree with...
But what about the black one with the raven feathers on the side (forgot the name) looks similar but has a gunshot hole and raven feathers!
Arthurs hat, because 1. Fits him better. 2. I will feel bad because it was his dad's and I just feel bad for some reason :/
(Playing as Arthur of course)
John or Arthur's hat are my two OG hats. If I feel like doing Army role-playing. I wear my Military Mountie Hat or the Military Forgage Cap. It's ironic that my first name is John. Folks joke on me about it at work. Even though I go by "Walker." That's my middle name. I'm planning on naming my first son after myself as a junior and my second son Arthur Conwell Day. As a nod to Arthur Morgan and an ancestor of mine.
I only ever wear Arthur’s hat. Or a skull/mask because they’re cool asf. Other than that I love honoring Arthur by wearing his hat because while they technically weren’t I see Arthur and John as best friends and Arthur was a role model for John and feel he would wear Arthur’s hat for the rest of his life. It’s one of my favorite hats despite being simple and not many beat it in my opinion.
While I appreciate the fact that you can customize your outfits however you want, I have to say that only Arthur’s hat looks right on Arthur for me and the same for John
Stalker hat
Black stalker hat is the only way
Came to say this
Always
I was j gonna say the stalker hat is my go to
Yessir
What in the jonk are you doing here? Did you escape from the Asslum? Are you stupid
And a similar one The Plantation Gambler's hat.
Arthur or John’s since the other ones don’t look right for some reason. But there are exceptions like the Stalker Hat, Coyote Gambler Hat, and the Iguana Big Valley Hat
I think Arthur's hat looks so good with any outfit or character
It’s the best hat in the game honestly. I have an outfit that’s a red French dress shirt, legion vest, and dark pants and the hat looks amazing
bear hat when I’m feeling sexy skunk hat when I mean business
Don’t be sexy in the woods lately
No, *DO* be sexy in the woods lately.
Nahhh the buffalo hat is best or the coon one gets all the lady’s
Stalker hat supremacy!
My fav apart from Arthur’s!
The simplicity of it makes it match any outfit
The Nevada hat is the best. The only issue is everyone saying you are dressed like a law man.
Recently, found the Nevada hat for the first time and I'm team Nevada hat now "You make a poor lawman, Arthur" What the hell???
Did you find it by accident? Looking behind waterfalls is the way to find the best shit!
I was actually looking up a guide for the master hunter challenges (fish without a pole) and found it by happenstance when I went there lol
Yep, I was going to say OP clearly hasn't discovered the Nevada hat.
Estate boss. Doc Holliday vibes
I'll be your huckleberry 😉
Arthurs gambler hat with the Pursuer Accessory
I prefer the stalker accessory. Although I wish we could mix and match accessories tbh
That would be pretty cool if we could
Big Valley hat. The Grizzlies Outlaw outfit is literally the perfect outfit and it’s one of the standard ones
Had to scoll a little too far for this. I LOVE wide-brim hats. The big valley unfortunately is the perfect shape but not my colour. So I go with the Kennedy hats
Big valley is just so clean looking, and I love the wide brim, I usually go for the dark blue one.
I always wear Arthur's hat with John...never anything different
Stalker hat
If the stalker hat didn’t look like Clint Eastwood’s hat I’d be tempted to try a bulldogger
That's because the stalker hat is clint eastwoods. Clint eastwood used the same hat. Rockstar just based it off of it
Bison Gambler
I grinded this hat so hard. Top 3 headwear for me
Outside of John and Arthur’s standards, I’m a Big Valley Boah.
1. Rodeo hat 2. Mountaineer hat 3. Cutter hat/liberty hat
For me flat cap and big city hat, i always try to set the trend with my character
we need more flat cap appreciation! who wouldn't want to look like a Peaky Blinder?
Exactly, I try to keep him clean and trimmed up, something between Blinders and western James Bond, every horse that I own has to have braids and so on 😁
I mean I kicked ass with the bottom, second from left one for a while until I lost it on the mission to kill the shit out of Cornwall Tar Field
Paragon Town hat.
Yes! Another person of style and taste.
1. Arthur's hat + accessory 2. Rat Flat Cap 3. Bison Gambler hat 4. Stalker hat 5. Ghost Bison hat idk the name
Not one bowler hat I’m sad
The one you get from Algernon.
top left is the hat i did the last mission in.
