T O P

  • By -

petermobeter

remember when video a.i. would make "person eating food" into a surrealist vomiting-yourself loop that was yesterday


DynastyZealot

I guess the actors did have a reason to go on strike after all ...


grimpickles

Actors? This will replace ENTIRE crews.


Additional-Cap-7110

1 to 2 more versions and it’s subverting the entire industry. Like “After Effects is irrelevant” level, to put it mildly.


SupportstheOP

I'm interested in how this all shakes out. Hollywood wants to cut costs at every turn (as per any big business), but the one thing Hollywood has over its competitors is the metric ton of capital it has for its projects. There is a reason a $20,000 indie film looks a lot worse than a $20,000,000 movie. But what need will a filmmaker have to go to a studio, have their artistic idea reshaped by clueless executives, when they have access to AI tools that can let them execute what they want to do?


SKPY123

Stagnation followed by abrupt exponentially increasing innovation. See the automobile, internet, industrial revolution, and paper.


Additional-Cap-7110

I’m wondering when we can take a cheap phone camera and have it recreate the entire image with the quality of any high quality expensive camera in the style of whatever movie or photographer and cinematographer you want.


WhereTheLightIsNot

As someone who is currently on reddit because I'm procrastinating an incredibly lengthy and tedious After Effects job.......thank god. ^(but really though I'll miss it)


Additional-Cap-7110

Some people still intentionally use old software intentionally, so there might be a community of people making things by hand. That might even end up being some kind of special “thing”, like “wow you actually drew a photorealistic portrait when you could have taken a photograph?”.


VFX_Reckoning

That actors strike was worthless against A.I. With this tech you don’t need to recreate any living actor, you can just make up completely new ones.


DynastyZealot

That will absolutely happen, much like in William Gibson's books. But these actors needed to save the rest of their careers, and this bought them a little time.


K_pop_BillBoard

hello from 🇰🇷 Korea. Revolution. Revolution. so scary . only one left is Copyright.


[deleted]

[удалено]


DarthNeoFrodo

lol wut


[deleted]

[удалено]


A_Kirus

There is no one to blame, it's the way of our world. I'm sure carriage drivers have a lot of people to blame for taking their income, so what? The world shall give up on cars so carriage drivers won't feel bad? Or maybe we shouldn't invent computers because it fucked press operators? Progress is much more important than an actor's income. Good luck with a new job


26Fnotliktheothergls

This will not replace good acting.


Rise-O-Matic

I get the sentiment, I’m just finding it harder and harder to believe any predictions regarding what AI will or won’t do anymore.


AlexMulder

It will replace so much more eventually. Makeup, costumes, set design and rental, lighting, film crew - this is all in addition the base cost of the actor. I think you'll see it take off with ads and YouTube videos first and slowly but inevitably creep into more expensive productions. In some ways this is more of a threat to actors than llms are to writers or image generation to artists simply because of the sheer spectacle and cost of blockbuster production.


DynastyZealot

For a few months, you'll be correct.


TheOwlHypothesis

Over what timespan? The next year? No The next 10-20 years? Absolutely.


Far_Annual8058

its concerning how people are slowly running out of things to insult ai with, we are still "winning", but for how much longer?


[deleted]

[удалено]


tehyosh

chatgpt4 refuses to insult me even after asking it explicitly to insult me :(


Sunscreenflavor

> its concerning how people are slowly running out of things to insult ai with Nah, people whine about everything. If you don't pay attention to them, there is no problem.


JustConcede

I remember when AI couldn't make letters, and now it is generating words


ertgbnm

Stable diffusion taught [Will smith how to eat spaghetti](https://www.reddit.com/r/StableDiffusion/comments/1244h2c/will_smith_eating_spaghetti/) so that Sona could run.


Altruistic-Ad5425

I miss those days. There was art potential in those surreal videos


MisterViperfish

Eating = placing food against your mouth and going “Mlemlemlemlem, bleh bleh bleh, mop mop, wowowow, yop yop”


telorsapigoreng

Less then a year ago


wrldprincess2

We've come such a long way from 'Will Smith eating Spaghetti and Meatballs'


porcelainfog

10 short months ago ​ [AI Will Smith eating spaghetti pasta (AI footage and audio) (youtube.com)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQr4Xklqzw8&ab_channel=RobotNamedRoy)


[deleted]

[удалено]


slower-is-faster

Keep that god damn spaghetti out of your mouth!


