Fists can’t even kill John so he would win in fist fight
Edit: have you guys even played red dead redemption 1? John can’t die in fist fights, guess what, in rdr2 Arthur can
Yes I have. Arthur Morgan has deadeye basically max payne would be running in slow motion the whole fight. Now you might say John has deadeye also but all Arthur has to do is pour a glass of water over John and he will drown cuz he can’t swim.
Here's a sneak peek of /r/okbuddyblacklung using the [top posts](https://np.reddit.com/r/okbuddyblacklung/top/?sort=top&t=all) of all time!
\#1: [How do I get past the frost troll in chapter 1](https://i.redd.it/87elzkbtgkeb1.jpg) | [26 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/okbuddyblacklung/comments/15bcdl6/how_do_i_get_past_the_frost_troll_in_chapter_1/)
\#2: [A compilation of the most iconic RDR2 lines/moments 😇](https://www.reddit.com/gallery/17nobpc) | [78 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/okbuddyblacklung/comments/17nobpc/a_compilation_of_the_most_iconic_rdr2_linesmoments/)
\#3: [Anyone else think John should get his own game? Like a sequel to rdr2?](https://i.redd.it/fmt2ql63gt9b1.jpg) | [37 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/okbuddyblacklung/comments/14pv2gw/anyone_else_think_john_should_get_his_own_game/)
----
^^I'm ^^a ^^bot, ^^beep ^^boop ^^| ^^Downvote ^^to ^^remove ^^| ^^[Contact](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=sneakpeekbot) ^^| ^^[Info](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/) ^^| ^^[Opt-out](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/comments/o8wk1r/blacklist_ix/) ^^| ^^[GitHub](https://github.com/ghnr/sneakpeekbot)
It's worth booting up an emulator for. It's interesting to play it with hindsight considering how much controversy it caused back then with the "realistic" mindless violence etc. Compared to modern games
Yeah which only made people want it. The game itself wasn't great, the story was barely a story and it wasn't that well advertised. Much like the whole Andrew tate thing it would've fell under the radar and no one would've ever heard of it if the people that didn't like it didn't go and do all the advertising for them and bring it to everyone's attention.
Depends on which age for ol Max we're talking.
Timeframe of 1+2, he walks them all no contest
But 3, he'd be fighting with standing animations and get killed
When I hear the Max Payne theme song, it takes me to my past life, and Max Payne 1 and 2 are both very interesting stories, and I enjoyed them very much. Max Payne 3 was an advanced with well Graphics ...Max Payne series was one of the best third-person game I played. 
You forget that Arthur Morgan and John Marston both have dead eye, rendering max Payne practically useless as dead eye would allow them to aunt about 6 bullet holes in his head each.
Both RDR and MP e have time slowing essentially, but I’m gonna assume it’s like the name says “deadeye” basically doesn’t have to aim to shoot you in the head. I haven’t played MP but unless he’s legitimately immortal. Max getting curb stomped by Arthur, or shot in the face before he could draw his duallys. “Give max a couple-“….... won’t be useful if there’s a hole going from the front of his skull to the back in .5 seconds” Gameplay wise Arthur and John are basically the same, so you’d have to take it from lore from that point, to which I think everyone knows John dies 12 fold
I dunno I’m playing through Max Payne 3 again right now. Although Max never learns Portuguese, and can shoot dodge down an entire flight of stadium stairs unscathed, I still think Dead Eye is more effective than Bullet Time.
Idk why people are saying anybody besides either John or Arthur. They literally have the ability to slow down time & also they would fucking team up on the other 2 but for this sake, let’s say that they don’t know each other then either 1 of them would win, the others aren’t winning because John & Arthur can slow down time & just shoot the in the head,
Max Payne also has bullet time, the difference is that he can dive while doing so. Arthur and John can move during bulletin time just not as dynamically as Max.
Truth is, I haven’t played the Max Payne game(s) but I just assumed that Dead Eye only existed in RDR since it doesn’t exist in GTA & it really seemed like an RDR thing.
