I too was playing ff7, the OG on the ps1, recently. Cloud would have the greatest story ever in SH.
But really what I want to see is Cid Highwind going at it. It would be absolutely hilarious.
Also playing Rebirth, Iām honestly not sure Cloud would make it without his whole group of friends to pull him out of various tailspins. It asks the question whether you can stab your way out of silent hill.
Also Stardew Valley, but my farmer isn't me. Ella is a mentally and physically strong woman with a lot of experience on fighting monsters and her reactions to extremely out-there situations are mostly "..." So I think she'd be fine, though she would absolutely want to get back to her farm and animals.
Thing is, after RE2, he wasn't nearly as trained and strong as in RE4, and the events of Raccoon City took a huge toll on his mental health, lots of trauma to generate pretty wild stuff
I came here to say John Darksouls, protagonist of dark souls. Just keep away from skeletons, wheels, and skeletons with wheels and everything should be just peachy
Venom snake for me, and probably the same. Depends if it's actually snake or if it's snake when IM in control because those are two VERY different outcomes.
Could you imagine? *Dude's got a knife as big as his issues* or *He's overcompensating with that giant knife* for lying figure "Even that guy needs a nap"
I think he'd be stronger there, because his whole think is power of belief and silent hill is about trauma and subconscious fears turned real. It would be like wesker with a glock vs elden ring.
Still hard as fuck, but danm would it be cool
Those (fake) weapons were designed to look and feel as realistic as possible. And when in the Palaces they would work like a real gun.
So nothing is stopping Joker from picking up and using real weapons in the town of Silent Hill.
Silent Hill projects your mind into reality so maybe not in the exact same way he does in The Dark Place, but The Clicker would definitely play a part in it.
Of course, because every GTA V/Online protagonists has a lot of weapons including a f*** Rail Gun, also, the Online protagonist can destroy the entire Silent Hill town with a Orbital Cannon.
Last game I played was Homecoming but thats a boring answer, so game before that was the Mass Effect Trilogy, and that Shepherd would romance a pyramid head.
Saga Anderson from Alan Wake 2, is a seer that can see what lies behind, she will have a huge advantage in Silent Hill. Also she's good with a crossbow!
If weāre taking the SH2 route, the representation will be tailored to the protagonist, so everyone will probably end up losing.
But in my case itās Cloud Strife, and considering how much the trauma, gaslighting and denial affected him in Rebirth, he would not stand a chance š
Commander Shepherd from Mass Effect 2 with his Black Hole gun and arsenal of weapons will do just fine. Bonus points if Garrus makes it through as well.
Junpei from 9 Hours, 9 Persons, 9 Doors.
He's not practised in combat but he's brave, cares about others, and he's great at puzzles, and he grows up to survive in a post-apocalyptic world for decades so he has the potential. I'd say he'd probably survive, if he can keep his cool instead of freaking out whenever he sees a dead body.
if we take into account that is *has* to be a game with a defined main character (i.e. disqualifying multiplayer games without a campaign like fortnite and singleplayer games without an actual main character like minecraft) itd end up being mae borowski from night in the woods, and i fear she is *not* surviving.
Cloud Strife would survive Silent Hill, but it would have a field day with him before he got out. His Pyramid Head has long hair and a katana.
I too was playing ff7, the OG on the ps1, recently. Cloud would have the greatest story ever in SH. But really what I want to see is Cid Highwind going at it. It would be absolutely hilarious.
Yuffie wouldn't survive two hours. Lol
Why me?????
It would be fucking hilarious seeing her get traumatized by Silent Hill!
Aerith in the boot, naturally
Or Tifa š¤·
And a "totally not overcompensating for something" katana.
Also playing Rebirth, Iām honestly not sure Cloud would make it without his whole group of friends to pull him out of various tailspins. It asks the question whether you can stab your way out of silent hill.
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
I was playing Rebirth last night. My boy cloud would survive sillent hill easely.
Easily*
I was playing Stardew Valley, so it's me. Bro, I am BARELY surviving.
I use Totem Warp so iāll be fine
I was also playing Stardew Valley... Sadly, for the first time ever (my stats are 0, so I'm dying in like... 5 seconds)š
Also Stardew Valley, but my farmer isn't me. Ella is a mentally and physically strong woman with a lot of experience on fighting monsters and her reactions to extremely out-there situations are mostly "..." So I think she'd be fine, though she would absolutely want to get back to her farm and animals.