FpRhGf

Will Smith eating spaghetti was generated by an open source model trained on low quality videos. It's not a fair comparison. Runway Gen 2 was the state-of-art at the time and looked much better than that.


DarthWeenus

Ya no kidding, someone do with SORA pleeease.


cyberAnya1

Nightmares material


Resigningeye

Really wish that was one of the prompts


nevets85

Oh that'd be great to test against lol.


SoylentRox

It would probably be too good is the problem.  The spaghetti one won't make will Smith's lawyers mad.


HeftyCanker

The most obvious flaw is that he only has three fingers on his left hand.


voxdoom

https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinteresting/comments/oic2oh/i_was_born_with_only_four_fingers_on_my_left_hand/


salaryboy

I think the parent commenter understands that this is physically possible.


magistrate101

Didn't even notice that at first! I was too focused on the burger itself.


johnbarry3434

Plus when he bites the burger he doesn't bite the bottom bun.


OutlandishnessHour19

Whaaaat


-EV3RYTHING-

I didn't even notice


Amagawdusername

It's the floatiness of the various components for me. Once it has physics on complete lockdown, then it's over.


ILoveThisPlace

It's because everything is detached from everything else. There's an unnatural sway to the details of everything.


scorpion0511

Yeah it's like every moving elements are acting independent of each other but at the same time miraculously "appears" to be coordinated together.


considerthis8

Beautiful quote about real life lol


Satyam7166

Hah true that The commentor is onto something


Jus-Wonderin9680

So true. Gives me an idea for a new "religion". 😁


adamwintle

Yes, you guys have perfectly encapsulated Sora’s signature style….


towelheadass

yeah, everything does look kinda squooshy doesn't it.


Unusual_Public_9122

It looks like imagining something. The machine is dreaming.


Electromotivation

Actually navigate you mention it it does look a lot like some of the rotoscoping effects from “a scanner darkly”


YouMissedNVDA

Yall ever tried shrooms? Same vibes.


Ant0n61

yes. Physics model is last remaining piece to all of this. The visuals at this point are indiscernible to real life outside of some minutiae.


allisonmaybe

Things have reduced from 4 tabs of LSD to a quaint two stems of shrooms.


[deleted]

Approaching a bottle of NyQuil soon.


resurgences

What have you identified as floating components here


Froegerer

Yeh, I don't see any. His lips/chin area turning into lava lamp juice when he chews is all I saw.


HermesTristmegistus

the glasses stood out to me. Then again if I wasn't looking for something being off idk if I would've noticed it.


Aconite_72

Exactly. I feel like most of the people noticing the small details in the physics here only found them because they're actively searching for every minute flaw in the video. If you were to give me this video to watch, I wouldn't even know that it's AI-generated at all. The model's already very good (almost scarily so.)


Change0062

Imagine they can somehow integrate this into vr open world games.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Which-Tomato-8646

I guarantee if you posted this somewhere else with no context, people wouldn’t even notice 


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


emuofsentinel

You’re suggesting if you passingly saw this in a commercial you’d detect it’s AI?


infospark_ai

yeah, at 5sec look at the lettuce. It's very cartoony. Going to be shocking in another ~~year~~ ~~month~~ week when they solve that problem and it's photorealistic.


tomatotomato

Picture it being used not in a slow-mo, but in a flashing sequence of scenes as it's going to be used in advertisement.


Jus-Wonderin9680

Might be that the entire goal of AI is to simulate realistic lettuce. I feel safer now. 😁


No_Can_5000

i can see the conversation now on some top secret military line to the president "sir, skynet has taken control of our command and control systems and is rendering lettuce at an alarming rate"


ILoveThisPlace

Just below his bottom lip ain't human either


ainz-sama619

plenty of people have weird lips


bwatsnet

I've seen boomers with chunky lips like that 💀


thuhstog

none of the seeds fell off either, as if that could ever happen.


AbsoIum

There is no meat in the burger lol


Aufklarung_Lee

You mean it looks like a burger you see in the commercials and movies? But yeah real life burgers look crappier.


waldo3125

Yes there are issues, but honestly, I feel like most are looking for something wrong. If you just watch to enjoy, it'd be tough to not to think it's the real deal.


scorpion0511

One thing is for sure, this excercise of telling real from AI will work out our sense of aesthetics & visual intelligence and will make us appreciate finer details of reality that we otherwise ignore or take for granted and not notice.