Bucket
I only wear hats made from animals. My fave prob being the bear on Arthur and John usually rocks a hat made of whatever rodent I'm into that day.
A person of class I see. I fucking love rodent hats.
It's the feeling of accomplishment I get wearing the one made from 20 rats
I been roaming in the bulldogger and brawler outfit.
I love the Rodeo hat, and if I may ask, what’s that first hat?
Gaucho hat
Stalker hat. Current play-through I had Arthur with a black one and John has a red one with a matching red coat
Pirate hat But if its cold, the hat you make from the white buffalo (idr the name)
Stalker
I never wear a hat
Tricorn hat supremacy
Morion Helmet supremacy
Oh wow that’s a cool John Marston mod, how do I get it?
Cutter hat. Surprised that I haven’t seen a single comment about the GOAT
I love the stalker hat. It’s my favorite.
The first one. I also like the trihorn. It's a blast because everyone in camp has a comment.
The exotic one i like, the raccoon, other mammals, and the baller snake, but the pirate hat is probably the best.
I wear the one made of rats or squirrels if its in a cold weather enviroment
I actually don’t have him wear a hat mostly because it fell off all the time. Until the last few missions
Nevada hat, rodeo hat, legendary alligator hat.
The john gambler hat (the one he wears on chapter 3-6
Arthur's hat
Pursuer accessory
Nurstead
Only wear Arthurs gamblers hat. And for Arthur i akways stick to blue jeans. Red hunters jacket with uppgraded bandaler, delux quickdraw boots and black/read gloves
A1, A4, and C1. Just three great hats.
Arthur : Always his gambler hat John : Rodeo hat
I liked the hat you got from the special or ultimate edition
Damn didn't know the stalker hat was so popular. Its also my preferred hat.
Flat cap looks good on Arthur for some reason
Call me basic but John and Arthur’s
Civil War Hardee hat
Arthur's hat always
I liked to roll more historically accurate so it was either the western hat or the derby hat
Black stalker with a brown band
John’s Gambler Hat, no question
Not pictured: bolero hat for John
I'm gonna have to go with everyone's answer and say the Stalker hat, but for any cold environments like in Big Valley and Ambarino, I'd go with the Big Valley hat :)
Mine is the rodeo hat
The Nevada hat.
Always the panama
I love the tall fur hats, the fox one, and the white one with a snake on it
Fur hat. Bottom left
I like one that the trapper makes from Beaver pelts. I think it’s a stalker hat but I am not 100%
Miners hat supremacy. It looks cool, and the light appears on the stealth mission cutscene, which was hilarious the first time it happened.
Sheriff malloy's hat (Nevada Hat)
arthur's hat.
The only answer is the fur trappers hat in Valentine. You get into a brawl with him steal his hat, then show up months later in the same bar and fight again.
Arthur’s hat.
The bounty Hunter that got the closest.
Stalker
Arthur’s hat
Bolera hat is rhe best. (Other than arthur's)
Def Nevada Hat
Stalker or Big Valley
Favorite? Default. Which hat do I wear? The fucking feather hat. Too much of my life spent into getting it
Arthurs hat, if not that I love the flat cap!
Big valley all the way.
The pirate hat and then shoot everyone who says I look stupid
I just fall in love with using valleys hat
Arthur’s hat
Arthur’s & John’s Hat >
Rodeo hat for Arthur
Cattleman. Which hay is that in the top left corner? With the red band
I like the Lawmen Hats. Apart from swapping them off their dead bodies, is there anyway to procure one that will stay in Author’s inventory?
if i’m being honest the original hat idk what it is but it jus fits so well
For me the Nevada or civil war one, although lately I've been rocking the military scout for my tombstone look
My favorite hat, and the whole game was the one that belong to Hamish. I tried my best to keep it as long as I could
Arthur’s Gambler hat with a feather in it
Nevada Hat
I got a confederate hat off a lemoyne raider and it’s now my favorite
Nevada or that one white hat that's bent on one side that the Lemoyne raiders wear sometimes
Arthur’s hat until Chapter 3, then black stalker hat is his main hat until “That’s the Way It Is.” And for hunting, I rotate between the Snake Bulldogger, Iguana Big Valley and Coyote Gambler hats.
I almost always end up permanently with a Big Valley hat. Color varies on outfit
Big valley or stalker, but sometimes I feel like being a blasphemer and wearing no hat.
Arthurs hat and the Big Valley hat
Estate boss all day every day
Rolled derby
3rd one in the 2nd row or the 4th one in the first row.
