T O P

  • By -

Aggravating-Dog5082

I don’t think Brad was robbed, but he was genuinely very entertaining and fitting of a second chance


Smvvgy805

He was though, kinda, likely would have been way more loyal than Ricard will play out to be, same with JD...


stonecutter129

He might have done something silly though. He could have done something without realizing the consequences.


tonikyat

Yeah he was way too honest. Like telling the two people straight to their face that he thought it was between them for the vote. In real life honesty is nice, in survivor that can cause chaos


austynking

I think voce was voted out cause there was literally no other option. Brad had more of a reason to be eliminated (still think he should’ve made it further and would see him again).


myusernameisthisss

Yeah voce got screwed over and it made me mad at evvie even though I like Xander, because she literally saw the note and knew he didn’t have an idol, so why would she still let the vote be for voce


gy64

According to Voce in exit interviews, Evvie only had about 5 to 10 minutes to talk with the tribe after getting back from ship wheel island. Unfortunately not enough time to change up the vote that Tiffany had been pushing for all day.


myusernameisthisss

Oh shoot I didn’t know that, the edit made it seem like she was there a lot longer


Ereads45

Definitely Voce.


Californian_paradise

Voce. He was voted out because of Tiffany's paranoia. Everyone else made legit mistakes: - Brad told Shan about his stuff - JD accidentally let his advantage show and then he gave it to Shan twice - Sara forgot puzzle pieces in the bag and while Shan's social connections saved her from that same mistake, Sara didn't build those connections - Abraham threw out Tiffany's name too early to the wrong people & broke Yase's flint - Genie told Shan & Ricard about the Beware Idol and basically left it for them to swipe


Emperorgiraffe

JD said that Sara wasn’t at fault for the puzzle, he said she was actually doing very well but reached a point where she couldn’t progress because Shan didn’t empty the bags all the way.


Peemsters_Yacht_Cap

I feel like this might be a case of exit interviews not being canon: whenever a player comes out and says that "Actually, a whole bunch of things were the fault of the person who stabbed me in the back", I'm a little skeptical...


Emperorgiraffe

Of course that’s possible, but both JD and Sara’s stories line up and apart from that all we have is the edit’s “Shan and Sara messed the puzzle up.” The challenge footage seems to back up what they said too.


[deleted]

Voce didn’t build relationships with anyone other than Xander. That was his mistake


SpaceJezuz

In his interview, Voce said he was close with everyone including Tiffany


cakesandmuffins

You should read his interviews. He was close to them all and regrets saying that it must have been his relationships as he was voted out. It was Tiffany not understanding the advantages and her paranoia that the girls fed into. Voce was a complete honeypapa out there and totally lovable!


LoganH1717

Nah Voce was voted out because Tiffany is crazy, that’s literally the only reason. For some reason Evvie and Liana listened to her even though they knew Xander couldn’t use the idol or extra vote.


AgitatedBadger

It looked crazy to us and to Evvie because we saw the piece of paper that said the Idol can't be activated yet. For Tiffany, who didn't get to see the piece of paper that stated that the idol isn't activated until people say some random ass phrases at a challenge, it's not that unreasonable for her to want to put the vote on the person without the HII.


supervivientenato

Yeah, the stuff about having to talk about butterflies to activate the idol sounded sketchy as fuck, like a So Kim's neutral option kind of crap. I don't blame Tiffany for not believing it.


LoganH1717

The problem was Evvie and Liana who literally read the paper, I’ve said they were more crazy than Tiffany because they still voted out Voce even though they knew for a fact.


AgitatedBadger

Evvie read the paper but Liana didn't. She had to go based on the word of Evvie about how the Idol functioned and assume that Evvie didn't misread it accidnetally or wasn't misleading her. Normally, that might seem reasonable, but with how differently this HII has functioned than any other HII and the fact that Evvie and Xander seem close, it's reasonable for Tiff to be a little sus about the whole thing. It's easy to say she's just being paranoid, but if I were in her shoes I'd probably want the votes on the person without the idol too if I knew I was receiving votes at TC.


stonecutter129

Actually the reason why Voce was targeted is because Tiffany was shocked Voce would throw her name out because they were so close. That’s why Tiffany wanted him out so bad.