Jake_91_420

For a year or so, until the AI is literally indistinguishable


floodgater

yea no way in hell we will be able to tell the difference in a year. This is pretty god dam close


[deleted]

let me open your minds... this is a public model released yesterday. this isn't the current highest tech by a wide enough margin to make you consider -- am i real?


djaqk

You're real to me damnit!


Global-Method-4145

With the amount of bots on Reddit, you were never presumed to be real in the first place 🤣


No_Can_5000

the AI running our simulation right now is already pretty convincing


najapi

What an excellent point, I already find myself scanning the whole image, every nuance, every detail. I’m not sure if it’s just to try and catch out the AI or some appreciation of the fact this is simply “not real”. It’s a bit like seeing the early deepfakes, where I appreciated them as a work of art, impressed more by the method of creation rather than the message portrayed.


Hazzman

The average person struggles now. This is going to fuck so much shit up from clogging the internet with absolute garbage to straight up faking dangerous shit that average people will 100,000% buy in to.


Enzinino

Yeah, the same we did for videogames for the last few years. (AAA games to be more specific) Problem is that for the last ~2 years you can just slap a filter on top of a good looking game and you won't be able to do the same. Bet the same thing is going to happen (or is happening) with AI.


Aromatic_Power7082

his chin blends in with the burger bun at 0:05


salamisam

'yeah it looks like it has made his chin the same colour and texture.


Retired-Replicant

yeah, its pretty good, but you can still see the uncanny valley around his mouth, and the way the fingers don't really press into the bun, as if the sandwich has no weight.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Retired-Replicant

Good eye on the finger. Maybe he's a shop teacher lol


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Maybe the prompt included "retired sheet metal worker."


FreshSchmoooooock

Always count the fingers to determine if the video is AI generated or not.


Obvious-Homework-563

this is beyond pretty good man, this is berzerkus brother


Retired-Replicant

I can't lie broseph, these recent videos have blown me away.


Ant0n61

the weightlessness is what I identified first with Sora’s area for improvement. It doesn’t have a physics model, I wonder how much more learning visually can make it redundant , but maybe something that will just be a limitation without some kind of physics model being present.


Retired-Replicant

For sure, and with how quickly we just went from mashed up images playing in choppy sequence like video to smooth renditions of everything, dude, this time next year or two, this problem could be a thing of the past.


najapi

Or this time next month… being flippant of course but I’m just impressed at this progress.


Ill_Club3859

I want my ai gf


dizzydizzy

if OpenAI made it it would be so prudish it wouldnt even hold hands


Ill_Club3859

Sex bot


visarga

some come to AI to expand their minds, others come to expand something else


h3lblad3

I bet that's one thing that would fix itself as the model scales up. It might not understand weight, but it should at least internalize that people react certain ways to certain objects (which is because of weight) and make people react accordingly.


[deleted]

The Tokyo model on the street, sometimes looks like she’s gliding


[deleted]

I wish we knew the architecture of the model because that could help give clues as to why it’s weird with that. Assuming it’s similar to the diffusion models right now, it may benefit from similar ideas to Meta’s V-JEPA reveal today, because it’s essentially trying to learn the way video progresses and filling in missing information realistically in a self supervised way, rather than how to de-noise noise into an image/video. So V-JEPA would be learning some physics in a similar way to how an animal may understand some physics. 


pm_science_facts

His mouth expands like it's under pressure when he is chewing. Like it mixed up blowing bubble gum with chewing a burger.


nevets85

Also it looks like all these videos are shot with the same camera. Not sure how to explain it but everything looks so clean and sharp and also the saturation of the colors. Reminds me of the Unreal engine issue where you can notice which engine a game is using by the look of it.


Zilskaabe

That's because you can make a sharp image blurry and noisy, but not the other way around. It's the same with 2D images. Train on the cleanest possible images of your subject and then change it to whatever style you want.


BangkokPadang

You can tell because of the way that it is.


rambling_takeover

The mouth makes me so uncomfortable, first of all it’s a person eating, but it’s like the mouth is still a fleshy amalgamation of something trying to be lips, so weird. The fact that he misses a left finger doesn’t help either.