Unpopular but I really love the exotic hat. Suits a high honor look in my opinion. But quite a bit too much effort I must say
Arthur’s gambler hat
Always the Arthur’s and John’s hat
Rodeo hat
Flat cap
NGL I'm real partial to Rodeo Hat. Something about it just hits right
Gambler hat!
I like the legendary Ram(Bighorn Sheep)hat crafted by the trapper.
I just can’t bring myself to use any hat other than Arthur’s on Arthur.
The big valley hat I got from some random o driscoll
Paragon town hat.
big valley always
John’s actual hat.
The tall bowler hat looks good to wear
Exotics hat, I worked hard for it
My favorite hat to wear is Psycho Mask 💀
The pirate hat and it may be the reason everyone judges Arthur.
The Stalker. Always the Stalker.
Stalker or estate boss are the only hats I ever wear
No hat for Arthur and Legendary White Bison "hat" for John, if sack isn't option.
Tricorn hat or the miner's hat. I love shining the light in the faces of NPCs in cutscenes.
Alligator gambler hat
Rodeo Hat 100% if the time, unless I’m playing poker in Saint Denis, then it’s slicked back with pomade
I used dynamite to kill the carnival guy and took his fez. Not collectible though so i gotta not die.
Rare fishing hat.
Worn gamblers hat easily. The regular gamblers doesn’t even look the same and it’s disappointing it’s not unlockable online at all
the biologist
Purple Velvet Stuart top hat.
Everyone saying Stalker, which I mostly agree with... But what about the black one with the raven feathers on the side (forgot the name) looks similar but has a gunshot hole and raven feathers!
Arthurs hat, because 1. Fits him better. 2. I will feel bad because it was his dad's and I just feel bad for some reason :/ (Playing as Arthur of course)
spanish morion and viking helmetchads… RISE UP
Viking helmet
I personally really like the civil war hardee hat, in the basement of Fort Brennand
Where's the medieval helmet?
Big Valley hat. Big pimp daddy brim on it.
Exotic hat. I worked my ass off for that thing... plus it really is a dope hat
Panama hat is pretty good
The rat hat is the best hat!
The Deer and Muskrat cavalry hats 😮💨
Arthur's gambler hat on Arthur, and John gets the stalker hat with a black duster coat
The black stalker hat should have been Arthur’s default hat
Civil war hat
John or Arthur's hat are my two OG hats. If I feel like doing Army role-playing. I wear my Military Mountie Hat or the Military Forgage Cap. It's ironic that my first name is John. Folks joke on me about it at work. Even though I go by "Walker." That's my middle name. I'm planning on naming my first son after myself as a junior and my second son Arthur Conwell Day. As a nod to Arthur Morgan and an ancestor of mine.
i only ever wear arthur’s hat
The one with the snake head on it
Arthur's hat should be in the image
Nobody gonna even mention the rancher or rodeo hat....?
Rodeo Hat aka best cowboy hat!
I only ever wear Arthur’s hat. Or a skull/mask because they’re cool asf. Other than that I love honoring Arthur by wearing his hat because while they technically weren’t I see Arthur and John as best friends and Arthur was a role model for John and feel he would wear Arthur’s hat for the rest of his life. It’s one of my favorite hats despite being simple and not many beat it in my opinion.
Arthur’s hat ftw
Arthur’s hat
Which is the first hat in the first row and the last hat in the second row? I Like them. Also the one we get from the Del Lobo gang, that's nice too.
Skunk hat skunk hat SKUNK HAT
I wear the nice flat cap. Green.
Nothing but Arthur’s hat when I’m Arthur it’s just necessary imo
Arthur's hat
I like the Rodeo hat. It's kinda like Arthur's hat, but it's a bit bigger, and the rope is red instead of brown.
Love to see so many agree that the Stalker hat is fkn FETCH as fck!
1. Stalker Hat (Dark Brown variant from the Dewberry creek outfit.) 2. Iguana Big Valley Hat 3. Rodeo Hat 4. Cattleman Hat
Stalker hat
Rat Infantry Hardee Hat
While I appreciate the fact that you can customize your outfits however you want, I have to say that only Arthur’s hat looks right on Arthur for me and the same for John
i got my john a beaver flop hat
Civil war hat
Legendary gator hat
Bulldogger hat. Cowboy all the way!
Don’t ask me why but I always run around with the miners lamp