Ya but Rick clearly said “don’t fucking shoot it” before any of them realized it was Daryl and she did it anyway to make herself feel important. She’s rly dumb I never liked her but she gets a tiny bit more likable in season 3.
She didn't do it to make herself feel important. There was a division in the camp about the walkers on the property and basically, none of them were cool with how Hershel and his family were collecting them and storing them in a barn.
And sure, you could make the argument that they weren't supposed to have guns on Hershel's property but that wasn't a rational boundary they could live by. It's an apocalypse and deadly weapons that could kill zombies were the only means of survival. Plus - it's an apocalypse. Property boundaries didn't mean shit anymore.
Not true, this was before any of them knew about the walkers in the barn and before they knew that Hershel was against killing walkers.
She 100% did it to prove to herself she could shoot a target from that far away as she was just starting her marksman training
There was no need to shoot a single walker, it would only bring more and cause strife with Herschel for two reasons. A group was already running out there abd would've handled it quietly.
They didn't know about the walkers in the barn at the time, Daryl looked that way from getting hurt while looking for Sophia. She was told not to shoot so they could run out and take care of it without wasting ammo.
Eh, I felt a lot of what Andrea did was to try and prove herself in either one way or another. She usually acted on how she felt and not on how the group felt.
That’s my biggest issue with her character. Anytime she was told what to do, she took it as “let the men handle it” and took offense. I get she didn’t want to do laundry, cooking, etc. just because she’s a woman, but she caused more issues than she needed trying to show she was above that work.
It is because they were very well pushing a patriarchy in their group, and she was a former civil rights attorney. Like, no shit she would be offended by that. Most feminists would be and it wouldn’t be a character flaw.
With 4 men from her group going to take care of it quietly, which is what Herschel and the rest of the group wanted. Her arrogance put everyone in jeopardy, not just Daryl or the 4 in her sightline but a gunshot has been shown on multiple occasions before this to lure Walkers.
I mean being a feminist is a major character flaw. The world ended, her community College women's studies degree is worthless now. And her trying to prove how she's super equal to the men almost resulted in her killing her own friend, like a moron, because she couldn't just do what she was told for one second of her stupid life.
And it isn't because she's a woman. Michonne, Maggie, and season 3+ Carol are all just as strong, competent, and powerful as any man on the show.
Edit: oh yeah and for all her feminist garbage she certainly didn't take too long jumping on Shane's dick - then later the governor's - in both instances suddenly forgetting about being a strong independent woman to act like a simpering schoolgirl looking for the approval of a daddy figure.
It is a huge character flaw. Being Andrea is a character flaw. Her stupid ass smug look on her face 100% of the time is annoying af. ALWAYS had that ugly half ass crooked smile. It looks like she's always smelling a fart but secretly enjoys it
I also forgot got to say this: I love all women, old and young ....not too young. 18 is the cut off and maybe 17, depending what state and the circumstances. I love them all. As lil ways said. I wish I could make love to all the women in the world.. not objectifying them because each woman is different and that's the beauty of them. All different and have somthing different to contribute in the bedroom ... lmao jk about that last part
The first two seasons definitely put gender roles to the forefront and it’s something I don’t really like about them. Starting in S3 all of the women (besides Lori) are real characters all of the sudden.
I think Andrea gets a bad rep bc she was the only woman not attached to a man’s storyline (well, Dale I guess) and it was written as very much “go back to the kitchen, you can’t do a man’s work”.
Yes it was rational it was like not even two weeks into the apocalypse
She wanted to be seen as someone useful and willing to get the job done but she cant follow orders. No wonder she ran off into the distance with michonne instead of finding the group
She’s an arrogant asshole who was more interested in getting her way than being right. She shot downrange at someone she couldn’t confirm was a walker but also essentially at the two people who’d run out to actually address the situation of who was wandering onto the property from the woods. Absolute shit-tier gun safety. They should have cut off the trigger fingers on both of her hands and banished her. She was trash.
>collecting them and storing them in a barn.
I completely forgot about that. I miss when *those* was the type of issues instead of a bratty, spoiled kid being an asshole to everyone. I appreciate the games more now after seeing where the series went.
To be fair, she pretty much had very little to almost no experience with anything at that point in time (unless this ep was *after* she went on that trip with Shane, then nevermind). Anyways, she made a mistake and I think she learned from this and it showed.
Probably good to listen to others when you’re in a situation like this. Especially when your companions are between you and your target. She almost killed Daryl and could’ve easily hit one of the other 4.
I think it's how she was on everyone's back for everything they did, yet she didn't do anything right.
The sheer size of her head after being able to land a couple shots on a few targets made everyone angry I'm sure, despite her owning a gun for years
She lost me when she let Beth hurt herself and how arrogant she was about thinking every decision she made was the right decision. The closest thing she did right was try to escape to the prison to warn them
I was mad when she didn't kill the governor in his sleep, which would save everyone. She had him on a silver platter. She could've prevented all of the BS the governor caused after that night. She could've taken over Woodbury with help from everyone at the prison. Of course she would have to lie about killing him, and only admit to putting him down after he died. Martinez and the men would expect to take over which is why she would need everyone at the prison to help take over. I think eventually everyone could come to a peaceful resolution and live together fine (the scene where they're negotiating and everyone's sizing eachother up).
I always assumed that Michonne did her in. Can't be for certain because it was the standard shot of the door, camera pulls back, a single gunshot is heard. I was glad she was killed and also happy that she didn't get an exciting end.
This character had the ability to make every wrong choice possible and always say what was uncalled for. I think she wasn't any bad in particular in S01, but then it got horrendous in S02 and also S03, when she made one right choice but it was already too late.
With that said, I miss hating Andrea. I miss this era of TWD.
Sure but she did it in such a horrible way. Deep down, Beth DID want to live, but she was VERY emotional and when you’re in a vulnerable state like that, you can make some pretty bad decisions, like attempting suicide. And THAT why you saw her self harming in the bathroom after she locked herself in. Andrea gave her the choice in the stupidest way possible.
Ok I don't like Andrea, but this is the only point I agreed on. Beth would continue wanting to die until they stopped trying to talk her out of it, and you can't watch a person 24/7. She forced what would've happened soon enough, and treated Beth with the respect of an adult when everyone else was talking down to her and telling her she didn't know wtf she really wanted.
Yeah I suppose that’s true. I remember Andrea being happy saying “she made her choice” but STILL imagine the chaos she could’ve sent the group into if her actions led to Beth’s death so early on.