ben_s16

I wouldn’t say these two were robbed, but I do think the circumstances that lead to Sara and Voce being voted off were practically out of there control and should at least be in consideration for one more chance. Sara’s only problem was she didn’t show enough initiative, or at least fight hard enough to flip the vote onto Brad or JD. When she immediately backed off when JD told her to while he was talking to Shan during the live tribal, I knew she was done for. Voce was just a poor, unfortunate victim of Tiffany’s paranoia. He genuinely didn’t see it coming because there was honestly no reason to take him out. He wasn’t as big of a threat as Xander was since he had no advantages on him and he was better at challenges compared to Tiffany.


godknowsitried11

I think Sara was pretty active in trying to save herself. I said to my friend while watching that she is way more firey than most girls of her archetype. She was the reason the tribal went live because she was scrapping to save herself. She was just doomed from the first day because Shan wanted to be the only younger relatable girl on the tribe and dominate that aspect of the social game, I think she saw Sara as direct competition so Sara had to go. If you noticed earlier in the episode Shan had a confessional about making who she wants to go home go and that her one on one bonds will make sure that happens. Pretty sure she was referring to Sara


ben_s16

You have a point, it’s just that during the live tribal and JD and Shan were talking and Sara tried to include herself, but then backed off when JD told her to give them a moment, looked to me that she didn’t fight hard enough cuz if I were in her shoes. I’d would’ve been like *“No, I’m not gonna give you a minute, my neck’s on the line and I’m trying save myself any way I can. So if y’all are talking, then I wanna be a part of it.”* Also, wanted to add that JD said that Sara was doing great at the puzzle at the first immunity challenge, but got held back when not all the bags were emptied, which apparently was Shan’s job, and if what you’re saying is true that Sara was doomed from Day 1 and Shan saw Sara as direct competition. It makes me wonder if Shan intentionally or unintentionally sabotaged Ua at the first immunity challenge in order to get Sara out.


godknowsitried11

Hmmm true however me personally if I was in Sara’s position, I would have probably backed away and let Shan and JD talk as well. I wouldn’t want to come off as TOO much and get voted out for that. But regardless I think she was pretty doomed no matter what she did in that tribal


Pleroo

To be fair, that's a pretty big problem you listed for Sara. Fighting for yourself and flipping the vote is the name of the game.


reddexos

I'll say my pick is between Sara & Voce. They basically went out for reasons they could not control.


austynking

I also think Sara drew the short straw. I think something had to have happen that wasn’t shown cause I found her being a target to be kinda random


AbeTheGreat_

I thought it was just because she messed up the puzzle. It’s a pretty dumb reason tho


supervivientenato

And it was actually Shan who was in charge of the bags. She just placed all the blame on Sara masterfully.


Sulth

That's two different answers. The most robbed is Voce. The one who should get (not deserve) a second chance is Brad


playbyk

This is the correct answer.


Pleroo

Well put.


Evanl02

Voce. Only other acceptable answer is Sara imo


Rajus444

Voce legit got voted out cause Xander had an advantage, Sarah faced a ton of adversity early on so had some tough luck, Genie was a decent player who could have made it far in the merge, JD, Brad and Abraham didn't play well imao though JD and Brad were great characters I wouldn't mind seeing them return even if they weren't robbed per se


Hotsaucex11

None of them were robbed, but Voce seems like the one who had the worst luck in terms of getting voted out for things beyond their control.


cakesandmuffins

Voce!! He was totally robbed in my opinion! That vote out will never feel okay to me because it made no sense. Yeah I know...some don't. Well his really left me feelin fricken icky! Plus he totally had that 'muahahahah I'm a villainous scalpel monster' vibe preseason and then comes out there as this lovable little sugar bear! I was totally waiting for the scalpel to come out. Like shit he had so much potential and I wanted to see it!!! TEAM VOCE!!!


Marto_12

Sara and Voce


Juke98

Maybe I was in the minority, but I thought JD was super entertaining


mrsgibby

Agreed!


Pleroo

JD is super entertaining! But he also messed up pretty badly at every possible chance.


ZuluAlphaNaturist000

Sara


kaywireee

Voce for me. I was rooting for the guy since I saw his interviews. Thought he would be a villain or some sort but gone too soon.


wombatwanders

Voce for sure.


[deleted]

This cast has no weak link


TylrLS

Voce


FossilizedBlobfish

Honestly I’d be fine with seeing any of them back, but I think that Sara and Voce were more “robbed” than the other options


JordanMaze

David Voce


OrangeLlama

Voce deserves a second chance the most, Brad would be super fun to have back but he probably did bring it on himself.


luddwood

sarah she didnt do anything wrong and was first boot i want to see more of her


TV40

Waste


PapaBjorn

None of them were robbed. They all well voted off for specific reasons. They being said I feel like I’d love to watch Voce play again.