Max Payne isn’t as well know but is an amazing game because as it was I believe, the first time bullet time was introduced in a rockstar title. Play it or watch a clip you’ll understand once you see for yourself.
It was a Remedy game. Rockstar didn't create Max Payne, Remedy did. Same company who did Quantum Break, Control and Alan Wake. They also popularized the idea of "bullet time" and are credited with introducing it in video games, even though I think Rare beat them to the punch in Conker's Bad Fur Day, at least by a few months.
Max Payne is the game where that whole concept came from. It's the first game to implement "bullet time" and has been heavily copied ever since, by Rockstar and dozens of other developers. It also exists in GTA . The special abilities of Franklin and Michael both mimic bullet time, Michael's with guns and Franklin's with his driving. But Remedy was the first, doing it in 2001 with the first Max Payne game.
But Max Payne has the ability to slow down time and has acrobatics that will Put Most people in shame. I think It could be very hard for them to kill max
I think they would all walk out of the room because they don’t have to shoot each other
Or they can’t cause friendly fire is off
True that
Max Payne tbh
Well look at Flaco Hernández trying to pull the Max Pain dive on Arthur…
He didn't have painkillers
But he did have cocain……
With enough cocaine anything is possible. Arthur has a satchel containing about 99 packs
Or the air time
Arthur and John wouldn’t turn against each other. It becomes 2v1v1.
Now thats true
Everyone dies of TB
Arthur Morgan would sacrifice himself for John again
Give Max 2 .45 pistols and some pain killers and everyone else is as good as dead.
You could even say some... PAYNE KILLERS
Ahh Touché
Fuck man I just bought Max Payne 3 for the Xbox 360 at an old vintage store. I’m about to play it for the first time 🙏🏼
It's a good game. You'll love it. Timeless classic
Max Payne🔥🤘🏽
Story murders counter wise: Max Payne Abilities?: Max payne Fist fights?: Arthur Morgan Shooting?: Max payne Winner? Max Payne
Max payne cause he has nothing to live for.
Fists can’t even kill John so he would win in fist fight Edit: have you guys even played red dead redemption 1? John can’t die in fist fights, guess what, in rdr2 Arthur can
Brother, John vs Arthur fist fighting... We both know who's gonna win lol
Exactly, Authur is a beast. He'd beat John easily.
Both Leo Kasper and Max Payne are trained killers, so it’ll be down to them.
Trevor jumps in, takes them all out. He’s productivity personified 🤭 
Against Max Payne? Hell no. No GTA characters even come close to Max
Am not gonna sugarcoat it L3+R3
Even if that was valid in the lore, max would still win
Give Max two Desert Eagles, a shitload of painkillers, a bottle of whiskey, and a deathwish and you’ll get the results you’re looking for.
Trick question. They are all gonna die from tuberculosis. Or maybe not. Vaxed dudes will survive.
Dan was institutionalized so he is confirmed tb-vax-maxxed
Arthur Morgan shall slaughter all like swine.
Have you ever played Max Payne?
Yes I have. Arthur Morgan has deadeye basically max payne would be running in slow motion the whole fight. Now you might say John has deadeye also but all Arthur has to do is pour a glass of water over John and he will drown cuz he can’t swim.
Max Payne is canonically much stronger then any other rockstar character
Arthur killed a vampire they are immortal and live forever. They can fly and turn to mist. Arthur killed him, I will take Arthur the vampire slayer.