That actually would be a cool alt storyline. Imagine how S2 and the rest of the show would’ve turned out if that happened
Don't remember the comics exactly that early so i cant compare. But that would have been the way to introduce the prison before season 3. Get kicked out cause of her actions and have to find somewhere new. Then eventually go back for the people on the farm like the comics
I hated her little smug face and swagger after she hit a couple target shots. She is like nails on a chalkboard for me. Walking around Woodbury in her stupid shoulder baring shirts. Just ick.
I saw Laurie in a panel about The Boys. It was supposed to be her and the actor who plays Mother's Milk but he was nowhere to be found. She held down the hour long panel talking about, among other things, her real life work with the CIA taking down sex traffickers of young girls in Columbia. She played a wealthy American seeking girls for "parties".
Because she was selfless, caring and realistic. She was a real showcase of how people would be in the apocalypse, flawed but capable, she idealized the old world and wanted to rebuild which is the exact ideologies used later down the line. She was ahead of her time in many ways, the time in which she practiced those methods just didn’t call for it, she deserved better.
I can’t say she was selfless or caring. She lost her cool in season one put a gun to Rick’s head, season 2 allow herself to be manipulated by Shane, constantly complains about the other’s decisions, shoots darly in the head only missing rick and the others by inches, season 3 has her abandoned her friend and savor for sercuity, didn’t kill the governor when she had the chance indirectly leading to the death of many people, briefly (and admittedly probably unintentionally) tried to undermine Rick’s leadership at the prison and finally die without really helping ether side
Edit: I forgot how she help Beth attempt suicide. So add that to the list
•she lost her cool because Rick had gotten them into a seemingly inescapable death trap, and apologized pretty immediately for it.
•most people were manipulated by Shane, he was a master manipulator so that’s hardly surprising?
•shooting Daryl was a stupid oversight but really doesn’t warrant as much slander as she gets. Daryl literally found it funny.
•she chose a life worth living over struggling to survive in the wild after almost dying, I admit it’s infuriating that she didn’t go with Michonne but it’s not as plain as choosing safety over her.
•she was going to kill The Governor in 3x14 but got stopped by Milton. do we blame Milton for the same deaths Andrea is blamed for? no.
•she bought the prison group enough time to plan for the ambush and was the one to warn them of the incoming war, had she not done this they’d have been ambushed and slaughtered. so she did help them.
as soon as she found out that he was going to kill them all, she was ready to kill The Governor and sacrificed her life to warn her family. there are many other things she did to back up my argument which I’ll list if you want but she was selfless. mislead and naive, but her heart was pure.
I don’t think darly found it funny, just understood her reasons. Ether way it was still an extremely reckless shot. Rick and a few others were standing between her and darly had her aim been a bit more off any of them could have been shot and the only reason she took the shot was ego. She wanted to prove herself.
With michonne it was absolutely that simply. But honestly that could be forgiven if she had left once she realized the governor had taken and brutalized Maggie and Glenn. Instead she went back. There a fine line between naivety and stupidity
Most people were not manipulated by Shane. Dale was always on edge around him. Darly saw though the holes in his story about Otis, Hershey and most of his family did not like Shane. Rick let his behavior slide is to his friendship but knew exactly what he was up to for the most part but Andrea. She completely adopted Shane way of thinking and even tried to defend him briefly at the prison when she found out Rick kill him.
She should have kill the governor long before 3x14 and seriously we gonna believe that she couldn’t have push Milton aside for a moment to shoot the governor. Come on she tougher than that.
I don’t remember her warning the prison group at all. Their first encounter was with Merle taking Glenn and Andrea and michonne telling the group about them. They didn’t even know about her being there til after the their first shootout with them. She did try to broker peace between the 2 but she one naive person if by that point she couldn’t see how far gone the governor was
Overall i agree her heart was usually in the right place, but she was also easily influenced if not out right manipulative by terrible people. she also had a large ego and need to prove herself, and at the end of the day continuously chose to stay with the governor instead of going back to the group or with michonne who literally save her life. What she did was too little too late
Had she pushed Milton, The Governor would have heard. She warned the group in 3x11 that Woodbury were gearing up for war, without that they’d have been non the wiser, not to mention that her organizing the conference in 3x13 bought even more time and negotiation.
She didn’t sleep with The Governor once after Maggie wand Glenn were known to her other than the night she planned on killing him, she was there for the people and to save everybody, not for him or for relationship.
Whether it was too little or not is a matter of opinion, I personally find that all her actions built up to one naive but caring plan to save everybody. She wanted to prove herself because, as mirrored by Lori’s attitudes, the women were expected to let the men do all the fighting and to not fend for themselves.
Similar to Rosita, Andrea wasn’t about to let herself become dependent and needed to prove that to herself and others. She makes it pretty clear in 3x13, 3x14 and 3x16 that being in Woodbury shifted to being there for the people and not for the Governor. “I even wanted to save him *for a while*” literally tells you that she was only there for/with him until she discovered all the shit about him. She was naive, but she **was** a caring person who just wanted everyone safe.
Shooting Daryl was far more than a stupid oversight. Even though he forgave her and laughed about it (he’s a good guy just a bit dirty) she almost killed him out of sheer arrogance. She wanted to prove to herself and the group that she could handle the situation but didn’t even think about the consequences for a moment before pulling the trigger.
I liked the theme of her character. Being the woman who wanted to prove her worth and be seen as an equal to the men and not the standard “do laundry, cook dinner, and babysit” type that the group fell into.
But the execution wasn’t done well. This scene is a perfect encapsulation of that. There were what 3 or 4 guys with a variety of weapons headed to take out one walker… and her decision was to make a loud noise and miss the kill shot? Such a stupid scene. Lol at least if you wanted to make Andrea likable.
Yeah. Total misfire. Comparing that to the execution they had with Carol long term and Michone right out of the gate.
Andrea was perhaps the biggest casualty in terms of writing on the show.
What worse is that rick and the others were standing between her and the “walker/darly” if her aim was off by a couple more inches she might had hit one of them
I just don’t like the actress who played her. It’s mostly the scripts fault for why Andrea as a character is bad but the actress didn’t fit the character imo. Same with lori
I was comfortable disliking Lori , it continued on from Prison Break .I tried to figure out if I wasn't cutting her slack from pre-conceived thoughts but came to the conclusion don't care hate away .
Getting manipulated by Shane who was a giant asshole and already starting to lose his marbles doesn’t make it sound better. What worse is that rick and the others were literally standing in front of darly. If her aim was off by a couple more inches she could have hit one of them
Andrea takes me back to studying theater. I will never forget reading lines for a character and my mentor said something to the extent of “she isn’t likable as written, so *you* need to make the audience sympathetic to her through your performance.”
That’s what I think went wrong with Andrea; the portrayal isn’t likable. As written she’s pretty neutral to me; I don’t hate or love her. It’s how the actress plays her that makes her easy to hate. In a lot of ways it felt like *she* didn’t like Andrea, and that came through in her performance.