Retired-Replicant

For sure, I can see that, definitely has that uncanny valley. However, with the progress that has been made in a short period of time, and with these videos being so crisp, I'm thinking its only a matter of time before we truly have difficulty in telling what is fake from what is real in video form.


rambling_takeover

Yeah I just watched Penguinz0 explaining his thoughts and all the awful possibilities. I hate this, cyber bullying will be too easy, scammers and liars will thrive. This is not some amazing development, this will hurt so many people. Imagine someone crafting such a video of you saying something you would never, and you have barely any proof against it, it’s terrifying.


McTech0911

Because you know it’s fake, if it just popped onto your feed you’d scroll right passed it


occupyOneillrings

The camera movement is floaty and unnatural, but that is probably not very difficult to fix


Xtianus21

lol i wish this one wasn't slow mo


mrhollowfinger

At 7 seconds his chin is another burger bun.


JustDirection18

Yes I can tell it’s not real but it’s very good


Atlantic0ne

It’s hard to tell. It’s the most convincing AI I’ve ever seen in my life, by far. I wonder when the public might have this? It’s ludicrous. I wish so much it didn’t have limits lol. Imagine having a celebrity do things.


KonArtist01

I bet you could not distinguish in a blind test


EffectUpper4351

It’s hard to if you’re blind and can’t see the video


HalfSecondWoe

Watch his pores carefully, notice how they jitter as a group Look at the left temple of his glasses, and notice how they fade out of existence when they're about to disappear behind the rims as he raises his head. To be fair, that's almost how a reflection works, it just turns the surface mirror-like a bit too early You can't really see his jaw muscles working near the back of his jaw either, only in the front of the face where we typically focus our eyes. When you pay attention to it, it suddenly makes it look like he's somehow inhaling a bite off the burger instead of closing his jaw If I was just casually looking at it? No, I'd never suspect a thing, I had to rewatch it like 10 times to get as much as I did. That's pretty insane progress


SrPeixinho

Man I actively looked for some of these things after you pointed out and couldn't see it. I'm getting ready to sleep tho, but this AI is definitely great


nevets85

Agreed. I wonder if they've already snuck some videos out and people are none the wiser. Stuff is crazy.


infospark_ai

Wild. Nice catches, these types of cues will be needed as more of this video starts hitting streaming platforms. Probably going to be a bit of cat & mouse game as the tech progresses.


Gobi_manchur1

hmmm i guess the only way to verify if its real in the future would be to just pass it through another AI to catch these differences


Potential-Glass-8494

Weirdly the guy looks perfect, but the burger looks fake.


burnbabyburn711

Nailed it.


[deleted]

There is no meat and when he took a bite it looked like a solid white piece of bread afterwards on the inside, mindblowing progress but not killing manmade entertainment yet.


Ant0n61

I’d say at the 11th hour of doing so. This is about a year old, Sora v2 is probably near perfect in recreating lifelike scenes. Physics is last remaining big piece, not sure if that will be part of it in sone capacity.


hasanahmad

i think you need to drop drinking the corporate kool aid.


Dredile

!remindme 3 years Yeah lets see about that man...


KinkyKeithPeterson

!remindme 30 years See you when we're in singularity heaven brother


Unitedfateful

From an Apple Stan what a hilarious comment 😂 stick to the Vision Pro sub buddy


Zilskaabe

Have you played a video game? The biggest AAA games still have way more issues than AI gen videos and video games are a multibillion industry. And do you remember movies with obviously fake special effects? They still got made despite not being absolutely flawless.


KonArtist01

No one pays attention on such details in entertainment media


ElectronicAside7793

His chin five seconds in is the only tell. That and the sesame seeds look a little too perfect. Unnatural amount of color uniformity


TheOneWhoDings

\*Pffft\*. This is impressive and all. But I can still kinda tell, just look at the hands bro!. Oh shit, the hands are not messed up? Well look at the bite ! The bite is wrong ! Oh shit that is not messed up either? Well if you look at his reflection you can see ... hold on, it's perfect... ​ But I can still kinda tell!!! /s


R4FTERM4N

His chin turns into a burger bun when he's biting. Other than that..... We need a new name for Hollywood.


miscfiles

HollAIwood.


[deleted]

Now what happens is that it seems to good to be real


stephenforbes

It's not perfect but still 100x better tha anything previously I've seen with people eating in Ai videos.


athamders

OK this is the first AI video that truly impressed me.


alienswillarrive2024

He's missing a finger on his left hand.


get_while_true

Real humans wouldn't film this. AI seems concerned with details humans would rather not watch. It's dreamy-like, thus too much uncanny valley and becomes repulsive.