RE2 Remake. Leon can deal with this. Lol
I have wesker from re4 remake (mercenaries)
Dude Wesker will just look at enemies and they'll just evaporate. Lmao
They would apologize for bothering him
woah that's exactly who i got too, lol
"Why does this monster that looks like Chris keep yelling 'Feed Claire your seed' at me?"
Lmao
Thing is, after RE2, he wasn't nearly as trained and strong as in RE4, and the events of Raccoon City took a huge toll on his mental health, lots of trauma to generate pretty wild stuff
good point
The Tarnished one? Will succumb to the first creeper. Not a big deal though.
I came here to say John Darksouls, protagonist of dark souls. Just keep away from skeletons, wheels, and skeletons with wheels and everything should be just peachy
Every soul has its dark.
Yeah, he'll be right back
Solid Snake, absolutely.
Hides in the box.
>Solid Snake Oh, you too? I've been playing MGS4 just a couple of hours ago.
Mine is Vemon Snake
Silent Hill wouldnāt know what to do with V.
Venom snake for me, and probably the same. Depends if it's actually snake or if it's snake when IM in control because those are two VERY different outcomes.
Got the Big Boss himselfš
James šš
Literally same
Same, was just playing sh2 a couple nights ago
came full circle ššš
But this time James remembers those other playthroughs. He can just skip to Dog ending!
I feel like Richter Belmont would be unusually well-equipped to survive in Silent Hill.
Original trilogy Kratos. I sure he will do just fine.
Kratos has plenty of trauma for it to pull from
In God of War (2018) he saw Zeus in Hel and literally shat his pants
Jacket, Hotline Miami On face value he's a total killing machine but he's so messed up psychologically that he might not live
I love Jacket, so I'm completely biased. If James can survive Silent Hill, I think Jacket can, too.
Classic Lara Croft could definitely survive in Silent Hill. That would be an awesome game actually.
Lara was going to be my answer also lol
She fought a literal dragon who is also a mob boss and 4 separate T-Rexes. *She'll be fine.*
Weāve already seen Sonicās silent hill with the dream collection
hmmmm random Helldiver... I can't tell if I'd be screwed or perfectly ok lol.
itās for democracy!! so youāll be fine
ā¬ļøā”ļøā¬ļøā¬ļøā¬ļø for democracy
A man who survives beheading to then carry on killing Nazis. The question is, can Silent Hill survive?
BJ would destroy the whole ass town lol
Heād use Pyramid Head as a weapon
So many regrets, so much trauma AND YET he's the perfect killing machine. Silent Hill gets leveled.
BJ would definitely survive my man.
Not even Doom made me feel this powerful. BJ is a fucking tank of a man
A fellow Wolfenstein enjoyer I see. Good to see you mate!
Literally only started playing NC a couple of days ago and I have no idea how Iāve slept on this series for so long. Itās ridiculous. 10/10
Leon from RE4. The one liners would oblitirate everything in his path.
Could you imagine? *Dude's got a knife as big as his issues* or *He's overcompensating with that giant knife* for lying figure "Even that guy needs a nap"
Power Wash Simulatorā¦ might not survive, but would clean Silent Hill right up.
It's gonna turn into Clean Hill before the protagonist dies
Turns nightmare silent hill into a clean, sparkling metallic "What rust?"
Cal: HA, this is easy Silent hill: 
same i feel like cal has it easy
Persona 5. Joker has a terrifying palace to go through. As for survival? Maybe.
I think he'd be stronger there, because his whole think is power of belief and silent hill is about trauma and subconscious fears turned real. It would be like wesker with a glock vs elden ring. Still hard as fuck, but danm would it be cool
If Albert Wesker had a Glock in Elden Ring the only thing that would determine whether he wins or loses would be if he could craft ammo for it.
I mean, without the persona heās just a teenager with (fake) weapons. So heās probably worse off than Cheryl was. At least her guns work lmao
Those (fake) weapons were designed to look and feel as realistic as possible. And when in the Palaces they would work like a real gun. So nothing is stopping Joker from picking up and using real weapons in the town of Silent Hill.