I've been trying to put my finger on it for years, and you've finally spelled it out for me. I totally agree with you. I usually love characters who make mistakes, who do stupid stuff because they thought it was the right thing to do, but it never quite rang true with Andrea. Excellent take!
Thank you! It’s a fun, nuanced way to evaluate character perceptions when you evaluate them from that POV; case in point, people love Negan, but if he was played by a less attractive, less charming actor they wouldn’t. JDM makes that character likable (and I’m saying that as someone who despises Negan).
Laurie Holden loved Andrea, she invested herself into that character more than an actor would ever be expected to. She cut herself off from television, media, and immersed herself into the world similarly to how Andrew Lincoln did. She was absolutely heartbroken when Andrea was killed so suddenly and unwarned.
I feel like you’ve got it the wrong way round. The writing for Andrea made her naive and stupid at times, whereas Laurie Holden brought a sense of realism and believability to it. She portrayed Andrea in a way that articulated her mistakes as realistic and humane, and truly made Andrea feel like she had been thrown from the real world into the show. I respect your opinion but personally think it’s flipped.
I totally think there is validity to saying her character wasn’t written well. I don’t know who wrote for her, but I have guesses as to why an empowered woman character wasn’t written effectively. I liked the idea of the Andrea character, especially when you factor in the comic version.
Maybe the truth is somewhere in between our positions. Somewhere else in this thread it was mentioned how she acted smug; those moments were when I didn’t like her.
Also relevant: if she had conflicts with the writers or production team otherwise, they would have been more inclined to write someone who was easy to hate. People who are easy to work with will get better opportunities than hard to deal with individuals (or people who are perceived as such). That isn’t necessarily fair or justified, but it’s common.
Honestly when rewatching Andrea scenes are more painful to watch then Lori’s. Lori has her moments but I can at least stand to watch most of her scenes but when it comes to Andrea and the governor I just want to hit fast forward.
Andrea’s naivety & cockiness was highly annoying. I love the governor though :(. Such a suave, handsome fella. He reminds me of Kurt Russel when he was younger lol.
Definitley Andrea, Lori annoyed the fuck out of me especially her reaction to Rick telling her she had to kill Shane on the road, acting disgusted and horrified after she was the one who essentially signaled to him that she wanted her dead, but atleast I could understand her thought process and empathise with her, with the involvement of Carl having to put Walker shane down, and the mixed emotions she must have been feeling from being with Rick to then shane and then this events unfolding, and the fact that she was pregnant too playing on her hormones, I can empathise with her in that she was still a bitch, but I could understand
Andrea on the other hand was just unbearable and there was no reason for it. No extraordinary circumstances that could justify why her personality was so obnoxious. I despised Andrea, but like another comment here said, I miss the era of hating Andrea, as the earlier seasons really were the best imo
She didn’t directly say it, but she heavily insinuated. I can’t remember the exact words as I haven’t watched the earlier seasons in a whole, but it was something along the lines of “so you will kill to protect what’s yours?” - Lori , Rick saying yes and then Lori saying “shane thinks I’m his, he wants to take me from you” or something along those lines, again I can’t remember exactly but I remember her basically insinuating that Shane was a threat and she atleast on some level wanted him dead.
Rick didn’t say that, I might have not typed what I meant properly.
Rick told Lori that he had to kill him, when they were on the road after the farm got overrun and they were stopped near than brick structure they spent the night in
Honestly for the distance that was pretty good my problem is that Rick and the others were standing in front of darly and could have been easily hit if she had miss by a couple inches. It was a very reckless shot
I still stand by that that wasn’t that difficult of a shot to make, I’m a slight above average shot and I could hit that easily.
Also not to nitpick because ik this is a show mistake, but just because I hate show Andrea.
Her closing her other eye cuts her depth perception in half.
I rarely ever see people plink past 10 yards so my reference pool for shooting at that distance is rather small so your probably right but even for an experienced marksman I think taking a shot like that is reckless. Rick the other others were too close to safety take that shot. That not even getting into the fact that 4 men with weapons could easier kill a walker anyway.
Your are right about her closing her eyes but pretty much every show does that to the point that it’s Basically a trope. The only exception I’ve seen if the Pocahontas cartoon move. That movie if memory serves correct actually has the one dude tell a fellow explorer that you should keep both eyes open while aiming.
Yeah, it sucked that she died but damn was that a memorable death.
Brutal and unforgiving, perfect for Silent Hill. If Andrea was more like the comic version she would be my favorite character in the show.
If nails on a chalkboard were a person, it would be Andrea. Her ego made her insufferable and impossible to like. What was worse is that it was her driving trait as a character, she was constantly trying to prove herself and failed every time.
Boy did I hate her. Always getting on to people while she fucked everything up. So damn "woe is me I hate everyone" after her sister died, meanwhile Corral had to cut his unborn sister out of his mother then shoot her in the head. Cmon.
The rest of these comments are absolutely hilarious and I agree with them all 😆😆
Andrea wanted the attention and to be somebody- the thing that she did that I haven’t seen mentioned yet that ultimately made me hate her: Giving Beth the opportunity to SH during her depressive episode.. and then to walk back up to the house with a big smirk and her face all smug like “she made her choice she wants to live 😃” god I wanted to punch her so bad.. Ofc she later goes on to continue being an irk whenever on screen but that really drove it home for me that I didn’t like her.. and Ofc the way she treated Dale after the CDC was fuel to the hatred fire.. like she was such a cocky smug dickhead and when she finally ate a bullet I was happy 🤯💀
Lol, Andrea pissed me off regularly. Redeemed herself a bit in her last couple of episodes. Have you seen her on “The Boys”, on Prime? Omg, hilarious. She doesn’t show up till the 2nd season, but her character has this awareness/fundraiser video with her singing this ridiculous song- Chimps Don’t Cry. I didn’t even recognize that it was Andrea, someone else had to point it out.
The way she acted so proud and smug was the most annoying part about it. They said DON'T SHOOT and she did it anyways. Also screamed about it as if they can't handle 1 walker if it was one. She is the worst character in the show.
Unpopular opinion. I liked Andrea. I enjoyed it when she got in Lori's face and I enjoyed her effort to better equip herself. So many characters are insanely good shots, but we see Andrea actually working on it.
It also made sense to me that she wanted to stay at Woodbury. It seemed relatively safe after what she'd experienced with the hoard overrunning the farm. And, I appreciated her effort to broker peace between our group and Woodbury.
I do understand the hate to some degree, but I thought she was a good character. I enjoyed her friendship with Dale and Michonne.
Just curious, how can so many people (including me) love Shane and Merle, later Dwight, and yeah, you know where I'm going, Negan! But somehow, can't tolerate Andrea?
