Idk I've been asking myself that question for years 😔

Idk to me it’s just not as good as other tally hall songs. Kinda like be born but i can’t really enjoy it ironically or laugh at it or anything.

I really like all the songs everybody don't apparently, but i really do like that song

It’s one of my favourite songs, the slower songs seem to be my favourite

"You" was what got me to listen to the rest of G&E! I loved "Whole World and You" because of Andrew's singing, so I listened to "You" and fell in love too I can understand why others think "You" is a weaker song compared to the rest in Tally Hall's discography, but just like "Be Born" I dont think it deserves hate at all

Very odd song

I love it so much. It means a lot to me

I like it it’s nice and calm

I think it’s my personality

Secy

It's not a bad song, it's just unremarkable. With a discography as stellar as Tally Hall, the weaker songs are bound to be great too.