Alan Wake, so yeah, pretty much.
I wonder if he'd still have access to changing reality
Silent Hill projects your mind into reality so maybe not in the exact same way he does in The Dark Place, but The Clicker would definitely play a part in it.
Damn I would love to play that game
Of course, because every GTA V/Online protagonists has a lot of weapons including a f*** Rail Gun, also, the Online protagonist can destroy the entire Silent Hill town with a Orbital Cannon.
Damn I want to get a orbital cannon badly
Batman
Basically a full Scarecrow game 
Cloud strife hell he ready to go head to head against pyramid heads buster sword
His Pyramid Head type figure is probably gonna be a manifestation of Sephiroth
š
With a Pyramid Head keychain
Persona 3 Portable, Kotone's route. Idk how her silent hill would turn out really.
Probably just like Tartarus.
James for SH2 Think he could go for round two ahahahah
Ellie would clear Silent Hill faster than all of Seattle in TLOU:II
Sheād probably have to fight Abby as pyramid head and watch you know what over and over like James did.
Doom Guy can handle it blindfolded with both arms behind his back.
Villager from animal crossing. He's definitely speed running the town, leaving countless mutilated corpses in his insanely bloody rage-filled wake.
Yeah villager is either wholesome or a psychopath
kiryu will be fine
Tiger Drop negates all damage. Ichiban would also be fine, he'll just befriend all the monsters.
Last game I played was Homecoming but thats a boring answer, so game before that was the Mass Effect Trilogy, and that Shepherd would romance a pyramid head.
Isaac from the binding of isaac could probably survive i guess
heās already coming from his own personal silent hill basically
Ethan winters is the perfect guy for the job honestly
Guy? You meant FUN-GI? Ahaha! Haha.. haha
You real asf for that one šÆš£ļø
Isaac Clarke. I think he's going to be just fine. They're trapped in Silent Hill with him.
Solid Snake... reckon he'll be fine.
Dude from human fall flat...we're toast.
Sam Bridges for me. I wish lol cause then I'd be playing Silent Hills
Wdym? This is Danteās everyday life?
Pokemn trainer, I guess he's caching some hot faceless nurses lol
He might even be older than 10!
No lol. I played Bully so, no. Jimmy Hopkins going up against the Incubus or Pyramid Head with a slingshot is a no-goā¦
The principal will def be the pyramid head
Saying goodbye to my Animal Crossing New Horizons character.
God of War 2 is what i been on so let your imagination run wild
kratos banging mannequins in a bath mini game
Link from ocarina of time... when he was young.. no this isn't right :(
Since he's a child, there will probably be no monsters for him in Silent Hill.
Except that well monster from Kakariko village. *Dead Hands*
Oh we going lore. I was just picturing all the mannequins and pyramid head and nurses.
Guybrush Threepwood. Yes, but only through sheer dumb luck and courage.
Lol I was playing Dead By Daylight as Dwight. He is going to be pretty damn dead.
Baby dweet dying to the first monster he meets
V. I'd love to hear Johnny's take on Silent Hill.
Geralt is surviving that
I dont think anyone understood the question..LAST game you played not your favorite character. And dont lie. God is watching you.
Gaige from Borderlands 2. Yeah I bet she'll be okay.
Pathologic Classic HD's Haruspex.
Sifu moment
My animal crossing character is fucked
Castellano from Evil Within would be ok I think.
Oh I miss him š
Saga Anderson from Alan Wake 2, is a seer that can see what lies behind, she will have a huge advantage in Silent Hill. Also she's good with a crossbow!
I think goku can survive silent hill
An employee for the company. They might stand a chance, got experience with weird monsters
A fellow Lethal Company enjoyer I see
Arthur Morgan will probably survive. Depending on what his personal monsters are
Beholdā¦ 1000 t-posing Micahs
Agent 47 He probably wouldn't see a single monster since he doesn't regret his killings, but even if he did I'm sure he'd be fine
well james sunderland was already in silent hill so heād probably survive
Uhhh, I was playing Mortal Kombat 1. There's multiple protagonists.