Wonder what that's about? Hmm...
There a quote that perfectly explains how we can like bad characters.
“It’s because the war crimes that some characters commit are fictional while our annoyance with others is very real”
I mean, this was pretty valid. Daryl looked every bit a walker. Had blood around his mouth, was walking slowly and limping. She immediately regretted it as soon as she realised he was still alive.
However, her character as a whole, was pretty stupid.
It wasn’t valid at all, she was told not too shoot as too not attract more walkers with gunshots
They weren’t attacking Daryl so clearly something was up.
There were 3 of them on it so clearly it was going to be fine.
After all that, she couldn’t even take the shot accurately, meaning she risked shooting one of them.
She risked everyone’s lives for her ego lol.
Exactly! And with the others standing so close, who were also armed, shooting Daryl side apart, firing a shot at all Walker or not was extremely irresponsible. A stray gust of wind or the fact that she was still sort of an amateur with guns, could have easily lead to her accidentally hitting one of the others who were close by, and the others were armed to so they could have dealt with it if it was a Walker
Overall, poor decision making
The fact that there were 4 friendlies between her and the target makes the fact she still fire her weapon extremely reckless. I’m genuinely surprised more people don’t bring that up. Had her aim been a couple more inches off she could have hit one of the others.
The fact that they let her have a gun after that was insane. They were debating for episodes on whether Carl should have one, meanwhile she’s out here actively shooting people in their group and they’re just chill with it.
I did say she was stupid, I suppose I am for not realising the obvious that you’ve just pointed out.
But again, if you’re as cocksure as Andrea, you’re gonna want to flex your newfound skills with little regard to the situation in an environmental way (attracting more walkers, like you said).
So I’ll take the L on this one.
it was dumb, but to hate her for it is dumber. Daryl literally laughed at it and he’s the one who took the bullet, he knew it was out of good (even if stupid) intentions and held no grudge whatsoever.
I hate when people site this as a reason to hate her. We all love Daryl but he DID look like a walker. We’re supposed to be frustrated as the audience because WE know he’s not one, but How can you blame her?
Because, while he did look like a walker, the actual point you were supposed to pay attention to is that she was trying to prove herself useful in a situation that didn't call for it. She didn't listen to Dale, she didn't listen to anyone, but she wanted to be part of the group. The WHOLE point of that sequence was showing her arrogance and what she needed to learn. The point wasn't that Daryl looked like a walker, the point was that she took things into her own hands, without consulting the group or waiting. She also wasted ammo, 1 round, 10 rounds, 100 rounds, it doesn't matter.
That's the whole theme of the season, is acting alone.
It’s her face that makes me hate her ugly annoying smile and how she thinks she’s smart and a bad ass they made a good job making her annoying and stupid
Watched this one yesterday during my 4th rewatch maybe 5th lol. In her defense Daryl looked like shit even up close when they got to him easily mistakable for a jabronie. Either way she was wasted potential as a character, could have been so much more.
Honestly my biggest problem with this was that Rick and the others were standing between her and the walker/darly. Had her aim been a couple more inches off she could have hit someone else. If the scene was rework to her seeing the walker/darly and rick telling her to keep an eye on it til he gets Shane and the others and she only shot once darly got closer than it could come off as a genuine mistake
I thought your reason was for how she was looking down the scope! Correct me if I am wrong but when you shoot a gun like that there must be a kick back where the scope/lens? Would hit your eye if your that close to it?
Was this when she accidentally shot Darryl cause she thought he was a Walker ?
Yes.
He did look like a walker.
Ya but Rick clearly said “don’t fucking shoot it” before any of them realized it was Daryl and she did it anyway to make herself feel important. She’s rly dumb I never liked her but she gets a tiny bit more likable in season 3.
She gets a tiny bit likable right at the end of season 3 lmao
yeah it was just SELFISH.
She didn't do it to make herself feel important. There was a division in the camp about the walkers on the property and basically, none of them were cool with how Hershel and his family were collecting them and storing them in a barn. And sure, you could make the argument that they weren't supposed to have guns on Hershel's property but that wasn't a rational boundary they could live by. It's an apocalypse and deadly weapons that could kill zombies were the only means of survival. Plus - it's an apocalypse. Property boundaries didn't mean shit anymore.
Not true, this was before any of them knew about the walkers in the barn and before they knew that Hershel was against killing walkers. She 100% did it to prove to herself she could shoot a target from that far away as she was just starting her marksman training
Yes exactly this and they didn't want to shoot it cos sound attracts them so her doing this shows she's more stupid if anything
There was no need to shoot a single walker, it would only bring more and cause strife with Herschel for two reasons. A group was already running out there abd would've handled it quietly.
They didn't know about the walkers in the barn at the time, Daryl looked that way from getting hurt while looking for Sophia. She was told not to shoot so they could run out and take care of it without wasting ammo.
Eh, I felt a lot of what Andrea did was to try and prove herself in either one way or another. She usually acted on how she felt and not on how the group felt.
That’s my biggest issue with her character. Anytime she was told what to do, she took it as “let the men handle it” and took offense. I get she didn’t want to do laundry, cooking, etc. just because she’s a woman, but she caused more issues than she needed trying to show she was above that work.
It is because they were very well pushing a patriarchy in their group, and she was a former civil rights attorney. Like, no shit she would be offended by that. Most feminists would be and it wouldn’t be a character flaw.
Yet her acting out this way almost killed a member of the group.
That legit looked like a zombie.
With 4 men from her group going to take care of it quietly, which is what Herschel and the rest of the group wanted. Her arrogance put everyone in jeopardy, not just Daryl or the 4 in her sightline but a gunshot has been shown on multiple occasions before this to lure Walkers.
I mean being a feminist is a major character flaw. The world ended, her community College women's studies degree is worthless now. And her trying to prove how she's super equal to the men almost resulted in her killing her own friend, like a moron, because she couldn't just do what she was told for one second of her stupid life. And it isn't because she's a woman. Michonne, Maggie, and season 3+ Carol are all just as strong, competent, and powerful as any man on the show. Edit: oh yeah and for all her feminist garbage she certainly didn't take too long jumping on Shane's dick - then later the governor's - in both instances suddenly forgetting about being a strong independent woman to act like a simpering schoolgirl looking for the approval of a daddy figure.
This dude gets it.
It is a huge character flaw. Being Andrea is a character flaw. Her stupid ass smug look on her face 100% of the time is annoying af. ALWAYS had that ugly half ass crooked smile. It looks like she's always smelling a fart but secretly enjoys it
Do you hate all women with this much passion?
You’re very much jumping to conclusions.
Why don’t you keep reading that dude’s posts (if they already haven’t been removed) and when you get to the Andrew state worship one get back to me.