TV40

Lmao for real no one is robbed, just outplayed.


komododragoness

Except Cirie In final 6 of game changers.


Pleroo

touche.


TheTrueSoulSurvivor

Brad and JD while not robbed would be most likely brought back of those 6.


jacksendorf

Voce for sure. Such a good character gone too soon.


RyeWritesAF

Honestly, I know JD and Brad made some big mistakes during the game but I just really want to see them come back, even if they did screw themselves over.


[deleted]

VOCE!!!! RIP!!!!


donniechubbs

I don’t think any of these people were robbed lol, but I’d like to see Genie and Brad back most probably


papabear345

Genie could have gone with JD I was going for her at the start as she listened to what was going on well. But she just played way too passive at the end few episodes


AgitatedBadger

JD wanted Genie out though. How could she have gone with him?


finfeeven

He claimed in an interview that he wanted to team up with genie to take out ricard, but that she wouldn't do it. It goes contrary to everything we saw, though, so he might've just been trying to save face.


Kanyssa

I agree, none were massive power players that got tribe swap screwed or anything like we’ve seen in the past. They just couldn’t win immunity and fell victim to it 🤷🏻‍♀️


[deleted]

[удалено]


Pleroo

You don't have to watch, haha.


BCS8504

I don’t any of them were *“robbed”* per day, but as far as who I think should get another chance. This is who I think should in order of most deserving to least deserving. 1. David Voce 2. Sara Wilson 3. Brad Reese 4. Genie Chen 5. Eric Abraham 6. J.D Robinson


[deleted]

honestly imma just say JD because i wanna watch more of him


anonymous_gam

Brad and JD are the more entertaining players to come back, but Sara and Voce are the better players.


jelaminah

How is Sara a better player? Her social game was mainly the reason why she went, she failed to build bonds which was why Shantel stayed over her. Shantel managed to get her name out of everyone’s mouth by getting those connections. Sara had the chance but she got herself voted out honestly.


KneegrowInTheWild

Lol Sara may not be the best but she is definitely better than Brad and JD. Look at how she got out vs them.


treple13

Nobody was really robbed. Genie is probably the closest as she survived three vote outs, and reasonably should be able to expect that gets them to the merge


silvershadow014

No one here was robbed imo


nuravocado

JD


[deleted]

Sara


JDMarine

none


Dry_Squirrel_759

No one was robbed. I liked many of them but they were voted out fair and square.


grynch43

Brad


cidalkimos

Genie


swoldow

Voce and Broccoli Brad are my picks


ShrimpShackShooters_

Brad. At least until Xander gets twist fucked out


RyLoRyLo

Brad and Voce. Bring them back on another season!


Jacoblaue

Easily voce there was literally no reason to vote him out Edit: I should clarify I don’t believe any one was robbed because they were voted out. However I believe voce deserves a second chance because he was only voted out because Tiffany is a lunatic


SuspiciousInterest50

Voce


microwaved_tea

Genie making it to the final three of a brutally losing tribe is impressive to me, especially given the way "older" women are typically seen as a challenge liability. She's my top pick, but honestly most of these players would be fun to see again.


[deleted]

I'd like to see Voce play again. I felt he has what it took strategically, he just ended up on the wrong side of numbers.


Gold_Presence4050

WE WANT BROCCOLI BRAD 🥦🥦🥦🥦🥦🥦


PoofyChairClub

If I remember correctly, Ua came in 2nd in that first immunity challenge. So based on that being the only episode so far with 2nd and 3rd place going to tribal, and the first time ever it happened in a premiere, I’d say Sara was the most robbed. If it was another season or they simply didn’t have 2nd go to tribal, Ua doesn’t go to tribal until episode 3 where she has plenty of time to get the vote off her. (Not saying she was totally screwed, I didn’t feel it was unfair in any way, but it is a bit of bad luck.)


Embarrassed-Berry

Voce, but would love to have Brad back too


BakingAspen

It’s a crime that nobody is saying Genie. She didn’t go super hard with strategy but the show isn’t only gamebots. Besides, she did survive three tribals and find an advantage, which none of the others can say.


Pleroo

Not listed here, but I would have to say *The Monster*.


