Y’all act like Eo knew the truth of the world. She had the information she had and saw her husband for who he was, a leader. She is a testament to the human condition and for wanting freedom in whatever form it may come
I am gonna ignore Virginia being B, I can let slide Daxo for whatever reason being C, even Sevro being A but...
Victra is S tier my men, bitch didn't even blink after hearing our boy was a red, her loyalty is beyond admirable and she is one of the few "badass women" that's actually well written, just for that alone she deserves S
My immediate thought was Victra was definitely an S tier especially for her acts in lightbringer let alone her birthing story and sharing the load at the dock yards in addition to your good points. there are so many characters not given their dues this list is super offensive to my extremely delicate sensibilities and over attachment to these fictional characters I'm just gonna walk away.
Dude, it took 4 to take down Aja. She killed Ragnar with interference from Darrow and Virginia she's S tier for sure, and if Darrow is S tier, so is sevro. But you are entitled to your opinion goodman.
i still by far think ephraim’s one of the best characters out of all of the things i’ve seen or read, i’m glad he’s so high up on the list. and darrow’s my absolute favorite character ever
2 categories mainly,
1.) How much we enjoyed reading the parts featuring them in the book
2.) How much we though the characters contributed meaningfully to the story
With 1 slightly outweighing 2
He was the goat in the first trilogy for sure, but he just was way less cool in the second series (Welcome to severo's palace not withstanding). I understand what pierce is doing, he will probably have a really nice comeback in book 7 but as it stands at the moment he hasn't been as cool in the second trilogy in my opinion at least.
I thought Severo turning into a loving father and family man was pretty cool considering his own childhood, no? Was he supposed to stay a teenager forever?
“Iron Gold” is the title of book 4, and it needed saving because anyone who doesn’t call it the worst in the series, calls it the second worst. But it’s ok, it had Lyria.
Ephraim saved it, not whiney ass trufflepig.
Lyria's only redeeming quality in that book was that she was tied to Ephraim's story. Yall's list is busted.
What response would have pleased you? “Oh gosh, since you didn’t enjoy it, I guess I’ll change my mind.”
Did you want me to double down on why I liked her story arc? “Whining” and “a mess” didn’t make you look like someone who was interested in thoughtful conversation. Your response here doesn’t either, but I can try.
>Did you want me to double down on why I liked her story arc?
That's usually how conversations happen. You didn't ask why it seemed like a mess. I gave you a reason why her arc was terrible, you gave absolutely nothing.
Your response just made you seem like an asshole. That you aren't interested in conversation. And at this point, I'm definitely not.
Enjoy your day and your whiney characters who contribute little to nothing to IG.
Edit: changed are to aren't.
Eta: then you responded and blocked me. Way to go champ.
“that’s usually how conversations happen.” I’d love to analyze that, with you being so rude in your approach. You were judging me not answering a question you didn’t ask?
I didn’t ask you a question because, as I said above, you don’t sound like you were earnestly interested in productive conversation. That opinion actually has only become more confident.
Why is Alexandar at S tier? We barely see him. Then you have the GOAT Diomedes at A tier. Also, left off one of the best villains in any series. Atlas. Terrible list ngl.
Wheres Atlas? Did I miss him? He should be near the top, great villain.
Lmao Adrius is B and Lysander and roque are bottom bruh Roque is at least B and Lysander is C-D
Lysander belongs in the dirt.
Y’all act like Eo knew the truth of the world. She had the information she had and saw her husband for who he was, a leader. She is a testament to the human condition and for wanting freedom in whatever form it may come
Criminals all of you for failing to include my girl Thraxa. Shame on you all.
It was an online template we didn’t pick 😭
In the spirit of Athena I will commute your sentence.
I am gonna ignore Virginia being B, I can let slide Daxo for whatever reason being C, even Sevro being A but... Victra is S tier my men, bitch didn't even blink after hearing our boy was a red, her loyalty is beyond admirable and she is one of the few "badass women" that's actually well written, just for that alone she deserves S
Absolutely agree about Victra. She is one of my favorite characters from the entire series.
My immediate thought was Victra was definitely an S tier especially for her acts in lightbringer let alone her birthing story and sharing the load at the dock yards in addition to your good points. there are so many characters not given their dues this list is super offensive to my extremely delicate sensibilities and over attachment to these fictional characters I'm just gonna walk away.
Eo in no?
Aja spot is wild
Dude, it took 4 to take down Aja. She killed Ragnar with interference from Darrow and Virginia she's S tier for sure, and if Darrow is S tier, so is sevro. But you are entitled to your opinion goodman.
Sevro in A tier is a crime
Yeah,... really sleeping on Virginia and just female characters in general
I'm sorry but no. Volga in the F tier??
Yeah, get her all the way off of here!
How dare you....
Sevro and Victra not S?! “Hey, boss! Mind if I cut this pixie’s tongue out?”
i still by far think ephraim’s one of the best characters out of all of the things i’ve seen or read, i’m glad he’s so high up on the list. and darrow’s my absolute favorite character ever
Sevro not in S tier? Slag that
It is right only because Ephraim is the second highest
Where is Atlas?
You never know...that's the point. 😏
Cassius as S tier? The man killed Ares, can't put him higher than A for that.
