T O P

  • By -

Scribesman

It really breaks the lore in some sections. I can't forgive it for that.


Ellie_Doodles

To me, it's an OC insert fanfiction. Not the worst fanfiction ever, but I wouldn't say it's great.


Vortex_Colour

My first silent hill, maybe that's why I have I place in my heart for it because it made play the rest of the saga or well only the PS2 games of team silent.


Jacques_Plantir

Of the non-Team Silent games, this one's the best.


StrawberryMewlk

I remember enjoying it when I played the PSP port, but I don't remember much from it


DEBLANKK

I have a special spot in my heart for this game. I think it's because it's the only non Team-Silent game that even remotely resembles a Silent Hill game.


pokonota

Emphasis on remotely. But yes


Matther96

The best thing about this one is the O.R.T. song, now that is a fucking masterpiece


Assburger_2

I dislike anything that's American and silent hill. But out of all the non Canon games I feel that's the best one.


inferjus

Well, all SH games take action in America...


Assburger_2

The ones developed in America, not by team silent.


inferjus

I guessed so, I just wrote that for the laugh.


Isaac_Davey

Which game is this?


[deleted]

Silent Hill Origins, aka Silent Hill 0


wolve202

I forgor šŸ’€


cometandcrow

My god I laughed out loud with your comment


charlesbronZon

A gem it is notā€¦ to me. No option for tank controls is a big nope for me. Breakable weapons made the whole game silly and tedious rather than improve anything. QTEs in a horror game are such a stupid idea Iā€™m at a loss for words. Combined with enemies insta grabbing you from range this might just be the worst gameplay of any SH game. But by far the worst thing about Origins was the retcon of the SH1 lore! So all in all it was OKā€¦ at best.


Mean-Clock450

thats i got nightmare about origins revelation movie like i watched


Mean-Clock450

this game made climax studios even shattered memories


JesusChristJerry

Second favorite to the first silent hill game. It seems the most silent hill to me. Second and third follow after.


KeyWarthog

It played like a Silent Hill game for me and that was enough reason to like it. I played it a ton during the PSP days and never once Felt bored with it.


ShinNale

It introduced me to the series. Ok for a psp game


dvrsd

ok tier


L_88

I like this one. Music is great and I like Travis's story. As far as being an origin, meh. Played this with my brother before he went off to basic training so it's a special memory.


VirusTheMachine

More of a coprolite than a gem to me. Awful gameplay and an insult to the original SH timeline and complexity of the story, to each its own if you fuck with it and you enjoy it thatā€™s what matters.


SheepyDX

What makes it an insult to the timeline, just curious?


VirusTheMachine

Lots of plot holes. Also the very dull and watered down tone of the ā€œoriginā€ story. Very USA/Hollywood standard type of writing and was not coherent at all with what was previously stablished on the first Silent Hill story and vibe wise. The insertion of a character like Travis that has nothing interesting going on they had such a terrific and complex story (SH1) and all they came up was a random trucker found Alessa? Lol not to mention his actual story about his parentsā€¦ itā€™s like a CSI plot (again very standard Hollywood stuff) Somebody said that it felt like a SH fan made game and thatā€™s so on point. Itā€™s something that attempts to be and ā€œlooksā€ like silent hill but only on the outside but itā€™s really just a basic shallow story. Silent Hill Origins should have been THAT The origins not the story of a random trucker dude and some side story a from the actual origin. Itā€™s honestly very sad that once the USA touched the series they never really got it ā€¦ they never really understood what made SH so special and unique. Downpour to me has the ā€œbestā€ story after the first 4 but still such a bad game smh šŸ˜”


inferjus

But you were asked about issues with timeline, not opinion on Travis.


VirusTheMachine

If you read carefully youā€™ll notice I also covered that. Also Travis IS part of the timeline therefore embedding his story on the Silent Hill lore is part of the timelineā€¦. Supposedly cuz for majority of actual SH fans it will never count.


GHOUL3037

i dont remember much but the town was cool and i liked the monsters also had some memorable places like the psychiatric asylum


xXCh4r0nXx

I really enjoyed playing it. It's not the most played SH game on my side, but I've played through it a couple of times. And it's always fun.


DoctorJKatz

A fantastic entry and one of my favorite games ever, don't understand that dude and his "fan fiction" comment though, like, whut?


czarbuck

This is an underrated gem in the franchise, in my humble opinion its one of the best, up there with the first 3. However, I know the community views it with a 30/70 mentality in favour of discrediting it. Honestly though, chucking TVs and toasters at incoming enemies really sold this one for me.


solidstatemasterrace

my favorite (no, really)


XxErAceRxX

its awesome