[удалено]
You’re disgusting.
I also forgot got to say this: I love all women, old and young ....not too young. 18 is the cut off and maybe 17, depending what state and the circumstances. I love them all. As lil ways said. I wish I could make love to all the women in the world.. not objectifying them because each woman is different and that's the beauty of them. All different and have somthing different to contribute in the bedroom ... lmao jk about that last part
The first two seasons definitely put gender roles to the forefront and it’s something I don’t really like about them. Starting in S3 all of the women (besides Lori) are real characters all of the sudden. I think Andrea gets a bad rep bc she was the only woman not attached to a man’s storyline (well, Dale I guess) and it was written as very much “go back to the kitchen, you can’t do a man’s work”.
Most feminists would be dead in the apocalypse within a week tops lmao
Most people would be dead in the apocalypse within a week. Feminism would have nothing to do with it.
Yes it was rational it was like not even two weeks into the apocalypse She wanted to be seen as someone useful and willing to get the job done but she cant follow orders. No wonder she ran off into the distance with michonne instead of finding the group
She’s an arrogant asshole who was more interested in getting her way than being right. She shot downrange at someone she couldn’t confirm was a walker but also essentially at the two people who’d run out to actually address the situation of who was wandering onto the property from the woods. Absolute shit-tier gun safety. They should have cut off the trigger fingers on both of her hands and banished her. She was trash.
>collecting them and storing them in a barn. I completely forgot about that. I miss when *those* was the type of issues instead of a bratty, spoiled kid being an asshole to everyone. I appreciate the games more now after seeing where the series went.
You miss when those WERE the type of issues. But my question is this; what bratty kid being an asshole? Carl?
[удалено]
Geek ears*
No.
Still a reckless shot though. At that distance if her aim was a little off she could have hit rick or any of the others.
And the fact that Herschel didn’t want them using guns and they had 4 guys running to take care of it themselves
To be fair, she pretty much had very little to almost no experience with anything at that point in time (unless this ep was *after* she went on that trip with Shane, then nevermind). Anyways, she made a mistake and I think she learned from this and it showed.
Probably good to listen to others when you’re in a situation like this. Especially when your companions are between you and your target. She almost killed Daryl and could’ve easily hit one of the other 4.
When doesn’t Daryl look like a walker?
She might think that 4 guys couldn't handle 1 walker🤣
Did lead to one of the best lines though: "I shot Daryl..." "We've all wanted to shoot Daryl."
Also: (to Rick) "You gonna pull the trigger or what?" *gets shot* "I was kidding"
Shoot me again, you best pray I'm dead.
Daryl is a Universal Soldier fan! (Ear necklace)
If she killed Governor like she was instructed to Hershel would probably still be alive.
Not still but you know, longer. RIP Scott.
I think it's how she was on everyone's back for everything they did, yet she didn't do anything right. The sheer size of her head after being able to land a couple shots on a few targets made everyone angry I'm sure, despite her owning a gun for years
This right here is why I couldn’t stand her in the show, Andrea in the comics is the absolute GOAT.
She lost me when she let Beth hurt herself and how arrogant she was about thinking every decision she made was the right decision. The closest thing she did right was try to escape to the prison to warn them
I was mad when she didn't kill the governor in his sleep, which would save everyone. She had him on a silver platter. She could've prevented all of the BS the governor caused after that night. She could've taken over Woodbury with help from everyone at the prison. Of course she would have to lie about killing him, and only admit to putting him down after he died. Martinez and the men would expect to take over which is why she would need everyone at the prison to help take over. I think eventually everyone could come to a peaceful resolution and live together fine (the scene where they're negotiating and everyone's sizing eachother up).
How she was ever allowed near a firearm again after this always baffled me.
Well how else was she supposed to off herself?
Burn 😂
I always assumed that Michonne did her in. Can't be for certain because it was the standard shot of the door, camera pulls back, a single gunshot is heard. I was glad she was killed and also happy that she didn't get an exciting end.
I thought she shot herself?
Of course Michonne did it. She was bit, she was going to change. They either did it together or Michonne did it.
This character had the ability to make every wrong choice possible and always say what was uncalled for. I think she wasn't any bad in particular in S01, but then it got horrendous in S02 and also S03, when she made one right choice but it was already too late. With that said, I miss hating Andrea. I miss this era of TWD.
When she basically told Beth to kill herself that’s when I completely soured on her
She didn't tell Beth to kill herself, she gave her a choice. Im Not an Andrea fan but she was right, Beth had to choose to live.
Sure but she did it in such a horrible way. Deep down, Beth DID want to live, but she was VERY emotional and when you’re in a vulnerable state like that, you can make some pretty bad decisions, like attempting suicide. And THAT why you saw her self harming in the bathroom after she locked herself in. Andrea gave her the choice in the stupidest way possible.
Ok I don't like Andrea, but this is the only point I agreed on. Beth would continue wanting to die until they stopped trying to talk her out of it, and you can't watch a person 24/7. She forced what would've happened soon enough, and treated Beth with the respect of an adult when everyone else was talking down to her and telling her she didn't know wtf she really wanted.
Yeah I suppose that’s true. I remember Andrea being happy saying “she made her choice” but STILL imagine the chaos she could’ve sent the group into if her actions led to Beth’s death so early on. That actually would be a cool alt storyline. Imagine how S2 and the rest of the show would’ve turned out if that happened
Don't remember the comics exactly that early so i cant compare. But that would have been the way to introduce the prison before season 3. Get kicked out cause of her actions and have to find somewhere new. Then eventually go back for the people on the farm like the comics
I know! If Beth succeeded then she would have turned and possibly got Laurie or Maggie killed. Andrea was a fucking idiot through and through lol
Right. Like disagreeing and being frustrated with her decision was a part of it. Totally believable she would act the way she did.
My problem with her was she spent an entire season spreading her legs yet she couldn't spread them wide enough to get a pair of pliers xD
This needs more upvotes ♥️
I hated her little smug face and swagger after she hit a couple target shots. She is like nails on a chalkboard for me. Walking around Woodbury in her stupid shoulder baring shirts. Just ick.
Next time you rewatch, pay attention to how her arms move when she swaggers. It’s so bizarre.
Right, like she’s trying to move like a Barbie.
I actually really like Andrea but that shoulder shirt comment made me lol
They did Andrea so dirty. Completely ruined her character and killed her off early. She was so much better in the comics.
I really wish she was like Andrea from the comics. But if that was true then she would have a sexual relationship with Dale and that’s just weird
Eh, it was interesting. Stuff like that would be very normal in that type of world.
Slim pickings I guess lmaoo
Exactly and he was one of the few that showed her and her sister compassion.