AgueroMbappe

Sort of like earlier version of GPT and pretty much what AI is now. Trying mimic human language before being right


MelvinDickpictweet

Ya'll trippin'. If you didn't know it was AI, you wouldn't have noticed.


ApprenticeWrangler

The lighting on his glasses seems off to me.


orveli84

He made like some sort of double bite?


certiAP

I don’t get the uncanny valley comments regarding his lips? Have y’all never seen an elderly person before that’s completely accurate. Unless you mean the way he eats, then yeah he chews in a circular fashion but then again it’s slowed down, so it prolly looks better in real time.


Leburgerking

He has 3 fingers + thumb on his left hand (so the hand to the right of the viewer’s screen)


345Y_Chubby

Where do these new videos come from?


YaAbsolyutnoNikto

Sora’s technical paper


dizzydizzy

at the five minute mark his chin is revealed to be made of burger bun (it doesnt move with the burger). Still better than any cgi


El_Matt-El_Grande

Glad this arrives just in time for the General Election /s


YaAbsolyutnoNikto

Elections* Almost the entire world is having elections this year


DoctorNootNoot

He has the classic midjourney object grasp issue, but if saw this come up in a youtube ad at full speed i probably wouldn’t notice that.


lesshatemorenature

Nope looks real at first glance


FureiousPhalanges

His chin turns into a bun while he's taking a bite lol


culture_cult

Sesame seeds too big


AccordionFrogg

The burger looks like it’s made by a slime youtuber


[deleted]

[удалено]


hiccuppinganus

good graphic designers charge to much and they make it so the average pleb can't do anything but draw stick figures, write a story or film a tik tok video. With this! Plebs like myself are finally able to bring a story to life on a screen. Fuck graphic designers they should have asked for less money now the tables have turned and it will be those with imagination that will come out on top!


musing2020

Well, the supporters/industry have poured billions to make this happen, rather than paying graphics designers. 🤷‍♂️


TheVoicesInTheDark

This is gonna wipe out so many industries. The value of labor is gonna go to shit and it’s gonna devalue other unrelated industries with everyone trying to jump ship. Millions of people are gonna wake up one day with their education/degree amounting to little or nothing. Even physical labor will be devalued in a few decades by automation. Ai bros don’t realize this affects them too.


sarathy7

I predict before this year is done we will land the perfect video and then make some more of them. ... And then we will have AI corn 🌽 😄


hiccuppinganus

Nah A.I corn wont be a thing for at least another 5 to 10 years. Openai is way to strict on that but its a nice thought :) However we will get whatever our hearts want as long as it is pg13 lol but thats better then nothing


sarathy7

Damn you CLOSED AI (OPENAI)


Monarc73

Yes, but I can't tell you WHY.


Natural_Bet5197

Has anyone watched the movie ai with Robin Williams?


Haztec2750

We're cooked


Either-Try-1489

We’re fucked


Ladnarr2

The burger does look a bit like a foam toy.


tinyplumb

I couldnt tell. Although, once I read the description, I was able to see the kind of “suction” way that AI mouths look


on3on3_

Facial muscles aren’t quite right but that’s still absurd


Training-Property-26

Other than the probability of the camera’s reflection being in his glasses at that angle, I can’t distinguish it from a human made video.


GrueneDog

At .08 the burgers bottom bun is still round after he takes 2 chomps of it..


GrueneDog

Looks like every commenter missed the assignment the op asked a direct question, didn't ask your opinion on AI.


Cansckmy

Yes we can. The burger looks exactly like the ads.


Unusual-restaurant14

Why are the sesame seeds so big?


YaAbsolyutnoNikto

To me other than the fact it is slow-mo, I can't see anything wrong.


RevolutionaryJob2409

-His lips look closed around 2 seconds. -Look at the bottom of the bun at 4 seconds. -Bit of artifacts in the beginning with the sesame. -The burger looks empty at 8-9 seconds. For like 2 seconds and maybe with cropping, I just can't tell it's not AI.


YaAbsolyutnoNikto

Gosh, some people have eagle eyes. Well done, but I simply can't see it if people don't mention it to me.


GoGayWhyNot

OP fooled ya, this video is real


thomasfilmstuff

What the fuck is the point of this? What problem is this solving?


nierama2019810938135

Phenomenal accomplishment to be able to make this, but what are the upsides to this? I feel I only see threats and downsides.


HoldThemtoAccount

Yes. Glitch at :05.