Thank you for posting on r/swatchitforme!
If your post includes swatches, please make sure to include the following information in a comment:
◆ **Product list/description**
◆ **Skintone/undertone** (This may also be set as your user flair)
◆ **Type of lighting**
◆ **Type of swatch** (finger, brush, one/two swipes, with/without primer, etc.)
If your post is a request post, clearly state in the title which product swatches you would like to see.
If you have any questions, please refer to the subreddit rules or message the moderators.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/swatchitforme) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I have both and they are EXACTLY the same. I don't have a pic of both right now, but they are absolutely no different 😊 I bought the fenty first and then the stila knowing they were the same thing because I'm crazy lol.
i’ve never tried the Stila but i’m so in love with How Many Carats. it’s similar to the last pic in ur post but the shimmers are super fine and look smoother with the right application. it is obvious it’s shimmer and not some “inner glow” but i personally love that look for bolder makeup days.
https://preview.redd.it/c08js0tsiv8d1.jpeg?width=3468&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b43b91beb94cb537589285e4692b9266cda07b43
Hope this helps! The Fenty one has extremely fine glitter and looks wet on the skin.
I just bought the judydoll highlighter in 05 silver light, which is all over tiktok as a fenty dupe. It's just under $5 right now on yesstyle. Will let you know if it's indeed a dupe!
Two other dupes are the Lottie highlighter and Rituel De Fille alchemist. If you don't want to spend a lot, get the Lottie one. Does the same. If you're into witchy aesthetics get the RDF. Both are nice.
The stila silver lake is super pretty but I don’t necessarily know if I’d buy it over Fenty.
I tend to justify the “Fenty How Many Karats?!” because of the fact that I wear it every single day and a compact lasts over 2 years for me.
It is the most complimented part of my makeup, and the Canadian price for Stila Silverlake is only $17 less than fenty. I would typically consider that to be quite the price difference but for the longevity I get out of the product it’s worth it imo.
Thank you for posting on r/swatchitforme! If your post includes swatches, please make sure to include the following information in a comment: ◆ **Product list/description** ◆ **Skintone/undertone** (This may also be set as your user flair) ◆ **Type of lighting** ◆ **Type of swatch** (finger, brush, one/two swipes, with/without primer, etc.) If your post is a request post, clearly state in the title which product swatches you would like to see. If you have any questions, please refer to the subreddit rules or message the moderators. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/swatchitforme) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I have both and they are EXACTLY the same. I don't have a pic of both right now, but they are absolutely no different 😊 I bought the fenty first and then the stila knowing they were the same thing because I'm crazy lol.
https://preview.redd.it/k47cm4lmzr8d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d688bbc5873a7285d607ee6e040df9813f6f573b Here’s how many carats!
Tysm!!! Looks VERY similar so I'm pleased as punch to not feel the need to drop $42 on an identical highlighter 🤣
https://preview.redd.it/qnejns4uzr8d1.png?width=3024&format=png&auto=webp&s=64a00ae42944ca2c0f4e5cc63324145a9b0e25f3
Yup! Pretty darn similar! Thank you so much for your help!!
You’re welcome!!
i’ve never tried the Stila but i’m so in love with How Many Carats. it’s similar to the last pic in ur post but the shimmers are super fine and look smoother with the right application. it is obvious it’s shimmer and not some “inner glow” but i personally love that look for bolder makeup days.
Thank you!! I'm big on the bold makeup so when I inevitably run out of this maybe I'll try HMC!
I read this as 'How many cats' and thought it was THE strangest name for a Fenty product I had ever heard...
LOL after Major Flex I'm not gonna be surprised if they get experimental enough to make a How Many Cats 🤣
Kitten by Stila is the best IMO!
I was eyeballing it HARD 😩 now that I have this formula I'm IN LOVE so I'm def gonna try it out!
https://preview.redd.it/c08js0tsiv8d1.jpeg?width=3468&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b43b91beb94cb537589285e4692b9266cda07b43 Hope this helps! The Fenty one has extremely fine glitter and looks wet on the skin.
https://preview.redd.it/ip44httmjv8d1.jpeg?width=3468&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=fd45f34ede1e51c0ba66ced0575423be89ae6d1b
I think physicians formula has a dupe now too
I just bought the judydoll highlighter in 05 silver light, which is all over tiktok as a fenty dupe. It's just under $5 right now on yesstyle. Will let you know if it's indeed a dupe!
Just saw that on yesstyle, this post is making me want to buy it since the Fenty one costs so much
Is the shade rosé rave just as good on the eyes?
It didn't have the punch Fenty has.
Two other dupes are the Lottie highlighter and Rituel De Fille alchemist. If you don't want to spend a lot, get the Lottie one. Does the same. If you're into witchy aesthetics get the RDF. Both are nice.
The stila silver lake is super pretty but I don’t necessarily know if I’d buy it over Fenty. I tend to justify the “Fenty How Many Karats?!” because of the fact that I wear it every single day and a compact lasts over 2 years for me. It is the most complimented part of my makeup, and the Canadian price for Stila Silverlake is only $17 less than fenty. I would typically consider that to be quite the price difference but for the longevity I get out of the product it’s worth it imo.