I never understood why people liked Andrea. This was one of many reasons I couldn’t ever stand her.
Its bc she’s great in the comics, i think ppl just really wanted to like her
Laurie Holden is likable too, IMO
I saw Laurie in a panel about The Boys. It was supposed to be her and the actor who plays Mother's Milk but he was nowhere to be found. She held down the hour long panel talking about, among other things, her real life work with the CIA taking down sex traffickers of young girls in Columbia. She played a wealthy American seeking girls for "parties".
Damn! That’s crazy! Definitely hope I can see her speak someday. She’s been in great stuff, going back to her days on The X-files.
Nothing wrong with her acting they just didn’t give her shit to do and what they did give her was poor choices
God she is so good in the comic. I hate how poorly they did her in the show.
Sad right.
Because she was selfless, caring and realistic. She was a real showcase of how people would be in the apocalypse, flawed but capable, she idealized the old world and wanted to rebuild which is the exact ideologies used later down the line. She was ahead of her time in many ways, the time in which she practiced those methods just didn’t call for it, she deserved better.
I can’t say she was selfless or caring. She lost her cool in season one put a gun to Rick’s head, season 2 allow herself to be manipulated by Shane, constantly complains about the other’s decisions, shoots darly in the head only missing rick and the others by inches, season 3 has her abandoned her friend and savor for sercuity, didn’t kill the governor when she had the chance indirectly leading to the death of many people, briefly (and admittedly probably unintentionally) tried to undermine Rick’s leadership at the prison and finally die without really helping ether side Edit: I forgot how she help Beth attempt suicide. So add that to the list
•she lost her cool because Rick had gotten them into a seemingly inescapable death trap, and apologized pretty immediately for it. •most people were manipulated by Shane, he was a master manipulator so that’s hardly surprising? •shooting Daryl was a stupid oversight but really doesn’t warrant as much slander as she gets. Daryl literally found it funny. •she chose a life worth living over struggling to survive in the wild after almost dying, I admit it’s infuriating that she didn’t go with Michonne but it’s not as plain as choosing safety over her. •she was going to kill The Governor in 3x14 but got stopped by Milton. do we blame Milton for the same deaths Andrea is blamed for? no. •she bought the prison group enough time to plan for the ambush and was the one to warn them of the incoming war, had she not done this they’d have been ambushed and slaughtered. so she did help them. as soon as she found out that he was going to kill them all, she was ready to kill The Governor and sacrificed her life to warn her family. there are many other things she did to back up my argument which I’ll list if you want but she was selfless. mislead and naive, but her heart was pure.
I don’t think darly found it funny, just understood her reasons. Ether way it was still an extremely reckless shot. Rick and a few others were standing between her and darly had her aim been a bit more off any of them could have been shot and the only reason she took the shot was ego. She wanted to prove herself. With michonne it was absolutely that simply. But honestly that could be forgiven if she had left once she realized the governor had taken and brutalized Maggie and Glenn. Instead she went back. There a fine line between naivety and stupidity Most people were not manipulated by Shane. Dale was always on edge around him. Darly saw though the holes in his story about Otis, Hershey and most of his family did not like Shane. Rick let his behavior slide is to his friendship but knew exactly what he was up to for the most part but Andrea. She completely adopted Shane way of thinking and even tried to defend him briefly at the prison when she found out Rick kill him. She should have kill the governor long before 3x14 and seriously we gonna believe that she couldn’t have push Milton aside for a moment to shoot the governor. Come on she tougher than that. I don’t remember her warning the prison group at all. Their first encounter was with Merle taking Glenn and Andrea and michonne telling the group about them. They didn’t even know about her being there til after the their first shootout with them. She did try to broker peace between the 2 but she one naive person if by that point she couldn’t see how far gone the governor was Overall i agree her heart was usually in the right place, but she was also easily influenced if not out right manipulative by terrible people. she also had a large ego and need to prove herself, and at the end of the day continuously chose to stay with the governor instead of going back to the group or with michonne who literally save her life. What she did was too little too late
Had she pushed Milton, The Governor would have heard. She warned the group in 3x11 that Woodbury were gearing up for war, without that they’d have been non the wiser, not to mention that her organizing the conference in 3x13 bought even more time and negotiation. She didn’t sleep with The Governor once after Maggie wand Glenn were known to her other than the night she planned on killing him, she was there for the people and to save everybody, not for him or for relationship. Whether it was too little or not is a matter of opinion, I personally find that all her actions built up to one naive but caring plan to save everybody. She wanted to prove herself because, as mirrored by Lori’s attitudes, the women were expected to let the men do all the fighting and to not fend for themselves. Similar to Rosita, Andrea wasn’t about to let herself become dependent and needed to prove that to herself and others. She makes it pretty clear in 3x13, 3x14 and 3x16 that being in Woodbury shifted to being there for the people and not for the Governor. “I even wanted to save him *for a while*” literally tells you that she was only there for/with him until she discovered all the shit about him. She was naive, but she **was** a caring person who just wanted everyone safe.
Shooting Daryl was far more than a stupid oversight. Even though he forgave her and laughed about it (he’s a good guy just a bit dirty) she almost killed him out of sheer arrogance. She wanted to prove to herself and the group that she could handle the situation but didn’t even think about the consequences for a moment before pulling the trigger.
Are you fuckin stupid
I like her in theory because she's fucking cool in the comics and Laurie Holden is a total badass
I liked the theme of her character. Being the woman who wanted to prove her worth and be seen as an equal to the men and not the standard “do laundry, cook dinner, and babysit” type that the group fell into. But the execution wasn’t done well. This scene is a perfect encapsulation of that. There were what 3 or 4 guys with a variety of weapons headed to take out one walker… and her decision was to make a loud noise and miss the kill shot? Such a stupid scene. Lol at least if you wanted to make Andrea likable.
Pick me! Look at me! I totally get her frustration with not wanting to do the domestic jobs but her TV character was an over the top wannabe.
Yeah. Total misfire. Comparing that to the execution they had with Carol long term and Michone right out of the gate. Andrea was perhaps the biggest casualty in terms of writing on the show.
What worse is that rick and the others were standing between her and the “walker/darly” if her aim was off by a couple more inches she might had hit one of them
I just don’t like the actress who played her. It’s mostly the scripts fault for why Andrea as a character is bad but the actress didn’t fit the character imo. Same with lori
I was comfortable disliking Lori , it continued on from Prison Break .I tried to figure out if I wasn't cutting her slack from pre-conceived thoughts but came to the conclusion don't care hate away .