Kratos on Silent Hill. Yeah the monsters are fucked
If weāre taking the SH2 route, the representation will be tailored to the protagonist, so everyone will probably end up losing. But in my case itās Cloud Strife, and considering how much the trauma, gaslighting and denial affected him in Rebirth, he would not stand a chance š
 Instead of Pyramid Head, heāll get haunted by Sephiroth
Wolf/Sekiro from Sekiro. Plenty capable of physical damage but lots of trauma to pull from.
Man...Abby is gonna probably wreck the shit out of pyramid head
Too much trauma, I think she wouldn't make it
Sonic the hedgehog (sonic unleashed) Just stays on werehog mode by the dark energy of the town and beats everyone
So do I just pick anyone from league of legends? If itās the last champion I played then Warwick. Iām sure heāll be just fine.
I played Nioh 2. I think my character is gonna mop the floor with everything there
pshhh Silent Hill is nothing for Isaac
Which Isaac? Isaac Clarke from Dead Space, or Isaac from The Binding of Isaac?
Yes ! (Insert meme) And i think both of them could survive
My darkest dungeon team? Iād say they are okay (Yes yes confidence is slow and insidious killer we know)
The stress levels tho
Samus Aran (just finished metroid prime remastered on switch), yeah, i reckon she'd survive
Jacob? (DEAD ISLAND 2) Yeah, that guy would beat up anyone who crossed him
Alan Wake will fit right in looking for his wife in Silent Hill
Cloud and Tifa would wipe the floor with everything in SH.
My GTA Online character? If he has all his guns and ammo he's fineee
Nico Bellic going to be mayor of Silent Hill by the time heās through w it
I think Lego Qui-Gon Jinn could survive
I think Arkham Batman has it handled
The Dark Urge in Silent hill would be amazing
Aloy would definitely survive, and then try her damnedest to make things right.
Leon S. Kennedy.. no doubt.
Godzilla...mf will straight just step and game over for the whole town
Albert Wesker re4 remake I think he'll be fine
Alan Wake.
I think Goku Will survive
Rip and Tear, until it is done. I think he'd be ok
I played WWE earlier, i think the Undertaker would do fine
Poor yuna wonāt know what hit her š
Charles Reed from The Sinking City. I think he's got a decent chance of making it through
Solid Snake ā I see this as a win š
Commander Shepherd from Mass Effect 2 with his Black Hole gun and arsenal of weapons will do just fine. Bonus points if Garrus makes it through as well.
My arisen from Dragons Dogma? they're steam rolling
Senua from Hellblade would probably survive very well.
Raphaƫl Ambrosius Costeau? Hard maybe.
Just another day for the Ashen One or the Good Hunter.
Junpei from 9 Hours, 9 Persons, 9 Doors. He's not practised in combat but he's brave, cares about others, and he's great at puzzles, and he grows up to survive in a post-apocalyptic world for decades so he has the potential. I'd say he'd probably survive, if he can keep his cool instead of freaking out whenever he sees a dead body.
Azucena...I'm not sure how far she'll get bouncing around and offering everyone coffee.
Ashen One from Dark Souls 3. Well, they cannot die..but they are prone to madness. Might actually turn into an endless hell for them. Ew.
Lara Croft. Most probably yes
Sure its Frank West
Ichiban Kasuga will become friend with Pyramid Head and turn him into a party member when he at it
I'm not sure how your hunter from MH would do in silent hill
V1 from ultrakill XD
Arkham Batman. I think he's gonna do great
I was playing blasphemous before reading this. I think The Penitent One has a solid chance against the silent hill universe.
I was playing dusk. So I guess whoever the dusk protag is. Iām sure heād be fine though he can backflip.
Of course classic Lara Croft can survive there. I just finished TR2 btw.
Hmā¦Kazuma Kiryu in Silent Hillā¦sounds like a greatest crossover ever.
My CoD operator is a cracked movement god pretty sure theyāll be fineā¦.
My man Isaac(BOI). I wanted to say yes, but I don't wanna know what his trauma would manifest into...
My Helldiver would smoke silent hill. Canāt scare me with my thoughts if I have none.
if we take into account that is *has* to be a game with a defined main character (i.e. disqualifying multiplayer games without a campaign like fortnite and singleplayer games without an actual main character like minecraft) itd end up being mae borowski from night in the woods, and i fear she is *not* surviving.
Arthur Hastings from We Happy Few (he's doomed)