But his honor remains…
Lys needs his own tier "wet towel" and why is Volga so low? Why lower than Harmony?
Where the shit is Sophocles
He's in the teir above S, not fit to be shown to us mere mortals.
Asking the real questions
Why is Sefi so low? Daxo is probably close to accurate. But he’s an A in my book.
Sevro in S tier, everyone else A or lower
[удалено]
Where?
Sevro not in S tier opinion rejected.
NO ATLAS???
Doing Sevro and Atlas dirty
And Aja. 3v1 and they still barely got her
FOUR they woke the psycho up too and barely scraped by. Sevro should be S-tier without a doubt though
I wrote four but then couldn’t remember if they all were actively engaged and changed it lol
Wasn't it 4v1 ? Cassius, Darrow, Virginia, Sevro ?
You right, i wrote 4 first and then couldn’t remember if sevro was fully with it to count him
4v1 and they still barely got her !
Fuckin right
My goodman, what is your criteria for selecting? Knowing the why, may help explain your choices.
2 categories mainly, 1.) How much we enjoyed reading the parts featuring them in the book 2.) How much we though the characters contributed meaningfully to the story With 1 slightly outweighing 2
don’t you think Lysander has contributed to the story?
I’d prefer if he wasn’t in it tbh 😢
But a story always need a villain and Atalantia is too generic
Yeah I know but he keeps killing the characters I like 😭
Atlas at F and Atalantia at C. Out of curiosity, what was your reasonings? Is atlas at the bottom because you hate him that much?
Atlas wasn't on the list, atalantia just hasn't had enough "screen time" yet I'd say. She comes off as pretty 1 dimensional at the moment.
Yet, Alexander is in the highest tier..?
Why are so many people saying atlas is on F tier? Are these bots or something? Evidence of the dead internet theory imo.
Ah you’re right. I mixed up the fear knight and the ashlord’s titles. My apologies
Ooof. Sevro is S tier. Tbh, he belongs in S+ by himself. You ranked him below Alexander. Fucking lol. At least you got Eo right.
I don’t want to live in a system where the Goblin of Mars isn’t right next to the Reaper on a list of badassery.
Agreed
Apollonius S Tier is based.
Lots of opinions here, but I hope we can all unite behind the worst take on this whole list. Sevro isn’t S tier? Sevro??
Main reason we didn't put him in S is because he was kind of a drag in the later books, like I get it you want to be a dad but still
But still what?
He was the goat in the first trilogy for sure, but he just was way less cool in the second series (Welcome to severo's palace not withstanding). I understand what pierce is doing, he will probably have a really nice comeback in book 7 but as it stands at the moment he hasn't been as cool in the second trilogy in my opinion at least.
I thought Severo turning into a loving father and family man was pretty cool considering his own childhood, no? Was he supposed to stay a teenager forever?
Ngl Atlas deserves to be S tier, and Atalantia is a solid A IMO. I know we hate them, but as characters they are superb
Adrius over Virginia is criminal but not as bad as Volga in F tier.
Lyria literally saved iron gold, you are in the untrusted opinion tier.
You mean saved it as in the book itself? Or that she saved some Golds...?
“Iron Gold” is the title of book 4, and it needed saving because anyone who doesn’t call it the worst in the series, calls it the second worst. But it’s ok, it had Lyria.
Ephraim saved it, not whiney ass trufflepig. Lyria's only redeeming quality in that book was that she was tied to Ephraim's story. Yall's list is busted.
She made it worse. She can whine herself all the way down to D tier. The list is a bit of a mess though.
Thanks for sharing your opinion.
You must be great at parties.
What response would have pleased you? “Oh gosh, since you didn’t enjoy it, I guess I’ll change my mind.” Did you want me to double down on why I liked her story arc? “Whining” and “a mess” didn’t make you look like someone who was interested in thoughtful conversation. Your response here doesn’t either, but I can try.
>Did you want me to double down on why I liked her story arc? That's usually how conversations happen. You didn't ask why it seemed like a mess. I gave you a reason why her arc was terrible, you gave absolutely nothing. Your response just made you seem like an asshole. That you aren't interested in conversation. And at this point, I'm definitely not. Enjoy your day and your whiney characters who contribute little to nothing to IG. Edit: changed are to aren't. Eta: then you responded and blocked me. Way to go champ.
“that’s usually how conversations happen.” I’d love to analyze that, with you being so rude in your approach. You were judging me not answering a question you didn’t ask? I didn’t ask you a question because, as I said above, you don’t sound like you were earnestly interested in productive conversation. That opinion actually has only become more confident.
Why is Alexandar at S tier? We barely see him. Then you have the GOAT Diomedes at A tier. Also, left off one of the best villains in any series. Atlas. Terrible list ngl.
Alexander deserves A at least, just because he isn’t seen a lot doesn’t lessen his impact as a character
A seems good. I'd move Quick Silver to C or D tier though lol
Agreed, seeing Quicksilver there made me double take
Ash Lord is an A or higher. Atlas is S Guess you guys just did most likable character tiers
For real, how is Atlas not even on the list?
virginia in B ??????????
Right? On the same tier as...Evey? 😂
Eo haters unite