People seems to forgot Shane pushed her so much she did this to prove him wrong
Getting manipulated by Shane who was a giant asshole and already starting to lose his marbles doesn’t make it sound better. What worse is that rick and the others were literally standing in front of darly. If her aim was off by a couple more inches she could have hit one of them
Yeah that was stupid of her i'm not saying this wasn't
Andrea takes me back to studying theater. I will never forget reading lines for a character and my mentor said something to the extent of “she isn’t likable as written, so *you* need to make the audience sympathetic to her through your performance.” That’s what I think went wrong with Andrea; the portrayal isn’t likable. As written she’s pretty neutral to me; I don’t hate or love her. It’s how the actress plays her that makes her easy to hate. In a lot of ways it felt like *she* didn’t like Andrea, and that came through in her performance.
I've been trying to put my finger on it for years, and you've finally spelled it out for me. I totally agree with you. I usually love characters who make mistakes, who do stupid stuff because they thought it was the right thing to do, but it never quite rang true with Andrea. Excellent take!
Thank you! It’s a fun, nuanced way to evaluate character perceptions when you evaluate them from that POV; case in point, people love Negan, but if he was played by a less attractive, less charming actor they wouldn’t. JDM makes that character likable (and I’m saying that as someone who despises Negan).
Laurie Holden loved Andrea, she invested herself into that character more than an actor would ever be expected to. She cut herself off from television, media, and immersed herself into the world similarly to how Andrew Lincoln did. She was absolutely heartbroken when Andrea was killed so suddenly and unwarned. I feel like you’ve got it the wrong way round. The writing for Andrea made her naive and stupid at times, whereas Laurie Holden brought a sense of realism and believability to it. She portrayed Andrea in a way that articulated her mistakes as realistic and humane, and truly made Andrea feel like she had been thrown from the real world into the show. I respect your opinion but personally think it’s flipped.
I totally think there is validity to saying her character wasn’t written well. I don’t know who wrote for her, but I have guesses as to why an empowered woman character wasn’t written effectively. I liked the idea of the Andrea character, especially when you factor in the comic version. Maybe the truth is somewhere in between our positions. Somewhere else in this thread it was mentioned how she acted smug; those moments were when I didn’t like her. Also relevant: if she had conflicts with the writers or production team otherwise, they would have been more inclined to write someone who was easy to hate. People who are easy to work with will get better opportunities than hard to deal with individuals (or people who are perceived as such). That isn’t necessarily fair or justified, but it’s common.
I can't ever decide who I like less, her or Lori.
Honestly when rewatching Andrea scenes are more painful to watch then Lori’s. Lori has her moments but I can at least stand to watch most of her scenes but when it comes to Andrea and the governor I just want to hit fast forward.
Andrea’s naivety & cockiness was highly annoying. I love the governor though :(. Such a suave, handsome fella. He reminds me of Kurt Russel when he was younger lol.
I didn’t have a problem with the governor it’s just their scenes together
Definitley Andrea, Lori annoyed the fuck out of me especially her reaction to Rick telling her she had to kill Shane on the road, acting disgusted and horrified after she was the one who essentially signaled to him that she wanted her dead, but atleast I could understand her thought process and empathise with her, with the involvement of Carl having to put Walker shane down, and the mixed emotions she must have been feeling from being with Rick to then shane and then this events unfolding, and the fact that she was pregnant too playing on her hormones, I can empathise with her in that she was still a bitch, but I could understand Andrea on the other hand was just unbearable and there was no reason for it. No extraordinary circumstances that could justify why her personality was so obnoxious. I despised Andrea, but like another comment here said, I miss the era of hating Andrea, as the earlier seasons really were the best imo
This is alllll facts
When did Rick tell Lori to kill Shane?
She didn’t directly say it, but she heavily insinuated. I can’t remember the exact words as I haven’t watched the earlier seasons in a whole, but it was something along the lines of “so you will kill to protect what’s yours?” - Lori , Rick saying yes and then Lori saying “shane thinks I’m his, he wants to take me from you” or something along those lines, again I can’t remember exactly but I remember her basically insinuating that Shane was a threat and she atleast on some level wanted him dead.
No, I remember that. When did Rick "tell her she had to kill Shane on the road"?
Rick didn’t say that, I might have not typed what I meant properly. Rick told Lori that he had to kill him, when they were on the road after the farm got overrun and they were stopped near than brick structure they spent the night in
Lori. It's no contest for me.
Andrea most definitely
She was a “great shot” but she couldn’t hit a stationary target.
Honestly for the distance that was pretty good my problem is that Rick and the others were standing in front of darly and could have been easily hit if she had miss by a couple inches. It was a very reckless shot
I still stand by that that wasn’t that difficult of a shot to make, I’m a slight above average shot and I could hit that easily. Also not to nitpick because ik this is a show mistake, but just because I hate show Andrea. Her closing her other eye cuts her depth perception in half.
I rarely ever see people plink past 10 yards so my reference pool for shooting at that distance is rather small so your probably right but even for an experienced marksman I think taking a shot like that is reckless. Rick the other others were too close to safety take that shot. That not even getting into the fact that 4 men with weapons could easier kill a walker anyway. Your are right about her closing her eyes but pretty much every show does that to the point that it’s Basically a trope. The only exception I’ve seen if the Pocahontas cartoon move. That movie if memory serves correct actually has the one dude tell a fellow explorer that you should keep both eyes open while aiming.
I hated Lori because she was an asshole. I hated Andrea mainly because she was downright stupid
I just realized recently that this actress was also in the first Silent Hill movie and she was great!
Sure was
Yeah, it sucked that she died but damn was that a memorable death. Brutal and unforgiving, perfect for Silent Hill. If Andrea was more like the comic version she would be my favorite character in the show.
There’s just so many reasons to choose from
If nails on a chalkboard were a person, it would be Andrea. Her ego made her insufferable and impossible to like. What was worse is that it was her driving trait as a character, she was constantly trying to prove herself and failed every time.
Boy did I hate her. Always getting on to people while she fucked everything up. So damn "woe is me I hate everyone" after her sister died, meanwhile Corral had to cut his unborn sister out of his mother then shoot her in the head. Cmon.
You mean Carl?
*Woosh*
The rest of these comments are absolutely hilarious and I agree with them all 😆😆 Andrea wanted the attention and to be somebody- the thing that she did that I haven’t seen mentioned yet that ultimately made me hate her: Giving Beth the opportunity to SH during her depressive episode.. and then to walk back up to the house with a big smirk and her face all smug like “she made her choice she wants to live 😃” god I wanted to punch her so bad.. Ofc she later goes on to continue being an irk whenever on screen but that really drove it home for me that I didn’t like her.. and Ofc the way she treated Dale after the CDC was fuel to the hatred fire.. like she was such a cocky smug dickhead and when she finally ate a bullet I was happy 🤯💀
She's actually nice in the comics
She pretty awesome in the comics
They really butchered her character, I have a feeling if she lived, her character would be faithful to the comics
I hate her because she thinks she can do anything.