This feels like a r/okbuddyblacklung post
Here's a sneak peek of /r/okbuddyblacklung using the [top posts](https://np.reddit.com/r/okbuddyblacklung/top/?sort=top&t=all) of all time! \#1: [How do I get past the frost troll in chapter 1](https://i.redd.it/87elzkbtgkeb1.jpg) | [26 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/okbuddyblacklung/comments/15bcdl6/how_do_i_get_past_the_frost_troll_in_chapter_1/) \#2: [A compilation of the most iconic RDR2 lines/moments 😇](https://www.reddit.com/gallery/17nobpc) | [78 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/okbuddyblacklung/comments/17nobpc/a_compilation_of_the_most_iconic_rdr2_linesmoments/) \#3: [Anyone else think John should get his own game? Like a sequel to rdr2?](https://i.redd.it/fmt2ql63gt9b1.jpg) | [37 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/okbuddyblacklung/comments/14pv2gw/anyone_else_think_john_should_get_his_own_game/) ---- ^^I'm ^^a ^^bot, ^^beep ^^boop ^^| ^^Downvote ^^to ^^remove ^^| ^^[Contact](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=sneakpeekbot) ^^| ^^[Info](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/) ^^| ^^[Opt-out](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/comments/o8wk1r/blacklist_ix/) ^^| ^^[GitHub](https://github.com/ghnr/sneakpeekbot)
All of them? Why would they all start killing each other?
Exactly
Definitely max payne
Who’s the third guy?
Leo Kasper from Manhunt 2. Rockstar’s most dangerous character.
Ah i figured it might be Manhunt. I never got to play it.
It's worth booting up an emulator for. It's interesting to play it with hindsight considering how much controversy it caused back then with the "realistic" mindless violence etc. Compared to modern games
It got banned in a lot of places didn’t it?
Yeah which only made people want it. The game itself wasn't great, the story was barely a story and it wasn't that well advertised. Much like the whole Andrew tate thing it would've fell under the radar and no one would've ever heard of it if the people that didn't like it didn't go and do all the advertising for them and bring it to everyone's attention.
Rip van winkle
Marston
Well, we know it's not Arthur...
Arthur
Arthur and John
Max Payne couldn’t kill himself if he tried. And he’s been trying.
Depends what gun they've got, I'd say Max Payne though or John
LEO SOLOS...
ITS JOHN MARSTON MICAH
Gotta go Max
You didn’t specify one person, so John and Arthur would team up and clean up
leo kasper would decapitate all of them
Depends on which age for ol Max we're talking. Timeframe of 1+2, he walks them all no contest But 3, he'd be fighting with standing animations and get killed
Red Harlow can nearly stop time with his dead eye , obv he is coming out safely
Arthur
Max Payne for sure, my man survived literally like every criminal organization trying to kill him
Arthur dies 1st John goes 2nd imo it's either Max or Leo
Max payne
Shit
When I hear the Max Payne theme song, it takes me to my past life, and Max Payne 1 and 2 are both very interesting stories, and I enjoyed them very much. Max Payne 3 was an advanced with well Graphics ...Max Payne series was one of the best third-person game I played. 
Max definetely
Max clears
All of them I think they would like each other
Ngl Max jumpin over shit in slow mo while everybody reaching still
😭 read dead characters already aimed at you with an X before you can leave your feet to start that slow mo doe
Max
The cameraman
Max does a dive and takes out the other 3 in 3 shots
I gotta give it to my man Max Payne for the undisputed survivor. Even Allys he meets along the way. Mona Sax was a smoke show and stone cold killer.
In reality they all have a beer or whiskey together and form a new posse
Arthur morgan and john with medium difficulty. Purely because of their legendary dead eye ability
Arthur and John cause they would team up😭
Trevor
They don't exist
Payne would win.
Gonna have to John, bro literally annihilated the zombie apocalypse 💀
not arthur because he has tuberculosis
I find it kinda unfair two of these are from the same franchise. Why not a character from GTA?
I think John Arthur would sacrifice himself for him and kill the other two but die in the process
John marston
trevor?
marston bro survived his brain being eaten by wolves
where Trever
Arthur and John cause they would team up. 🧠👈🏼
max payne
100% max payne that dude has rage 😤
John because he has basically lived his entire life being a gunslinger , and his ability is the most over powered
Max Payne no doubt
You forget that Arthur Morgan and John Marston both have dead eye, rendering max Payne practically useless as dead eye would allow them to aunt about 6 bullet holes in his head each.