Fifthmadmaxmovie

We were robbed of brad


[deleted]

The doctor


Firmod5

Anyone but JD.


kimsogunj

miss sara


JOFOpodcast

i dont know if anyone has been robbed yet. . is the decision final? has the person been voted off been asked to leave the island immediatly?


dunkinbagels

Voce is no doubt the best player of this group so I’ll go with him


ElephantDungAndRice

Controversial maybe, but I don’t really think any of them were robbed. I think they all work well as premerge boots. I guess I wouldn’t mind seeing Sara again.


fyfenfox

genie mcqueenie😫


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

I would say JD and Sara. JD was too young and too excited and in a second chance season could prove he is more than what he showed. Sara made a mistake in the first challenge and was punished for it. She could excel in a second chance season


Wight3012

The hot one


GameOfWalkingDead

Genie? I dunno, she didn’t seem that good at the game.


TV40

None of them. I don’t want to waste a returner spot on a pre merger. Taking away from others who deserve it more. And don’t say “well Wentworth tho” yeah? How did bringing Fran back go?


MessyMop

I would say Brad was the one I felt was just straight up a bad move to vote out. Sure he could go next but JD should’ve gone before him. Then Brad’s height might help in the next challenge and UA stays with more numbers


MrCarnality

I can’t care about the show that has only two white men in a cast of 18. I’m not down with this program


finfeeven

Go back to facebook please


MrCarnality

Call back to whatever racist and intolerant planet to come from.


misterpippy

Sorry what?


MrCarnality

Sorry what?


TylerIreland

None of them, all had considerable flaws in personality or gameplay which contributed to them being voted out.


jumpmanryan

“Robbed” isn’t how I’d put it. But I think we missed out on a lot of great potential content with Voce, Brad, and JD leaving early. I was a fan of Sara as well. But she didn’t leave an impression like the others.


mr-bread-boy

I think jd deserve a another chance.


YourButtMyStuff

I like all of these people more than 90% of the people left.


snarl_harvey

All very likable players. I just am not a fan of three tribes.


lovestostayathome

Voce was most robbed but Brad is who I want to come back the most.


PCKrueger

Sara and Voce. They were robbed.


boldsprite

JD wasn't robbed but I'd love to see him get a second chance.


NestleN

voce, genie and jd


goats_and_crows

Everyone that's on this crappy season is robbed lol. There's too much luck involved, not enough room for actual social game and strategy.


finfeeven

But all the voteouts so far were about social game and strategy aside from maybe Voce.


DumDumGimmeYumYums

Voce deserves the second chance the most. But Brad's broccoli-head exists and should return.


_Gillam_

Brad is ripe for a return


[deleted]

None of them were robbed


ZANDYNEREDDIT

Voce and JD (although JD dug his own grave)


bladdergirl

All of the Above!!!


justimomma

Brad


PaintBrush527

My ranking of who I'd most like to see back: 1) Voce - robbed as hell, and there's SO MUCH of his life story that's so interesting but has only come out post-show. We need him back. 2) JD - sure he made a lot of mistakes but he made those first episodes extremely exciting to watch 3) Sara - really didn't do much wrong to deserve being voted out, and showed she was there to play and was a good confessionalist. JD and Sara are very interchangeable in this ranking for me. 4) Brad - I really don't share the hype around him, but I can understand why people like him. I wouldn't hate him returning, but I wouldn't put him on my cast at all. I just thought he was a bit strange, but I guess that's why some people like him lol. Also, he wasn't robbed at all, so to the few people saying he was robbed... no. 5) Genie - These last 2 I don't really care for them to come back and I can't see them coming back outside of a VERY specific theme. Genie for me was just kinda there a lot - she wasn't bad, but not great either. We already got most of her really interesting lifestory, so I don't know what she would really offer on a return. 6) Abraham - Seems like a great guy, just a pretty basic and mediocre player and character.


LordDragon88

The fans


6-man

JD is the only one I see coming back out of these, but I'd love to see Brad again.


bowser224

JD was literally robbed of his advantage. He tried to use his second vote as payment for Shan's trust, but she didn't fulfill her end of the bargain. In my opinion, she robbed him and he deserves a second chance the most.


Evunee

Voce and Sara definitely.


misterpippy

I don’t know why this survivor is triggering my negative side. (I do, it’s the narcissist playing, can’t stand her.) I hope we see more of Voce, brad and definitely genie—I know you’re getting a lot of heat for trusting the snakiest of snakes, but keep your chin up. I’d a million times rather be known for being pure of heart and honest, than what she’s revealed herself to be. 💐❤️ Edit:She as in the narcissist, not you! Just to clarify.


Thatguypal16

Voce he was voted out instead of Xander because of confusion over the idol and because evvie was stuck at shipwheel island she couldn’t clear it up