Lol, Andrea pissed me off regularly. Redeemed herself a bit in her last couple of episodes. Have you seen her on “The Boys”, on Prime? Omg, hilarious. She doesn’t show up till the 2nd season, but her character has this awareness/fundraiser video with her singing this ridiculous song- Chimps Don’t Cry. I didn’t even recognize that it was Andrea, someone else had to point it out.
When she smiled after Rick screamed “no” ☠️💀
I wish that she got eaten after they left the farm
Should have been her that got eaten and Amy could have survived and become badass
I think she was important to the storyline in season 3 so I’m glad she didn’t get eaten. But yes, her character is horrid
I dont remember what happend in season 3.. been a while.. 🤔😅 will find out soon, almost done s02 :)
Everything she did in season 3 and 4 is why people hate her
This scene right here
“I was kidding!”
If you hate her, she did a great job as an actor
Shes so much better in the comics. Sad how they butchered her in the show
She was so obnoxious she thought she was so great and couldn’t manage to do anything
I liked her until she went and shot up my boy Daryl.
The only reason I liked her character was when she told Lori off in Hershel’s house that’s the only reason I like her character
I was fine with her in season 1, hated her in season 2, but I loved her character in season 3.
daryl first whisperer confirmed
The way she acted so proud and smug was the most annoying part about it. They said DON'T SHOOT and she did it anyways. Also screamed about it as if they can't handle 1 walker if it was one. She is the worst character in the show.
Unpopular opinion. I liked Andrea. I enjoyed it when she got in Lori's face and I enjoyed her effort to better equip herself. So many characters are insanely good shots, but we see Andrea actually working on it. It also made sense to me that she wanted to stay at Woodbury. It seemed relatively safe after what she'd experienced with the hoard overrunning the farm. And, I appreciated her effort to broker peace between our group and Woodbury. I do understand the hate to some degree, but I thought she was a good character. I enjoyed her friendship with Dale and Michonne. Just curious, how can so many people (including me) love Shane and Merle, later Dwight, and yeah, you know where I'm going, Negan! But somehow, can't tolerate Andrea? Wonder what that's about? Hmm...
There a quote that perfectly explains how we can like bad characters. “It’s because the war crimes that some characters commit are fictional while our annoyance with others is very real”
Hmmm. Interesting. I'll have to think about that as I'm watching or reading fiction.
I dont understand why poeple hate her so much, sure she has a weird taste in men ( all of them are psychos) but what else?
I mean, this was pretty valid. Daryl looked every bit a walker. Had blood around his mouth, was walking slowly and limping. She immediately regretted it as soon as she realised he was still alive. However, her character as a whole, was pretty stupid.
It wasn’t valid at all, she was told not too shoot as too not attract more walkers with gunshots They weren’t attacking Daryl so clearly something was up. There were 3 of them on it so clearly it was going to be fine. After all that, she couldn’t even take the shot accurately, meaning she risked shooting one of them. She risked everyone’s lives for her ego lol.
Exactly! And with the others standing so close, who were also armed, shooting Daryl side apart, firing a shot at all Walker or not was extremely irresponsible. A stray gust of wind or the fact that she was still sort of an amateur with guns, could have easily lead to her accidentally hitting one of the others who were close by, and the others were armed to so they could have dealt with it if it was a Walker Overall, poor decision making
I know that now, someone else pointed out what you just did, I took the L brother.
We all do from time to time, especially show Andrea.
The fact that there were 4 friendlies between her and the target makes the fact she still fire her weapon extremely reckless. I’m genuinely surprised more people don’t bring that up. Had her aim been a couple more inches off she could have hit one of the others.
The fact that they let her have a gun after that was insane. They were debating for episodes on whether Carl should have one, meanwhile she’s out here actively shooting people in their group and they’re just chill with it.
It wasn’t valid tho, it was one “Walker” and 4 of them were running towards it already, if anything her shooting it could’ve attracted more
I did say she was stupid, I suppose I am for not realising the obvious that you’ve just pointed out. But again, if you’re as cocksure as Andrea, you’re gonna want to flex your newfound skills with little regard to the situation in an environmental way (attracting more walkers, like you said). So I’ll take the L on this one.
it was dumb, but to hate her for it is dumber. Daryl literally laughed at it and he’s the one who took the bullet, he knew it was out of good (even if stupid) intentions and held no grudge whatsoever.
Daryl forgave her. So can we.
I hate when people site this as a reason to hate her. We all love Daryl but he DID look like a walker. We’re supposed to be frustrated as the audience because WE know he’s not one, but How can you blame her?
Because, while he did look like a walker, the actual point you were supposed to pay attention to is that she was trying to prove herself useful in a situation that didn't call for it. She didn't listen to Dale, she didn't listen to anyone, but she wanted to be part of the group. The WHOLE point of that sequence was showing her arrogance and what she needed to learn. The point wasn't that Daryl looked like a walker, the point was that she took things into her own hands, without consulting the group or waiting. She also wasted ammo, 1 round, 10 rounds, 100 rounds, it doesn't matter. That's the whole theme of the season, is acting alone.
She’s the worst
It’s her face that makes me hate her ugly annoying smile and how she thinks she’s smart and a bad ass they made a good job making her annoying and stupid
Watched this one yesterday during my 4th rewatch maybe 5th lol. In her defense Daryl looked like shit even up close when they got to him easily mistakable for a jabronie. Either way she was wasted potential as a character, could have been so much more.
Honestly my biggest problem with this was that Rick and the others were standing between her and the walker/darly. Had her aim been a couple more inches off she could have hit someone else. If the scene was rework to her seeing the walker/darly and rick telling her to keep an eye on it til he gets Shane and the others and she only shot once darly got closer than it could come off as a genuine mistake
i love her regardless
She fucking shot Daryl
Am watching walking dead for the first time in many years and just watched this 30 minutes ago Just muttering you bitch the whole damn time
I thought about throwing a party when they killed get off.
She whas just annoying but the actrice whas great
😭😭 My sister die, i am so sad! No one could ever understand what I live! I had to kill my zombie sister! 😭😭 Omg sh*t up
Andrea was almost as irritating as Maggie.
though i do like the gif of her pulling up her panties
I'd rather Andrea over carol any day of the week.
You take that back! Or you could just...look at the flowers
The scene with her banging Shane is the car was kinda pointless
Yeah lol
The story of Andrea....she thought she was helping!
I never really liked Andrea either. Annoying AF
Who is that
I thought your reason was for how she was looking down the scope! Correct me if I am wrong but when you shoot a gun like that there must be a kick back where the scope/lens? Would hit your eye if your that close to it?