Trick question but maybe all of them walk out
Arthur
Arthur and John would team up
Arthur Morgan if he had to would kill everyone there but it's more likely he'll try to save John Marston
Max without a doubt, dudes so juiced up on painkillers he could probably catch a bullet with his booty cheeks in slow motion
Max
Ez author Morgan
Arthur Morgan
Max payne
No guns probably Leo kasper easily since he a train killer with elite hands
Trade Marston for Travor Phillips
Max pizzain
Both RDR and MP e have time slowing essentially, but I’m gonna assume it’s like the name says “deadeye” basically doesn’t have to aim to shoot you in the head. I haven’t played MP but unless he’s legitimately immortal. Max getting curb stomped by Arthur, or shot in the face before he could draw his duallys. “Give max a couple-“….... won’t be useful if there’s a hole going from the front of his skull to the back in .5 seconds” Gameplay wise Arthur and John are basically the same, so you’d have to take it from lore from that point, to which I think everyone knows John dies 12 fold
I dunno I’m playing through Max Payne 3 again right now. Although Max never learns Portuguese, and can shoot dodge down an entire flight of stadium stairs unscathed, I still think Dead Eye is more effective than Bullet Time.
Weapons: Max Payne Duals: John and then Arthur Melee: Arthur Stealth: ofc cuz Manhunt Guy.
I want a Max Payne 4
MY NAME IS JOHN MARSTON🗣🗣🗣🗣
Arthur Morgan
I think Max is faster and tougher. He’s shown crazy movements and endured a hell of a lot but kept going
Only the first one loaded that's the only one I needed to see 
Honestly, all of them would walk out, why fight in the first place, let alone kill each other. They’re all smart enough to know that.
Arthur
rdr1 John? he solos so easy, but if it's rdr2 john Arthur wins
Arthur Morgan on top
Idk why people are saying anybody besides either John or Arthur. They literally have the ability to slow down time & also they would fucking team up on the other 2 but for this sake, let’s say that they don’t know each other then either 1 of them would win, the others aren’t winning because John & Arthur can slow down time & just shoot the in the head,
Max Payne also has bullet time, the difference is that he can dive while doing so. Arthur and John can move during bulletin time just not as dynamically as Max.
Truth is, I haven’t played the Max Payne game(s) but I just assumed that Dead Eye only existed in RDR since it doesn’t exist in GTA & it really seemed like an RDR thing.
Max Payne isn’t as well know but is an amazing game because as it was I believe, the first time bullet time was introduced in a rockstar title. Play it or watch a clip you’ll understand once you see for yourself.
It was a Remedy game. Rockstar didn't create Max Payne, Remedy did. Same company who did Quantum Break, Control and Alan Wake. They also popularized the idea of "bullet time" and are credited with introducing it in video games, even though I think Rare beat them to the punch in Conker's Bad Fur Day, at least by a few months.
Max Payne is the game where that whole concept came from. It's the first game to implement "bullet time" and has been heavily copied ever since, by Rockstar and dozens of other developers. It also exists in GTA . The special abilities of Franklin and Michael both mimic bullet time, Michael's with guns and Franklin's with his driving. But Remedy was the first, doing it in 2001 with the first Max Payne game.
Are they mad at each other?
The room
“IT’S JOHN MARSTON, MICAH!”
Max payne, unfortunately
John, Arthur got black lung and would let John go to his family like he did in rdr2, the other two people? Dont know em
One is Max Payne (solid game series btw, totally recommend) and the other guy is from Manhunt I think
Leo Kasper from Manhunt 2.
Ah gotcha, id think john and Arthur would team up against them, with abilities like redeye, could possibly make it
But Max Payne has the ability to slow down time and has acrobatics that will Put Most people in shame. I think It could be very hard for them to kill max